Exchange Transfusion Safety and Outcomes in Neonatal Hyperbilirubinemia

Abstract

Objective:

To characterize prevalence of exchange transfusion (ET), clinical characteristics of infants receiving ET, and ET-associated morbidity and mortality.

Study design:

We conducted a multicenter cohort study of infants ≥23 weeks gestational age (GA) with hyperbilirubinemia who underwent ET within 30 days of birth from 1997–2016. We examined clinical characteristics and adverse events after ET. We used multivariable logistic regression to examine the association between clinical risk factors and death.

Result:

A total of 1252 were included; 4% died within 7 days of ET and 6% died before discharge. Compared to infants ≥37 weeks GA, infants ≤29 weeks GA had greater odds of death (adjusted odds ratio [95% confidence interval] = 20.08 [7.32, 55.07]).

Conclusion:

Infants ≤29 weeks GA had greater odds of death following ET compared to term infants. These data will support clinicians in evaluating risks and prognosis for infants who require ET.

Introduction

Hyperbilirubinemia affects up to 85% of neonates born at term gestation (≥37 weeks gestational age [GA]) and 80% of premature newborns [1–3]. While severe hyperbilirubinemia (total serum bilirubin [TSB] level of >20 milligrams per deciliter [342.1 μmol/L]) occurs in <2% of term infants, it can lead to permanent neurodevelopmental delay and kernicterus (i.e., chronic bilirubin encephalopathy) [2]. Furthermore, though preventable, kernicterus occurs in 20% of infants with TSB >30 mg/dL [4, 5]. The prevalence of kernicterus on autopsy in preterm infants who die is thought to be around 4% [6]. Additionally, although small case series have described survivors with neurologic sequelae associated with hyperbilirubinemia in term infants [7, 8], there are no data on the prevalence of kernicterus in preterm survivors.

Kernicterus is preventable through the use of phototherapy, treatment with intravenous immunoglobulins (IVIg), or the use of exchange transfusion (ET) to lower serum bilirubin levels [9]. Phototherapy is an effective, non-invasive, first-line treatment to lower levels of unconjugated bilirubin. IVIg has some support as an adjuvant therapy for hyperbilirubinemia in cases of Rh hemolytic disease, although the efficacy is controversial [10]. ET is more efficient at reducing bilirubin levels and is often used when maximal phototherapy and/or IVIg are unsuccessful or when hemolysis is excessive [11, 12]; however, ET has known complications including vascular accidents, cardiovascular compromise, and electrolyte and hematologic derangement [13]. Furthermore, infants undergoing ET are at higher risk of requiring intubation and mechanical ventilation, both of which are associated with additional complications [14].

The incidence of meeting or exceeding American Academy of Pediatrics thresholds for ET is low, involving approximately 1.2 per 1000 live births. Nevertheless, premature infants have a 10-fold increased risk of eventual bilirubin level meeting or exceeding thresholds for ET compared with term neonates [15]. Furthermore, the frequency of ET has steadily declined over time due to increased hyperbilirubinemia screening, treating pregnant women who are Rh negative with Rh factor therapy, the increased use of phototherapy, development of IVIg, and ET safety concerns [4, 16]. Previous studies evaluating safety do not have the most current data and have been single-center evaluations or included only relatively small neonatal populations [13, 14, 16–19]. In this cohort study, we sought to further assess and characterize the prevalence of ET use in our neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) population, as well as the safety of ET for treating hyperbilirubinemia.

Methods

Study Design

We conducted a retrospective cohort study of infants ≥23 weeks GA discharged from 1997–2016 from Pediatrix Medical Group NICUs. For the ET population, we included infants with hyperbilirubinemia who underwent ET within 30 days of birth. Demographic, clinical, and maternal data were extracted from a clinical data warehouse that prospectively captures data from electronic health records, including daily progress notes and other documentation generated by clinicians using a computer-assisted tool [20]. The study was approved by the Duke University Institutional Review Board as exempt research.

Variables of Interest

We defined ET as any infant who received ET. Known partial volume ETs were excluded. Hyperbilirubinemia was defined as either: 1) a documented diagnosis of hyperbilirubinemia; or 2) a serum bilirubin level greater than 15 mg/dL for infants 38 weeks gestation and older, or greater than 10 mg/dL in infants aged ≤37 weeks prior to or on the day of ET, without evidence of an alternate diagnosis that may have justified a requirement for ET [21, 22]. We also evaluated maximum bilirubin levels for infants one day following ET and 7 days after ET, and we noted the use of IVIg prior to ET. Small for gestational age (SGA) status was defined based on the Olsen definition [23]. Number of ETs was evaluated as a percentage of total infants over time during the study period.

Laboratory abnormalities evaluated 1 day prior to, 1 day after, and within 7 days after ET included: thrombocytopenia (platelets less than 100,000/µL [24, 25]), hypocalcemia (total serum calcium level less than 7 mg/dL [26]), and hyperkalemia (potassium greater than 7 mEq/L [27]). Our database did not allow us to distinguish timing of laboratory values, so we could not determine whether laboratory values on the day of ET occurred before or after the ET. As a sensitivity analysis to ensure we did not miss important abnormalities, we evaluated the proportion of abnormal laboratory values on the day of ET in infants who were missing values within 7 days after ET. Severe intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) included grade III and IV [28]. We defined neonatal sepsis as any positive blood or cerebrospinal fluid culture, including definite and probable coagulase negative staphylococcal at any point prior to, on 1 day after, and within 7 days after ET [29]. Necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) included diagnosis of stage 2 or 3 by the Bell criteria [30]. Seizures were defined as documented by the provider. IVH, sepsis, NEC, and seizures were evaluated at any point prior to, on 1 day after, and within 7 days after ET. Respiratory support was collected on the day of, 1 day after, and within 7 days after ET and included nasal cannula, continuous positive airway pressure, and mechanical ventilation as documented by the provider. With the exception of laboratory abnormalities and sepsis, events were only reported after ET if they were not present prior to ET. Laboratory abnormalities and respiratory support were reported among infants who had evaluations (non-missing data) within the time period of interest.

Statistical Analysis

We used descriptive statistics, including counts, percentages, medians, and percentiles, to summarize demographic characteristics and clinical data. Among the entire population of infants ≥23 weeks gestational age, we determined the overall prevalence of ET in the setting of hyperbilirubinemia in the first 30 postnatal days by discharge year. Among the ET analysis population, clinical characteristics of interest included postnatal age at the time of ET and at discharge, the number of ETs, and receipt of IVIg prior to ET. We reported the presence of the above clinical and laboratory events of interest prior to and after ET. We reported the percentage of infants who died of any cause within 7 days following ET and during hospitalization overall and by GA. We also reported the percentage of infants who experienced grade 3 or 4 IVH, sepsis, necrotizing enterocolitis, thrombocytopenia, hypocalcemia, hyperkalemia, and seizures within 7 days following ET by GA. We used multivariable logistic regression to examine the association between death before discharge and GA, SGA status, and maximum total serum bilirubin. STATA 15.1 (College Station, TX) was used to perform statistical analyses. A p-value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results

Of a total 1,247,425 infants ≥23 weeks gestational age from 392 sites, 1252 (0.1%) underwent ET. Overall, the number of infants receiving ET decreased from a maximum of 0.3% to a minimum of 0.05% of all infants ≥23 weeks in our study population over the course of the study period (Figure 1). Among the infants who underwent ET, the median (25^th–75^th percentile) gestational age and birthweight of infants receiving ET were 37 weeks (33–38 weeks) and 2789 grams (1928–3275 grams), respectively. A slight majority of infants were male (55%), and a plurality had White race (45%) (Table 1). The majority (91% [1134/1252]) of the study population received only one ET, and 14% of the study population (176/1252) received IVIg prior to ET (Table 1). The trend of IVIg utilization increased over time; incidence did not exceed 7% in the first six years of study, then increased to between 12% and 23% over the subsequent seven years, followed by an incidence of 30% or greater in four of the five final years of study. The median postnatal age at the time of ET was 1 day (0, 3 days) with more than one-quarter of infants receiving an ET on the day of birth; median postnatal age at discharge was 11 days (7, 24).

Figure 1. Percentage of infants undergoing ET over time.

This figure displays the percentage of infants who have undergone ET from 1997–2015.

ET, exchange transfusion

Table 1.

Demographic characteristics of infants undergoing exchange transfusion

Characteristic	N=1252 (%)
Gestational age (weeks)
≤29	159 (13)
30–34	272 (22)
35–37	338 (27)
>37	483 (39)
Birth weight (g)
<1000	101 (8)
1000–1499	109 (9)
1500–2499	284 (23)
>2499	758 (61)
Male	687 (55)
SGA	134 (11)
Race/ethnicity
White	540 (45)
Black	263 (22)
Hispanic	295 (25)
Other	93 (8)
Inborn	856 (69)
Number of exchange transfusions
1	1134 (91)
2	104 (8)
⪰ 3	14 (1)
IVIg prior to exchange transfusion	176 (14)

IVIg, intravenous immunoglobulin; SGA, small for gestational age

There was a slight decrease in median bilirubin level (mg/dL) after ET, with stable levels between one and seven days following ET (Table 2). Less than half of the infants received respiratory support prior to ET (46% [566/1240]), and of those not receiving respiratory support, 69/676 (10%) received respiratory support within 7 days after ET. While a relatively large proportion of infants received mechanical ventilation prior to receiving an ET (23% [282/1252]), few of those not receiving ventilation began receiving mechanical ventilation within seven days post ET (3% [32/950]). The most common adverse effect of ET was thrombocytopenia at 7 days following ET, which affected 64% (646/1013) of our study population. Of 52 infants without platelet evaluation within 7 days who had platelet evaluation on the day of ET, 7/52 (13%) had thrombocytopenia on the day of ET. Hyperkalemia affected 5% (46/886) by 7 days after ET. Of 48 infants without potassium evaluation within 7 days who had potassium evaluation on the day of ET, 3/48 (6%) had hyperkalemia on the day of ET. Hypocalcemia was not detected prior to ET, but appeared in 2% (19/818) of infants whose calcium was measured within 7 days following ET. Of 75 infants without calcium evaluation within 7 days who had calcium evaluation on the day of ET, 5 (7%) had hypocalcemia on the day of ET. Prior to ET, sepsis occurred in 2% (31/1252) of patients, while within 7 days after ET, only 0.6% developed a new episode sepsis (7/1252). The incidence of necrotizing enterocolitis was <1% at all time periods evaluated. The incidence of seizures was documented to be similar at 2% prior to ET and 2% on 7 days after ET (Table 2).

Table 2.

Clinical and laboratory characteristics of infants undergoing exchange transfusion

	Prior to ET	1 day after ET	7 days after ET
Bilirubin level*, median (25th – 75th %ile)	18 (12, 22)	14 (11, 18)	15 (11, 18)
GA ≤29 weeks	12 (9, 16)	9 (6, 13)	10 (7, 13)
GA 30–34 weeks	14 (10, 20)	14 (10, 18)	15 (11, 18)
GA 35–37 weeks	18 (13, 23)	15 (11, 18)	16 (13, 19)
GA >37 weeks	20 (16, 24)	15 (12, 19)	16 (12, 19)
Respiratory support†, n/N (%)	566/1240 (46)	41/674 (6)	69/676 (10)
Intubation, n/N (%)	282/1240 (23)	19/950 (2)	32/950 (3)
Grade III & IV IVH, n/N (%)	26/1252 (2)	5/1226 (0.4)	13/1226 (1)
Sepsis, n/N (%)	31/1252 (2)	3/1252 (0.2)	7/1252 (0.6)
Necrotizing enterocolitis, n/N (%)	7/1252 (0.6)	2/1245 (0.2)	5/1245 (0.4)
Thrombocytopenia (<100,000 /mL), n/N (%)	64/348 (18)	413/895 (46)	646/1013 (64)
Hypocalcemia‡ (<4.2 mg/dL), n/N (%)	0/177	9/670 (1)	19/818 (2)
Hyperkalemia‡ (>7 mEq/L), n/N (%)	6/202 (3)	21/747 (3)	46/886 (5)
Seizures, n/N (%)	22/1252 (2)	7/1230 (0.6)	22/1230 (2)

^*Bilirubin level for “Prior to ET” is from the day of ET

^†Includes nasal cannula, continuous positive airway pressure, or ventilator

^‡Laboratory values other than bilirubin for “Prior to ET” were obtained 1–2 days prior to ET

ET, exchange transfusion; GA, gestational age

Hospital mortality could be determined for 1161/1252 (93%) infants. A total of 4% (42/1161) of infants receiving ET died within 7 days following ET; overall hospital mortality was 6% (65/1161). Infants ≤29 weeks’ GA had the highest mortality within 7 days after ET, 17% (24/141). They also had the highest overall hospital mortality of 27% (38/141) (Table 3). Of the infants who died during hospitalization, none developed NEC, 2 developed seizures, and 5 developed IVH within the 7 days post ET. On adjusted analysis, there was no significant association between death during hospitalization and maximum TSB (odds ratio [OR]=0.95, [0.90, 1.00]; p=0.05) or SGA status (OR=2.07, [0.99, 4.31]; p=0.05). Compared to infants >37 weeks GA, infants ≤29 weeks GA (OR=20.08, [7.32, 55.07]; p<0.001) and 30–34 weeks GA (OR=3.31, [1.12, 9.79]; p=0.03) had significantly increased odds of death (Table 4).

Table 3.

Laboratory and clinical outcomes associated with exchange transfusion by gestational age

	Gestational age (weeks)
	≤29	30–34	35–37	>37
Death within 7 days of ET	24/141 (17)	10/252 (4)	3/311 (1)	5/457 (1)
Death within hospitalization	38/141 (27)	14/252 (6)	7/311 (2)	6/457 (1)
Grade III & IV IVH within 7 days of ET	9/138 (7)	4/268 (1)	0/338 (0)	0/482 (0)
Sepsis within 7 days of ET	5/159 (3)	0/272 (0)	2/338 (0.6)	0/483 (0)
Necrotizing enterocolitis within 7 days of ET	2/157 (1)	2/268 (0.8)	0/338 (0)	1/482 (0.2)
Thrombocytopenia (<100,000 /mL) within 7 days of ET	96/141 (68)	157/236 (67)	161/268 (60)	232/368 (63)
Hypocalcemia (<4.2 mg/dL) within 7 days of ET	7/123 (6)	4/206 (2)	4/215 (2)	4/274 (1)
Hyperkalemia (>7 mEq/L) within 7 days of ET	15/126 (12)	10/219 (5)	10/233 (4)	11/308 (4)
Seizures within 7 days of ET	5/152 (3)	4/269 (1)	5/332 (2)	8/477 (2)

Data are given as n/N (%)

ET, exchange transfusion; IVH, intraventricular hemorrhage

Table 4.

Multivariable logistic regression to evaluate association between risk factors and hospital death for infants undergoing exchange transfusion

Risk factor	Adjusted OR (95% CI)	p-value
Gestational age (weeks)
≤ 29	20.08 (7.32 – 55.07)	<0.001
30–34	3.31 (1.12 – 9.79)	0.03
35–37	1.50 (0.43 – 5.29)	0.52
>37	[ref]
Small for gestational age	2.07 (0.99 – 4.31)	0.05
Maximum total serum bilirubin (mg/dL)	0.95 (0.90 – 1.00)	0.05

CI, confidence interval; OR, odds ratio

Comments

In this large cohort of more than 1200 preterm and term infants who received ET for hyperbilirubinemia, we found that infants <35 weeks GA, and especially those ≤29 weeks GA, were at a higher risk of death following ET compared to term infants. We also evaluated use of IVIg prior to ET and adverse events by GA surrounding ET, which has not been previously reported. Only 14% of infants received IVIg within our study population, with increasing incidence over time. One prior retrospective study found that only 6 of its 107 participants (6%) received IVIg prior to ET, demonstrating a similar pattern of use to the early years of our study [16]. Interestingly, a 2018 Cochrane review of 9 studies with 658 infants examining the efficacy of IVIg in preventing ET did not show sufficient benefit to warrant a recommendation for systematic use of IVIg as a primary intervention for alloimmune hemolytic disease of the newborn to prevent ET [31]. Nevertheless, the increasing incidence of IVIg utilization may indicate improved ability to identify those infants in whom IVIg may provide benefit.

Thrombocytopenia was the most common laboratory adverse event we observed in this cohort, while hypocalcemia and hypokalemia were less common. Hakan et al. [16] and Steiner et al. [17] conducted retrospective studies examining the adverse events associated with ET in 107 and 306 infants, respectively. These studies found thrombocytopenia, hypocalcemia, and hypokalemia to be among the most common adverse outcomes, which were defined in both studies as occurring within 7 days after ET [16, 17]. Furthermore, in a study by Sabzehei et al. [17] that examined 148 infants who received ET, the authors found thrombocytopenia in 26 (17.6%) and hypocalcemia in 17 (11.5%) neonates [19]. These studies are significantly smaller than our current study and looked at only one time point following ET. We described these adverse effects at two different time points following ET to provide a more accurate timeline of when these conditions may occur; this timeline may inform medical providers regarding improved treatment and/or prevention strategies. There were also rarer adverse events such as need for respiratory support, sepsis, and NEC. The association between ET and NEC has been previously reported in the literature and ranges from 0.9% (1/106) to 1.3% (8/614) of infants undergoing ET in multiple retrospective studies completed by chart review [32, 33], though another retrospective study with fewer infants (n=55) did not observe this association [18]. An association between NEC and IVIg has been reported [34].

Adverse neurological outcomes, such as IVH and seizures, occur in infants following ET. Although few studies have explored the incidence of these outcomes, a retrospective study by Patra et al. found that among a group of 66 preterm and term infants who received ET, only 1 infant experienced a seizure [18]. In our larger study, 2% developed seizures, and 1% developed IVH within 7 days after ET. Not surprisingly, these diagnoses were most common in the most premature infants. The difference in these findings is most likely due to variation in the size of study populations. Although these neurological events were not the most common adverse outcomes, they have the possibility to produce long-term effects and should be considered when assessing risk of ET. Our study is limited in that we do not have data on long-term neurodevelopmental outcomes.

Finally, mortality continues to be a concern for infants receiving ET. Although the overall hospital mortality was low, when comparing mortality by gestational age, infants <35 weeks GA, and especially those ≤29 weeks GA, were at a significantly higher risk of death after ET. Preterm infants may be at higher risk for death associated with ET because they are more likely to experience poor health and a greater number of comorbidities leading up to a need for ET. Furthermore, transfusions of any kind can put them at risk for NEC and/or severe IVH that may lead to seizure [35]. The odds of death for an infant receiving ET was slightly lower with higher levels of maximum TSB, which was unexpected, given our knowledge of indications for ET. While our study produced these surprising results, additional information regarding the rate of bilirubin rise along with the bilirubin by hour of life and by GA may provide more insight. Unfortunately, time of bilirubin levels was not available from our dataset. While our dataset did not include cause of death, a recent study discussed how the risks for death are mostly due to complications prior to ET and that none died due to ET itself. Sabzehei et al. [17] conducted a 5-year retrospective study, which was shorter than our study, examining the outcomes of 148 infants that received ET [19]. Much like our study design, Sabzehei et al. [17] included many similar outcomes such as thrombocytopenia, hypocalcemia, hypokalemia, NEC, and cardiovascular support, but the ways in which the investigators reported death differed from our methods. Sabzehei et al. [17] reported death by GA, but only differentiated between preterm (0%) and term infants (1%), whereas we separated death by several categories of GA [19]. Furthermore, our study made the distinction between death within 7 days of ET (4%) and death during hospitalization (6%). The differences in death observed in these two studies can likely be attributed to study size, since our study examined a much larger patient population. Finally, we found that infants who were small for gestational age had a trend towards higher odds of hospital mortality, although this was not statistically significant. This finding is similar to prior studies and may be attributable to increased risks of respiratory distress syndrome, necrotizing enterocolitis, late-onset sepsis, severe retinopathy of prematurity, and chronic lung disease [36].

Our study had several limitations. First, due to the retrospective nature of this study, we could not randomize those who received ET, nor could we control for differences in clinical practice or how diagnoses were documented by the provider. Second, we could not account for the cause of cardiovascular support or intubation, nor could be account for the causes of jaundice within our selected population. Third, we do not have the exact time of ET documented, so it is unclear whether the lab studies were obtained before, during, or after transfusion on the particular day that ET was performed. Whether there were practice differences is also unclear, including use of citrate for exchange transfusion or a protocol for calcium repletion that may have accounted for the low rate of hypocalcemia. Finally, because infants did not have laboratory testing every day, variable numbers of infants could be evaluated for adverse events surrounding ET at different time points (Table 2). Despite these limitations, there are a number of strengths that enhance the overall validity of our study. Access to the Pediatrix Clinical Data Warehouse provided a large, diverse, and more globally representative study group, as well as a long study period; access to this data permitted us to quantify adverse outcomes and death by such measures as gestational age and days after ET.

In conclusion, infants ≤29 weeks GA had significantly greater odds of death following ET compared to term infants, but higher maximum TSB was not significantly associated with increased death. Adverse events such as thrombocytopenia, hypocalcemia, and hypokalemia were most commonly observed around the time of ET, and neurological effects such as IVH and seizures were less common. These data will support clinicians in evaluating risks and prognosis for infants in the NICU who require ET.