A review of coccidiosis in South American camelids

Abstract

Camelids (llamas, alpacas, vicuñas, guanacos) are important for the economy of South America and Eimeria infections are important as cause of mortality in camelids. Of the five most prevalent species of Eimeria in South American camelids, Eimeria macusaniensis, Eimeria lamae, Eimeria alpacae, Eimeria punoensis, and Eimeria ivitaensis, E. macusaniensis is considered the most pathogenic. There is considerable confusion concerning the endogenous developmental stages of Eimeria spp. in camelids. Many papers on camelid coccidiosis were published in local Peruvian journals, not easily accessible to wider audience. The objective of the present paper is to summarize information on history, validity of Eimeria species, life cycle, pathogenicity, prevalence, epidemiology, diagnosis, and control of coccidiosis in camelids.

Introduction

The South American camelids consist of four species—llamas (Lama glama), alpacas (Lama pacos), guanacos (Lama guanicoe), and vicuñas (Lama vicugna); their generic nomenclature is controversial. I have used the genus Lama for all four species. Traditionally, they are distributed at high altitudes (3600–5400 m) in South America where they are source of meat, hide, fiber, transport and their feces are used for fuel and fertilizer (Díaz et al. 2016). In many countries, such as the USA, they are reared for recreation and the commercial product is a live animal. Coccidiosis is an important cause of mortality in llamas and alpacas. There are many uncertainties concerning the life cycle of Eimeria species in camelids and early literature from Peru is in local journals, not easily accessible. The object of this review is to summarize information on coccidiosis in camelids.

Species of Eimeria in camelids

There are five common species of Eimeria in South American camelids (Table 1). They are morphologically so different in size and shape that species can be identified without the need of sporulation (Fig. 1). Of these, E. macusaniensis and E. ivitaensis are one of the largest among species of Eimeria in general (Levine 1973).

Table 1.

Common species of Eimeria in South American camelids

Character	E. macusaniensis	E. lamae	E. alpacae	E. punoensis	E. ivitaensis
Oocyst shape	Ovoid, piriform	Ellipsoidal, ovoid	Ellipsoidal, ovoid	Ellipsoidal, ovoid	Ellipsoidal
Sizea	81–107 × 61–80 100–110 × 77–84 b	30–40 × 21–30 35–38 × 26–30	22–26 × 18–21 24–27 × 22–24	17–22 × 14–18	83.5–98.6 × 49.3–59.1
Mean	93.6 × 67.4 106.6 × 80.5	35.6 × 24.5 36.7 × 28. 9	24.1 × 19.6 25.8 × 22.9	19.9 × 16.4	88.8 × 51.8
Wall thickness	8.3–11.4	1.4–1.8	1.2–1.6	0.8–1.1	4.0–4.5
Micropylar cap	2–5 high, 9–14 wide	1.5–2.2 high, 8.8–11.4 wide	0.7–1.3 high, 4.4–7.5 wide	0.4–0.8 high, 3.5–5.5 wide	Absentc
Sporocyst shape	Elongate	Elongate, ovoid		Elongate, ovoid	Elongate
Size range	33–40 × 16–20 44–48 × 20–23	13–16 × 8–10 17–20 × 9–12	10–13 × 7–8 10–12 × 7–9	8–11 × 5–7	32.6–40.8 × 11.9–13.6
Mean	36.3 × 18.3 45.2 × 22.6	15.2 × 8.5 18.6 × 10.7	11.0 × 6.8 11.3 × 7.8	9.2 × 6.1	35.4 × 13.1
Stieda body	Faint	Present	Faint	Faint	Not described
Original host	Lama pacos	Lama pacos	Lama pacos	Lama pacos	Lama pacos
Reference	Guerrero et al. (1971)	Guerrero (1967a, b)	Guerrero (1967a, b)	Guerrero (1967a, b)	Leguía and Casas (1998)

^aThe measurements are in μm. Guerrero (1967a, b) measured 50 or more oocysts and sporocysts; the number of specimens measured by Leguia and Casas (1998) and Schrey et al. (1991) was not stated

^bFigures in bold are from oocysts in Lama glama (Schrey et al. 1991)

^cAbsent in original description of Leguía and Casas (1998) but present in some oocysts (see Fig. 1)

Fig. 1.

Unsporulated oocysts of five common species of Eimeria in South American camelids. Unstained. Courtesy of Dr. M. M. Cafrune. A E. ivitaensis. B E. macusaniensis. C E. lamae. D E. alpace. E E. punoensis. Note micropylar caps (arrowheads). The scale bar = 20 μm and applies to all parts

The sporulation time differs among these Eimeria species. Eimeria macusaniensis oocysts take longer time to sporulate, perhaps related to the thickness of the oocyst wall. Temperature of incubation can also affect sporulation; E. macusaniensis oocysts sporulated in 9 days at 30 °C, in 21 days at 18–25 °C but oocysts did not sporulate at 6–7 °C (Rohbeck 2006).

History

Eimeria macusaniensis oocysts are morphologically and biologically distinctive, resembling watermelon seed or a cut avocado; its oocysts are up to 107 μm long, have a very thick wall, and prepatent period is > 30 days. Examination of coprolites and llama mummies dating about 10,000 years (Halocene period) in Patagonia, Argentina found E. macusaniensis and E. ivitaensis oocysts (Martinson et al. 2003; Fugassa et al. 2008, 2010; Velázquez et al. 2014; Taglioretti et al. 2014, 2015); shape and sizes of these oocysts were remarkably preserved (Fugassa et al. 2008). Similar findings are reported for coprolites from Chile dating to Pre-Inca Hispanic Contact Period (de Souza et al. 2018).

Although coccidia have been recognized for more than two centuries (Levine 1973), little attention was paid to coccidia in camelids. Yakimoff (1934) in Leningrad, Russia first reported Eimeria infection in feces of one of the five llama fecal samples sent to him by Professor Iwanoff; nothing was said who collected samples and the locality. Yakimoff (1934) named the parasite, Eimeria peruviana, n.sp. The oocysts were 27.9–37.5 × 18–22 μm with 10.5–15.0 × 7.5 μm sporocysts, some oocysts had a micropyle but others did not. No other details were given. It appears that there was a mix up with other feces sent by Iwanoff because E. peruviana has not been found subsequently. Because there are no archived specimens, this question cannot be resolved retrospectively. I consider it nomen nudum/species enquirende.

As per Guerrero (1967a), Eimeria infections were reported in alpacas in Peru by Arnao (1951), Chávez (1959), Chávez and Guerrero (1960), Chávez (1965), and Vásquez et al. (1965); these papers were published in local journals or in conference proceedings and are no longer available because the files have been discarded (personal communication from Dr. Guillermo Leguía to me, January 10, 2018). As per Guerrero (1967a), Arnao (1951) first reported Eimeria sp. in feces of alpacas, and Chávez (1959) found Eimeria oocysts in 17% of 2109 fecal samples. Chávez and Guerrero (1960) found Eimeria in the intestine of an alpaca and in feces of 14% of 300 alpacas (Chávez and Guerrero 1960). Vásquez et al. (1965) reported Eimeria oocysts in the intestine of llamas in Peru.

Carlos Antonio Guerrero (1967a, b) from Peru came to the University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois, USA, and under the supervision of Professor Norman D. Levine, formally described and named the three species of Eimeria, E. alpacae, E. punoensis, and E. lamae. The samples had been collected from the rectum of 12 alpacas from an alpaca farm in Peru, mixed with 2.5% potassium dichromate or 10% formalin and sent to USA. Apparently, most oocysts had sporulated during transit thus, in the original published paper there was no description of unsporulated oocysts (Guerrero 1967b). However, unsporulated oocysts of E. alpacae and E. punoensis (but not E. lamae) were described in his thesis (Guerrero 1967a). After completing his graduate studies, Guerrero returned to Peru and together with Hernandez and Alva reported severe coccidiosis in a 5-month-old alpaca; the alpaca was in poor nutritional condition and had died a day before necropsy (Guerrero et al. 1967). It had mixed infection of E. lamae, E. alpacae, E. punoensis, and an unnamed Eimeria species. They also reported schizonts, gamonts, and oocysts in histological sections; the stages found were arbitrarily assigned to four species of Eimeria. Four years later, Guerrero et al. (1971) described and named Eimeria macusaniensis.

Guerrero et al. (1970b) also first reported on experimental infection of E. lamae in alpaca. Two alpacas were fed 100 oocysts (6 months-old alpaca #1) or 100,000 oocysts (4 months old alpaca #2). Both excreted E. lamae oocysts 10 days (alpaca #2) or 16 days (alpaca #1) later. Alpaca #2 developed diarrhea and died day 15 post inoculation (p.i.). Small schizonts (not illustrated) were found in the duodenum, and numerous gamonts and oocysts were found throughout the small intestine at necropsy.

Three decades later, Leguia and Casas (1998) described the fifth species of Eimeria, E. ivitaensis (Table 1).

Prevalence of Eimeria species oocysts in feces

Prevalence data in llamas (Table 2), alpacas (Table 3), guanacos (Table 4) and vicuñas (Table 5) indicate these camelids are commonly infected with Eimeria species. The data from North America and South America camelids are grouped together but the patterns of infections might be different in these continents. In general, E. lamae was the most prevalent and E. ivitaensis was the least prevalent. Infections were most common in nursing animals. Up to 90% of cria under 2 months of age were found infected (Guerrero et al. 1971). It is noteworthy, that despite excretion of as many as 411,600 oocysts per gram of feces (opg), all vicuñas were asymptomatic (Cafrune et al. 2014).

Table 2.

Prevalence of Eimeria in Llama (Lama glama)

Country, region	No. tested	No. positive (%)	Eimeria species	Remarks	Reference
Argentina					Cafrune et al. (2009)
Jujuy	478	233 (48.7)	E. macusaniensis in all, mixed with E. ivitaensis in 2	1 llama with mixed E. macusaniensis and E. ivitaensis had diarrhea
Salta	48	17 (35.4)	E. macusaniensis in 17
Catamarca	100	65 (65)	E. macusaniensis in all, mixed with E. ivitaensis in 2
Switzerland	293 from 38 farms	(68)	E. macusaniensis	Only herd prevalence stated.	Hertzberg and Kohler (2006)
USA					Rickard and Bishop (1988)
Oregon	189 adults	69 (37)	E. alpacae (27%), E. macusaniensis (1%) E. punoensis (17%), E. lamae (9%),	1 species in 58%, 2 species in 38%, 3 species in 4% in adults.
	50 crias	30 (60)	E. alpacae (52%), E. macusaniensis 0, E. punoensis (40%), E. lamae (32%),	In crias, 47% contained 2 species, 30% had 3 species, 23 % had 1 species. All animals were healthy.
10 states	301	36 (12)	E. macusaniensis	<1 year 19 of 86 (22.1%), > 1 year 17 of 200 (8.5%)	Jarvinen (1999)
Colorado and Wyoming	121 Colorado	76 (62.8)	E. alpacae 75, E. macusaniensis 0, E. lamae 1	4 herds surveyed	Schrey et al. (1991)
	23 Wyoming	15 (65.2)	E. alpacae 5, E. macusaniensis 2, E. lamae 8,

Table 3.

Prevalence of Eimeria in alpacas (Lama pacos)

Country-region	No. tested	No. positive (%)	Eimeria species %	Remarks	Reference
Japan  Kanto	53	42 (79.2)	E. lamae 1.9 E. macusaniensis 7.5 E. punoensis and/or E alpacae 69.8	53 of 390 alpacas from 1 farm tested	Hyuga and Matsumoto (2016)
New Zealand	460	15 (3.2)	E. macusaniensis	5 farms were surveyed	Rawdon et al. (2006)
Peru  Cuzco	160	67 (58.1)	E. lamae 60.4, E. punoesis 30.0, E. alpace 45.6 E. macusaniensis 50.4	90% of 2 months-old alpacas were positive with an oocyst burden of 1016 oocysts per gram of feces	Guerrero et al. (1970a)
Southern Peru	316	145 (46.2)	E. macusaniensis 56.5	22 herds surveyed	Cordero Ramirez et al. (2011)
Puno	478	418 (87.5)	E. lamae 15.6, E. punoesis 20.0, E. alpace 16.9 E. macusaniensis 25 E. ivitaensis 6.2	< 90 days old healthy cria, infection with multiple species was common	Rodríguez et al. (2012)
Puno	350	224 (64.3)	E. lamae 91, E. macusaniensis 35, E. punoensis 78, E. alpacae 87, E. ivitaensis 13	Unweaned alpacas 2 from 23 herds	Díaz et al. (2016)
Switzerland	72	Not stated	E. macusaniensis	Present in 68% of farms, no individual animal data	Hertzberg and Kohler (2006)
UK	Not stated	Not stated	E. ivitaensis	Present in 2 herds. Zinc sulfate sp. gr. 1.36 used for flotation	Twomey et al. (2010)
USA-10 states	115	8 (7.0)	E. macusaniensis		Jarvinen (1999)
Maryland	61	14 (26.2)	E. alpacae in 7, E. punoensis in 5, mixed in 2	Two farms. Cesium chlorite sp.gr. 1.4 used for flotation	Trout et al. (2008)

Table 4.

Prevalence of Eimeria in guanaco (Lama guanicoe)

Country-region	No. tested	No. positive (%)	Eimeria species	Remarks	Reference
Argentina  Salta	4	1 (25.0)	E. macusaniensis	Semi captive	Cafrune et al. (2009)
Mendoza, San Juan	35	Not stated	E. macusaniensis, Eimeria sp.	Wild guanaco surveyed. Only published as abstract	Borghi et al. (2004)
Patagonia	12	10 (80.3)	E. macusaniensis in 9, Eimeria spp. in 10	Mortality due to starvation in wild population. Feces were from animals necropsied	Beldomenico et al. (2003)
Chile  Magallanes	15	6 (40.0)	E. macusaniensis	Semi captive	Correa et al. (2012)
Peru  9 districts	132	43 (33.3)	E. punoensis 21.2%, E. alpacae 13.6%, E. lamae 4.5%, E. macusaniensis 15.9%	Wild population	Castillo et al. (2008)
USA-10 states	27	2 (7.4)	E. macusaniensis		Jarvinen (1999)

Table 5.

Prevalence of Eimeria in vicuñas (Lama vicugna)

Country-region	No. tested	No. positive (%)	Eimeria species	Remarks	Reference
Argentina  Jujuy	81 juveniles 154 adults	81 (100.0) 143 (92.8)	E. punoensis (100%), E. alpacae (85.1%), E. lamae (48.1%), E. macusaniensis (82.7%), and E. ivitaensis. (3.7%) E. punoensis (89.6%), E. alpacae (66.8%), E. lamae (27.2%), E. macusaniensis (15.5%), and E. ivitaensis. (1.2%)	Born and raised at an experimental station. Prevalences were higher in May versus in November, 2011. All were asymptomatic. Mixed infections were common	Cafrune et al. (2014)
Bolivia  Apolobamba	25 adults 7 juveniles	22 (88) 7 (100)	E. alpacae 88%, E. puneonsis 80.0%, E. lamae 12%, and E. macusaniensis 8% E. alpacae 100%, E. puneonsis 100%, E. lamae 42.9%, and E. macusaniensis 14.3%	Wild population	Beltrán-Saavedra et al. (2011)
Peru  Pampa Galeras	39 Adults	15 (41.0)	E. punoensis/E. lamae	Wild population, opg (<48)	Bouts et al. (2003)

Clinical infections

Little is known of camelid coccidiosis in the wild (Leguía 1991; Mamani Paredes et al. 2009; Cafrune et al. 2014). However, Eimeria infections can be pathogenic in camelids dependent on age, concurrent infections, environmental conditions, stress of captivity and transportation, and nutrition in general (Díaz et al. 2016). Some of these factors have been investigated.

Reports of clinical coccidiosis in camelids are summarized in Table 6. Except for a report of coccidiosis in a captive guanaco from the USA (Hodgin et al. 1984), all clinical reports were in llamas and alpacas.

Table 6.

Summary of reports of clinical Eimeria infections in South American camelids

Country	Host	Eimeria spp.	Main findings	Reference
Australia	Alpaca	E. macusaniensis	A 10-year-old alpaca died suddenly without prior clinical signs. Severe, necrotic enteritis with massive parasitization of small intestine. No evidence for clostridial or other toxins. Oocysts in feces were 80–82 × 50–52 μm and sporocysts were 34 × 18 μm	Lenghaus et al. (2004)
Germany	Llama	E. macusaniensis	Thirteen of 16 one to three year-old llamas developed diarrhea and died within 2 months after a long distance travel from northern Germany to Bavaria. Enteritis associated with E. macusaniensis was found in three llamas necropsied.	Hänichen et al. (1994)
New Zealand	Alpaca	E. macusaniensis	A 10-year-old female alpaca diagnosed with histologically confirmed ulcerative coccidial enteritis affecting ileum and rare parasitism in duodenum. Endogenous stages (schizonts, gamonts, oocysts) were present in histological sections. Oocysts were seen antemortem and the alpaca had been treated with an unspecified anticoccidial drug	Rawdon et al. (2006)
Peru
Puno	Alpaca	Eimeria spp.	Heavy coccidiosis in a 5-month-old alpaca. Schizonts and gamonts of E. lamae and E. ivitaensis found in histological sections	Guerrero et al. (1967)
Southern sierra	Alpacas	E. macusaniensis	Twelve 25–35-day-old alpacas that died suddenly (n = 4) and 8 with diarrhea were necropsied and studied histologically. Macroscopic and microscopic lesions were seen in jejunum and ileum. Necrosis, fusion and blunting of villi were associated with schizonts and gamonts, and oocysts	Rosadio and Ameghino (1994)
IVITA, La Raya, Cusco	Alpaca	E. macusaniensis, E. lamae, E punoensis; E. ivitaensis	Investigations of causes of diarrhea in 48 newborn alpacas found entrotoxemia in 30, collibacillosis in 7, and Eimeria in 11; E. macusaniensis in 4, E. macusaniensis and E. punoensis in 7, and E. lamae in 4. Authors mentioned finding E. macusaniensis stages in small intestine, cecum, and colon. Intracellular stages of E. ivitaensis were reported in crypts of jejunum and ileum for the first time	Palacios et al. (2005)
Marangani, Cusco	Alpaca	E. macusaniensis; E. ivitaensis	Sudden onset of diarrhea, emaciation, and death in seven 4–5-month-old alpacas from one herd. Enteritis was the main finding. E. macusaniensis stages were found in jejunum, ileum, cecum, and ascending colon whereas E. ivitaensis stages were restricted to jejunum and ileum. Schizonts, gamonts, and oocysts were identified for both species; schizonts of E. ivitaensis caused more damage than schizonts of E. macusaniensis. Microgamonts of both species appeared similar but gamonts were different; the wall forming bodies of E. ivitaensis were small and basophilic whereas those of E. macusaniensis were large and eosinophilic	Palacios et al. (2004,2006)
Arequipa, Puno, Cusco	Alpaca	E. macusaniensis	Histological evaluation of 108 cases of Clostridium-induced enterotoxemia in 2–8-week-old alpacas revealed (a). E. macusaniensis in 33 (30.5%). (b) massive infection in 3 of 31 alpacas less than 2 weeks old; 2 of these were only 10 days old. (c) infections observed even in well managed herd. (d) severe lesions in jejunum and ileum in crypts	Rosadio et al. (2010)
Silli, Cusco	Alpaca	Eimeria sp.	Causes of diarrhea in an outbreak involving 50 1- to 5-week-old alpacas were investigated. 80% had Eimeria spp. infections; alone in 19, and in combinations with other agents in 21 alpacas. Illustrations from a 21-day-old alpacas show heavy coccidial infections, different from E. macusaniensis	Rojas et al. (2016)
UK	Alpaca	Oocysts of E. macusaniensis, E lamae, and E. alpace in feces	The index case, a 16-month-old alpaca, was found dead with a short period of restlessness. Histologic examination revealed acute, necrotic enteritis with Clostridium perfringens toxemia. Lesions associated E. macusaniensis stages. 54 additional cases of coccidiosis recorded; 40 confirmed, 9 suggestive, and 5 incidental. Most cases were in adults. Of the 26 with established diagnosis, 10 were associated with E. macusaniensis, 7 with E. punoensis, 1 with E. alpacae, 1 with E. lamae; mixed Eimeria spp. in 7.	Schock et al. (2007)
USA
Michigan	Guanaco	E. macusaniensis	3-month-old female guanaco from Detroit Zoological Park died of acute illness with leptospiral nephritis and hepatitis. The animal had abdominal pain. At necropsy a 60 cm section of jejunum was congested. Histologically, it had subacute enteritis with gamonts and oocysts of E. macusaniensis; feces were not available for oocyst identification.	Hodgin et al. (1984)
Wyoming	Llama	E. macusaniensis	3-year-old female llama died after short illness associated with enterotoxemia. Asexual and sexual stages reported in ileum. E. macusaniensis oocysts found in feces	Schrey et al. (1991)
Missouri	Alpaca or llama not distinguished	Eimeria sp.	2 alpacas with weight loss and hypoproteinemia. Both had been vaccinated against C. perfrigens. First alpaca 10-year-old diagnosed antemortem with E. macusaniensis based on jejunal biopsy died 5 days despite of treatment with sulfadimethoxine. The alpaca had chronic weight loss. Coccidial stages found in jejunum and ileum. The second animal died after diarrheal episode. Necropsy revealed Eimeria stages in jejunum and ileum but no oocysts in feces	Chigerwe et al. (2007)
New York	Alpaca	E. macusaniensis	Two-year-old female alpaca with abdominal pain, hypoproteinemia. Ultrasound examination revealed thickened loop of small intestine with collapsed lumen. Histological examination of biopsied small intestinal area revealed severe parasitism with E. macusaniensis stages. The alpaca recovered after sulfadimethoxine treatment. Oocysts of two species of Eimeria were present in feces, predominantly E. punoensis	Johnson et al. (2009)
Oregon	15 llamas, 34 alpacas	E. macusaniensis	See text for details	Cebra et al. (2007)
Illinois	1 llama	E. macusaniensis	Weight loss. Gametogony described in detail	Dubey (2018)

Among reports summarized in Table 6, a comprehensive investigation of causes of mortality was performed on 15 llamas, and 34 alpacas submitted to the Oregon Diagnostic Laboratory, Oregon State University hospital during 2002–2006 (Cebra et al. 2007). The following is the most important information from this paper:

1. E. macusaniensis infections were diagnosed in 49 camelids 3 weeks to 18 years old. The clinical signs were weight loss, lethargy, and diarrhea. Of these, 10 llamas and 9 alpacas were examined at necropsy.

2. Feces or intestinal contents of 42 camelids were examined by flotation; E. macusaniensis oocysts were not found in 17 but E. macusaniensis-associated enteritis was confirmed histologically. The other Eimeria oocysts identified were: E. lamae and E. alpacae.

3. Multiple sections of intestines were available for histological examination in 29 of 34 cases of E. macusaniensis. Eimeria macusaniensis lesions were most severe in jejunum and ileum. Meronts, macro and micro-gamonts, and oocysts were reported in histological sections; the identification of species was based on large size of wall-forming bodies in developing gamonts and oocysts found.

4. Early gamonts, but no mature gamonts, were detected in 13 camelids in whose feces oocysts were not demonstrable.

5. Most interesting information was obtained from outbreaks of coccidiosis in 15 camelids on four farms. One outbreak occurred in a group of alpacas, 20 days after being introduced to new premises that had been vacant for 6 months. Six additional alpacas became ill within 13 days; four of these died and were necropsied. Eimeria macusaniensis was diagnosed histologically. Eimeria macusaniensis oocysts were detected in feces of five alpacas 37 days after move to the new premises; these alpacas had diarrhea. The resident alpacas moved to the same pasture at the same time remained healthy.

6. This investigation concluded that E. macusaniensis-associated coccidiosis is common cause of illness in camelids of all ages in Oregon.

Concurrent infections and other causes of mortality

During a retrospective study of 3766 alpacas that had died between 1998 and 2000 in three production centers in Peru, parasitic disease accounted for 3.0%; 51.7% of deaths were attributed to infectious causes (Mamani Paredes et al. 2009). Among the parasitic diseases, coccidiosis was found in 25.4%. Thus, coccidiosis was recognized as cause of mortality only in few alpacas. However, a critical evaluation of etiology was lacking in this investigation.

Neonatal diarrhea is a common problem in raising livestock and diagnosis is problematic because of multiple etiology. Examples of pathogens found in cases of neonatal diarrhea in camelids are shown in Table 7. Despite all referred pathogens that can cause diarrhea, their relative importance is difficult to determine. An unusually severe outbreak of diarrhea was investigated in an alpaca herd in Silli, Cusco, Peru (Table 7). Of 50 affected alpacas, 6 died and 44 were euthanized; all were examined at necropsy (Rojas et al. 2016). Histologically, 44 of 50 alpacas had enteritis and 80% had Eimeria sp. infections. It is uncertain whether the diagnosis of Eimeria infections was based solely on fecal testing or histology. One illustration (Fig. 3 of Rojas et al. 2016) of small intestine shows heavy coccidiosis with small-sized Eimeria but there was no mention of species involved or description of parasitic stages (my attempts to obtain more information about endogenous stages were unsuccessful).

Table 7.

Pathogens identified in feces of neonatal alpacas with diarrhea

Source	No.	Age (days)	Year	Percent of samples						Reference
				E. coli	Corona virus	Cryptosp oridium	Giardia	Rota virus	Eimeria
Oregon, USAa	45	10–210	1999–2002	NS	42	9	18	2	13	Cebra et al. (2003)
Ohio, USAb	59	4–120	1999–2004	0	6.9	25.9	32.8	0	12.1	Whitehead and Anderson (2006)
Puno, Peruc	48	newborn	2002–2003	77f	NSe	4.1	NS	NS	31.4g	Palacios et al. (2005)
Cusco, Perud	50	7–35	January–February, 2010	34	40	20	NS	32	80	Rojas et al. (2016)

^aOregon State University Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory, Corvallis, Oregon, USA

^bVeterinary Clinical Sciences, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA

^cFacultad de Medicina Veterinaria, Universidad Nacional Mayer de San Marcos, Lima, Peru

^dInstituto Veterinario de Investigaciones Tropicales y de Altura (IVITA), Cuzco, Peru

^eNS = not stated

^fOf the 37 cases of bacterial infection, 30 were due to enterotoxemia

^g4 cases of Eimeria macusaniensis and enterotoxemia, 7 mixed infection with E. macusaniensis and E. punoensis, and 4 cases due to E. lamae

Fig. 3.

Small intestine of a 7 years-old pregnant alpaca that died with a severe hemorrhagic enteritis attributed to Eimeria macusaniensis. Courtesy of Dr. Gerald E. Duhamel, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York

In an enquiry of causes of neonatal deaths in young alpacas (2–4 months old) from three alpaca centers in Peru, histological sections of intestine of 108 alpacas considered to have died from enterotoxemia were examined for evidence of E. macusaniensis infection. Only sections of intestines from grossly visible lesions were examined. Most (n = 103) sections were from the ileum with only five from jejunum. Eimeria macusaniensis developmental stages were detected in 33 alpacas. Of the 31 alpacas with available ages, three were 2 weeks old; two were only 10 days old (Rosadio et al. 2010). These findings indicate that alpacas can become infected on the day of birth because the minimum prepatent period of any camelid Eimeria is 10 days (Table 8).

Table 8.

Experimental infections of camelids with Eimeria species

Host species (no.)	Eimeria species	No. of oocysts	Prepatent period in days	Reference
Llama (4)	E. alpacae-25%, E. punoensis 75%-both from llama	10,000–2 llamas, 50,000, 2 llamas	E. alpacae-16-18, E. punoensis-10	Foreyt and Lagerquist (1992)
Llama (4)	E. macusaniensis- Guanaco	500–5000	36–41	Jarvinen (2008)
(3)	E. macusaniensis- Alpaca	1000	33, 34
Llama (6)	E. macusaniensis- Llama and alpaca	20,000–100,000	32–36	Rohbeck (2006)
Alpaca (4)	E. macusaniensis- Alpaca and llama	20,000	31 or 35	Cebra et al. (2012)

^aSource of infection is in bold

Coinfection of coccidiosis and enterotoxemia were associated with mortality in newborn alpacas in another report (Palacios et al. 2005, Table 7).

Stress

Housing in close quarters and poor nutrition are some of the complicating factors in coccidiosis. Stress of transportation and change of ownership/location can predispose camelids to coccidiosis. Shows, sales, and movement for breeding, and the management in the new farm can cause stress. In one instance, 30 llamas developed clinical coccidiosis after being transported to a new farm (Cebra et al. 2007). Adult alpacas have developed fatal coccidiosis within 5 weeks after transportation to a new farm (Chigerwe et al. 2007; Johnson et al. 2009).

Diagnosis

Antemortem

Lethargy, diarrhea, abdominal distention, anorexia, weight loss, constipation, and colic have been reported in camelids with uncomplicated coccidiosis (Costarella and Anderson 1999; Cebra et al. 2007; Johnson et al. 2009). Coccidiosis should be suspected with these signs in camelids. Additionally, several camelids suffering from coccidiosis died suddenly (Rosadio and Ameghino 1994; Lenghaus et al. 2004; Palacios et al. 2006; Schock et al. 2007). It should be noted that diarrhea is an inconsistent finding, especially in adult camelids (Cebra et al. 2014).

Fecal examination

The detection of oocysts in feces can help diagnosis. Although most coccidian oocysts float in sugar or salt solutions with specific gravity (sp. gr.) of 1.28, E. macusaniensis oocysts are large and heavy and do not float well in these solutions (Cebra and Stang 2008). Solutions of sp. gr. > 1.28 are recommended for floatation of this Eimeria species. Super saturated sugar solution (sp. gr. 1.33, Johnson et al. 2009), saturated zinc sulfate solution (sp.gr. 1.36, Twomey et al. 2010), Cesium chlorite solution (sp. gr. 1.4, Trout et al. 2008) or mixed salt solutions (zinc chloride 105 g, NaCl 20 g, water to 100 ml, sp. gr. 1.59, Cafrune et al. 2009) are some examples of flotation solutions. The sedimentation methods used for trematode ova are as effective as the flotation method (Rohbeck 2006). The number of oocysts detected does not correlate with clinical signs (Foreyt and Lagerquist 1992; Costarella and Anderson 1999; Beldomenico et al. 2003; Cebra et al. 2007; Jarvinen, 2008; Foreyt and Lagerquist 1992; Rohbeck 2006; Cafrune et al. 2014). Some cases of coccidiosis may be missed because of the development of clinical signs before oocysts are excreted in feces (prepatent phase). To alleviate this problem, Cebra et al. (2012) developed a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test for E. macusaniensis and E. lamae diagnosis. In experimentally infected alpacas, oocyst DNA was detectible up to 7 days before oocyst detection in feces. The internal transcribed primers (ITS) were species-specific without cross detection of E. macusaniensis and E. lamae. Finding Eimeria oocyst DNA, 7 days before prepatent period is intriguing.

Biopsy and ultrasound examination

Ultrasound examination results revealing local distention and increased thickness of small intestine, particularly of ileum, may provide suggestive diagnosis (Costarella and Anderson 1999; Cebra et al. 2007; Johnson et al. 2009). Smears made from biopsied material can reveal the parasitic stages (Cebra et al. 2007). However, histological examination is needed to evaluate lesions (Cebra et al. 2007; Chigerwe et al. 2007; Johnson et al. 2009).

Other laboratory testing results

Hypoproteinemia and hypoalbuminemia are the most consistent finding (Cebra et al. 2007). Hyponatremia is also relatively common, and a rare finding in camelids without some form of enteritis.

Post mortem diagnosis

Gross lesions are most common in ileum, although any region of small intestine, cecum and colon may be affected (Rosadio and Ameghino 1994; Palacios et al. 2006; Cebra et al. 2007; Johnson et al. 2009). Mucosal thickening, congestion, plaques and severe hemorrhagic enteritis may be seen in primary lesions (Figs. 2 and 3). Secondary bacterial infection can lead to severe necrotic enteritis (Cebra et al. 2007; Schock et al. 2007; Johnson et al. 2009; Rosadio et al. 2010). The bowel may also appear grossly normal, even with severe infection.

Fig. 2.

Proliferative enteritis in ileum of an alpaca. This animal had concurrent Salmonella infection. Courtesy of Prof. Robert Bildfell, Oregon State University, Corvallis, USA

Microscopically, there is hyperplasia, non-suppurative enteritis, depending on concurrent infections (Figs. 4 and 5). Blunting, fusion, and necrosis of villi, particularly at the tips have been reported (Rosadio and Ameghino 1994; Johnson et al. 2009). Although developmental stages of camelid Eimeria occur in the mucosal epithelium and lamina propria, occasionally Eimeria and associated changes have been noted in the tunica muscularis mucosae (Johnson et al. 2009).

Fig. 4.

Massive infection of Eimeria macusaniensis small intestine of a 7-month-old alpaca from Indiana, USA (OSU case 07-1238). This animal also had histologically verified enterotoxemia in other sections of small intestine. The gamonts are immature and there are no oocysts. Hematoxylin and eosin stain. Courtesy of Prof. Michael Oglesbee, The Ohio State University, Columbus, USA

Fig. 5.

Biopsy of jejunum from a 2-year-old female alpaca with severe enteritis associated with Eimeria macusaniensis (Johnson et al. 2009). Hematoxylin and eosin stain. Courtesy of Dr. Gerald E. Duhamel, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York. Arrows point to loss of surface villar mucosal structures. A The mucosa is replaced with gamonts and oocysts. Note severe inflammation within the underlying submucosa. B Higher magnification shows ulcerative enteritis. Note an oocyst (arrowheads)

The detection of developing stages of coccidia can establish diagnosis of coccidiosis (Fig. 6). As stated earlier, of the five most prevalent species of Eimeria in camelids, E. macusaniensis has been most commonly identified in lesions. Its oocysts are distinctive, and it has large-sized gamonts (Figs. 4, 5, and 6). Its schizont stage is unknown (Dubey 2018). In few cases, E. ivitaensis has been associated with clinical coccidiosis in alpacas in Peru (Palacios et al. 2006) and the United States (Cebra et al. 2014; Cebra 2015).

Fig. 6.

Gamonts and oocysts of Eimeria macusaniensis in sections of small intestine of llama. A Note intracellular gamonts. (a) Early macrogamont with PAS-positive (amylopectin granules) around the central nucleus, and small-sized wall forming bodies (WFB, arrowheads). (b) More advanced macrogamont with WFB (arrowheads). (c) Immature microgamont with many nuclei. PAS-counter stained with hematoxylin. B Macrogamont with different sized WFB (arrow, arrowhead). Hematoxylin and eosin stain. C Microgamont with numerous nuclei arranged at the periphery (arrows) or centrally (arrowheads). D An intracellular oocyst. Note, sporont filling the interior of the oocyst, thick oocyst wall (arrow), truncated anterior micropylar end, and thick parasitophorous vacuole (arrowheads). Hematoxylin and eosin stain

Eimeria lamae is another pathogenic species. It is reported to develop in surface epithelium versus in crypts parasitized by E. macusianiensis and E. ivitaensis (Guerrero et al. 1967); I have not found description of endogenous stages.

Experimental infections

In addition to experimental infections of two alpacas in Peru by Guerrero et al. (1970a) already discussed, results of four other experiments are summarized in Table 8. Main observations from experiments in Table 8 are:

1. Minimum prepatent periods were: 31 days for E. macusaniensis, 16 days for E. lamae, and 10 days for E. punoensis (Table 8).

2. Inoculated camelids generally remained asymptomatic despite excreting as many as 10,305 opg; peak oocyst excretion for E. lamae, and E. punoensis was during the second week of inoculation (Foreyt and Lagerquist 1992). However, 2 of 5 llama crias fed 20,000 E. macusaniensis oocysts had pulpy or watery or bloody diarrhea 3–10 or 9–16 days p.i. (Rohbeck 2006).

3. Eimeria macusaniensis was cross transmissible between guanaco, alpaca, and llama.

4. Eimeria macusaniensis oocysts survived for 84 months, the longest period of any known Eimeria species (Jarvinen 2008).

5. Eimeria macusaniensis was mildly immunogenic because llamas excreted E. macusaniensis oocysts after reinoculation; in challenged llamas the prepatent period was longer (37–40 days versus 32–36 days after primary infection), patency was shorter (39–43 days versus 20–23 days after challenge) and fewer oocysts were excreted after challenge) (Rohbeck 2006).

Treatment

There are no anti-coccidial drugs approved specifically for camelids. Benzene acetonitrile compounds (ponazuril, diclazuril, toltrazuril), sulfonamides, and amprolium have been used to treat or prevent coccidiosis in camelids (Cebra et al. 2007, 2014; Ballweber 2009; Thomas and Morgan 2013; Franz et al. 2015).

Efficacy of various drugs for treating clinical coccidiosis is unknown. None of anticoccidials have any measurable effect on late stages of gamonts and oocysts that have been commonly related with clinical coccidiosis associated with E. macusaniensis and E. ivitaensis.

Treatment for coccidiosis included amprolium hydrochloride (10 mg/kg) in a 1.5% solution orally daily up to 15 days, or sulfadimethoxine (110 mg/kg) orally daily for 10 days, and supportive therapy. However, some camelids died despite this therapy and had confirmed coccidiosis histologically (Cebra et al. 2007). In one instance, an entire herd of 30 alpacas that developed coccidiosis 20 days after introduction to a new farm was treated with amprolium hydrochloride, two died and four were euthanized. Two of the four that died had histologically confirmed coccidiosis (Cebra et al. 2007).

The benzene acetonitrile compounds in general have low toxicity. They are used extensively to treat coccidiosis in camelids in countries where they are readily available in a convenient treatment form.

Prophylactic treatment should be considered during winter when outbreaks of coccidiosis are common. Decoquinate may be added to feed at 0.5 mg/kg/day for 4 weeks (Cebra et al. 2014).

In summary, therapeutic treatment for coccidiosis in South camelids needs validation.

Conclusion and prospective

It is evident from the above review that coccidiosis can be serious in captive camelids. Under free range/wild environment in South America, camelids can excrete numerous oocysts in feces without showing clinical signs. The pathogenesis of fatal coccidiosis is not fully understood, because even adult camelids can die suddenly, and animals can develop clinical signs long before oocysts are detected in feces. Whether there are differences in biology of Eimeria species in camelids in North America and South America needs further investigation. Among the five valid species of South American camelid Eimeria, E. macusaniensis appears to be most pathogenic. Only gamonts and oocysts have been confirmed in histological sections of intestines in cases associated with E. macusaniensis. There is need to investigate unknown endogenous stages of camelid coccidia. It appears that heavy parasitization of E. macusaniensis in crypts of ileum predisposes camelids to other enteric pathogens, particularly Clostridium perfrigens toxemia. There are no anticoccidial drugs specifically approved for use in camelids.