Table 1. Studies on peripheral-physiological correlates of the flow state.
Ref. | N subjects |
Age mean/ range |
Sample | Experiment type | Design | Measure | Peripheral-physiological correlates of flow |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kivikangas (2006) | 32(m) | 17–34 | Healthy students | FPS game: Halo: combat evolved | 40 min gameplay | FEMG, EDA | Negative correlations between CS activity & flow |
Chanel et al. (2008) | 20 (7f) | 27 | Healthy participants | Tetris game | 5 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
EDA, BP, Res, T | Increase in EDA & HR with increasing difficulty |
Nacke & Lindley (2008) | 25(m) | 19–38 | Healthy students | FPS game: Half-Life 2 | 10 min Under-challenged, Immersion, Flow |
FEMG, EDA | Highest ZM activity & EDA values in the flow condition |
Drachen et al. (2010) | 16 | – | – | FPS games: Prey, Doom3, Biochock | 20 min gameplay | EDA, HR | Negative correlation between HR & flow subscale score |
Chanel et al. (2011) | 20(7f) | 27 | Healthy participants | Tetris game | 5 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
EDA, BP, Res, T, EEG | Least LF-HRV in the flow condition |
Keller et al. (2011) | 8(4f) 61(m) |
– | Healthy students | Computerized knowledge task, Tetris game | Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
HRV, Cortisol | Lower HRV & higher cortisol in the flow condition |
Peifer et al. (2014) | 22(m) | 20–34 | Healthy students | Cabin Air Management System software | 60 min performance | ECG, Cortisol | Inverted U-shaped relationship of LF-HRV & cortisol level with the flow experience; positive linear relationship between HF-HRV & flow |
Léger et al. (2014) | 36 | – | Healthy students | Enterprise Resource Planning software | Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
ECG, EDA, EEG | Smaller variation of EDA, lower HR, & higher HRV in the flow condition |
Harmat et al. (2015) | 77(40f) | 27 | Healthy subjects | Tetris game | 6 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
fNIRS, ECG, Res | Larger RD & lower LF-HRV in the flow condition |
Tozman et al. (2015) | 18(6f) | 19 | Healthy students | Sporting race game: Rfactor | 6 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
ECG | Negative linear relationship between LF-HRV & flow in the flow condition; Inverted U-shaped relation between LF-HRV / HF-HRV & flow in the anxiety condition |
Bian et al. (2016) | 36(16f) | 20–27 | Healthy adults | VR game: Air Bombardment | 6 min gameplay | ECG, Res, FEMG | Inverted U-shaped relationship between LF-HRV, HF-HRV, & flow |
Harris, Vine & Wilson (2016) | 33(10f) | 20 | Healthy students | Simulated car racing game | Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
ECG, eye gaze position | Lower SD of horizontal gaze position & Lower HF-HRV in the flow condition |
Ulrich, Keller & Grön (2016) | 23(m) | 24 | Healthy students | Mental arithmetic task | 30 s Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged | fMRI, EDA | Greater EDA in the flow condition |
Tian et al. (2017) | 40(27f) | 17–24 | Healthy students | Blocmania 3D game |
6 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged | ECG, Res, EDA | Faster respiratory rate, increased RD, moderate HR, moderate HRV, & moderate EDA in the flow condition |
De Sampaio Barros et al. (2018) | 20 (7f) | 26 | Healthy adults | Tetris, Pong games | 3 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged, Autonomy |
ECG, Res, NIRS | Lower HRV in the autonomy condition |
Kozhevnikov et al. (2018) | 56(17f) | – | Healthy students | Unreal Tournament 2004 game | 30 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
ECG | Lower HF-HRV in the flow condition |
Moreno et al. (2020) | 1 | 27 | Expert gamer | Portal game | 45 min gameplay |
EDA, EEG | Increased EDA during moments of goal attainment |
Notes.
- ECG
- electrocardiography
- EEG
- electroencephalography
- FEMG
- facial electromyography
- EDA
- electrodermal activity
- BP
- blood pressure
- T
- temperature
- HR
- heart rate
- HP
- heart period
- ZM
- zygomaticus major
- CS
- corrugator supercilii
- HRV
- heart rate variability
- LF-HRV
- low-frequency heart-rate variability
- HF-HRV
- high-frequency heart-rate variability
- Res
- respiration
- RD
- respiratory depth
- fNIRS
- functional near-infrared spectroscopy
- NIRS
- near-infrared spectroscopy
- fMRI
- functional magnetic resonance imaging
- FPS
- first person shooter
- SD
- standard deviation
- m
- male
- f
- female