Effect of Acupuncture on Pregnancy-Related Insomnia and Melatonin: A Single-Blinded, Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Trial

Abstract

Objective

The aim of the current study is to evaluate the efficacy and safety of acupuncture on sleep quality and overnight melatonin secretion, measured as urinary 6-sulfatoxymelatonin, in pregnant women.

Patients and Methods

This randomized, parallel, single-blinded (participant), controlled trial was conducted on 72 pregnant women with insomnia. Study participants were randomly assigned to either the intervention, 10 sessions of acupuncture treatment over a 3-week period, or control group by block randomization (1:1). Patients in both groups were evaluated at baseline and post-treatment (third week) using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) score (as the primary outcome) and urinary 6-sulfatoxymelatonin.

Results

Fifty-five of 72 participants completed the study. There was no statistically significant difference regarding PSQI score and 6-sulfatoxymelatonin level between intervention and control groups at the baseline (P=0.169 and P=0.496). At the end of the study period, treatment with acupuncture significantly improved the PSQI score (P<0.001) with a large effect size of 3.7, as well as 6-sulfatoxymelatonin level (P=0.020) with a medium effect size of 0.6 as compared to the control group. No adverse effects were noted during acupuncture sessions and follow-up visits.

Conclusion

Acupuncture was shown to significantly improve the sleep quality in pregnant women, possibly through increasing melatonin secretion, and could be recommended as a low-cost and low-risk alternative treatment to pharmacological therapies.

Introduction

Insomnia is highly prevalent amongst pregnant women and affects their quality-of-life, but its significance is often underestimated in clinical practice. A recent meta-analysis on sleep quality among pregnant women suggested that an average of 45.7% pregnant women suffer from poor quality of sleep.1 Reports suggest that sleep duration decreases with gestational age during the pregnancy, reaching minimum values in the third trimester.1,2 Insomnia during pregnancy appears to have different risk factors in comparison to the non-pregnant state, for example gastroesophageal reflux, increased size of the uterus and anatomical disturbance as well as hormonal change leading to insomnia.2,3

It has been demonstrated that reduced sleep duration in pregnancy is associated with increased risk of preterm delivery and postnatal depression.4 Currently, there is a paucity of knowledge on the exact effects of maternal insomnia on fetal development; however, a recent review article suggest that sleep disruption during pregnancy may negatively affect fetal growth and gestational length.5 Furthermore, in animal studies, it has been shown that maternal sleep deprivation negatively affects neurogenesis in the fetal brain, resulting in subsequent cognitive impairments.6,7 Therefore, prompt treatment of insomnia in pregnant women seems vital to improve both maternal and fetal/neonatal outcomes.

In the current clinical practice, benzodiazepines and non-benzodiazepine hypnotics are among the most commonly used medications to improve sleep quality in pregnant women.8,9 Although no direct teratogenicity has been found in women using benzodiazepines or zolpidem,8 it is recommended to avoid routinely prescribing these medications due to higher incidence of adverse perinatal outcomes such as preterm delivery,10 low birth weight,10 cesarean delivery,11 and neonatal abstinence syndrome (especially with benzodiazepines).12

Acupuncture is among the popular alternative therapeutic modalities for treatment of insomnia.13,15 Interestingly, a recent survey in the United States showed that insomnia is one of the top 10 indications among patients visiting an acupuncture clinic.16 In a systematic review on the efficacy of acupuncture for insomnia in a non-pregnant population, acupuncture seems to be a safe and effective method for improving sleep quality.13 However, due to discrepancies in the quality of studies, it is premature to make any firm conclusions.

Recent reports suggest that acupuncture can increase the serum concentration of melatonin.17,18 Since decreased levels of melatonin are associated with sleep disturbances during pregnancy,19 acupuncture may be one promising candidate for relieving pregnancy-related insomnia by upregulating melatonin level. To our knowledge, there has been only one study assessing the effectiveness of acupuncture for treating pregnancy-related insomnia.14 The mentioned study was performed on 12 pregnant women in the acupuncture group and 10 in the control group, receiving only sleep hygiene education (gestational age ranging from 15–30 weeks) for 8–12 acupuncture sessions during an 8-week period. The results suggested that acupuncture may improve sleep quality during pregnancy; however, it was limited by methodological inadequacy and the small number of participants.

We designed a randomized controlled trial to investigate the efficacy and safety of acupuncture on sleep quality and urine 6-sulfatoxymelatonin, for the first time, among pregnant women suffering from insomnia.

Patients and Methods

Trial Design and Study Subjects

The current study was a single-blinded (participant), parallel, randomized controlled trial conducted on 72 pregnant women with insomnia referring to Motahari and Hafez clinics, affiliated to Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, from December 2017 to August 2018. The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and the protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of Shiraz University of Medical Sciences (IR.SUMS.MED.REC.1396.77) and all participants signed the written informed consent before participation in the trial. This trial was registered at Iranian Registry of Clinical Trials as IRCT20140525017827N3. This study was in accordance with the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) and Standards for Reporting Interventions in Clinical Trials of Acupuncture (STRICTA) guidelines for designing and reporting controlled trials.20,21

Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria

Inclusion criteria for the study were the following: 1) maternal age 20–45 years; 2) being in second or third trimester of pregnancy, but has at least 4 weeks left to delivery date; 3) documentation of short-term insomnia according to International Classification of Sleep Disorders, Third Edition (ICSD-3);22 4) baseline Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) score more than five; and 5) having night sleep disturbance for at least 4 weeks prior to study, but not before pregnancy. Exclusion criteria were the following: 1) any chronic medical illnesses; 2) history of any psychiatric disorders; 3) history of any sleep disturbance before pregnancy; 4) use of hypnotic drugs; 5) history of alcohol or drug abuse; 6) bleeding tendency and signs of infection at the acupoints; 7) sleep apnea; and 8) high risk complicated pregnancies such as multiple gestation, gestational diabetes mellitus, preeclampsia, fetal growth restriction, etc. Additionally, pregnant women with a night-shift job (ie, nurses) were excluded from the study because of the altered melatonin secretion pattern due to light exposure at night.23

Randomization, Allocation, and Blinding

Block randomization was done using a computer-generated random number list, with a block size of four (random list generated with SPSS 17.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL)), provided by an investigator with no clinical involvement in the trial. The sealed envelope containing an allocation sequence number for each patient will be regarded as a means of allocation concealment.

The outcome assessor, statistician, and study subjects were blinded throughout the study period. This means that those participants who had a previous history of acupuncture treatment and acknowledged the effects of acupoints were excluded. The acupuncturist used a neutral approach when communicating with participants and avoided revealing cues that might indicate whether acupuncture with real or sham needles are being done. However, the acupuncturist was not blinded due to the nature of the intervention. This method of blinding has been used in previous acupuncture studies and shown to be a high-quality method for blinding participants.24,25

Interventions

In the intervention group, standard acupuncture was performed for 10 sessions during a 3-week period (4 times in the first week and 3 times per week for the following weeks). Sterilized stainless-steel needles (0.3*40 and 0.3*25 mm) were inserted, forming a 90-degree angle with the skin surface and rotated anti-clockwise. The acupoints used in this study include KI-3 (Taixi), HT-7 (Shenmen), ST-36 (Zusanli), PC-6 (Neiguan), DU-20 (Baihui), GB-20 (Fengchi), and EX-8 (Anmian 1). The details on the anatomical location of these points are reported in Table 1.

Table 1.

Description of Acupoints Used in the Current Study

Needling Point	Location
KI-3 (Taixi)	Midway between the medial malleolus and medial border of the achilles tendon
HT-7 (Shenmen)	On the radial side of the tendon of flexor carpi ulnaris muscle at the wrist crease
ST-36 (Zusanli)	On the posterior and lateral side of the knee joint, 5 mm below capitulum fibulae
PC-6 (Neiguan)	Three fingers width up from the wrist crease and between the tendons of the flexor carpi radialis and palmaris longus
DU-20 (Baihui)	On the top of the head at the intersection of middle sagittal line and the line connecting two ears
GB-20 (Fengchi)	On the posterior neck, in the depression between the upper portions of sternocleidomastoid and the trapezius muscles
EX-8 (Anmian 1)	Posterior to the ear, at the indentation next to the mastoid process, between TB-17 and GB-20 points

The acupoints were obtained from an in-depth review of literature for finding acupoints used for relieving insomnia, which are considered safe during pregnancy.13,26,27 The expert acupuncture practitioner with >15 years of experience performed needle manipulation (manual) until the study subject achieved proper needling sensation “De Qi”, then the needles were left in place for approximately 30 minutes.

In the control group, only sleep hygiene education and fake acupuncture with blunt and non-penetrating needles were performed by superficial contact of needles in the same acupoints as real acupuncture. Thus, the aim was not to perform manual manipulation or achieving “De Qi” sensation. This placebo method has been used in previous studies of acupuncture and shown to be a valid technique for blinding of participants in the control group.24 In both groups, sleep hygiene education was given to each participant by one of the investigators based on “sleep hygiene” recommendations discussed earlier.28 These educational points were repeated and discussed with the patients at every visit during follow-up to improve their adherence to the recommended points.

Outcomes Assessment

Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI)

The main study outcome was the quality of sleep measure by PSQI scale, which was filled out for both groups before and after the study period at  the third week. PSQI is a questionnaire designed by Buysse et al29 as a self-reported multidimensional method for evaluating sleep quality in patients. This questionnaire consists of 19 questions investigating the subjects regarding seven domains of sleep quality: subjective sleep quality, sleep latency, sleep duration, habitual sleep efficiency, sleep disturbance, use of sleeping medications and daytime dysfunction over the last month. A higher PSQI score is associated with worse sleep quality in patients. Therefore, it is generally accepted that a patient with a PSQI score higher than 5 is suffering from a disturbed sleep pattern.30 In the current study, the Persian version of the PSQI questionnaire was used to collect the data. The study by Moghadam et al31 revealed that the Cronbach’s alpha coefficient for the Persian version of PSQI was 0.77.

Urine 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin Measurement

Patients were instructed to collect first-spot morning urine samples at 6–8 AM. The urine sample was stored in a dark urine specimen container to prevent light exposure. Urine samples were centrifuged (at 2,500 rpm) for approximately 20 minutes and kept at −20°C until analysis. Laboratory staff analyzing urine samples and reporting results were blinded to treatment groups. Urine 6-sulfatoxymelatonin was measured by commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) kits (IBL International, Hamburg, Germany). It is well-elucidated that morning urine 6-sulfatoxymelatonin, the main metabolite of melatonin, is a useful measure of the total amount of melatonin produced overnight.32 The ratio of urine 6-sulfatoxymelatonin divided by urine creatinine (Cr) level was expressed as ng/mg, in order to account for the differences in glomerular filtration rate among participants.

Sample Size

The strategy of sample size calculation was based on mean reduction of PSQI score (−0.70±0.95) for the pilot sample, and the expectation of two more times reduction in acupuncture group (mean=−1.4). By considering α=0.05, power=80%, and an approximately 20% dropout rate, 72 patients were examined and equally assigned to each group (n=36).

Statistical Analysis

All statistical analyses were performed with the SPSS version 17.0 for Windows (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). Appropriately, data were presented as mean±standard deviation or frequency (percentage). Independent sample t-test or Mann Whitney U-tests were used for between-group comparison. Paired t-test or Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used for within-group comparisons. The standardized mean differences (SMDs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) was used to estimate the effect size of intervention. An effect size of d=0.2 is considered a small effect size, d=0.5 represents a medium effect size, and 0.8 or above a large effect size. A P-value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

Seventy-two pregnant women with insomnia were randomly assigned to the intervention (n=36) and control (n=36) groups. As shown in Figure 1, 55 of 72 study participants completed the trial.

Figure 1.

CONSORT flow diagram for the design of this clinical trial.

According to Table 2, the mean age of participants was 31.7±5.7 years for the intervention group and 30.2±3.4 years for the control group (P=0.267). Gestational age, documented by obstetrical sonography and reported by weeks, at the beginning of the study was similar across the study groups (P=0.157). There were no significant differences between the study groups in terms of body mass index (BMI), educational level, occupation status, and gravidity (P>0.05).

Table 2.

Demographic Characteristics of Study Groups

Characteristics	Intervention (n=26)	Control (n=29)	P-valuea
Maternal age, years	31.7±5.7	30.2±3.4	0.267
Gestational age, weeks	25.9±7.0	23.2±7.2	0.157
Body mass index (BMI), kg/m2	26.2±4.3	25.6±4.1	0.630
Education
Diploma or under diploma	14 (53.8%)	12 (41.4%)	0.355
University degree	12 (46.2%)	17 (58.6%)
Gravidity
1	6 (23%)	9 (31%)	0.656
2	12 (46.2%)	10 (34.5%)
≥3	8 (30.8%)	10 (34.5%)
Occupation
Housewife	24 (92.3%)	23 (79.3%)	0.256
Employed	2 (7.7%)	6 (20.7%)

Notes: ^aIndependent sample t-test or chi-square as appropriate.

Abbreviation: BMI, body mass index.

Baseline PSQI scores for the intervention and control groups were 12.7±1.8 and 12.2±1.8, respectively, which showed no significant difference (P=0.169). Regarding between-group analysis, the study subjects obtained significantly lower PSQI scores in the intervention group (6.0±1.1) compared to the control group (12.1±2.0) at the end of the intervention (P<0.001). This lower PSQI score in the intervention group indicates a better sleep quality for those receiving real acupuncture. These results are summarized in Table 3.

Table 3.

Comparison of Total PSQI Scores between the Two Groups before and after Intervention

Total PSQI Score	Intervention (n=26)	Control (n=29)	P-valuea
	Mean±SD	Mean±SD
Before treatment	12.7±1.8	12.2±1.8	0.169
After treatment	6.0±1.1	12.1±2.0	<0.001
P-valueb	<0.001	0.326

Notes: ^aIndependent sample t-test. ^bPaired sample t-test.

Abbreviation: PSQI, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index.

Data regarding the acupuncture and urinary level of 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin is listed in Table 4. At baseline, urinary 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin level was 19.8±5.0 ng/mg in the intervention group and 20.7±4.9 ng/mg in the control group, which showed no significant difference (P=0.496). However, between-group analysis revealed a significant difference between the acupuncture and control groups after the intervention in the 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin level (27.4±6.5 ng/mg vs 22.8±7.6 ng/mg, P=0.020).

Table 4.

Comparison of Urinary 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin/Creatinine Ratio between the Two Groups before and after Intervention

Urine 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin (ng/mg Cr)	Intervention (n=26)	Control (n=29)	P-valuea
	Mean±SD	Mean±SD
Before treatment	19.8±5.0	20.7±4.9	0.496
After treatment	27.4±6.5	22.8±7.6	0.020
P-valueb	<0.001	0.147

Notes: ^aIndependent sample t-test. ^bPaired sample t-test.

Abbreviations: ng, nanograms; mg, milligrams; Cr, creatinine.

The effect size of intervention on sleep quality (PSQI) and 6-Sulfatoxymelatonin level was reported to be 3.7 (CI=2.8–4.6) and 0.6 (CI=0.1–1.2), which revealed a large (>0.8) and medium (>0.5) effect size, respectively.

No serious acupuncture-related adverse events (AEs) were recorded during the study. The only reported AE was needling pain. No participant in either group was reported to take hypnotic medication for insomnia during the study-period. Neonatal AEs were also evaluated. One newborn was admitted to the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) from the intervention group due to transient tachypnea and two newborns from the control group due to neonatal sepsis and hyperbilirubinemia. Thus, these AEs seem not to be attributable to the use of acupuncture.

Discussion

There is a growing interest for using acupuncture in treatment of insomnia in the general population.13 However, data on its effectiveness in pregnant women with insomnia is sparse. The term “pregnancy-related insomnia” differs from insomnia during other stages of life, due to different pathological or physiological conditions leading to a disturbance in sleep pattern of pregnant women.33 To the best of our knowledge, this is the first randomized placebo-controlled trial evaluating acupuncture efficacy and safety for pregnancy-related insomnia through both subjective and laboratory (melatonin) measurements.

In our study, the acupuncture treatment resulted in a significant improvement of 6.7 points in total PSQI score among pregnant women. This finding is consistent with the results of a previous study that found acupuncture for 8–12 sessions improved sleep quality in pregnant women.14 However, utilization of a validated measurement tool (eg, validated questionnaire) as well as a placebo (sham)-controlled group was not mentioned.

We observed an increase in endogenous melatonin secretion (as measured in morning spot urine) after acupuncture treatment, which was followed by improvement in sleep quality in participants, assessed by PSQI, in the current study. However, it is too early to claim a causal relationship between increasing melatonin after acupuncture and improvement in sleep quality at this stage. Spence et al17 obtained similar results, showing a significant increase in urinary melatonin excretion after performing acupuncture on 18 adult subjects with anxiety disorder suffering from insomnia.

Acupuncture efficacy could be attributable to its regulatory effect on various neuroendocrinological pathways. It has been shown that stimulation of certain acupoints resulted in a change in a wide range of neuroendocrinological mediators, such as norepinephrine, melatonin, gamma-aminobutyric acid, and β-endorphin.34 Accordingly, in an animal study, manual stimulation of Baihui, Shenman, and Sanyinjiao acupoints was shown to improve the sleep duration in insomniac rats. This promising effect of acupuncture was attributable to its effect on increasing the expression level of melatonin protein, as well as melatonin-1 and melatonin-2 mRNAs in rat models.18

Melatonin crosses the placenta freely and plays an important role in fetal development. Maternal serum melatonin is shown to regulate fetal rapid eye movement (REM) and non-REM sleep cycle during the third trimester of pregnancy,35 which is directly associated with fetal brain neuronal growth and activation during this period of time.36 Therefore, increased melatonin secretion following acupuncture may not only improve maternal sleep quality, but also have the potential to positively affect fetal brain development.

A previous study has shown that women have an increased desire and awareness to experience acupuncture, as an alternative treatment, in both antenatal and postnatal periods, and those who received acupuncture treatment during pregnancy reported positive feedback regarding the effectiveness of this therapy.37 Acupuncture is considered generally safe during pregnancy.27 One proof for this claim is that several studies conducted for treatment of low back and pelvic pain, tension type headache, dyspepsia, nausea and vomiting, anxiety and depression during pregnancy have shown no serious adverse effects related to the acupuncture.38,42

In addition to modern medicine, Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) theories have been used to explain that acupuncture treatment may be regulating yin and yang to reinforce improving sleep quality.13 The diagnosis made according to TCM theories has been suggested to be related to acupuncture response in patients. For instance, particular features of TCM diagnoses were predictors of treatment response to acupuncture used for hot flashes in patients suffering from cancer.43 Therefore, it may be logical to select patients for acupuncture based on an individualized process, in order to optimize the response obtained from treatment.

This study has some limitations: 1) Study subjects were not followed-up for a long-period to see whether or not the efficacy of treatment was persisting for longer periods of time. 2) Acupuncturist could not be blinded to the assigned groups due to the nature of intervention. 3) The relatively small number of participants analyzed at the end of study (n=55), which limits the generalizability of the results. 4) The PSQI questionnaire is a subjective tool, and may not accurately reflect sleep quality, so further trials using objective measurement tools are recommended.

Conclusion

Results of the current trial suggest that acupuncture treatment significantly improves the sleep quality in pregnant women, possibly through increasing melatonin secretion. Further randomized clinical trials with larger sample sizes and longer follow-up periods are needed to confirm these results.

Funding Statement

The project was financed by Vice Chancellor for Research of the Shiraz University of Medical Science, Shiraz, Iran. The funding organization played no role in the study design, data collection, analysis, and interpretation of data.

Data Sharing Statement

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request. Also, the individual deidentified participant data is available after contacting the corresponding author via email. The data will be available immediately following publication without an end date.

Author Contributions

All authors contributed to data analysis, drafting or revising the article, gave final approval of the version to be published, and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.

Disclosure

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.