Vanadium: Risks and possible benefits in the light of a comprehensive overview of its pharmacotoxicological mechanisms and multi-applications with a summary of further research trends

Graphical abstract

Abstract

Background

Vanadium (V) is an element with a wide range of effects on the mammalian organism. The ability of this metal to form organometallic compounds has contributed to the increase in the number of studies on the multidirectional biological activity of its various organic complexes in view of their application in medicine.

Objective

This review aims at summarizing the current state of knowledge of the pharmacological potential of V and the mechanisms underlying its anti-viral, anti-bacterial, anti-parasitic, anti-fungal, anti-cancer, anti-diabetic, anti-hypercholesterolemic, cardioprotective, and neuroprotective activity as well as the mechanisms of appetite regulation related to the possibility of using this element in the treatment of obesity. The toxicological potential of V and the mechanisms of its toxic action, which have not been sufficiently recognized yet, as well as key information about the essentiality of this metal, its physiological role, and metabolism with certain aspects on the timeline is collected as well. The report also aims to review the use of V in the implantology and industrial sectors emphasizing the human health hazard as well as collect data on the directions of further research on V and its interactions with Mg along with their character.

Results and Conclusions

Multidirectional studies on V have shown that further analyses are still required for this element to be used as a metallodrug in the fight against certain life-threatening diseases. Studies on interactions of V with Mg, which showed that both elements are able to modulate the response in an interactive manner are needed as well, as the results of such investigations may help not only in recognizing new markers of V toxicity and clarify the underlying interactive mechanism between them, thus improving the medical application of the metals against modern-age diseases, but also they may help in development of principles of effective protection of humans against environmental/occupational V exposure.

1. Introduction

1.1. A general overview

With its unique features, vanadium (V) receives a great deal of attention from chemists, biologists, biochemists, toxicologists, and pharmacologists. The biological activity of this element has prompted investigations of many organic V complexes and its inorganic compounds in terms of their potential use in the treatment of certain diseases in humans. Studies carried out so far on V have shown that the bioactive complexes/compounds of this metal can be therapeutically active at low concentrations [1,2].

Taking into account the clear interest in the anti-viral, anti-bacterial, anti-parasitic, anti-fungal, anti-cancer, anti-diabetic, anti-hypercholesterolemic, cardioprotective, and neuroprotective activity of V and in the possibility of using this element in the treatment of obesity, the present review focuses on mechanisms underlying the pharmacological potential of this metal and obstacles to use it as a metallopharmaceutical in the future. Key information about the mechanisms of the toxicity, essentiality, physiological role, and metabolism of V is collected as well along with selected aspects illustrated on the timeline. The review paper also summarizes the available literature data on the use of V in the tissue engineering and industrial sectors with a brief description of the risk for human health. In addition, our report draws attention to the directions of further research on V and to interactions of this metal with other elements, especially those with antioxidant potential. Comprehensive research on the interactions of V with antioxidant elements (summarized graphically in a separate chapter of the present report) is particularly important in view of minimization of the adverse effects of V resulting from its strong toxicological/pro-oxidative potential.

1.2. Vanadium – background

Vanadium (V) is a part of the 4th period, Group 5 (VB), of the periodic table of elements. It is a transition element (with atomic number 23 and relative atomic weight of 50.94) capable of forming various compounds and functioning as an anion or a cation [3]. It exists in +2, +3, +4, and +5 oxidation states, most commonly in the tetravalent and pentavalent form [2] (Fig. 1 ). In body fluids and extracellularly, V predominates in the pentavalent form, usually as a vanadate anion (VO₃ ⁻). Conversely, intracellularly, it exists mainly in the tetravalent form, as a vanadyl cation (VO²⁺) (Fig. 1) associated, inter alia, with proteins [4]. It is estimated that about 1% of intracellular VO²⁺ occurs in an unbound form [5]. It is known that the form in which V exists in the cell depends on the ratio of the total pool of reducers to cellular oxidizers [4].

Fig. 1.

Vanadium and its most common forms. Based on available literature data cited in section 1.1.

1.3. Vanadium – a brief historical outline with a Polish accent on the timeline

As presented in Fig. 2 , vanadium was first discovered at the beginning of the 19th century, in 1801, by Spanish mineralogist Andrés Manuel del Río, who named it “erythronium” from the red color of the compound. However, the discovery was not attributed to him. Due to a mistake made in 1805 by one of the members of the Commission of the French National Institute in Paris, i.e. chemist Collet-Descostills, the discovery was not accepted. This was followed by a rediscovery of the element in 1830 by Swedish physician and chemist Nils Gabriel Sefström, who named it „vanadium” [6]. In Polish chemical literature, Radwański described this element for the first time in 1839 giving it a Polish name "wanad", which is still used [7].

Fig. 2.

Historical outline of vanadium discovery. V: vanadium. Based on available literature data cited in section 1.2.

1.4. Vanadium: a summarizing note about biological/industrial importance and pharmacological applications

Vanadium is ubiquitously detected in the environment - in soil, water, and air [8]. It plays an important biological role [4] and has a very wide area of applications, which are graphically summarized in Fig. 3 and described in the further subsections of the present report.

Fig. 3.

Industrial, biological, and pharmacological importance of vanadium. V: vanadium, NI: normal intake.

2. Vanadium – industry

As illustrated in Fig. 3, vanadium (V) is commonly used in many industries, especially in glass, paint, ceramic, photographic, chemical, electrochemical, and refining industries. It is also used in metallurgical industry for production of steel and non-ferrous alloys [1,9,10]. Vanadium-containing steel (with high hardness, strength, elasticity, and abrasion resistance) has been widely used as spring steel, tool steel, and high-speed steel. Currently, steel with the addition of V and V-containing non-ferrous alloys are used to build jet engines, machine parts (including construction equipment), as well as aircraft and automobile components. Non-iron alloys containing V are also used in space technology and nuclear power industry. Moreover, steel with V was well suited for production of armored fighting vehicles used during the Second World War [[11], [12], [13], [14], [15], [16]]. More details about V-containing steel and alloys, which were and still are used to produce various structural components of aircraft, weapon, rocket engines, etc., are summarized in the following table (Table 1 ).

Table 1.

Use of vanadium in certain industrial sectors.

Arm/military/other	Chemical composition of steel/alloy				References
	Elements	Content [%]	Vanadium	Content [%]
Steel with vanadium addition
Armored fighting vehicles
PzKw V (Panther) tank (Panzerkampfwagen V Panter)	C Cr	0.50 2.13	V	0.14	[17]
PzKw V (Panther) tank (Panzerkampfwagen V Panter)	C Cr	0.44 1.72	V	0.10	[18]
Panzerkampfwagen II (PzKpfw II)	C Cr Si Mo Cu Ni	0.40 1.3 0.25 0.50 0.18 trace	V	0.17	[19]
Combat aircraft/parts for aircraft and rockets/other
Alloys with vanadium addition
Ti-6Al-4V
Components parts for weapons and aircraft (engine parts, fasteners)	Ti Al	90 5.5−6.76	V	3.5−4.5	[12,13,14,15]
Ti-13V-11Cr-3Al
SR-71 Blackbird Component parts aircraft, missile applications	Ti Cr Al	∼75 10-12 2.5−3.5	V	12.5−14.5	[13,14,20]
Ti-3Al-2.5 V
Component parts for aircraft (pipes in hydraulic systems)	Ti Al	95.755-95.5 2.5−3.5	V	2−3	[13,14]
Ti-8Al-1Mo-1V
Component parts for aircraft (compressor blades)	Ti Al Mo	90 7.35-8.35 0.75-1.25	V	0.75−1.75	[14]
Ti-6Al-6 V-2Sn
Component parts for aircraft (jet engines), rocket engine housings, weapon components	Ti Al Sn	82.89-87.8 5−6 1.5-2.5	V	5−6	[14,20]
Ti-10V-2Fe-3Al
Component parts for aircraft (landing gear, parts responsible for take-off and landing)	Ti Al Fe	82.8-86.8 2.6-3.4 1.6-2.2	V	9.0−11.0	[12,13,14,16]
Ti-15 V-3Cr-3Al-3Sn
Component parts for aircraft (hulls, wires)	Ti Al Cr Sn	76 2.5−3.5 2.5−3.5 2.5−3.5	V	14−16	[13,14,16]
Ti-3Al-8V-6Cr-4Mo-4Zr
Component parts for aircraft (fasteners)	Ti Al Cr Mo Zr	75 3-4 5.5−6.5 3.5−4.5 3.5−4.5	V	7.5−8.5	[14,16]
Ti-3.5Al-5Mo-6 V-3Cr-2Sn-0.5Fe
Aerospace industry	Ti Al Mo Cr Sn Fe	∼86 3.5 5 3 2 0.5	V	6	[16]
Ti-5Al-5Mo-5 V-1Cr-1Fe
Aerospace industry	Ti Al Mo Cr Fe	∼88 5 5 1 1	V	5	[16]
Ti-5Al-5 V-5Mo-3Cr-0.5Fe
Aerospace industry	Ti Al Mo Cr Fe	∼86 5 5 3 0,5	V	5	[16]
Ti-5Al-5Mo-5 V-3Cr-1Zr
Aerospace industry	Ti Al Mo Cr Zr	∼86 5 5 3 1	V	5	[16]
Ti-5 V-5Mo-5Al-3Cr
Aerospace industry	Ti Mo Al Cr	∼87 5 5 3	V	5	[16]
Ti-3Al-8V-6Cr-4Zr-4Mo
Aerospace industry	Ti Al Cr Zr Mo	∼83 3 6 4 4	V	8	[16,20]

3. Vanadium – pharmacological aspect

As shown in Fig. 3, vanadium is also a potential candidate for therapeutic applications. Its anti-viral, anti-bacterial, anti-parasitic, anti-fungal, anti-cancer, anti-diabetic, and anti-hyper-cholesterolemic activity and cardioprotective, neuroprotective, and anti-obesity effects have been arousing interest of many research centers worldwide for many years. It has been reported that in human beings, pharmacologic amounts of V, i.e. 10 to 100 times higher than the normal intake, affect cholesterol and triglyceride metabolism, influence the erythrocyte shape, and stimulate hepatic glucose oxidation and glycogen synthesis [21]. In addition, V (in certain conditions) has been found to act as an antioxidant (Fig. 3), as evidenced in animal studies [[22], [23], [24], [25]]. More details about the mechanisms of the pharmacological activity of V are graphically illustrated and summarized in another part of the present report.

4. Vanadium – a physiological role: a summary of the most important issues

The research on certain aspects of the biological activity of V (presented in Fig. 4 ) has demonstrated an essential role of this element in the metabolism of carbohydrates (through the effects on the glycolysis, glycogenolysis, glycogenogenesis, and gluconeogenesis pathways), lipids (by stimulation of lipogenesis and inhibition of lipolysis), phospholipids, and cholesterol. The influence of V on bone mineralization, thyroid and erythrocyte metabolism, accumulation and transport of calcium in the cell, and the synthesis of secondary transmitters mediating in the transduction of intracellular signals is known as well. Furthermore, V also regulates the activity of key enzymes involved in the phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of proteins, kinases, and phosphatases, taking part not only in carbohydrate and lipid metabolism but also in cell proliferation and differentiation [1,2,4,26,27].

Fig. 4.

Role of vanadium in the mammalian organism. Based on available literature data cited in section 4.

5. Vanadium – a biphasic effect

5.1. Summarizing note with certain aspects of essentiality of V on the timeline

With its physiological duality, vanadium is essential in trace amounts (0.05 μM) and toxic in excess (>10 μM) [28,29] (Fig. 5 ). Its deficit and excessive concentrations can lead to a range of pathologies and cause irreversible damage to various tissues and organs.

Fig. 5.

Summary of positive and negative aspects of vanadium. AmDAssoc: American Dietetic Association. Based on available literature data cited in section 5.1 and other reports [[30], [31], [32], [33], [34]].

At low concentrations, V has been found to exert a beneficial effect on the growth and physiological functions of some microorganisms, plants, and fungi. The essentiality of this element has been demonstrated for bacteria (genus Azotobacter), cyanobacteria (genera Nostoc and Anabaena), certain algae (genera Scenedesmus, Chlorella, Fucus, and Bumilleriopsis), brown algae (Ascophyllum nodosum), fungi (genera Aspergillus, Culvularia, and Amanita), and lichens [[35], [36], [37]] (Fig. 5).

A positive effect of V on nitrogen (N) fixation (by Azotobacter) has been suggested by Bortels in 1933 (Fig. 6 ). In 1984 and in 1986, V turned out to be essential for the activity of certain enzymes [[42], [43], [44]] such as bromoperoxidase (BrOP), nitrogenases, and chloroperoxidase isolated from algae, nitrogen-fixing bacteria, and fungus Culvularia inaequalis, respectively [36,37,45] (Fig. 6).

Fig. 6.

Summary of selected aspects of vanadium toxicity/essentiality on the timeline. V: vanadium, N: nitrogen, V-BrPO: vanadium bromoperoxidase. Based on available literature data cited in section 5.1 and other reports; ^†after [33], **after [38], ^††after [39], *after [40], ^##after [41].

Furthermore, vanadium has also been recognized as essential for proper growth and development of certain animals [29,35]. The first suggestion about the essentiality of V for animals appeared in 1949, i.e. nearly 150 years after the first discovery of this metal [after 38] (Fig. 2). About 22 years later, in 1971, Schwarz and Milne, Hopkins and Mohr, and Strasia reported that V is necessary for rats and chicks (Fig. 6). In turn, in 1989, Anke and co-authors also reported that V is essential for goats (Fig. 6). In the meantime, in 1981, the first review about the physiological and biochemical effects of V was published (Fig. 6).

To date, symptoms of V deficiency have been described, inter alia, in birds, chickens, rats, guinea pigs, and goats [35,38,46]. The most substantive evidence for V essentiality was found in rats and goats [after 35]. On this basis, Nielsen and Uthus proposed considering vanadium as an essential trace element for proper growth and development of higher animals [38] In contrast, the essentiality of this metal for humans is unproven (Fig. 5), although some authors suggest that it is an essential trace element for man [38], mostly because vanadium has broad pharmacological activity, which points to the biological importance of this metal. The American Dietetic Association (AmDAssoc) considers V as essential in human nutrition [after 41] (Fig. 5). Nevertheless, no symptoms of V deficiency in humans have been described yet. The final proof for the essentiality of V for humans requires confirmation of the specific function of this element, as in the case of algae or fungi. However, it is definitely known that the high content of V in the environment and diet is harmful to animals and humans [1].

5.2. Summarizing note with certain aspects of toxicity of V on the timeline

As generally accepted, the toxicity of V is dependent on many different factors, including the composition of the diet, type of the V compound (inorganic/organic), nature of ligands attached to V complexes, valence, dose, route of entry of this metal into the organism, duration of action/exposure, and individual and species sensitivity (Fig. 7 ).

Fig. 7.

Summary of the mechanisms and factors of vanadium toxicity: vanadium; LPO: lipid peroxidation; ROS: reactive oxygen species; MRC: mitochondrial respiratory chain; OXPHOS: oxidative phosphorylation; M: mitochondrion; Cyt c: cytochrome c; PARP: poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase. Based on available literature data cited in section 5.2.

The history of research on the adverse effects of action of this metal dates back to 1876 when Priestly described toxicity of V in certain animals (Fig. 6). As regards animals, rabbits and guinea pigs were found to be more sensitive to this element than mice and rats [5,47,48] (Fig. 7). In turn, a classic paper about the toxic and pharmacologic action of vanadium was written in 1912 and analyses of the content of V in various organisms were initiated 18 years later in 1930 (Fig. 6).

It is known that, in some conditions, V can act as a strong pro-oxidant and interact synergistically with other oxidants enhancing oxidative stress [2,31,49], which in turn can result in many negative consequences including disintegration of cell membranes, denaturation of proteins, and degradation of DNA [50] (Fig. 7). It may also weaken the antioxidant barrier [49,[51], [52], [53]] and intensify lipid peroxidation (LPO) [49,[53], [54], [55], [56], [57], [58]] i.e. the free radical process underlying one of the mechanisms of cell damage [50] (Fig. 7). In addition, V can reduce the thiol status [49,59], release some transition metals [60], interact with other elements [49,53,61], and accumulate in certain internal organs including the liver and kidneys [46,56,[62], [63], [64]] evoking hepato- and nephrotoxic effects, respectively (Fig. 7). In higher concentrations, V can also act as a pro-apoptotic factor (by induction of oxidative stress) and lead to programmed cell death (apoptosis) with damage to mitochondrial membranes, cytochrome c (cyt c) outflow, and activation of caspases and poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) [5] (Fig. 7), which plays a role of a cell death promoting factor [65]. Disorders of the electron transport chain and oxidative phosphorylation resulting in a decrease in the level of ATP [1] are the other adverse effects of V action (Fig. 7).

The mechanisms of toxicity of V require further experimental work, as they have not been fully elucidated yet. Some of them have been reported to be implicated in the adverse effects of V action. For example, the mechanism by which V produces a reprotoxic effect is believed to be linked to oxidative stress [66] and/or actin cytoskeleton damage [67] (Fig. 7). It has been suggested that the hepatotoxic, nephrotoxic [48,62,[68], [69], [70], [71]], cardiotoxic [72], genotoxic [73,74], neurotoxic [72,75,76], and carcinogenic [48,77] effects of this metal as well as inflammatory and fibrotic changes in the lungs [78] are associated with the pro-oxidative potential of V and its ability to intensify LPO (Fig. 7). It is known that LPO products can stimulate the expression of oncogenes [79], which in turn can lead to transformation of normal cells into cancerous cells (Fig. 7). Epidemiological studies suggest that exposure to elevated levels of V may be a risk factor for cancer development [80]. Studies on an animal model have revealed a positive correlation between the frequency of neoplasia and susceptibility to V-induced inflammation [80], which is involved in the pathogenesis of many diseases (not only malignant diseases) and results from V-induced oxidative stress. In turn, long-lasting oxidative stress with simultaneous weakening of the antioxidant system (present in every living organism) can lead to permanent cell/tissue damage and, consequently, to initiation of the disease process. Therefore, the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) under oxidative stress (one of the main factors affecting morbidity) can lead to damage to DNA and, consequently, to initiation of carcinogenesis.

6. Vanadium – health hazards

6.1. Environmental/occupational exposure to V: the most important aspects

The risk for animal and human health related to exposure to V is largely dependent on the degree of its oxidation state. It has been highlighted that V at the highest oxidation state (+5) is the most toxic vanadium form [9]. One of the compounds of this metal, vanadium pentoxide (V₂O₅), which contains V at the highest oxidation state +5, has been reported to easily reach the alveolar surface, subsequently enter circulation directly, and diffuse in the entire organism inducing diverse injuries [9]. The risk of poisoning with the pentavalent V form is constantly growing due to its extensive release into the environment by metallurgical industry, chemical plants, oil refineries, and coal and mazut-fired heating plants [8,9,45,81]. Moreover, relatively high pollution of the environment with V₂O₅ is also caused by dust derived from the combustion of liquid and solid fuels as well as municipal waste [10,81], resulting in an increased risk of exposure of anyone who lives near such areas. Consequently, the level of this metal in the soil increases. In turn, higher concentrations of V in the soil lead to more intensive uptake of this metal being by plants due to the lack of a selective mechanism protecting plants against excessive absorption of the element. Thus, V can enter the animal and human organism via the food chain. Additionally, the lack of proper industrial wastewater management containing this metal can be another risk factor for animal and human health [9,82].

In the case of occupational exposure, workers repairing thermal power boilers and high-pressure combustion engines as well as those responsible for production of V₂O₅ and replacement of V-based catalytic converters are the most vulnerable to the most toxic pentavalent form of this metal [9]. In the literature, occupational exposure to V₂O₅ is described as the etiological factor of the asthmatic syndrome known as "boilermaker disease" [83].

6.2. Basic symptoms of exposure to V via inhalation and ingestion: a brief note

The most important symptoms of exposure to V via the oral route (presented in Fig. 8 ) include gastrointestinal disorders, abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, loss of appetite, weight reduction, and green-black tongue. In turn, the symptoms of exposure to this metal through inhalation (illustrated in the same Figure) include rhinitis, chest pain, pharyngitis, bronchitis, pneumonia, bradycardia, cough, dyspnoea, bronchial asthma, headache, dizziness, conjunctivitis, blurred vision, apathy, and depression [9,31,81,[84], [85], [86]].

Fig. 8.

Major symptoms of vanadium poisoning via ingestion and inhalation. Based on available literature data cited in section 6.2.

7. Vanadium - metabolism: a summary of key information

The most important issues of the metabolism of V and forms in which this metal is present in physiological fluids/tissues are collected in Fig. 9 . As illustrated, V consumption, which depends on the diet, is estimated to be around 15−20 μg/day (typical daily dose consumed by humans) or 10−60 μg/day (daily dose ingested by the U.S. population) [8,87]. After intake, vanadate (mainly as VO₄ ⁻) reaches the gastrointestinal (GI) tract and, in the acidic environment of the stomach, most of the anionic vanadate (absorbed more effectively than VO²⁺) is transformed into vanadyl (VO²⁺), precipitated to insoluble vanadyl hydroxides [VO(OH)₂] in the slightly alkaline medium of the intestine, and excreted with feces (∼94−98 %) [33,39]. In turn, resorbed V is removed from the organism through kidneys [87,88] probably in the form of unidentified complexes with high-(protein-bound) and low-molecular-weight species (VO²⁺-complexes) [38,89]. The level of V in urine is estimated to be around 12 % of the intake amount [87].

Fig. 9.

Summary of metabolism of vanadium and species of this metal in physiological fluids and tissues. V: vanadium, V⁵⁺: pentavalent vanadium, V⁴⁺: tetravalent vanadium, VO₄⁻/VO₃⁻: vanadate anion, VO²⁺: vanadyl cation, V*: exchangeable vanadium (‘free’), VO(OH)₂: insoluble vanadyl hydroxide, GSH: reduced glutathione, Hb: hemoglobin, RBC: erythrocytes, ALB: albumin, Tf: transferrin, IgG: immunoglobulin G, FER: ferritin, Citrate-T: citrate transporter, Lactate-T: lactate transporter, Organic-AT: organic anion transporter, LMMF: low molecular mass fraction, HMMF: high molecular mass fraction, TfF: transferrin fraction, HbF: hemoglobin fraction. Based on available literature data cited in section 7 and other reports [60,90,91].

As reported, the absorption of V from the GI tract is mainly estimated in the range of 0.2–2 %, although amounts greater than 10 % have been indicated to be absorbed as well (Fig. 9) [21,46,92,93]. Additionally, Sanchez et al. [94] found an absorption rate of V at the level of 52 % in rats treated with bis(maltolato)oxovanadium(IV) (BMOV, 6.22 mg/day) in drinking water for five weeks. It has been highlighted that such differences may be associated with several factors, inter alia, the diet composition and/or chemical form of ingested V [38]. After entering the bloodstream, 80–90 % of V is bound by albumin (ALB), which plays a pivotal role in the transport of various metals [95] or transferrin (Tf) (preferably), which is the main V transporter in the blood plasma [8,33]. Both Tf and ALB bind V in the 4+ and 5+ oxidation state [96].

It has been reported that V in the form of vanadyl (VO²⁺, tetravalent V⁴⁺ state) binds to Tf at the same binding site as the Fe³⁺ ion [97] and that V⁵⁺, for which the cationic form (dioxovanadium cation, VO₂ ⁺) has been indicated, also occupies the same pockets as Fe³⁺ [98]. Studies conducted by Azevedo et al. [99] have confirmed that both V⁴⁺ and V⁵⁺ can bind to apo-Tf and holo-Tf, thus they can be efficiently up-taken by cells through receptor-mediated endocytosis of Tf. In addition, Tf can bind V^III forming di-vanadium(III)-Tf [(V^III)₂-Tf], which can be up-taken by cells via receptor-mediated endocytosis as well [100]. It has also been reported that V species can enter cells via membrane citrate transporters, the lactate transporter, and the organic anion transporter (Organic-AT) [101]. Additionally, VO²⁺ can be up-taken via passive diffusion [102,103] and bound by immunoglobulin G (IgG) or low-molecular components of plasma such as phosphate, citrate, lactate, and oxalate [33,39,91,104,105]. In turn, V⁵⁺ ions such as H₂VO₄ ⁻/HVO₄ ^2- can enter cells through anion channels, i.e. phosphate or sulfate channels [106]. In cells, V⁵⁺ is reduced to VO²⁺ by some reducing substances such as ascorbic acid and thiol-containing cysteine [107]. For instance, in erythrocytes (RBC), V⁵⁺ is principally reduced by glutathione (GSH) to VO²⁺, which binds to hemoglobin (Hb) [108,109] (Fig. 9).

The total content of V in the organism of adults is about 100−200 μg (equivalent to the mean tissue concentration of about 40 nM) [6]. Half of this amount is located in bones, which are the major storage pool for long-term V accumulation and where vanadate can substitute phosphate in the mineral hydroxyapatite [Ca₁₀(PO₄)₆(OH)₂] [33,37,106] (Fig. 9). The other amount is mainly deposited in the liver, kidney, and spleen [108] due to the importance of these organs in detoxification of the organism and excretion of harmful substances. Muscles, lungs, and brain are the other sites of V accumulation [108] (Fig. 9). As regards V speciation, most of this metal in the liver is present in the transferrin and low-molecular mass fraction (TfF and LMMF, respectively) [108] as well as a vanadyl-ferritin [(VO2⁺)-FER] complex [26]. The FER-V and LMMF-V fractions have also been identified in the spleen [108]. In kidneys, V was divided between a high molecular mass fraction (HMMF) and LMMF; additionally, an exchangeable fraction of this metal has been indicated [108] (Fig. 7). In turn, large amounts of V in the lungs have been identified in the hemoglobin and Tf fraction (Hb-F and TfF, respectively) and in the readily exchangeable fraction [108] (Fig. 9).

8. Vanadium – medical aspect in a nutshell

8.1. Biomedical materials with vanadium

While discussing V in terms of its medical application, it has to be mentioned that this metal is applied in tissue engineering to obtain biomaterials that allow regeneration of damaged tissues/organs and restoration of their lost functions [110]. As presented in another subsection of this paper, V is part of metallic biomaterials (mainly titanium alloys), bioactive coatings (including polymeric coatings), and diamond-like layers applied to the surface of some titanium alloys in order to increase the bioactivity of implants and improve osseointegration [11].

8.1.1. Metallic biomaterials and bioactive coatings with vanadium

Two titanium alloys with V such as Ti-6Al-4 V and Ti-6Al-4 V ELI are used as biomedical materials, mainly in bone surgery, due to their good mechanical properties, very high resistance to corrosion, and biocompatibility [11] (Table 2 ). In addition, 2V-49Co-49Fe (named Permendur) is another vanadium-containing alloy. 2V-49Co-49Fe with 2 % of V is mainly used for production of devices supporting the work of the heart (Table 2) [11].

Table 2.

Vanadium-containing biomaterials and their use in medical devices.

Metallic biomaterials
Type of alloy	Percentage composition [%]			Application	Reference
Ti-6Al-4V	Ti 90	Al 6	V 4	hip joint replacement knee joint replacement dental implants (zygomatic implants), bridges/crowns, dental bridges orthodontic implants spine stabilizers trauma devices/bone fixation (intramedullary rods and nails, surgical screws/bone plates) encapsulation of cardiac pacemaker	[11,13,111,112,113,114,115,116,117,118,119]
Ti-6Al-4V ELI	Ti 90	Al 6	V 4	medical implants	[11,13]
Ti-3Al-2.5V	Ti 92.755−95.5	Al 2.5−3.5	V 2−3	dental implants hip and knee joint replacement (orthopedic implants) trauma devices (intramedullary rods)	[11]
Magnetic alloys
2V-49Co-49Fe (Permendur)	Co 49	Fe 49	V 2	devices supporting the work of the heart	[11]
Biocompatible coatings applied on metallic alloys
TiO2:nHA:Ag-Ti-6Al-4V SC-Ti-6Al-4V V-DLC	Ti 90 Al 6 V 4 Ti 90 Al 6 V 4 –			orthopedic/dental implants hip joint replacement trauma/orthopedic surgery	[11,120,121]
Polymeric composite biomaterials
Composition of polymeric coating	Properties			Application	Reference
V2O5/PLGA	antimicrobial activity			implant materials	[122]

Ti: titanium; Al: aluminum; V: vanadium, ELI: extra low interstitial (max. Fe: 0.14 %, max. O: 0.13 %). TiO₂:nHA:Ag-Ti-6Al-4V: titanium oxide-based coating containing hydroxyapatite nanoparticle and silver particles, SC-Ti-6Al-4V: surface-coated Ti-6Al-4 V, V-DLC: diamond-like layer with vanadium (DLC type carbon layer), V₂O₅: vanadium pentoxide; PLGA: (Poly)Lactide-co-Glycolide copolymer.

The presence of vanadium in biomedical materials requires our additional comment. Since implants made of titanium alloys (containing V) are exposed to body fluids, V may be released into surrounding tissues, exerting adverse effects. The fact that the implant surface has a significant impact on reactions that occur at the implant-tissue interface should also be taken into account. Therefore, the surface layer of the implant is often modified in order to induce a specific reaction of the tissue to the implant. In the case of some implants (e.g. orthopedic and dental implants), a surface with appropriate bioactivity and roughness is created to achieve rapid osseointegration and a durable connection between biomaterial and tissue [11].

As reported, layers with varied composition are often applied on the surface of metallic alloys in order to improve the biological activity of the implant and provide an additional barrier against the release of metals from metallic biomaterials [11]. For example, titanium oxide(TiO₂)-based coating containing nano-hydroxyapatite (n-HA) and silver particles (Ag) is applied on the Ti-6Al-4 V alloy (Table 2) [120]. The TiO₂: n-HA: Ag layers are used as bioactive coatings with antimicrobial properties to increase biological activity, osseointegration, and biochemical stability in implantable medical devices (Table 2).

Moreover, polymeric V-based coatings made of a (Poly)Lactide-co-Glycolide copolymer (PLGA) with antimicrobial activity (Table 2) [122] and a diamond-like layer including V (V-DLC) are also formed to be used as implant materials [11] (Table 2).

8.2. Vanadium as a potential drug in the treatment of certain modern-age diseases

Research on the pharmacological potential of V (in vitro and in vivo experimental models) has shown that some compounds/complexes of this element can be effective against: (a) viruses (including HIV-1 and HIV-2 immunodeficiency virus, dengue virus, SARS virus, and influenza virus) (Fig. 10 ) [33,123] responsible for acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), dengue fever, severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), and acute respiratory infection (influenza), respectively; (b) parasitic protozoa of the genus Trypanosoma responsible for American trypanosomiasis and African trypanosomiasis known as Chagas disease and sleeping sickness, respectively; protozoan parasites of the genera Leishmania and Entamoeba (Fig. 10) [39,45,[123], [124], [125], [126], [127], [128], [129]] responsible for the development of leishmaniasis and amoebiasis, respectively; (c) fungi from the genera Candida, Aspergillus, Trichophyton, and Microscopus (Fig. 10) [[130], [131], [132], [133], [134], [135]] responsible for the development of many fungal infections, and (d) gram-negative and gram-positive bacteria (Fig. 10) [26,123,124,[131], [132], [133],136,137] causing e.g. food poisoning, gastrointestinal and respiratory infections, typhoid fever, pneumonia, strep throat, tuberculosis, and skin diseases. It was also shown that certain V compounds/complexes may have anti-cancer, anti-diabetic, and anti-hypercholesterolemic activity and can act as cardioprotective and neuroprotective agents. More details about these issues along with relevant literature data are provided in sections 8.2.2.5 (anti-cancer), 8.2.2.6 (anti-diabetic), 8.2.2.7 (cardioprotective), 8.2.2.8 (neuroprotective), and 8.2.2.10 (anti-hypercholesterolemic activity). Moreover, the possibility of using this metal in prevention of obesity has been suggested as well [138] (Fig. 11 ).

Fig. 10.

Vanadium against certain viruses, bacteria, parasites, and fungi. Based on available literature data [26,33,39,45,[124], [125], [126], [127], [128], [129], [130], [131], [132], [133], [134], [135], [136], [137]].

Fig. 11.

Summary of the mechanisms of the pharmacological activity of vanadium. Anti-V, Anti-B, Anti-P, Anti-F, Anti-C, Anti-D, Cardio-P, Neuro-P, Anti−HC, and Anti-O: anti-viral, anti-bacterial, anti-parasitic, anti-fungal, anti-cancer, anti-diabetic, cardioprotective, neuroprotective, anti-hypercholesterolemic, and anti-obesity, respectively, CD4: CD4 receptor, CXCR-4: CXCR-4 chemokine co-receptor, RT: reverse transcriptase, Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase: sodium-potassium pump, ROS: reactive oxygen species, ERK: extracellular regulated kinase, MEK: ERK kinase activator, SAcP: acid phosphatase secreted by Leshmania, pRb: retinoblastoma protein, AS: antioxidant status, GSH: reduced glutathione, GSSG: disulfide glutathione, Top-IB: IB type topoisomerase, NEP: neutral endopeptidase, VO₄³⁻: vanadate ion, PO₄³⁻: phosphate ion, PTP: protein tyrosine phosphatase, Pi3K: phosphoinositide 3-kinase (phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase), Akt: protein kinase B (PKB), GLUT-4: glucose transporter type 4, PTK: tyrosine protein kinase, eNOS: endothelial nitric oxide synthase, NO: nitric oxide, FLIP: FLICE-inhibitory protein; Bim: Blc-2 interacting mediator of cell death; FasL: Fas ligand; breakD: breakdown; Ca: calcium; K: potassium, FKHR/FKHR1/AFX: class O members of the forkhead transcription factor family, PTP-1B: protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B; JAK2: Janus kinase 2; STAT3: signal transducer/activator of transcription 3; NPY: neuropeptide Y; PPARγ: peroxisome-activated receptor γ; C/EBPα: CCAAT-enhancer-binding protein α; LPL: lipoprotein lipase. ↓: decrease, ↑: increase, ↓: inhibition/inactivation, ↑: activation, ↑↑: hyperactivation, ⊣ blockade of expression,→: modulation. Based on available literature data cited in section 8.2 and other reports [[139], [140], [141], [142]].

8.2.1. Mechanisms of the pharmacological potential of vanadium

8.2.1.1. Mechanisms of the anti-bacterial activity of vanadium: a summarizing note

The mechanisms of antibacterial activity of V, which have not been fully elucidated yet, include: (a) inhibition of the activity of Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase (Fig. 11) [26,123,137,143], (b) generation of ROS (Fig. 11), (c) impact on transport of substrates (e.g. thymidine, uridine, leucine, glucose) into the cell through the bacterial cell membrane (Fig. 11) along with induction of potassium (K⁺) outflow from the cell [137], (d) interaction with topoisomerase type II (gyrase) (Fig. 11), which is necessary for the proper functioning of the genome and bacterial growth, with the ATP-binding site used as a target for antibacterial drugs [144,145], (e) interaction with DNA in an intercalative manner [133] resulting in modification of the DNA structure (unwinding, stiffening, and elongation of the double helix) with formation of an intercalative complex [146], (f) interaction with components of the cytoskeleton, which results in morphological alterations of bacterial cells thereby preventing proper division [137], and (g) other nonspecific mechanisms of action (Fig. 11), with emphasis on the better bioavailability of V complexes due to the presence of a specific ligand allowing the complex to penetrate the hydrophobic lipid-rich bacteria wall [acc. to 123, 124].

8.2.1.2. Mechanisms of the anti-viral activity of vanadium: a summarizing note

Most data in this area were obtained in in vitro studies of the influence of V on human immunodeficiency HIV-1/HIV-2 virus [33]. Some complexes of this element have been shown to inhibit the activity of viral reverse transcriptase (RT) [after33,123], which is responsible for the synthesis of DNA on the viral RNA matrix in the reverse transcription process facilitating integration of the viral DNA into the genome of the host cell. Thus, by inhibiting RT activity, vanadium blocks viral replication. Furthermore, the binding of V complexes to the CD4 molecule (present on the surface of T-helper cells) and the chemokine CXCR-4 co-receptor has been suggested as well (Fig. 11). This leads to blockage of the passage of the virus to the host cell [after 123], thereby preventing its multiplication and protecting against the development of infection.

8.2.1.3. Mechanisms of the anti-fungal activity of vanadium: a summarizing note

Among the mechanisms of the anti-fungal activity of V complexes which, likewise the mechanisms of the anti-bacterial and anti-viral activity of this metal have not been fully recognized yet, interactions with DNA by intercalation have been proposed [133]. Additionally, inhibition of biosynthesis of an important component of the fungal cell membrane, i.e. ergosterol [134] (Fig. 11), by affecting the expression of genes involved in the synthesis of this compound [135] have been suggested.

8.2.1.4. Mechanisms of the anti-parasitic activity of vanadium: a summarizing note

The mechanisms of the anti-parasitic activity of vanadium (against trypanosomiasis, amoebiasis, and leishmaniasis) mainly suggested in in vitro studies include: (a) intercalation of V complexes into DNA (Fig. 11) [after 123] (anti-tryposomal and anti-amoebiasis activity), (b) inhibition of the activity of phosphatases [125] (Fig. 11) due to the structural similarity of vanadate to phosphate [39,45]; these enzymes are involved in gluconeogenesis - a metabolic pathway necessary for the growth of Leishmania spp. [126], (c) inhibition of the activity of acid phosphatase (SAcP) (Fig. 11) [127], which is a virulence factor most commonly secreted by Leishmania during growth [128], and (d) activation of macrophage/Th1-type response with the release of ROS and pro-inflammatory cytokines (including IL-1β and IL-6) [129] capable of destroying intracellular pathogens [147] (activity against Leishmania).

8.2.1.5. Mechanisms of the anti-neoplastic activity of vanadium: a summarizing note

Among the mechanisms of the antitumor activity of V compounds/complexes, which still require further studies, intensified ROS generation (including iron-induced ROS following ferritin disintegration due to V action) is suggested [33] (Fig. 11). ROS production is commonly known to lead to disturbance in cellular metabolism and damage to lysosomes and mitochondria (critical for maintaining cellular homeostasis) [148], resulting in activation of caspases and apoptosis [123,149,150]. Inhibition of the cell cycle by hyperactivation of the Ras-Raf-MEK-ERK pathway is also proposed [after 123] (Fig. 11). This pathway activates inhibitors of cyclin-dependent kinases and thus maintains the retinoblastoma protein (pRb) in the hypophosphorylated form capable of blocking the cell cycle [151]. The involvement of V in suppressing neoplastic transformation through apoptotic signaling and/or cell cycle arrest has also been suggested by Chakraborty et al. [152] as based on evidence from animal studies. Moreover, focus is placed on: (a) interactions of V with the components of the spindle [123], (b) intercalation with DNA [33] (Fig. 11), (c) potentiation of anti-proliferative activity [136], (d) inhibition of the activity of IB topoisomerase (Top-IB) [153] (Fig. 11) capable of relaxing highly twisted DNA molecules [154], (e) inhibition of the activity of neutral endopeptidase (NEP) [155], which inactivates anticancer enkephalins [156], (f) modulation of phase I and/or II xenobiotic metabolizing enzymes [[157], [158], [159], [160]], and (g) alteration of antioxidant status (AS) [158,160,161] (Fig. 11). A reduction in the GSH/GSSG ratio [153] (Fig. 11), which can lead to intensification of oxidative stress in the cell [49], is highlighted as well. Additionally, some V compounds have been reported to be able to counteract tumor metastasis [155].

Much attention is still focused on studies of the design of V compounds for cancer treatment, as evidenced by recently published articles. However, all V compounds/complexes (used in these studies) were mainly tested in different cell lines, not in vivo conditions (in an animal model). For example, the results from a study conducted by Ni et al. [162] showed that certain multidentate oxovanadium(IV) complexes have promising anti-cancer activity against human HepG2 and SMMC-7721 hepatocellular carcinoma cells. One of these compounds exhibited much more potent anti-tumor properties and turned out to be less toxic to normal human cells than the cisplatin complex. It suppressed tumor cell proliferation by causing cell cycle arrest and directly induced apoptosis in a dose-dependent manner. As emphasized by the authors, structural elements (i.e. metal components, variations of the coordination mode, labile water molecules, and chelated ligands) probably exert an essential cooperative effect on the anti-tumor activity. Another in vitro study demonstrated that V as oxido-vanadium(IV) complex [VOL(bipy)] was able to induce early apoptosis more efficiently in the HepG2 cell line than in normal L929 cells [163]. Moreover, the authors revealed that the rates of necrosis/late apoptosis were also induced in the HepG2 cells more potently than in the L929 cells. Based on these results, they suggested that the VOL(bipy) complex can be considered as a new strategy for treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma. In addition, they hypothesized (on the basis of studies conducted by other researchers) that the VOL(bipy) complex may be modified by co-application with an antioxidant to be safer than the administration thereof alone. In turn, a study reported by Kowalski et al. [164] revealed that oxidovanadium(IV) coordination complexes containing a 2-methylnitrilotriacetate ligand are good candidates for preclinical development of novel anticancer drugs targeting pancreatic cancer. As suggested, the molecular mechanisms of cytotoxicity of these complexes were dependent on generation of ROS and cell cycle arrest in the G2/M phase with simultaneous activation of the p53/p21 pathway. An earlier study conducted by the same author [165] showed a selective cytotoxic effect of V complexes containing phenanthroline and quinoline as organic ligands against a human pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma cell line (PANC-1). The results from this work revealed that V complexes caused cell cycle arrest in the G2/M phase and induced a significant increase in ROS generation in a time- and concentration dependent manner. In addition, at a higher concentration, V complexes induced a mixed type of cell death in PANC-1 cells, including apoptotic and necroptotic processes [165]. The authors emphasize that the type of cell death induced by V complexes is mainly determined by ligands and recommend further studies supporting the therapeutic potential of V in pancreatic cancer treatment. In turn, data from another research group [166], who examined the effect of a substituent in the hydrazone ligand of a family of μ-oxidodivanadium(v) hydrazone complexes on the structure, DNA binding, and anticancer activity, have revealed that V complexes exhibited promising anti-cancer activity against SiHa cervical cancer cells. Their experiments demonstrated that these complexes acted in an apoptotic mode and were non-toxic to the normal T293 cell line [166]. More recently, the anticancer properties of a family of vanadium(V) complexes with a diaminotris(phenolato) chelating ligand have been explored by Reytman et al. [167], who demonstrated their promising in vitro efficacy against HT-29, OVCAR-3, A2780, A2780cis, and A2780adr cells. In addition, a new promising effect of V compounds involving oncolytic viruses and their potential to combat cancer has recently been suggested. The authors reported that the infection of oncolityc viruses in resistant tumor cell lines was enhanced by V compounds [168]. As emphasized, this is of particular interest because it offers new opportunities for the development of strategies for the treatment of cancer.

8.2.1.6. Mechanisms of the anti-diabetic activity of vanadium with a historical outline of issues related to its anti-diabetic effects: a summarizing note

One of the mechanisms suggested for the insulin-like effect of V is linked to the inhibitory action of this element on the activity of protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTP) [123] (Fig. 11). This effect results from the antagonism related to the structural similarity of vanadate anions (VO₄ ³⁻) to phosphate anions (PO₄ ³⁻) [39,45]. By inhibition of protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B (PTP-1B) responsible for inactivation of the insulin receptor (INS-IR), which plays a key role in glucose metabolism, vanadium contributes to activation of the receptor presumably by preventing dephosphorylation of tyrosine phosphorylated residues of the beta subunit of INS-IR [169]. This in turn activates the PI3K-Akt pathway (3-phosphatidylinositol kinase (PI3-K)/Akt protein kinase) responsible for the metabolism of carbohydrates and lipids [2] and thus leads to potentiation of insulin-induced signal transduction. In consequence, the transport of glucose into cells increases [39] (Fig. 11). The inhibitory effect of ROS (generated by V compounds) on the activity of PTP-1B is also proposed [170] (Fig. 11). In addition, vanadium (a) causes an increase in the number of glucose-type 4 (GLUT-4) transporters in the cell membrane [171] (Fig. 11), which allows glucose molecules to be transported to adipocytes and muscle cells [172], (b) affects the insulin-like growth factor receptor (IGF-IR) by inactivation of associated PTP, (c) activates receptor and non-receptor protein tyrosine kinases (PTK), (d) stimulates glycogenogenesis, and (e) inhibits glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis [172,173] (Fig. 11). It has also been highlighted that the interaction with membranes may be important in the stabilization of V complexes, and structural changes in membrane proteins may contribute to their insulin-mimetic mechanisms and toxicities [102].

As illustrated in Fig. 12 , the first report describing certain effects of V action in patients with diabetes mellitus (DM) appeared in 1899. Some 80 years later, Tolman and co-workers [175] demonstrated that V can directly influence glucose (GLU) metabolism and suggested that it may play a role in the regulation of GLU in vitro. Over the same period, other authors reported that V in the form of vanadate and vanadyl can stimulate GLU oxidation in rat adipocytes [176,177]. In turn, in 1985, Heyliger et al. [178] described the antidiabetic properties of V in vivo for the first time. Since then, the number of experiments (in an animal model) in which some V compounds (i.e. vanadyl sulfate - VOSO₄, VS; sodium metavanadate - NaVO₃, SMV; sodium orthovanadate - Na₃VO₄) were used as potential antidiabetic drugs has been constantly growing. For example, in 1987, Meyerovitch and co-investigators [179] reported that V is able to normalize the blood GLU level (in vivo model) (Fig. 12). Besides, other authors described the use of V in diabetes mellitus (DM) (Fig. 12). In 2000, one of the organic V compounds, i.e. bis(ethylmaltolato)oxovanadium(IV) (BEOV) first synthesized in the late 1990s [180] was used in the first phase I clinical trial in non-diabetic volunteers (Fig. 12). A few years later, in 2007/08, the same V compound was used in a phase IIa trial in seven type 2 diabetic subjects [180,181] (Fig. 12). However, in 2009, the diabetes program was ceased (Fig. 12). Akesis Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (in January 21, 2009) announced it has discontinued its sole clinical development program for AKP-020, a Phase IIa drug candidate for the treatment of diabetes mellitus [182]. As reported, the renal changes resulting from the doses used in the preclinical safety program were the cause of this decision [174] (Fig. 12). Vanadium is well-known to be nephrotoxic in vivo. Data on the effects of this metal on the animal kidney are available in the literature. For example, a study conducted by De la Tore et al. [183] showed that certain markers of nephrotoxicity such as the serum creatinine and urea levels as well as the urinary creatinine concentration increased and decreased, respectively after V administration, compared to the V-untreated animals. The creatinine clearance was also found to be lowered in the V-supplied rats [183]. Moreover, V-induced morphologic changes in the kidney and a significant influence of age on the renal effects of this metal were observed as well [183]. All those findings gave rise to the following statement: “the obtained results can be of concern if in the future, vanadium compounds can be administered in the treatment of diabetic patients” [183]. In addition, another study in rats demonstrated V-induced kidney fibrosis [184] at glomerular tuft, preglomeruli, pretubules, and interstitium (cortex and medulla) [185]. In turn, an earlier study conducted by Boscolo et al. [186] also showed alterations in the urinary excretion of certain electrolytes in rats chronically treated with V.

Fig. 12.

Summary of the most important aspects related to vanadium anti-diabetic effects on the timeline. V: vanadium, DM: diabetes mellitus, GLU: glucose, INS: insulin, BEOV: bis(ethylmaltolato)oxovanadium(IV). ↓: decrease. Based on available literature data cited in section 8.2.2.6 and other reports; **after [34], ^#after [174].

Vanadium compounds/complexes are generally known to exhibit INS-mimetic properties through which they are involved in the regulation of GLU metabolism. As illustrated on the timeline (Fig. 13 ), vanadyl sulfate (VS) was one of the inorganic V forms most often used in studies with diabetic patients. Overall, the history of these studies dates back to 1995 when Cohen and co-workers [187] conducted the first trials on the effects of VS in patients with non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM). In 1996, Halberstam et al. [188] and Boden et al. [189] also used VS in NIDDM patients (Fig. 13). In turn, sodium metavanadate (SMV) was administered in patients with NIDDM and in those with insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) by Goldfine et al. [190,191]. The researchers used VS in studies with NIDDM patients in 2000 [192] (Fig. 13). In the subsequent years, i.e. in 2001 [193], 2008 [194], and 2013 [195], VS was applied in studies with NIDDM, obese, and IDDM patients, respectively (Fig. 13).

Fig. 13.

Summary of trials with inorganic vanadium compounds used in diabetic patients on the timeline. V: vanadium, VS: vanadyl sulfate, SMV: sodium metavanadate, NIDDM: noninsulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, IDDM: insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus, Over-W: over-weight, wk: weeks, mo: months. Based on available literature data cited in section 8.2.2.6.

It has been estimated that the dose of V capable of normalizing the GLU level in the blood of rodents is about 100 mg V/kg/day (at the level of V in the blood within the range of 10–20 μM). The same effect in humans was achieved at a dose of 1.5 mg V/kg/day (at the level of V in the blood within the range of 1–5 μM) [30] (Fig. 14 ).

Fig. 14.

Vanadium doses in normalization of glucose in rodents and humans. V: vanadium, GLU: glucose. Based on available literature data cited in section 8.2.2.6.

To sum up, the highest scientific interest was devoted to studies on the potential use of vanadium in the treatment of diabetes, which is related to its antidiabetic properties. Positive results of administration of V compounds were demonstrated both in diabetic animals and in human patients. With regard to various animal models of diabetes, many reports in this research area have been published and there are ongoing studies focused on this issue, as evidenced by the works by Adam et al. [196] and Krośniak et al. [197]. Briefly, Adam’s research group focused on the synthesis of a new anti-diabetic complex containing vanadium(IV) and vitamin A. The authors showed a reduced blood glucose level, a lowered creatinine concentration, and a decrease in the activity of glutamate-pyruvate transaminase (GPT) in the serum of diabetic mice treated with a V(IV)-vitamin A complex, compared to the untreated diabetic mice group. In turn, data from mouse studies conducted by Krośniak et al. [197], in which the influence of eight new V compounds on organs mass were tested, revealed that V complexes had a remarkably different effect on organ weight despite the similar composition and the same co-ligand. As stressed by the authors, this may point to separate metabolic pathways of these compounds in the body and a role of tridentate L Schiff base ligands. More recently, a report has been published by Szklarzewicz et al. [198] showing studies that compared V complexes with diverse structures and correlated them with their properties. The investigators synthesized three new complexes of this metal (at three different oxidation levels; III, IV, and V) with Schiff base ligands showing differences in the coordination of the metal with the ligand in order to compare their physicochemical and spectroscopic properties as potential antidiabetic drugs.

As far as application of V in diabetic patients is concerned, this may be a considerable problem and may pose a risk of toxicity, as this element is highly toxic and is able to accumulate and interact with other metals. A summary of its serious side effects, including tissue V accumulation in experimental animals (in rats with diabetes) treated with this metal orally, was reviewed in the work by Domingo et al. [62]. Other reports by Domingo [48,199] provided a summary of side effects derived from the oral administration of V compounds observed in diabetic patients. As known, such diseases as diabetes mellitus or cancer are chronic diseases requiring chronic treatment; therefore, as emphasized by the author, the long-term/chronic administration of V may be unavoidable and can lead to long-term side effects resulting from significant tissue V accumulation. Thus, the toxicity of V that could derive from the chronic treatment with this element is of particular concern. Hence, researchers [174,199] question the legitimacy of the possible application of V in oral diabetes therapy (Fig. 13). Moreover, as stressed by some investigators [168], it also has to be kept in mind that diabetes mellitus is sometimes characterized as a metabolic disease with which patients live for many years; therefore, low toxicity of potential drugs should be of particular concern.

8.2.1.7. Mechanisms of the cardio-protective action of vanadium: a summarizing note

The results of previous studies on both organic and inorganic V compounds have shown that this element can act as a cardioprotective agent. It may protect the heart against ischemia-reperfusion injury, prevent hypertension and hypertrophy of myocardium, and improve heart performance [200]. Inhibition of PTP activity and activation of the 3-phosphatidylinositol kinase (PI3-K)/Akt protein kinase signaling pathway (PI3K-Akt) have been proposed as mechanisms responsible for V-induced cardioprotection [200] (Fig. 11). Akt, known as protein kinase B (PKB), is responsible for the phosphorylation of many different proteins involved in basic cellular processes such as proliferation, growth, migration, and metabolism [201] and plays an important role in the regulation of myocardial hypertrophy and in angiogenesis [acc. to 33]. Activation of the PI3K-Akt pathway results in the phosphorylation of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) responsible for catalyzing nitric oxide (NO) production (Fig. 11). In turn, as an initiator and mediator of cardioprotection, NO has anti-hypertrophic activity and plays an important role in the regulation of vasorelaxation [202,203]. Diffusion of NO from the endothelium to vascular smooth muscle activates cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP), which inhibits the influx of Ca²⁺ ions into the cell and/or the activity of the calcium pump (Ca²⁺-ATPase) and activates potassium channels leading to vasodilation [202]. Furthermore, stimulation of glucose transport by the influence of V on the GLUT-4 glucose transporters (Fig. 11), resulting in normalization of their level in myocardial cells [204], is another mechanism of the V cardioprotective action [200] proposed in studies conducted on rats with pharmacologically induced diabetes. In addition, vanadium (as vanadate, which shows pro-hypertensive properties) [186] can induce vascular smooth muscle contraction (acting as a vasoconstrictive agent) by increasing the intracellular calcium (Ca²⁺) concentration [205] (Fig. 11). In vivo studies carried out on smooth muscle (isolated from guinea pig's airways) [206] have shown that the inhibition of the activity of the sodium-potassium pump (Na⁺/K⁺-ATPase) by this element [143] does not seem to be linked to the mechanism responsible for smooth muscle contractility [206]. A vasoconstrictive effect has also been demonstrated for vanadyl, for which a different mechanism of action was suggested, compared to that proposed for vanadate [207]. In addition, vanadium as vanadyl may also have an anti-hypertensive effect, as demonstrated by studies conducted on spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) and in those with hypertension induced by a fructose-rich diet (FHR rats) receiving vanadyl sulfate (VOSO₄) or bis(maltolato)oxavanadium(IV) (BMOV) [[208], [209], [210]].

8.2.1.8. Mechanisms of the neuro-protective action of vanadium: a summarizing note

In terms of mechanisms underlying the neuroprotective effects of V, it has been speculated that this element activates the PI3K-Akt signaling pathway (survival signals) by inhibiting PTP, thereby inactivating forkhead box class O (FOXOs) family members (such as FKHR, FKHRL1, AFX) and finally resulting in suppression of expression of apoptosis-inducing factors such as Bim and Fas ligands (FasL). It has also been assumed to activate extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) [[211], [212], [213], [214], [215]] (Fig. 11)

8.2.1.9. Involvement of vanadium in the mechanisms of appetite regulation in terms of anti-obesity effects: a summarizing note

In vivo studies in a rodent model (on rats) have shown that V administered in the form of BMOV leads to an increase in the intake of V and a decrease in the water and food intake, body weight, and serum leptin (LEP) concentration (LEP_S) [216] (Fig. 15 ). The influence of this metal on the signaling pathway through LEP (JAK2/STAT3 pathway) [217,218] was suggested as a mechanism underlying these changes [216] (Fig. 15).

Fig. 15.

Mechanism of vanadium-induced weight loss – in vivo studies. V: vanadium, LEP: leptin, LEP_S: the concentration of leptin in the serum, LEP-R: leptin resistance, Hyper-LEP: hyperleptynemia, LEP-S: leptin sensitivity, INS: insulin, INS-R: insulin resistance, INS-S: insulin sensitivity, NPY: neuropeptide Y, PTP-1B: protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B, JAK2: Janus kinase 2, STAT3: signal transducer/transcription factor, IRS: insulin receptor tyrosine kinase substrate ↓: decrease, ↑: increase, ↓: activity/pathway blockade, ↑: activation, ↓: signal blockade. Based on available literature data cited in section 8.2.2.8.

It is believed that the increase in the activity of PTP-1B blocks Janus tyrosine kinase 2 (JAK2), i.e. a substrate for PTP-1B [219,220], resulting in blockage of leptin signaling (JAK2/STAT3) and cascades of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3-K) involved in the signaling pathway of both insulin (INS) and leptin (LEP) [220,221] (Fig. 15). Therefore, the signal from INS and LEP is blocked (Fig. 15). In turn, by inhibition of the activity of PTP-1B [222], vanadium leads to activation of the JAK2/STAT3 leptin signaling pathway [217,218] (Fig. 15) and thus inhibits the synthesis of neuropeptide Y (NPY) and its release in the hypothalamus. Consequently, appetite, body fat mass, and body weight are reduced [221,223] (Fig. 15). There is also an increase in leptin (LEP-S) and insulin (INS-S) sensitivity and a decrease in insulin (INS-R) and leptin (LEP-R) resistance [138,218,220,224] (Fig. 15). INS-R (which causes disturbances in the synthesis of lipoproteins and their changes in blood plasma) [225] along with LEP-R and LEP-R-related hyperleptinemia (Hyper-LEP) have been reported to be significant risk factors of hypertension, type II diabetes, dyslipidemia, atherosclerosis, and cardiovascular diseases [138,226,227] (Fig. 15). Thus, by affecting the activity of PTP-1B, V induces the JAK2/STAT3 signaling pathway, which improves sensitivity to LEP and INS and makes this element (as suggested) useful for treating obesity [138,217,218]. An increase in INS-S was found in diabetic rats receiving vanadyl sulfate (VOSO₄) for 30 days [228] and in type I and II diabetes patients after administration of sodium metavanadate (NaVO₃) for 2 weeks [190].

Noteworthy is also the fact that, through its direct influence on the organization of membrane lipids and cholesterol/sphingolipid-rich microdomains (where proteins involved in signal transduction are concentrated, e.g. the INS receptor), V enhances the effects caused by INS and, consequently, results in INS-R reduction [229]. A decrease in INS-R was demonstrated in obese rats (fa/fa Zucker rats) receiving V in the form of an organic derivative BMOV for 6 weeks [230] and in hypertensive rats chronically treated with VOSO₄ [209]. Both V compounds were administered in drinking water.

8.2.1.10. Mechanisms of the anti-hypercholesterolemic activity of vanadium: a summarizing note

The mechanism of the anti-hypercholesterolemic action of V is related to the effect of this element on the cholesterol biosynthesis pathway shown in Fig. 16 . In vitro studies have demonstrated that V can inhibit the synthesis of this steroid [231] by blocking the utilization of mevalonate [232,233], which is formed from 3-hydroxy-3-methyl-glutaryl-coenzyme A (3-HMG-CoA) in a reaction catalyzed by HMG-CoA reductase and further transformed into isopentenyl-5-pyrophosphate (IPP) in phosphorylation/decarboxylation reactions [234] (Fig. 16I). An increase in the catabolism of cholesterol by V is another possible mechanism of action of this element [235] (Fig. 16I).

Fig. 16.

Cholesterol biosynthesis pathway with probable sites of vanadium action (I) along with changes in the lipid profile in humans occupationally exposed to vanadium (II) and in diabetic patients receiving inorganic vanadium salts (III). CoA: coenzyme A, 3-HMG-CoA: 3-hydroxy-3-methyl-glutaryl-CoA, IPP: isopentenyl-5-pyrophosphate, GPP: geranyl-pyrophosphate, FPP: farnesyl-pyrophosphate, C: cholesterol, HDL: high-density lipoproteins, LDL: low-density lipoproteins, HDL-C: HDL cholesterol, ApoA-I: apolipoprotein A, TC: total cholesterol, LDL-C: LDL cholesterol, ApoB: apolipoprotein B, VOSO₄: vanadyl sulfate, NaVO₃: sodium metavanadate. Based on available literature data cited in section 8.2.2.9.

The impact of V on stimulation of the lipoprotein lipase (LPL) activity has been highlighted as well [29,236]. The LPL enzyme controls many metabolic processes, e.g. it participates in the metabolism of lipids and lipoproteins [237]. Thus, any disorders in its proper functioning (during INS-R) [211] result in development of atherosclerosis, obesity, and type II diabetes [237].

Unfavorable changes have been found in the lipid profile of individuals that are occupationally exposed to V (working in production of V-containing steel) (Fig. 16II). There was an increase in the levels of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) and apolipoprotein A (Apo-AI, main HDL apolipoprotein) in the serum and a decrease in such atherogenic indices as TC/HDL-C, LDL-C/HDL-C, and ApoB/ApoA-I [238] (Fig. 16II). A decrease in cholesterol and/or low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) have also been found in the serum of type II diabetes patients after 6 weeks of administration of VOSO₄ [192,193] and in type I and II diabetes mellitus patients after 2-week treatment with sodium metavanadate (NaVO₃) [191] (Fig. 16III).

A reduced cholesterol level has been demonstrated in the blood of healthy rats receiving V₂O₅ (0.56 mg V₂O₅/kg) once a month for 12 months [78], in obese rats (fa/fa Zucker rats) treated with sodium orthovanadate (Na₃VO₄, 0.8 mg/mL) in drinking water for 4 months [239], and in diabetic rats receiving VOSO₄ (0.75 mg/mL, 1 mg/mL, 1.1 mg/mL or 0.5 mmol/kg/day) [[240], [241], [242], [243]], sodium metavanadate (NaVO₃, 0.20 mg/mL), sodium orthovanadate (Na₃VO₄, 0.50 mg/mL) [241], or organic V complexes such as V5dipic-NH2 (0.1 mg/mL) [244] or bis(curcumino)oxavanadyl (BCOV, 0.05, 0.1 or 0.2 mmol/kg/day) [243] in drinking water for different periods (20 days, 2, 4, and 10 weeks, or 5 months). In turn, a decrease in the level of triglycerides (TG) in the blood was found: (a) in obese rats (fa/fa Zucker rats) receiving Na₃VO₄ (0.8 mg/mL) in drinking water for 4 months [239], (b) in obese non-diabetic Zucker fatty rats (ZF) and diabetic Zucker fatty rats (ZDF) after administration of organic (maltolic) vanadium derivatives, i.e. bis(maltolato)oxovanadium(IV) (BMOV, 0.19 mmol/kg/day, in drinking water) and bis(ethylmaltolato)oxovanadium(IV) (BEOV, 0.1 mmol/kg/day, with a probe), respectively, for 3 weeks [245], and (c) in diabetic rats receiving VOSO₄ [240,[242], [243], [244]], V5dipic-NH2 [244], or BCOV [243]. BCOV has also been shown to reduce the serum LDL level significantly in these animals [243].

9. Vanadium - important research trends

9.1. Research on non-elucidated mechanisms

Given the increasing practical application of V in medicine and the fact that accumulation of this metal in certain internal organs/tissues during the treatment of chronic diseases may be a significant problem, it is still advisable to carry out studies on V toxicity and mechanisms of its toxic action (Fig. 17 ). It is also necessary to study the pharmacological activity of V as well as the mechanisms of absorption and excretion thereof. Moreover, the mechanisms of transport of V to target organs and its uptake by cells as well as the in vivo form of this metal and its influence on the immune system deserve further exploration (Fig. 17). The mechanisms of immune response upon V exposure should also be better clarified. Additionally, comprehensive research on the interactions of V with other elements is needed as well (Fig. 17).

Fig. 17.

Vanadium-associated issues – deserving more in-depth investigations.

9.2. Research on the interactions with elements having antioxidant potential: magnesium

Metal interactions affecting the cell metabolism, action of organs and, consequently, the function of the entire organism is still an important issue in toxicology, pharmacology, and medicine. Therefore, examination of the consequences, character, and mechanisms of interactions of V (which raises hopes for the use thereof in the treatment of certain diseases in humans) with elements, especially those with antioxidant potential, in an in vivo experimental model are still a current and vital issue. Moreover, considering the well-known pro-oxidant properties of V, the fact that the increased generation of ROS and oxidative stress play a crucial role in V-induced toxicity, and the suggestions of other authors that the hepatotoxic, nephrotoxic, cardiotoxic, genotoxic, neurotoxic, and carcinogenic effects of this metal as well as inflammatory and fibrotic changes in the lungs are associated with its redox-active nature and ability to intensify LPO (see Fig. 7), detailed investigations to evaluate the consequences of possible interactions of V with antioxidant elements during combined chronic treatment are even more desirable. This aspect is also important in the context of occupational exposure and growing environmental pollution with V.

The results of studies conducted in a rodent model by Ścibior et al. [57] showed protective action of Mg against the pro-oxidant activity of V. They also provided evidence that the beneficial Mg-induced limitation of the increase in the hepatic LPO during the administration of V may result from the independent action of Mg and from the antagonistic interaction with V. These effects were observed when healthy rats were exposed to V (as SMV) at the concentration of 0.125 mg V/L with supplementation with Mg (as MS at the concentration of 0.06 mg Mg/mL) for 18 weeks. However, further studies are needed to explain the exact mechanism(s) accounting for the protective effect of Mg (at the dose used) against the V-induced oxidative stress in the liver. The other findings reported by Ścibior et al. [52] demonstrated a markedly reduced level of LPO in the bone of healthy rats supplemented with Mg (as MS) during the 12-week SMV exposure (0.125 mg V/mL). These changes, as those mentioned previously for the liver, were also influenced by the independent action of Mg and by its antagonistic interaction with V. Moreover, the distinct trend toward the antagonistic interaction between V and Mg was revealed with regard to the level of LPO in the erythrocytes of healthy rats exposed to SMV (0.125 mg V/mL) during 12-week MS supplementation (0.06 mg Mg/mL) [53]. It should be added that the concentration of V mentioned above was selected based on earlier studies conducted by other researchers [[246], [247], [248], [249], [250]] who tested similar V concentrations in a rat model as well as reports of the levels of this metal in the blood and urine of occupationally exposed people [251,252], which were comparable with those noted in SMV-exposed rats. Based on the results obtained, it can be concluded that the issues related to the interactions of V with Mg (as one of the elements with antioxidant potential) are important not only for extending the knowledge of the mechanism of the effect of V on the organism. They are also essential to improve the understanding of the role of Mg in prevention of V toxicity and clarify the mechanisms underlying the potential protective action of this bioelement in V poisoning. This is even more relevant in view of the fact that long-lasting oxidative stress with simultaneous weakening of the antioxidant system can lead to permanent cell/tissue damage and, consequently, to initiation of the disease process. In addition, the examination of the combined V-Mg effects in mammalian organisms may also be helpful for the future safe use of V in medicinal applications. Undisputed is the fact that recognition of doses of elements showing synergistic/antagonistic action towards each other may play a role in both medicine and pharmacology. However, although some studies cited above reveal that supplementation with Mg during V exposure has beneficial effects reflected in reduction of the level of LPO in certain cells/tissues of healthy rats, further studies (in other animal models) have to be conducted to recognize whether the antagonistic effects of Mg on pharmacological amounts of V will allow V to exert beneficial effects, or whether their synergistic actions yield beneficial effects at lower amounts of V. Some time ago, Matsuda et al. [253] demonstrated for the first time that V and Mg administered in combination as SMV (0.3 mg/mL) and MS (0.3 mg/mL), respectively, to diabetic rats in drinking water for 3 weeks had a synergistic effect, as they augmented whole-body insulin sensitivity and glycogen synthesis. Based on these findings, the authors suggested a potential role for combination therapy with trace elements in type 2 diabetes mellitus and other insulin-resistant states. Diabetes is accompanied by changes in the level of Mg in tissues [254] and by weakening of the antioxidant barrier [255] and oxidative stress [256]. With regard to this issue, Sanchez et al. [94] showed that treatment with V of Mg-deficient rats corrected many alterations generated by Mg deficiency. Subsequently, Bermúdez-Peña et al. [257] evaluated whether V treatment might affect alterations in Mg metabolism associated with diabetes. The authors revealed the existence of interplay or other interactions between both elements in diabetic rats. As they stressed, these results might help to clarify the role of V as an anti-diabetic agent.

The existing literature comprises a few articles about the interactions between V and Mg [[51], [52], [53],57,63,94,253,[257], [258], [259], [260]], which has been reported to be able to protect against the harmful effects of ROS [[261], [262], [263], [264]]. A summary of data about the interactions between both metals (demonstrated to date in relation to parameters investigated in a rodent model) is presented in Fig. 18 .

Fig. 18.

Summary of vanadium-magnesium interactions – in vivo model: our studies (I) and studies of other authors (II). V: vanadium; Mg: magnesium, Fe: iron, Cu: copper: P: phosphorus, RBC: erythrocytes, GR: glutathione reductase, LPO: lipid peroxidation, CH: cerebral hemisphere, B: bone, WB: whole blood, L: liver, K: kidney, P: plasma, TS: transferrin saturation, L-AA: L-ascorbic acid, ALP: alkaline phosphatase, SOD: superoxide dismutase, Sa: mean roughness, Sq: root mean square roughness, Sz: ten-point height, Ins: insulin, HOMA-IR: insulin resistance index. Based on available literature cited in section 9.2.

Antagonistic interactions between V and Mg have been demonstrated for (a) the activity of glutathione reductase in erythrocytes (GR_RBC) and the concentration of vanadium (V_RBC), iron (Fe_RBC), and copper (Cu_RBC) in erythrocytes, (b) the level of lipid peroxidation in the liver (LPO_L) and bone (LPO_B), and (c) the concentration of vanadium in the kidney (V_K) and cerebral hemisphere (V_CH). In turn, a clear trend towards the V-Mg antagonistic interaction has been observed for (a) the concentration of magnesium in erythrocytes (Mg_RBC) and plasma (Mg_P), (b) the level of lipid peroxidation in erythrocytes (LPO_RBC), (c) the concentration of zinc (Zn_B) and potassium (K_B) in bone, (d) the level of iron in the kidney (Fe_K), (e) the concentration of V in whole blood (V_WB), and (f) iron transferrin (Tf) saturation (TS) (Fig. 18I).

In contrast, synergistic interactions between V and Mg have been revealed for (a) the concentration of L-ascorbic acid in bone (L-AA_B), (b) the activity of alkaline phosphatase (ALP_B) and superoxide dismutase (SOD_B) in bone, (c) the concentration of calcium in erythrocytes (Ca_RBC) and in the liver (Ca_L). Synergy has also been determined for such roughness parameters as (d) mean roughness (Sa) and (e) root mean square roughness (Sq) (Fig. 18I), which were measured by optical profilometry in a three-dimensional (3D) scale in morphological studies of the femur of rats receiving V and Mg separately and in combination [260]. In turn, a trend towards synergistic interactions between both metals has been observed for (a) the level of sodium in erythrocytes (Na_RBC) and bone (Na_B), (b) the concentration of calcium (Ca_K) in the kidney, and (c) the ten-point height (Sz) defined as the arithmetic average height of the sum of five local maxima and five local minima (Fig. 18I).

The interactive effects between V and Mg (studied in an animal model) have also been revealed for such parameters as V intake, V absorption, urinary and fecal V excretion, serum Mg and insulin concentration, and insulin resistance index (HOMA-IR) (Fig. 18II).

As far as the historical outline of interactions is concerned, in 1970, Hill and Matrone proposed the theory of mineral interactions (Fig. 19 ) suggesting that metals with similar chemical and physical properties would interact with each other biologically [after 265]. In 1982, Georgievskii described synergistic and antagonistic interactions between certain elements, whereas O’ Del defined the term “interaction” in 1997 [after 265] (Fig. 19).

Fig. 19.

Historical outline of certain issues linked to mineral interactions and studies on the effects of combined administration of vanadium and elements with antioxidant properties to animals (mainly to rats). Mg: magnesium, Zn: zinc, Se: selenium, Cr: chromium. *after [265].

Studies on the influence of combined administration of V and elements with antioxidant potential date back to 1966 when Berg [258] described the effect of co-administration of V with Mg on the growth and mortality in chicks (Fig. 19). In 1989, Yamaguchi et al. [266] reported that Zn prevented the toxic effect of V (Fig. 19). In the late 1990s, two reports described the effect of Se on V toxicity in different regions of the rat brain [267] and a synergistic interaction between V and Mg on glucose metabolism in diabetic rats [253]. Additionally, the influence of combined administration of V with Zn or Se to rats [268] has been described (Fig. 19). The research on the interactions of V with antioxidant elements has been gaining popularity since 2005. Since that time, more reports have appeared about the effects of co-application of V with Cr(III) [59,[269], [270], [271], [272]] or Mg [[51], [52], [53], [54], [55], [56], [57], [58],63,259,260] to rats (Fig. 19). Moreover, there have also been reports on the effect of V administered as BMOV on bioavailability, biochemical parameters in serum, excretion and content of V and Mg in certain internal organs/tissues of healthy rats receiving V-containing feed and varying levels of Mg (magnesium oxide, MgO) [94], and the effect of V (BMOV) on the metabolism and distribution of Mg and some biochemical blood parameters in diabetic rats receiving feed containing V and Mg (MgO) [257].

It should also be added that more attention should be given to studies on treatment with V in association with compounds with antioxidant properties to optimize the therapeutic potential of V compounds and minimize their possible side effects. This is even more relevant in view of the work conducted by Wang et al. [273], who showed that the treatment with N-acetylcysteine (NAC), i.e. a thiol antioxidant reducing the accumulation of ROS and oxidative damage [274], inhibited V-induced ROS generation in human normal liver L02 cells but did not attenuate the antitumor activity of V in human hepatoma HepG2 cells. As emphasized by the authors, these results may be helpful in the therapeutic application of V compounds along with antioxidants as synergistic agents in order to reduce their potential toxicities in normal cells without affecting their antitumor activities in cancer cells. In addition, the same researchers suggest that combined administration of V with an antioxidant might be beneficial for diabetes therapy [273]. Recently, protective action of pyruvate against V-induced oxidative stress and cytotoxicity has been demonstrated in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO-K1) cells [275]. It has been suggested that the antioxidative effects of pyruvate, especially its ability to neutralize hydrogen peroxide, may be involved in the observed mechanism of protection.

To sum up, comprehensive investigations in an animal model on the interactions of V with antioxidant elements, such as Mg or certain compounds with antioxidant properties or dietary/plant-derived antioxidants, are particularly important. They would allow us not only to recognize a potential antidote minimizing the adverse effects of V resulting from its strong pro-oxidative activity but also to evaluate the potential efficacy of combined V-Mg treatment in certain modern-age diseases.

10. A brief summary and perspectives

Due to its multidirectional biological activity and a wide range of effects on the mammalian organism, vanadium has been arousing interest of many research centers worldwide for many years. The use of this metal in medicine is of particular concern. Some V compounds/complexes have been found to be promising for potential therapeutic use. Their beneficial therapeutic properties have been reported and diseases of interest against which they could be effective have been suggested. The number of studies on the use of V in medicine is constantly growing and its potential medical application remains an open question. Given the recent progress in the research on the pharmacological activity of different V compounds/complexes, it can be assumed that new V-based drugs will be available for therapeutic purposes in the future. Recently, much attention has been focused on the design of V compounds that can be useful for potential applications as anticancer agents. There are also ongoing studies on different anti-diabetic V complexes for their future safe use in the treatment of diabetes. On the other hand, however, many multidirectional studies on V (which has a narrow therapeutic index) have shown that further analyses are still required for this element to be used as a metallodrug in the fight against certain life-threatening modern-age diseases. It has been highlighted that the ability of V to accumulate and its strong toxicological potential are an important obstacle limiting the use of this metal in pharmacology. Therefore, it would be advisable to shift the balance towards the beneficial action of V, whose pharmacological potential has repeatedly been revealed, as evidenced by the results of many studies conducted in a variety of different cell lines and in animal models. However, this is a serious challenge and considerable research is still devoted to design V complexes with low toxicity and sufficiently high efficacy.

Besides the issues mentioned above and those presented in section 9 titled ‘Vanadium - important research trends’ and the need to identify the susceptibility of different cells/tissues to the effects of V, the following aspects draw researchers' attention: (a) identification of V species as an important factor in the assessment of toxicity of this element and its potential health risks to humans [276] (Fig. 20 ), (b) examination of the well-defined forms of this metal in terms of their availability, selectivity, and specificity [277] with recognition of key factors that may affect the mode of V action (Fig. 20), (c) biotransformation of V compounds in the organism and distribution between blood bioligands as a relevant issue of the drug metabolism and mechanism of action [103,109], (d) the role of the carrier ligand that may not be limited only to facilitating the transport/absorption of V compounds [278] with establishing the toxicity profiles of the ligand [167], (e) elucidation of the role of V species in interactions with immune system modulators and other transcription factors influencing immune signaling [277], and (f) recognition of therapeutic targets, pharmacokinetics, and pharmacodynamics in detail, which may help to design better and more effective V-based drugs [101].

Fig. 20.

Key factors affecting the mode of V action.

Declaration of Competing Interest

The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.