Unprotected mothers and infants breastfeeding in public amenities during the COVID-19 pandemic

The outbreak of the coronavirus disease, named COVID-19, has quickly spread at the global scale. On July 11, 2020, there have been a total of 12,286,264 confirmed cases worldwide (WHO 2020a). Recent studies related to air pollution have reported that the novel coronavirus could survive in the ambient air for several hours and potentially transmit through aerosols, especially in enclosed indoor environments with limited social distancing and poor ventilation (Morawska and Milton 2020; Sharma et al. 2020; WHO 2020b). When breastfeeding in public amenities, mothers can wear masks or cloth face coverings to protect themselves from respirable virus carriers in the air, while their infants cannot wear any respiratory protection to avoid direct exposure to the indoor air. With respect to the airborne transmission of COVID-19, breastfeeding in public amenities therefore represents a blind spot in the current regulatory guidelines and risk mitigation efforts (CDC 2020; NHC 2020; WHO 2020c). Here we outline the common issues in the current design of lactation facilities and the use of other public amenities by breastfeeding mothers, as a timely reminder on the potential risks to breastfeeding mothers and unprotected infants during the current pandemic (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1.

Risk of infants' exposure to airborne pathogens and pollutants in a public lactation room. The number of lactation rooms have increased in the public space, yet many issues remain to be solved, such as inadequate area, location near toilets, poor ventilation and lack of air temperature control

Breastfeeding is the most effective way to ensure the health and survival of infants. For newborns, breastmilk is the ideal food because it is safe, nutritious and contains antibodies (WHO 2020d). While the COVID-19 has been detected in human breastmilk (Groß et al. 2020), there has been no evidence to date suggesting transmission to infants via breastmilk, but this appears more and more likely because a recent report has evidenced transplacental transmission to the fetus followed by neurological manifestations (Vivanti et al. 2020). The World Health Organization (WHO) has recommended mothers with confirmed or suspected COVID-19 infection to continue breastfeeding with necessary precautions (WHO 2020e). In the same vein, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends mothers to consider extending the duration of breastfeeding to supply antibodies to their infants or toddlers during the current pandemic (AAP 2020). Overall, breastfeeding appears to be a good practice to maintain the health and reduce the risks for infants during the current pandemic, yet there is a need for sufficient lactation rooms in the public space.

Once a privileged facility, lactation rooms have become more common as a public amenity for lactating mothers and their infants. For instance, the US federal laws require that employers with over 50 employees must provide a place—other than a bathroom—for employees to give breastmilk to infants (NCSL 2020). Some states require shopping malls, airports and public service centers to provide areas for breastfeeding (NCSL 2020). A recent survey shows that only 77% of US airports display information on accesses to lactation rooms (Lee et al. 2019). In China, the National Health Commission requires that baby care rooms with an area no less than 10 m² should be provided at transportation hubs, commercial centers, hospitals, tourist attractions and other public places either wider than 10,000 m² or with more than 10,000 visitors per day (NHC 2016). The commission also recommends employers to provide lactation rooms under the same conditions. As a result, in September 2018, there were about 286,000 organizations across the country which had provided lactation rooms in their workplace in China (Anonymous 2019). Overall, the number of lactation rooms has clearly increased, but their design and location may not be optimized.

Several issues have been evidenced in recently set-up public amenities for breastfeeding. For instance, many public lactation rooms are located in corners with an inadequate design, often as small, enclosed spaces with windowless walls. This is dangerous for the heath of mothers and babies because enclosed spaces such as schools and beauty salons are known to concentrate air pollutants (de Gennaro et al. 2014; Rogula-Kopiec et al. 2018). A survey of 105 lactation facilities in US university campuses revealed that over 80% of the designated spaces were structurally enclosed, and only about 40% of those places had in-room control of air temperature (Henry-Moss et al. 2019). Worse, only 8% of the busiest US airport fulfilled the minimum requirements of space and facilities for a public lactation room (Haight and Ortiz 2014). In China, while surveys are scarce, many lactation rooms and baby care rooms were found to be inadequate in sizes and ventilation (PMM 2018). For example, a survey of 60 public locations in three major Chinese cities disclosed that only 24% of locations provided an adequate area of more than 10 m² for baby care (Teng 2017). Moreover, 70% of those rooms were located next to public toilets, and only 35% of the rooms had good ventilation. This is a serious health issue because Zhu et al. (2001) found severe contamination in indoor air by bacteria in baby care rooms at a hospital, resulting in an overall low compliance rate of 40% versus the national standard. In conclusion, many lactation facilities are inappropriate in terms of location, ventilation, temperature control and health security. Mothers may therefore be tempted to find other locations.

Some mothers opt to breastfeed in public toilets as a secure place shielded from public views and free of intrusion by the opposite sex (Sha 2017). Such practice, which is commonly perceived as breastfeeding in public, threatens the unprotected infants because human wastes carry a myriad of pathogens (Haight and Ortiz 2014; Spurles and Babineau 2010; Datta et al. 2020). Indeed, pathogens could be transmitted not only by airborne transport of respiratory droplets, but also via the fecal–oral route from toilet flushing or poor hygiene. This is very likely because Knowlton et al. (2018) found that the atmospheric concentrations of fine particles, below 0.3 μm, and bioaerosols both increased significantly after toilet flushing in hospitals. Moreover, those aerosols formed a prolonged and uniform suspension in air with no obvious attenuation within 30 min after toilet flushing. In the same vein, 81% of aerosols and 78% of surfaces of public toilets located in an office building and a hospital contained respiratory or enteric viruses including the adenovirus, the Torque teno virus and the norovirus GII (Verani et al. 2014). Overall, breastfeeding in public toilets presents high risk of contamination, which might be aggravated by the fast breathing of infants.

Infants should be exclusively breastfed for six months and then continue to be fed with breastmilk and complementary food at least until 12 months (AAP 2012; WHO 2020f). For infants within six months of age, the general recommendation is 8–12 times during 24 h, each feeding lasting 10–20 min (CDC 2018; Littleton and Richardson 2019). Most importantly, infants younger than 12 months have much faster respiratory rates than adults, generally in the range 30–50 breaths per minute compared with 12–18 by adults (Fleming et al. 2011). While being breastfed, the infant’s nose and mouth are exposed to the ambient air, and the infant maintains a faster breathing rate for the suck-swallow-breath coordination. This suggests that infants are at elevated risks of exposure to airborne pathogens in public amenities during breastfeeding.

The COVID-19 episode has also accentuated the risk induced by poor ventilation. Indeed, regulators and utility operators have discouraged the use of air conditioning in confined public spaces to prevent the spread of COVID-19 by air circulation (CPMI 2020; WHO 2020g). This creates a dilemma for facilities lacking natural ventilation such as public lactation rooms. Furthermore, COVID-19 remained viable and infectious in aerosols for three hours at ambient conditions (van Doremalen et al. 2020). Higher rates of viral transmission were observed in confined space when persons were in contact with COVID-19 infected patients (Zhao et al. 2020). In addition, breastfeeding in public toilets or family restrooms increases the risk of fecal–oral transmission of COVID-19 (Xiao et al. 2020). High viral loads of COVID-19 have been detected in human feces, even in asymptomatic individuals and recovered patients several weeks after their respiratory samples became clear (Han et al. 2020; Wu et al. 2020; Zhang et al. 2020). Direct evidence was provided on June 25, 2020, by the Beijing Center for Disease Prevention and Control, which announced that two persons became infected after using a public toilet that was later tested positive (Li 2020). This was known as the first confirmed case of COVID-19 transmission in public toilet environments in China. Overall, the risk of virus transmission to breastfeeding mothers and infants in public amenities is high. What could we suggest to improve their safety?

There is actually no viable means of protecting an infant’s respiration while being breastfed. To this date, no specific guideline has been published to mitigate such risks during the current pandemic (CDC 2020; NHC 2020). Given that many public breastfeeding amenities are small and poorly ventilated, we suggest that, when not in use, doors should be regularly opened to allow natural ventilation, while standard cleaning and disinfection protocols for public spaces are followed (CDC 2020). When breastfeeding in a public facility, mothers should wear respiratory protection to protect themselves and others who may use the same facility concurrently or shortly after. Mothers should use the facility alone during the current pandemic to reduce the risk of cross-infection between users. In light of the known risks of fecal–oral transmission of COVID-19, breastfeeding in public toilets is not recommended during the current pandemic. Instead, mothers should be encouraged to breastfeed in open areas where good ventilation and physical distancing can be achieved. Efforts should also be put in improving the design of public lactation rooms, including the provision of adequate areas and emergency ventilation facilities. Safety windows should be installed well above the average height of adults with exhaust fans in operation to maintain good ventilation in the room without compromising the privacy of users. More generally, air pollution and the associated health risks should be alleviated both indoors and outdoors using any means (Yu 2014, 2019; Feng and Zheng 2019; Wang et al. 2020). Here, recent results suggest that the use of essential oils, a traditional medicine, may offset the deleterious effect of airborne particulate matter (Kfoury et al. 2016).

Funding

This work was funded by the “Young Talent Support Plan” of Xi’an Jiaotong University.

Compliance with ethical standards

Conflict of interest

Authors declare that they have no conflict of interest in this work.