Transgenic animal models of congenital diaphragmatic hernia: a comprehensive overview of candidate genes and signaling pathways

Abstract

Congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) is a relatively common and life-threatening birth defect, characterized by incomplete formation of the diaphragm. Because CDH herniation occurs at the same time as preacinar airway branching, normal lung development becomes severely disrupted, resulting almost invariably in pulmonary hypoplasia. Despite various research efforts over the past decades, the pathogenesis of CDH and associated lung hypoplasia remains poorly understood. With the advent of molecular techniques, transgenic animal models of CDH have generated a large number of candidate genes, thus providing a novel basis for future research and treatment. This review article offers a comprehensive overview of genes and signaling pathways implicated in CDH etiology, whilst also discussing strengths and limitations of transgenic animal models in relation to the human condition.

Introduction

Congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) is a developmental abnormality characterized by the presence of a defect in the integrity of the forming diaphragm, affecting between 1.9 and 2.3 cases per 10,000 newborns in the United States [1] and Europe [2]. Defects in the posterolateral diaphragm, commonly referred to as Bochdalek hernias, comprise approximately 90-95% of all CDH cases with about 80% occurring on the left side, 15% on the right and less than 5% bilaterally [3]. Non-posterolateral CDH manifests as anterior conditions such as Morgagni hernias in the anterior retrosternal or peristernal diaphragm and central hernias in the central tendinous portion of the diaphragm [4]. Posterolateral diaphragmatic defects permit protrusion of the abdominal viscera into the thoracic cavity, thus interfering with normal lung development and frequently leading to severe respiratory distress at birth due to the unfortunate combination of pulmonary hypoplasia and persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn [3, 5].

Over the last decade, CDH remained a life-threatening congenital disorder with mortality rates up to 50% [6–9]. Treatment usually consists of surgical movement of the abdominal viscera out of the thoracic cavity and closure of the diaphragmatic defect. Large defects may be difficult to repair through direct sutures, requiring the use of a prosthetic patch or abdominal muscle flap [10, 11]. Apart from surgical methods, treatment options for CDH are limited due to its poorly understood etiology, thereby motivating the need for better experimental models to elucidate its pathogenesis while also testing new therapeutic approaches. Investigation of novel medical therapies and pharmacological compounds that have the ability to arrest or reverse associated lung hypoplasia in animal models of CDH require the application of standardized research methodologies [12]. In this review article, we discuss the development of and findings associated with transgenic animal models of CDH to highlight the progress made to date in understanding CDH pathogenesis and evolution.

Transgenic animal models of CDH

Both environmental and genetic factors are thought to contribute to the etiology of CDH. To date, genetic causes have been identified in approximately 30% of neonates with CDH [13–15]. With the advent of innovative molecular techniques in recent years, transgenic animal models of CDH have become more common, offering new candidate genes and signaling pathways implicated in the pathogenesis and etiology of diaphragmatic defects and associated lung abnormalities (Table 1). So far, 18 mouse models with phenotypic similarities to human CDH have been listed in the Mouse Genome Database (http://www.informatics.jax.org).

Table 1.

Transgenic mouse models of congenital diaphragmatic hernia

Symbol	Gene name	Diaphragmatic defect	Pulmonary abnormality
Rarα, Rarβ2	Retinoic acid receptor, α and β2	Diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia, abnormal alveoli
Lrp1	Low density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 1	Diaphragmatic hernia	–
Nr2f2 (Couptf2)	Nuclear receptor subfamily 2, group F, member 2	Posterior diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia
Wt1	Wilms tumor 1 homolog	Posterior diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia
Msc (MyoR)	Musculin	Posterior diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia, abnormal branching, abnormal vasculature
Tcf21 (capsulin)	Transcription factor 21	Posterior diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia, abnormal branching, abnormal vasculature
Gli2/3	GLI-Kruppel family member 2 and 3	Diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia, absent right lung accessory lobe, thick mesenchyme
Shh	Sonic hedgehog	Diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia
Kif7	Kinesin family member 7	Posterior diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia
Zfpm2 (Fog2)	Zinc finger protein, multitype 2	Posterolateral diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia, absent right lung accessory lobe
Gata4	GATA-binding protein 4	Central diaphragmatic hernia (with sac)	Abnormal saccule morphologic features, abnormal vasculature
Sox7	Sex determining region Y-box 7	Retrosternal diaphragmatic hernia	–
Frem1	FRAS1-related extracellular matrix 1	Retrosternal diaphragmatic hernia	Lung lobulation defects
c-Met	Mesenchymal-epithelial transition factor	Amascular diaphragm with hernia	Abnormal saccule morphologic features
Fgf10	Fibroblast growth factor 10	Posterolateral diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia
Slit3	Slit guidance ligand 3	Anterior midline diaphragmatic hernia	–
Lox	Lysyl oxidase	Central diaphragmatic hernia, thin diaphragm muscle	Lung hypoplasia, abnormal acini, abnormal elastic fibers
Pdgfra	Platelet-derived growth factor receptor, α-polypeptide	Posterolateral diaphragmatic hernia	Lung hypoplasia, abnormal alveoli, increased cell proliferation
Robo1/2	Roundabout guidance receptor 1/2	Posterior diaphragmatic hernia	Abnormal alveoli, thick septa
Ndst1	N-deacetylase-N-sulfotransferase-1	Diaphragmatic hernia in the anterior midline of the septum transversum	–

Retinoid signaling pathway

Several knockout models have originated from gene pathways found to be associated with CDH such as the retinoid signaling pathway [13]. Mice deficient in both subtypes of retinoic acid receptors α and β (Rarα and Rarβ) have been shown to produce offspring with CDH [16–21], consistent with the vitamin A-deficient mouse models observed by Anderson [22, 23]. Single Rar null mutation mice did not exhibit the expected anomalies, which were reported in vitamin A-deficient rats [9]. However, when the function of these receptors was suppressed, multiple congenital anomalies were observed, including right-sided CDH in Rarαβ2 mutant mice and left-sided CDH in Rarαβ2^+/− animals. In addition, these mice suffer from severe pulmonary hypertension at birth [9]. Unfortunately, these animals demonstrate a relative low rate of diaphragmatic defects and a high incidence of comorbidities including cranial, vertebral, limb, cardiac, foregut and pulmonary malformations that do not accurately reflect human CDH [20, 21]. Nevertheless, mutations in the stimulated by retinoic acid gene 6 (STRA6) and cellular retinoic acid binding protein 1 (CRABP1) on chromosome 15 have been identified in CDH patients [9].

Nr2f2 (Couptf2)

Another gene associated with the retinoid signaling pathway is chickovalbuminupstreampromoter transcription factor II (COUP-TFII), a transcription factor belonging to the steroid/thyroid hormone receptor superfamily, whose DNA-binding site has been found to downregulate hormonal induction of retinoic acid receptors [24–26]. Recently, COUP-TFII was renamed as nuclear receptor subfamily 2, group F, member 2 (NR2F2) [13]. Mapping to chromosome 15q26, the NR2F2 gene is located on a well-known CDH hotspot region in humans, making it a strong candidate gene for CDH pathogenesis. Based on this knowledge, You et al. [27] have developed a tissue-specific Nr2f2 null mutant mouse model that exhibits Bochdalek-type CDH. In ablating Nr2f2 in the foregut mesenchyme, diaphragmatic defects occurred due to the failure of the posthepatic mesenchymal plate to attach to the lateral body wall [27].

Wt1

Developing transgenic animal models for various applications has also uncovered genes less likely to be associated with CDH. Originally created as a model to study early urogenital development [28], Wilm’s tumor 1 (Wt1) null mutant mice displayed diaphragmatic defects in addition to urogenital malformations. Mutations of the WT1 gene, which encodes a DNA-binding protein with four zinc fingers, have been identified in two CDH-related cases of Denys-Drash syndrome [29] and in one case of Meacham syndrome [30]. A decade ago, vitamin A-deficient, nitrofen and Wt1 null mutant mouse models of CDH all suggested a common pathogenic mechanism for CDH development with similarities to the human condition [31]. Moreover, Carmona et al. [32] have shown that conditional deletion of Wt1 in the septum transversum mesenchyme causes CDH in mice. It is now established that Wt1 and Couptf2 both interact with retinoid signaling during embryogenesis [33]. Interestingly, Wt1 and Couptf2 are not expressed in the muscle precursors but in the non-muscle mesenchymal component of the pleuroperitoneal folds (PPFs) [33].

Msc (MyoR) and Tcf21 (capsulin)

The double mutant musculin (Msc)^−/− and transcription factor 21 (Tcf21)^−/− mouse model, initially generated to characterize facial muscle development, features posterior CDH along with facial muscle defects. Although these double mutant mice died shortly after birth, the model’s diaphragmatic defect suggests that both Msc and Tcf21 are required to maintain the integrity of the forming diaphragm. Today, their synonyms are known as myogenic bHLH transcription factor R (MyoR) and capsulin, respectively [34, 35].

Gli2/3, Shh and Kif7

GLI-Kruppel family member 2 (Gli2), Gli3 and sonic hedgehog (Shh) are members of a highly conserved morphogenetic family, which is known as the Shh signaling pathway [9, 36]. Murine models of VACTERL (vertebral, anorectal, cardiac, tracheoesophageal, renal and limb anomalies) syndrome involving Gli2^−/−-, Gli3^−/−- and Gli2^−/−/Gli3^+/−-mice developed left-sided CDH in addition to the reported VACTERL anomalies [36]. This is the first model that imitates the human VACTERL association, suggesting that aberations in Shh signaling might be involved in the VACTERL syndrome [37]. Furthermore, as Gli2, Gli3 and Wt1 all encode zinc finger proteins, other zinc finger transcription factors have also been associated with the development of transgenic animal models of CDH. Kinesin family member 7 (Kif7) has recently been identified as an essential component of the Shh signaling pathway as a negative regulator in early embryonic development [38]. Kif7 encodes a motor protein that functions downstream of the G protein-coupled transmembrane receptor smoothened, and interacts with Gli2 and Gli3 [38]. Additionally, Kif7 is required for the patterning and differentiation of the diaphragm in a model of syndromic CDH [38].

Zfpm2, Gata4, Sox7 and Frem1

Zinc finger protein, multitype 2 (ZFPM2), previously known as friend of GATA-binding protein 2 (FOG2), similarly encodes a zinc finger protein that primarily interacts with another zinc finger protein GATA4 to regulate various developmental processes in the diaphragm, lung and heart [39–41]. Moreover, ZFPM2 is located on chromosome 8p23 and interacts physically with COUP-TFII [42, 43]. Despite sufficient evidence that certain genes are involved in the pathogenesis of different types of CDH, only one mutation in ZFPM2 has been demonstrated in a single patient with non-syndromic CDH until now [9]. In a cohort of 275 CDH patient exomes, Longoni et al. [44] have estimated the prevalence of damaging ZFPM2 mutations to be almost 5%. Furthermore, genetic analysis of a multi-generational family identified a heritable intragenic ZFPM2 deletion with an estimated penetrance of 37.5% [44]. Mice treated with the chemical mutagen N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea in turn produced Fog2^−/− offspring with pulmonary hypoplasia and abnormal diaphragmatic development characteristic of CDH [39], while a double knockout strain of Gata4 mice predisposed inbred mice to comparable physical defects [45]. Using mouse genetics, Merrell et al. [46] have confirmed that Gata4 mosaic mutations in PPF-derived muscle connective tissue fibroblasts result in the formation of localized amuscular regions that are biomechanically weaker and lead to CDH. Both ZFPM2 and GATA4 genes have been reportedly deleted in human CDH patients [40], strengthening their claims as candidate genes for CDH. Recurrent microdeletions of 8p23.1 that include GATA4 and sex determining region Y-box 7 (SOX7) are associated with a high risk of both CDH and cardiac defects [47]. Although Gata4-deficient mice showed both CDH and cardiac defects, humans with cardiac defects attributed to GATA4 mutations have not been reported to have CDH [47]. On the other hand, Wat et al. [47] revealed that haploinsufficiency of Sox7 or Gata4 is sufficient to produce anterior CDH in mice and that haploinsufficiency of SOX7 and GATA4 may each contribute to the development of CDH in patients with 8p23.1 deletions. After identification of a FRAS1-related extracellular matrix 1 (FREM1) deletion in a child with isolated left-sided posterolateral CDH that was covered by a membranous sac, Beck et al. [48] created a Frem1-deficient mouse model that exhibits a similar phenotype including a retrosternal diaphragmatic defect and decreased levels of cell proliferation in the anterior portion of the developing diaphragm, demonstrating that FREM1 deficiency can cause CDH in both humans and mice. Due to phenotypic overlaps between Frem1-deficient mice and mice that are deficient for the retinoic acid-responsive transcription factor Gata4, the authors performed further experiments, proving that Frem1 interacts genetically with Gata4 in the development of lung lobulation defects in this model [49].

c-Met and Fgf10

In addition to ZFPM2 and GATA4, several other candidate genes have been implicated in CDH pathogenesis, yielding more transgenic animal models and thus greater insight into CDH etiology. For instance, the mesenchymal-epithelial transition factor (c-Met) proto-oncogene codes for a receptor tyrosine kinase responsible for migration of muscle precursor cells into the diaphragm [50], while fibroblast growth factor 10 (Fgf10) is critical for early lung development [51]. Oral administration of nitrofen in Met^−/− mice with amuscular diaphragms and Fgf10^−/− mice with hypoplastic lungs induced CDH in both murine models, suggesting that diaphragmatic defects occur independent of myogenesis and lung formation [52].

Slit3, Lox, Pdgfra, Robo1/2 and Ndst1

As part of the Slit guidance ligand (SLIT) family of proteins responsible for axon crossing at the midline, homozygous Slit3-deficiency in mice causes failure of the central tendon region of the diaphragm to separate from the liver tissue, producing central (i.e. septum transversum) CDH [53, 54]. As a result, this specific model suffers from having the diaphragm defect in the ventral midline portion of the central tendon rather than in the posterolateral diaphragm. Other anomalies include renal and ureteric agenesis along with constant herniation of the liver and the gallbladder [54], which are uncommon in human CDH. Similarly, lysyl oxidase (Lox)^−/−-mice were shown to have ruptured diaphragms due to fragmentation in the central tendon [55, 56]. On the other hand, while mice homozygous for null mutations in platelet-derived growth factor receptor α (Pdgfra) develop posterolateral diaphragmatic defects, they also present with a wide range of additional comorbidities including cardiac defects, renal and urogenital anomalies, facial clefts as well as pulmonary hypertension [57]. Roudabout (Robo) genes encode cell-surface receptors that have responsibility of their secreted ligands, Slit proteins, in various cellular processes [58–60]. The Slit-Robo signaling pathway has been demonstrated to play several key roles including neural crest cell migration and sensory ganglia morphogenesis, leukocyte chemotaxis, epithelial adhesion, embryonic and heart development as well as diaphragm and kidney formation [53, 54, 58, 61–65]. In fact, inactivation of Robo1 and Robo2 in mice leads to diaphragmatic malformation and mispositioning of the stomach in the thoracic instead of the abdominal cavity, which likely contributes to poor lung inflation and lethality at birth, reminiscent of CDH cases in humans [58]. Zhang et al. [66] have reported that ablation of the heparan sulfate biosynthetic enzyme N-deacetylase-N-sulfotransferase-1 (Ndst1) in mouse endothelium disrupts vascular development in the diaphragm, leading to hypoxia as well as subsequent diaphragmatic hypoplasia and central-type CDH. Interestingly, the phenotypes displayed in these mice resembled the developmental defects observed in Slit3 knockout mice. Furthermore, introduction of a heterozygous mutation in Robo4, the gene encoding the cognate receptor of Slit3, aggravated the defects in vascular development in the diaphragm and CDH [66]. Consequently, these results suggest that loss of Ndst1 causes defective diaphragm vascular development and CDH and that heparan sulfate facilitates the angiogenic Slit3-Robo4 signaling cascade during vascular development.

Conclusion and future directions

Experimental animal models of CDH have not only allowed us to study the pathophysiology and etiology of this relatively complex birth defect, but have also provided new insights into the molecular and biochemical basis, thus contributing to advances in the medical and surgical management. Hence, CDH animals in which this malformation occurs naturally are ideal models to investigate disease pathogenesis and associated pulmonary hypoplasia, as there is little or no interference to the animal prior to the study. Additionally, transgenic animal models of CDH not only mimic the natural occurrence of this condition, but also give a better understanding into the genes involved and how their modification might alter the course of the disease. Teratogen-induced CDH models although useful, have in turn the drawback of exposing the animals to a generalized noxious stimulus, which can result in widespread detrimental effects rather than simply targeting a specific organ system. The combination of transgenic animal models with regenerative tissue engineering and stem cell-based therapy may play a role in future CDH research by developing a myogenic patch capable of restoring muscle fraction in fetal diaphragmatic defects and promoting regeneration of hypoplastic lungs [67–70].

Compliance with ethical standards

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.