Short abstract
LINKED CONTENT
This article is linked to Tian et al and Tian and Rong papers. To view these articles, visit https://doi.org/10.1111/apt.15731 and https://doi.org/10.1111/apt.15986
1.
EDITORS,
Tian et al have reviewed gastrointestinal characteristics of 2023 patients with COVID‐19 described in case reports and retrospective cohort studies. 1 The prevalence of gastrointestinal symptoms varied extensively among different studies (3%‐79%), which were all retrospective and from Eastern countries. The authors acknowledged that the retrospective design of included studies could have led to some selection bias.
Here, we report findings from a prospective cross‐sectional study of prevalence and patterns of gastrointestinal symptoms, assessed through the Gastrointestinal Symptoms Rating Scale (GSRS), 2 in all patients with COVID‐19 (diagnosed with nasopharyngeal swab and RT‐PCR for SARS‐CoV‐2) hospitalised at our centre up to 15 April 2020. We excluded patients with a critical clinical picture at admission and those with recent (15 to 30 days before the start of COVID‐19 symptoms) history of gastrointestinal symptoms or clinically active gastrointestinal disease. All patients who did not present with gastrointestinal symptoms at diagnosis repeated the GSRS questionnaire 48‐72 hours after the start of COVID‐19 therapy. Clinical pictures were defined according to recommendations from the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention.
We have enrolled 420 patients (M = 238, F = 182, median age 61). Of these, 247 (59%) reported at least one gastrointestinal symptom, of which the most common were diarrhoea (37%), nausea (19%), urgency (17%), loose stools (16%) and upper abdominal pain (14%). At the GSRS evaluation, the highest mean scores were for urgency (mean = 4), diarrhoea (mean = 3.8), nausea (mean = 3.6), and loose stools (mean = 3.4).
117 patients (47% of the overall cohort) presented with gastrointestinal symptoms at admission, while 130 (53%) became symptomatic only after the start of COVID‐19 therapy, which included anti‐virals (n = 318, 76% of the overall cohort), hydroxychloroquine (n = 314, 75% of the overall cohort), antibiotics (n = 231, 55% of the overall cohort), anti IL‐6 agents (n = 105, 25% of the overall cohort).
Upper gastrointestinal symptoms, including heartburn (15/117 vs 4/130, P = 0.007), acid reflux (15/117 vs 6/130, P = 0.02), hunger pains (10/117 vs 1/130, P = 0.003), nausea (43/117 vs 35/130, P = 0.04) and rumbling (11/117 vs 3/130, P = 0.02), were more frequent at admission, while diarrhoea appeared more commonly after therapy (57/117 vs 98/130, P < 0.0001). Finally, through multivariate analysis, gastrointestinal symptoms (OR 2.35, 95% IC 1.04 to 5.3, p= 0.04) were independent predictors of a critical clinical picture.
In conclusion, this is the largest prospective Western cohort to describe the prevalence and patterns of gastrointestinal symptoms in patients with COVID‐19 so far. Through a validated scoring system, we found that gastrointestinal symptoms are present in a large proportion of patients with COVID‐19, but that they appear only after the start of COVID‐19 related therapy in nearly a half of patients. We also found two different patterns of symptoms according to the timing of appearance (at admission vs after therapy). Finally, we found that gastrointestinal symptoms could predict a worse clinical picture. Further clinical and translational studies are advocated, respectively, to confirm our findings and to address their nature through a mechanicistic approach.
REFERENCES
- 1. Tian Y, Rong L, Nian W, He Y. Review article: gastrointestinal features in COVID‐19 and the possibility of faecal transmission. Aliment Pharmacol Ther. 2020;51:843–851. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 2. Svedlund J, Sjödin I, Dotevall G. GSRS a clinical rating scale for gastrointestinal symptoms in patients with irritable bowel syndrome and peptic ulcer disease. Dig Dis Sci. 1988;33:129–134. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Declaration of personal interests: AG reports personal fees for consultancy for Eisai S.r.l., 3PSolutions, Real Time Meeting, Fondazione Istituto Danone, Sinergie S.r.l. Board MRGE, and Sanofi S.p.A, personal fees for acting as a speaker for Takeda S.p.A, AbbVie, and Sandoz S.p.A, and personal fees for acting on advisory boards for VSL3 and Eisai. None of the other authors has conflicts of interest to disclose.
Conflict of interests: None of the Authors has conflicts of interest to declare.
Full list of collaborators: “Gemelli against COVID” group: Valeria Abbate; Fabiana Agostini; Elena Amato; Gloria Andriollo; Gabriele Antonucci; Francesca Benvenuto; Ludovica Berardini; Roberto Bernabei; Antonio Bianchi; Marzio Biasucci Luigi; Stefano Bibbò; Federico Biscetti; Alberto Borghetti; Silvia Bosello; Vincenzo Bove; Giulia Bramato; Vincenzo Brandi; Dario Bruno; Chiara Bungaro Maria; Alessandro Buonomo; Livia Burzo; Giulia Cammà; Rosaria Calvello Maria; Esmeralda Capristo; Leonardo Cecchini Andrea; Angelo Calabrese; Lorenzo Capaldi; Angelo Carfì; Cristiano Caruso; Antonio Casciaro Francesco; Rossella Cianci; Francesca Ciciarello; Antonella Cingolani; Gaetano Coppola; Andrea Corsello; Federico Costante; Stefano D’Addio; Alessia D’Alessandro; Emanuela D’Angelo; Francesca D’Aversa; Tommaso De Cunzo; Flavio De Maio; Giuseppe De Matteis; Martina De Siena; Francesco De Vito; Valeria Del Gatto; Davide Della Polla; Luca Di Gialleonardo; Simona Di Giambenedetto; Roberta Di Luca; Alessandra Esperide; Domenico Faliero; Massimo Fantoni; Annalaura Fedele; Daniela Feliciani; Francesco Franceschi; Laura Franza; Barbara Funaro; Domenico Fusco; Maurizio Gabrielli; Antonella Gallo; Giovanni Gambassi; Matteo Garcovich; Irene Gasparrini; Silvia Gelli; Antonella Giampietro; Laura Gigante; Elisa Gremese; Valeria Guglielmi; Caterina Guidone; Amerigo Iaconelli; Angela Iaquinta; Michele Impagnatiello; Riccardo Inchingolo; Raffaele Iorio; Rita Lo Monaco; Francesco Landi; Rosario Landi; Raffaele Landolfi; Massimo Leo; Maria Leone Paolo; Antonio Liguori; Maria Lizzio Marco; Pietro Locantore; Francesco Lombardi; Loris Lopetuso;Francesco Macagno; Noemi Macerola; Francesco Mancarella; Francesca Mangiola; Giuseppe Marrone; Ilaria Martis; Maria Martone Anna; Valeria Matteo Maria; Luca Miele; Domenico Milardi; Alessio Migneco; Irene Mignini; Massimo Montalto; Flavia Monti; Vincenzina Mora; Ambra Murace Celeste; Rita Murri; Elisabetta Nardella; Gerlando Natalello; Alberto Nicoletti; Tommaso Nicoletti; Cosimo Pagano Francesco; Giovanni Papparella Luigi; Alfredo Papa; Mattia Paratore; Simone Perniola; Erika Pero; Giuseppe Perrinello; Luca Petricca; Marco Pizzoferrato; Fabrizio Pizzolante; Caterina Policola; Valerio Pontecorvi; Valentina Popolla; Enrica Porceddu; Angelo Porfidia; Gabriele Pulcini; Lodovico Rapaccini Gian; Luca Richeldi; Emanuele Rinninella; Sara Rocchi; Laura Rossi; Raimondo Rossi; Enrica Rossini; Elisabetta Rota; Fabiana Rovedi; Gabriele Rumi; Andrea Russo; Andrea Salerno; Lucia Salvatore; Luca Santarelli; Paolo Santini; Maurizio Sanguinetti; Angelo Santoliquido; Caterina Sarnari; Tommaso Schepis; Francesca Schiavello; Luisa Sestito; Carlo Romano Settanni; Jacopo Simonetti; Andrea Smargiassi; Leonardo Stella; Rossella Talerico; Claudia Tarli; Alberto Tosoni; Luca Tricoli; Marcello Tritto; Federico Valletta; Lucrezia Verardi; Lorenzo Vetrone; Elena Visconti; Lorenzo Zelano.
Contributor Information
Gianluca Ianiro, Email: gianluca.ianiro@hotmail.it.
Gemelli against COVID‐19 Working Group:
Valeria Abbate, Fabiana Agostini, Elena Amato, Gloria Andriollo, Gabriele Antonucci, Francesca Benvenuto, Ludovica Berardini, Roberto Bernabei, Antonio Bianchi, Marzio Biasucci Luigi, Federico Biscetti, Alberto Borghetti, Silvia Bosello, Vincenzo Bove, Giulia Bramato, Vincenzo Brandi, Dario Bruno, Chiara Bungaro Maria, Alessandro Buonomo, Livia Burzo, Giulia Cammà, Rosaria Calvello Maria, Esmeralda Capristo, Leonardo Cecchini Andrea, Angelo Calabrese, Lorenzo Capaldi, Angelo Carfì, Cristiano Caruso, Antonio Casciaro Francesco, Rossella Cianci, Francesca Ciciarello, Antonella Cingolani, Gaetano Coppola, Andrea Corsello, Federico Costante, Stefano D’Addio, Alessia D’Alessandro, Emanuela D’Angelo, Francesca D’Aversa, Tommaso De Cunzo, Flavio De Maio, Giuseppe De Matteis, Martina De Siena, Francesco De Vito, Valeria Del Gatto, Davide Della Polla, Luca Di Gialleonardo, Simona Di Giambenedetto, Roberta Di Luca, Alessandra Esperide, Domenico Faliero, Massimo Fantoni, Annalaura Fedele, Daniela Feliciani, Laura Franza, Barbara Funaro, Domenico Fusco, Maurizio Gabrielli, Antonella Gallo, Giovanni Gambassi, Matteo Garcovich, Irene Gasparrini, Silvia Gelli, Antonella Giampietro, Laura Gigante, Elisa Gremese, Valeria Guglielmi, Caterina Guidone, Amerigo Iaconelli, Angela Iaquinta, Michele Impagnatiello, Riccardo Inchingolo, Raffaele Iorio, Rita Lo Monaco, Francesco Landi, Rosario Landi, Raffaele Landolfi, Massimo Leo, Maria Leone Paolo, Antonio Liguori, Maria Lizzio Marco, Pietro Locantore, Francesco Lombardi, Loris Lopetuso, Francesco Macagno, Noemi Macerola, Francesco Mancarella, Francesca Mangiola, Giuseppe Marrone, Ilaria Martis, Maria Martone Anna, Valeria Matteo Maria, Luca Miele, Domenico Milardi, Alessio Migneco, Irene Mignini, Massimo Montalto, Flavia Monti, Vincenzina Mora, Ambra Murace Celeste, Rita Murri, Elisabetta Nardella, Gerlando Natalello, Alberto Nicoletti, Tommaso Nicoletti, Cosimo Pagano Francesco, Giovanni Papparella Luigi, Alfredo Papa, Mattia Paratore, Simone Perniola, Erika Pero, Giuseppe Perrinello, Luca Petricca, Marco Pizzoferrato, Fabrizio Pizzolante, Caterina Policola, Valerio Pontecorvi, Valentina Popolla, Enrica Porceddu, Angelo Porfidia, Gabriele Pulcini, Lodovico Rapaccini Gian, Luca Richeldi, Emanuele Rinninella, Sara Rocchi, Laura Rossi, Raimondo Rossi, Enrica Rossini, Elisabetta Rota, Fabiana Rovedi, Gabriele Rumi, Andrea Russo, Andrea Salerno, Lucia Salvatore, Luca Santarelli, Paolo Santini, Maurizio Sanguinetti, Angelo Santoliquido, Caterina Sarnari, Tommaso Schepis, Francesca Schiavello, Luisa Sestito, Jacopo Simonetti, Andrea Smargiassi, Leonardo Stella, Rossella Talerico, Claudia Tarli, Alberto Tosoni, Luca Tricoli, Marcello Tritto, Federico Valletta, Lucrezia Verardi, Lorenzo Vetrone, Elena Visconti, and Lorenzo Zelano