Skip to main content
. 2020 May 27;6(5):e04048. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e04048

Table 1.

Comparison of analytical performance (linear range and LOD) of the different nano biosensing systems for detection of HIV-1.

Detection Method Strategy Limit of Detection Linear Range Ref.
Electrochemical Square Wave Voltammetry (SWV) CNT screen printed working electrode 0.1 pg/μl 0.2–25 μg/ml [29]
PTCA/graphene sheets functionalized with AnNPs 34 f M 10 pM - 1μM [32]
Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS) graphene/nafion nanofilm modified GC electrode 0.23 f M 10 pM–10 nM [33]
GC electrode modified with AuNPs/PABA/ERGO nanocomposite film 340 f M 10 fM – 10 μM [34]
Signal amplification of multiwall carbon nanotubes loaded AgNPs 0.5 pM 1–100 pM [47]
Differential Pulse Voltammetry (DPV) Long range self-assembled DNA nanostructures on gold electrode 5 aM 2 aM–10 pM [48]
Graphene stabilized AuNCs modified GC electrode 10 f M 0.1 fM – 100 nM [49]
Hybride Methods Chitosan/Fe3O4 immobilized DNA probe 50 pM 50–100 pM [51]
ssDNA/polyaniline/graphene nanocomposites platform 50 fM 50 fM -10 nM [52]
Binding of DNA probe to porous NiCo2O4/CoO/CNTs composite 16.7 fM 0.1 pM-2nM [53]
Optical Fluorescence FRET between CdTe QDs and CDs 1 nM 0–50 nM [59]
Integration of Lateral Flow assay strips and QDs 0.76 pM 1 pM–10 nM [61]
CdTe QDs tagged complementary DNA probe 50 pM 5μM–2000 μM [62]
FRET between AuNPs/graphene oxide and CDs 5 fM 5μM–0.4 nM [68]
Peroxidase like activity of Pt/Au NPs and separation of magnetic NPs 5 pM 10pM–500pM [71]
DNA nanomachine based on Au NPs and RCA 1.46 fM 5 fM-1.67 pM [72]
Hairpin shaped probe tagged with AG NCs 4.4 nM 10–200 nM [75]
FRET between CNPs oxide and Ag NCs 0.4 nM 1–50 nM [76]
FRET between DNA Ag NCs and BHQ 35 pM 50 pM–5 nM [77]
DNA/AG NCs probe and Exo III-assisted cyclic amplification 35 pM 50 pM- 5 nM [78]
Fluorescence enhancement of Ag NCs by dimer formation and auxiliary G rich sequence probe 12 pM 0.2–700 nM [79]
Non overlapping emission of different molecular beacon template Ag NCs 0.12 nM 0–250 nM [80]
Different interaction of ss DNA and ds DNA with MoS2 sheet 5.3 pM 0.01–0.25 nM [81]
Fluorescence Polarization Self-assembly of Au NPs to form the dendric macromolecules 73 pM 150 pM- 6 nM [94]
Chemiluminescence Hybridization chain reaction and AuNPs 5 fM 0.02–1 pM [96]
Molecularly Imprinted Polymer and Europium sulfide nano crystals 0.3 fM 0.3–3 fM [97]
Nano plasmonic SPR biosensing strategy based on dynamic entropy-driven strand displacement reactions and double-layer DNA tetrahedrons 48 fM 1 pM–150 nM [100]
SERS biosensing strategy based on hybridization of DNA conjugated on MGTIC/AuNPs 0.24 pg/ml 8 pg/ml – 64 ng/ml [108]
SERS biosensing strategy based on formation of multi metal molecule DNA nanoconjugation 100 AM 0–10 pM [109]
Dinamic Light Scattering (DLS) Combination of polymerase chain reaction and DLS 1.8 aM 10 aM–1.9 pM [113]
Photoelectrochemical HCR and enzyme catalysis for cascade signal amplification 11.3 aM 50 aM–100 pM [115]