The association between denture care and oral hygiene habits, oral hygiene knowledge and periodontal status of geriatric patients wearing removable partial dentures

Abstract

Purpose:

This study aims to evaluate the association of the denture care with oral hygiene habits, knowledge and periodontal status geriatric patients wearing removable partial denture (RPD) and to compare the relationship between denture cleaning and tooth brushing frequency.

Patients and methods:

In total, 553 participants wearing RPD for at least 6 months and aged 65–86 years were asked to complete a questionnaire following the clinical examination. Chisquare analysis and Fisher’s exact test utilized to analyze the data.

Results:

A significant relationship was found between the frequency of smoking, denture age, overnight denture wearing, denture stomatitis and denture cleaning (p<0.05). 54.10% of the participants reporting that they did not have information about denture care had poor denture cleaning. Among patients brushing once per day, 26.34% had a good level of denture cleaning; whereas, this was 39.40% for those brushing three times in a day.

Conclusion:

The type of advice (verbal or written) and oral hygiene habits demonstrated a more significant impact on the cleaning level of dentures than the socioeconomic level, smoking, overnight use, denture age. The success of denture maintenance might depend on the patients’ knowledge of denture care and hygiene habits and geriatric patients’ motivation.

Introduction

Edentulousness is a multi-factorial phenomenon that has an impact on the quality of life of individuals (1,2,3, 4). The maintenance of the continuity of the mastication system and elimination of aesthetic and phonetic problems require a successful restoration and rehabilitation. A removable partial denture (RPD) is intended for partially edentulous patients who cannot have a bridge or an implant due to lack of required teeth to serve as bridge support, high cost and so forth and who want to have replacement teeth for function. Out of various treatment strategies for partial edentulism such as implant- and tooth-supported fixed prostheses, a well-designed partial removable dental prosthesis (PRDP) is still one of the mostly performed treatment modalities (5,6) fulfilling the needs of millions of individuals worldwide (7,8,9) or applied for aesthetic reasons. Regular oral and denture hygiene habits play important role in maintenance of oral health and long- term use of removable prostheses (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10).

The awareness and motivation of RPD wearers to maintain a high level of hygiene of residual teeth are extremely important to maintain the health and integrity of teeth and periodontal tissues (11).

A great number of geriatric patients need dental care including RPD. Researches have shown that older people do not clean their dentures properly and do not acquire adequate oral hygiene habits (12,13,14, 15,16) due to a number of factors such as social status, age, education, systemic diseases, and smoking (12,13,14, 15). Also lack of information about the maintenance of oral health and periodic recalls play an essential role in above mentioned situation.

Previous studies have shown a correlation between RPDs and increased risk of periodontal diseases (17,18). Therefore, proper denture use and care constitutes important component not only for functional and aesthetic reasons, but also for the health of the supporting periodontal tissues and appropriate maintenance of the denture itself for RPD wearers (19). Akaltan et al. concluded that adequate oral hygiene and regular systemic controls can improve periodontal health of patients with RPD (20). The purpose of this study is to determine the relationship between smoking, denture age, denture stomatitis, overnight denture wearing habits, knowledge of denture hygiene maintenance, and oral hygiene habits with denture cleaning among the geriatric population using RPDs. This study also aims to evaluate education and socioeconomic levels of geriatric patients wearing RPD.

Patients and methods

In total, 553 partial denture wearers aged 65–86 years (mean age 73 ± 11) and using prostheses for at least 6 months completed a questionnaire following clinical examination at the Okmeydanı Oral and Dental Health Hospital, Istanbul, Turkey (Figure 1). The protocol of this study was approved by the Okmeydanı Training and Research Hospital Ethics Committee (No.838). This study was performed in compliance with the Declaration of Helsinki.

Figure 1.

Questionnaire.

This study was conducted among geriatric patients applied to the departments of the prosthodontics and periodontology, who already have RPDs. They were informed about the research project and gave their consent in writing.

The subjects were interviewed by experienced single periodontologist using a structured questionnaire which sought to identify gender, educational status, socioeconomic level, smoking habits, frequency of visiting a dentist, denture age, denture stomatitis, overnight denture wearing, denture cleaning frequency, methods and status of ever being informed by dentist about denture hygiene maintenance and oral hygiene habits (PGK).

The level of prosthesis hygiene was assessed using the Budzt-Jorgensen & Bertram method (21) by an another experienced single prosthodontist (AK) and ranked in categories, namely, good (no plaque or calculus), fair (plaque or calculus covering less than one-third of the prosthesis), or poor (plaque and calculus covering one-third or more of the prosthesis). Prosthesis types were evaluated on the basis of the previous study where oral mucosal lesions among denture wearers was examined (22), and classified as partially removable dental prosthesis in the maxilla and/or mandible. The denture age of prosthesis was categorized in three groups as less than one year (< 1 year), between one and five years (1–5 years), equal to and greater than five years (≥5 years). The level of education was classified as illiterate, primary school, secondary school and higher levels; whereas, income level was categorized as poor, low-, middle- and high-income patients. In this study, gingival bleeding was evaluated on the basis of existence of bleeding during tooth brushing. The participants were asked whether they had undergone periodontal treatment before the date of this study.

Statistical analysis

The data was analyzed with SPSS 20 statistical package (SSS Inc., USA).

Ki-square analysis was applied to reveal the relationship between groups of nominal variable. In case where sufficient volume could not be obtained as per 2x2 table cells, Fisher’s Exact Test was used. Furthermore, RxC tables were verified with Pearson Ki-Square analysis by using Monte Carlo simulation.

The level of significance was identified as 0.05 during interpretation of the results according to which p<0.05 shows meaningful relationship and p>0.05 indicates that any meaningful relationship does not exist.

Results

In this study, 51.9% of the subjects were females and 48.1% was male (Table 1 In terms of level of education, 14.47% of participants was illiterate, 63.65% completed primary school education, 10.13% had secondary school degree, and 11.75% held higher education degree (Table 1).

Table 1.

Distribution of demographic characteristics of the subjects.

		n	(%)
Gender	Female	287	51.9
	Male	266	48.1
	Total	553	100
Educational level	Illiterate	80	14.47
	Primary school	352	63.65
	Secondary school	56	10.13
	Higher	65	11.75
	Total	553	100
Income	Poor	103	18.63
	Low	223	40.33
	Moderate	173	31.28
	High	54	9.76
	Total	553	100

While 40.33% of the participants stated that they had low income level, 31.28% and 9.76% reported they had moderate and high individual income levels respectively (Table 1).

Significant relationship was found between the frequency of smoking habits and denture cleaning (p<0.05). 50% of the smoking participants and 31.39% of the non-smokers had poor denture cleaning (Table 2).

Table 2.

Relationship of prosthesis hygiene level with oral hygiene knowledge, habits and periodontal status of subjects.* Chi square analysis was performed with the help of Monte Carlo Simulation.

		Prosthesis hygiene level								Chi square test
		Good		Fair		Poor		Total
		n	(%)	n	(%)	N	(%)	n	(%)	Chi square	p
Smoking status	Yes	28	17.72	51	32.28	79	50.00	158	100	17.991	0.001
	No	116	29.37	155	39.24	124	31.39	395	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
Denture age	1 year or less	61	33.15	52	28.26	71	38.59	184	100	16.92	0.002
	1-5 years	33	27.73	53	44.54	33	27.73	119	100
	More than 5 years	50	20.00	101	40.40	99	39.60	250	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
Denture stomatitis (Prosthesis-related oral mucosal lesions)	Yes	24	15.00	70	43.75	66	41.25	160	100	14.355	0.001
	No	120	30.53	136	34.61	137	34.86	393	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
Overnight denture wearing	Yes	106	29.53	130	36.21	123	34.26	359	100	6.744	0.034
	No	38	19.59	76	39.18	80	41.24	194	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
Frequency of denture cleaning	Once a day	63	31.31	73	36.87	63	31.82	198	100	9.42	0.151
	Twice a day	34	30.28	46	42.20	30	27.52	109	100
	Three times a day	34	25.58	40	31.01	56	43.41	129	100
	More than three times	13	21.43	22	39.29	22	39.29	56	100
	Total	144	28.46	181	36.79	171	34.76	553	100
Received instructions	Yes	134	27.24	188	38.21	170	34.55	553	100	9.202	0.01
	No	10	16.39	18	29.51	33	54.10	61	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
If yes, in what form?	Written	3	17.65	9	52.94	5	29.41	17	100	*	0.003
	Verbal	33	27.73	43	36.13	43	36.13	119	100
	Both written and verbal	98	28.24	136	39.19	113	32.56	347	100
	Other	0	.00	0	.00	9	100.00	9	100
	Total	134	27.24	188	38.21	170	34.55	553	100
Frequency of brushing remaining teeth	Once a day	59	26.34	98	43.75	67	29.91	224	100	36.531	0.001
	Twice a day	42	28.00	65	43.33	43	28.67	150	100
	Three times a day	31	36.90	25	29.76	28	33.33	84	100
	Never	0	.00	0	.00	14	100.00	14	100
	Total	132	27.97	188	39.83	152	32.20	472	100
Gingival bleeding	Yes	56	23.14	86	35.54	100	41.32	242	100	4.223	0.121
	No	88	28.30	120	38.59	103	33.12	311	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
Periodontal treatment	Yes	24	24.24	37	37.37	38	38.38	99	100	0.242	0.886
	No	120	26.43	169	37.22	165	36.34	454	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100
Oral hygiene level	Poor	0	.00	14	7.49	173	92.51	187	100	809.022	0.001
	Fair	11	4.80	188	82.10	30	13.10	229	100
	Good	133	97.08	4	2.92	0	.00	137	100
	Total	144	26.04	206	37.25	203	36.71	553	100

Furthermore, it was found that denture cleaning was directly associated with the period of time participants used their RPDs, overnight use of RPDs and denture stomatitis (p<0.05). Among the participants who reported they had been wearing RPDs less than 1 year, 30.15% had a good level of denture cleaning; whereas, this rate was found as 20% among those wearing RPDs more than 5 years. As for the participants removing their RPDs before sleep and continuing to wear RPDs overnight, 34.26% and 41.24% had poor denture cleaning respectively. While 41.25% of patients with denture stomatitis had poor denture cleaning, only 15% of them had a good level of denture cleaning (Table 2).

In addition, significant relationship was found between the information provided to the wearers about denture care and denture cleaning. Of the participants reported that they did not have information about denture care, 54.10% had poor denture cleaning and 16.39% had good denture cleaning (Table 2).

17.65% of the participants who stated they only received written instruction on denture care and 27.73% whom verbal instruction was given had good level of denture cleaning; whereas, 28.24% of those provided with both verbal and written instruction exhibited good level of denture cleaning (Table 2).

There is also significant relationship between the denture cleaning and the frequency of brushing remaining teeth. 26.34% of the participants brushing once in a day and 36.90% of those brushing three times per day had good level of denture cleaning. Among patients with good level of prosthesis hygiene, 97.08% revealed good level of oral hygiene. On contrary, 92.51% of the patients with poor level of prosthesis hygiene had poor level of oral hygiene (Table 2).

Discussion

Hygiene habits, behaviors and knowledge about the denture care of geriatric RPD wearers have been the subject of researches over the years (23,24,25,26,27,28,29). Several factors that may be related to the level of denture cleaning were approached by the questionnaire, within the scope of which gender, education, socioeconomic level, smoking habits, denture age, denture stomatitis, overnight denture wearing, frequency of visiting dentist, knowledge about denture hygiene maintenance and oral hygiene habits were examined (29). The present study was undertaken to determine knowledge about the use and care of partial denture among geriatric patients.

In general, the education and socio-economic levels of geriatric patients are associated with their oral health condition. A previous study has demonstrated that the education level and socio-economic stability is positively associated with interest in oral health (30). The present study mainly includes the population with low socioeconomic and low education levels. The positive correlation between the prosthesis and oral hygiene indicates that denture cleaning is relevant with the level of knowledge of periodontal care. According to these findings, the level of denture cleaning of participants’ RPDs was not sufficiently qualified.

Smoking and its relation with the oral hygiene level have been subjects of many articles. Previous reports in literature support that smoking deteriorates oral hygiene (31). Findings of this study concerning higher percentage of good oral and denture hygiene among non-smokers compared to the smokers are consistent with the outcomes revealed by several previous studies (31, 32).

The behavior of the dentists and dental staff is the primary tool guiding the behavior of the geriatric patients. The attitude, body language and communication skills of the dentist are critical to create positive dental visit experience. This study revealed the correlation between the level of cleaning of participants’ RPDs and the manner in which patients were advised concerning the care of their denture. 70.53% of the patients who received both had better denture cleaning in comparison with the patients provided only with verbal instructions. In accordance with the result of previous studies, this result shows the importance of giving detailed information to patients (17, 33,34,35).

Geiballa et al. showed that the majority of dentists did not pay attention to the post treatment instructions concerning the maintenance of fixed prosthesis (36).

It is important to have regular dental visits and follow patients which will allow monitoring of patient oral health. Regular calls maintain good level of cleaning of participants’ RPDs (35) due to the fact that updated verbal and written instructions are provided (28, 37).

In the geriatric population studied, 33.15% of the participants wearing their RPDs less than 1 year had good level and 38.59% had poor level of denture cleaning. 20% of the participants using RPDs more than 5 years had good level and 39.6% had poor level of denture cleaning. This study also presented that denture age had adverse effect on level of cleaning of dentures. It was claimed that patients gave more attention to clean their dentures after they were provided with updated instruction. In compliance with the results of previous studies, these results showed that a large number of patients had to be informed about denture cleaning and care (27, 30).

This study also revealed significant relationship between overnight denture use and the level of cleaning of dentures (p 6lt 0.05). The result of this study showed that subjects wearing their RPDs overnight had poor level of denture cleaning. A previous study reported that wearing partial denture continuously resulted in more plaque accumulation compared to those using the partial denture only during the day (38). Some studies revealed that denture stomatitis was associated with failure to remove denture overnight (23,24,25). According to the previous studies, the rate of denture stomatitis differed between 15 and 71%, and the prevalence of denture stomatitis had strong relationship with denture hygiene and denture plaque amount (39,40). Furthermore, higher rate of denture stomatitis was found among patients with poor and fair level of denture cleaning compared to the patients with good level of denture cleaning (p < 0.05).

RPDs may increase the risk of caries, damage on periodontium and the amount of stress on natural teeth due to poor oral hygiene, increased plaque and calculus accumulation, and transmission of excessive forces from occlusal surfaces of the frame of RPDs to the periodontal structures. Adverse impacts of the removable partial dentures on the periodontium can be eliminated, if good oral hygiene is maintained. Ideally, partial denture wearers should brush their remaining teeth after every meal by which periodontal health of the remaining dentition can be maintained. On the other hand, RPDs of the patients whom professional tooth cleaning was applied regularly have only minor adverse effects on the periodontium (19, 41). Shigeto et al. showed that RPS-wearing patients who received periodic maintenance care 4 times/year were effective to maintain good periodontal conditions (42).

Dula et. al. assessed education, motivation and awareness of the patients during the stage of RPD’s construction and concluded that planned prosthetic treatment with an appropriate design and good oral hygiene could reduce the possibility of occurrence of periodontal disease of abutment teeth (43).

This study further revealed that good level of cleaning of denture was maintained among geriatric patients, who brushed their remaining teeth three times a day. In this framework, it can be recommended that periodontal disease should be eliminated before construction of partial dentures, and the natural teeth should be prepared to provide stability and support for the denture.

The oral cavity offers ideal bacteria breeding area and those affected with periodontal disease are exposed to increased risk of potentially fatal bacteria that enter the bloodstream via infected oral tissue. According to the present study, periodontal treatment before prosthetic construction had no effect on the level of denture cleaning. The reason is that geriatric patients may not correct oral hygiene habits depending on the inadequacy of hand skills. In this study, overnight denture wearing condition was considered; whereas, in-water storage of RPD, which affects periodontal health and denture cleaning, was not analyzed. Therefore, it is recommended that further studies should question whether patients keep their RPS within the water. As xerostomia and the type of brushing method have also impact on the oral hygiene and periodontal health, further studies should also take these two factors into consideration within the scope of their examinations in relevant field.

Conclusion

It could be concluded that the level of cleaning of dentures is associated with giving detailed information to the geriatric patients about how to use their RPDs, type of advice (verbal or written), regular dental visits, good oral hygiene, smoking habits, socioeconomic level, overnight use and denture age. Furthermore clinicians play an important role on maintenance of patient motivation. It is possible to prevent the periodontal diseases by providing detailed information about the oral hygiene habits to the patients and having them maintain adequate oral and denture hygiene. Consequently the clinicians should advice and motivate the patient in RPD maintenance and oral hygiene procedures.

Further longitudinal studies are needed to better evaluate the effect of periodontal treatment before prosthetic construction in geriatric population.