Thromboembolic Findings in COVID-19 Autopsies: Pulmonary Thrombosis or Embolism?

Abstract

In their article, Lax and colleagues reported the frequent occurrence of pulmonary thrombosis in a series of autopsies of patients with COVID-19. The editorialist discusses how these findings help to further inform our emerging understanding of thromboembolic disease in COVID-19.

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) initially presented as pneumonia of unknown cause in Wuhan, China, in December 2019, and SARS-CoV-2 was identified as the causative agent in January 2020 (1). Since then COVID-19, with its pulmonary and other systemic manifestations, has spread globally—with more than 4.2 million cases and over 291 000 deaths in 187 countries reported (2). With spread of disease, abnormal coagulation variables with high incidence of venous thromboembolic (VTE) complications have been noted, raising the need to develop specific VTE diagnostic and therapeutic strategies (3).

Complete autopsy studies were almost nonexistent in the initial phases of the outbreak; reasonably so, due to concerns related to infectivity, transmission rates, and biosafety. The few reports initially published were limited to postmortem biopsies in COVID-19–positive patients (4–6) or from lobectomy specimens initially resected for lung adenocarcinoma, but patients were later found to be COVID-19–positive (7). Pathologic features of exudative and proliferative phases of diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) were noted in these initial reports and overlapping features with SARS were also noted. Later complete autopsies performed in United States further supported the presence of DAD (8, 9).

More recently, Wichmann and colleagues (10) reported the findings of 12 consecutive, legally mandated autopsies of patients with COVID-19. The authors noted a high incidence of pulmonary embolism with or without underlying deep venous thrombosis, despite the absence of history of VTE. Massive pulmonary embolism was the cause of death in one third of the cases, with an additional one fourth with recent deep venous thrombosis but without pulmonary embolism. Seventy-five percent were men and two thirds of these were noted to have recent thrombosis in prostatic venous plexus. Preexisting coronary heart disease (50%), respiratory tract, obesity, and type 2 diabetes mellitus were noted but an absence of antemortem VTEs. Histologically exudative phase DAD was noted in two thirds and presence of pulmonary thrombi in 5 out of 8 cases with DAD. Similar histologic findings of DAD with microthrombi in 45% cases were also recently reported by Menter and associates in a series of 21 COVID-19–positive autopsies, 4 with prominent central pulmonary embolism (11).

In this issue, Lax and colleagues (12) report the findings of autopsies performed on 11 patients randomly selected among 48 hospitalized COVID-19–positive decedents. Significant preexisting comorbid conditions included hypertension, type 2 diabetes mellitus, obesity, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, coronary heart disease, cancer, as well as history of cerebrovascular disease (ischemic stroke in 4 patients) and pulmonary embolism (1 patient). After autopsy tissue fixation, grossly visible pulmonary thrombi were noted in all cases with associated infarcts in 9 out of these 11 (81%) autopsies. During their hospital stay, 10 of the 11 deceased patients had received prophylactic dose anticoagulant therapy, with 2 receiving this therapy even before admission; thus suggesting that pulmonary thrombi were formed despite anticoagulant therapy. Apart from DAD, histologic evaluation highlighted the presence of multiple thrombi in small to mid-sized pulmonary arteries with adjacent lung parenchymal infarcts.

These autopsy studies highlight the importance of thromboembolic events in COVID-19. Wichmann and colleagues highlighted the high incidence of pulmonary embolism with or without deep venous thrombosis, as well as presence of recent thrombi in prostatic venous plexus, in patients with no history of VTE, suggesting de novo coagulopathy in these patients with COVID-19. In contrast, Lax and colleagues highlighted changes consistent with thrombosis occurring within the pulmonary arterial circulation, in the absence of apparent embolism.

Microvascular thrombi can be seen in DAD (the histologic equivalent of adult respiratory distress syndrome or acute respiratory distress syndrome [ARDS]) with various causes, including sepsis, trauma, viral or mycoplasma pneumonia, aspiration, as well as toxic inhalation, as noted by Tomashefski and coworkers (13). Thus, microvascular thrombosis is not a distinctive or diagnostic feature of lung parenchymal involvement in patients with COVID-19. Ultrastructural evidence of acute endothelial injury has also been demonstrated, regardless of and without correlation with the cause of ARDS. Macrothrombi (thrombi in arteries with internal diameter >1 mm), large microthrombi, and capillary microthrombi have also been reported in patients with ARDS, due to other causes listed above. Pulmonary infarcts are also seen in patients with ARDS who died sooner (10 to 19 days) and later (≥20 days) after intubation (13). Taken together, prior reports and more recent descriptions of DAD in COVID-19 suggest that these microscopic findings are not specific to the etiology, but rather a general feature of acute lung injury at various stages of response to injury.

The contributions of pulmonary thrombosis, embolism, or their combination to deaths of patients with COVID-19 may remain unaddressed because of the limited number of autopsy studies available. Although histologic or ultrastructural-level morphologic differences may not be evident, pathogen-specific molecular or immunologic differences may contribute to the different scenarios suggested in the current studies. To more thoroughly assess these questions will require tissues obtained either as postmortem biopsies or as complete autopsies. Further, appropriately stored tissues may be used in future studies to assess not only the underlying pathogenesis but also to inform the development of diagnostic biomarkers and clinical trials of therapeutic strategies aiming to better equip us for the next pathogen, epidemic, or even pandemic.

Biography

Disclosures: The author has disclosed no conflicts of interest. His form can be viewed at www.acponline.org/authors/icmje/ConflictOfInterestForms.do?msNum=M20-3255.

Corresponding Author: Charuhas Deshpande, MD, Associate Professor, Clinical Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Founder 6.039, 3400 Spruce Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104; e-mail, Charuhas.Deshpande@pennmedicine.upenn.edu