Table 2. Studies on neural correlates of the flow state: brain imaging investigations.
Ref. |
N subjects |
Age mean/ range |
Sample | Experiment type | Design | Measure | Neural correlates of flow |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Klasen et al. (2008) | 18 | – | – | FPS game: Counter Strike | 12 min gameplay | fMRI | Correlation between game pleasure, cerebro-thalamic motor, & visual network activity |
Klasen et al. (2012) | 13(m) | 18-26 | Healthy students | FPS game: Tactical Ops Assault on Terror | 12 min gameplay | fMRI | Activation of somatosensory networks & motor areas during situations with enhanced probability of flow |
Ulrich et al. (2014) | 27(m) | 23 | Healthy students | Mental arithmetic task | 184 s Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged | Perfusion MRI | Increased activity in the left IFG, left putamen, & posterior cortical regions as well as decrease in MPFC and AMY in the flow condition |
Yoshida et al. (2014) | 20(10f) | 21–25 | Healthy students | Tetris game | 4 min Under-challenged, Flow | fNIRS | Higher activation of VLPFC in the flow condition |
Harmat et al. (2015) | 77(40f) | 27 | Healthy subjects | Tetris game | 6 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
fNIRS, ECG, Res | No association between frontal cortical oxygenation & flow |
Ulrich, Keller & Grön (2016) | 23(m) | 24 | Healthy students | Mental arithmetic task | 30 s Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged | fMRI , EDA | Increased activity in the left IFG, left putamen, & posterior cortical regions in the flow condition; decreased activity in MPFC, PCC and AMY in the flow condition |
De Sampaio Barros et al. (2018) | 20 (7f) | 26 | Healthy adults | Tetris, Pong games | 3 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged, Autonomy | ECG, Res, NIRS | Higher activation in lateral PFC & deactivation in MPFC in the autonomy condition |
Ulrich et al. (2018) | 22(m) | 24.9 | Healthy students | Mental arithmetic task | 170 s Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged | Perfusion MRI, tDCS | Increase in the flow index of lower-flow group under anodal midfrontal tDCS stimulation & stronger deactivation of AMY |
Gold & Ciorciari (2019) | 11(m) 21(11f) |
29–31 | Trained & untrained gamers | FPS games: Counter Strike Global Offensive , Battlefield 4, Tetris game | 20 min & 3 min Under-challenged, Flow, Over-challenged |
tDCS | Higher level of flow after the active tDCS over DLPFC & right parietal cortex |
Ju & Wallraven (2019) | 31(m) | 24.8 | Healthy students | Car driving game | 3 min gameplay | fMRI | Positive correlations between the flow experience and brain activity in regions related to visual and spatial execution as well as attentional processes & negative correlations with the DMN’s activity |
Notes.
- fMRI
- functional magnetic resonance imaging
- MRI
- magnetic resonance imaging
- fNIRS
- functional near-infrared spectroscopy
- NIRS
- near-infrared spectroscopy
- ECG
- electrocardiography
- EDA
- electrodermal activity
- tDCS
- transcranial direct-current stimulation
- FPS
- first person shooter
- Res
- respiration
- IFG
- inferior frontal gyrus
- PFC
- prefrontal cortex
- MPFC
- medial prefrontal cortex
- AMY
- amygdala
- VLPFC
- ventrolateral prefrontal cortex
- DLPFC
- dorsolateral prefrontal cortex
- PCC
- posterior cingulate cortex
- DMN
- default mode network
- m
- male
- f
- female