Recent trends in Pediatric Hematology Oncology fellowship match and the workforce impact

In the manuscript authored by Macy et al., global trends of the pediatric subspecialty workforce are described by reporting the numbers of applicants entering fellowship training from 2001 to 2018.¹ They conclude there has been an increase in the number of physicians entering pediatric subspecialty training. We would like to highlight discrepant changes in accrual into Pediatric Hematology Oncology (PHO) fellowship training, compared to other subspecialties (Table 1). Among the larger fellowship programs, Macy et al. reported PHO to have a marked increase in the number of individuals entering fellowship 2008–2018. However, in the recent PHO fellowship matches there has been a significant and consistent decrease in total applicants. The 2021 fellow match resulted in an 8% decrease in applications and left nearly half (44%) of PHO fellowship programs unfilled (Table 2). Across the country, PHO programs have been scrambling to fill these unoccupied positions. More broadly, fellowship program directors and division chiefs are trying to understand the cause of continued decline in PHO training interest and its future impact on our workforce.

Table 1.

National Resident Matching Program (NRMP) pediatric subspecialty fellow match results 2018–2021.⁴

Specialty	Salarya	2021			2020			2019			2018
		Total applicants	% Positions filled	Unfilled programs	Total applicants	% Positions filled	Unfilled programs	Total applicants	% Positions filled	Unfilled programs	Total applicants	% Positions filled	Unfilled programs
Neonatal-Perinatal Medicine	0.99	267	93	16	240	87.2	25	245	86.7	25	243	87.1	22
Pediatric Critical Care Medicine	1.00	233	99.5	1	227	98.5	3	217	99	2	204	96.2	6
Pediatric Emergency Medicine	0.89	221	100	0	253	98	3	270	100	0	232	98.9	2
Pediatric Cardiology	0.95	157	94.9	6	160	92.4	13	177	98.1	3	161	96.6	4
Pediatric Hematology Oncology	0.69	133	75.6	32	147	82.8	22	165	89.8	14	163	90	15
Pediatric Hospital Medicine	0.72	122	98.8	1	105	97.1	1	79	92.9	3	66	96	2
Pediatric Gastroenterology	0.70	118	98.2	2	106	95.1	5	102	92.1	6	100	93.3	7
Pediatric Endocrinology	0.66	63	60.2	32	70	62	34	53	50.5	42	65	66.7	29
Pediatric Pulmonology	0.74	56	68.4	23	52	66.2	21	43	54.1	29	48	68.1	21
Pediatric Nephrology	0.68	53	73.9	16	39	59.4	22	27	41.5	33	39	62.1	19
Pediatric Infectious Diseases	0.63	42	54.5	30	49	63	23	40	46.8	35	45	55.6	25
Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics	NA	34	76.2	8	26	52.2	19	35	62.5	15	35	67.3	19
Pediatric Rheumatology	0.66	28	73.5	9	33	69	13	22	48.7	15	24	53.7	17
Adolescent Medicine	0.64	26	76.7	7	36	96.7	1	32	75	7	25	67.7	9
Child Abuse	NA	19	70.8	7	18	54.5	10	17	65	7	18	51.9	13
Academic General Pediatrics	0.70	7	50	7	12	52.6	9	10	50	8	—	—	—

NA data not available.

^aSalary is calculated as the ratio of the highest pediatric subspecialty median salary at the assistant professor rank.⁵

Table 2.

NRMP Pediatric Hematology/Oncology subspecialty match results, 2008–2021.⁴

Match year start date	Total programs	Total fellow positions	Total applicants	Matched applicants	Unfilled programs (%)	Unfilled positions (%)	Unmatched applicants (%)
2008	54	129	150	118	10 (18.5%)	11 (8.5%)	32 (27%)
2009	57	142	144	123	14 (25%)	19 (13%)	21 (17%)
2010	58	146	149	132	10 (17%)	14 (9.5%)	17 (13%)
2011	62	158	154	133	15 (24%)	25 (16%)	21 (16%)
2012	62	158	156	143	13 (21%)	15 (9%)	13 (9%)
2013	65	164	183	154	8 (12%)	10 (6%)	29 (19%)
2014	62	157	178	151	6 (10%)	8 (5%)	27 (18%)
2015	65	162	181	153	7 (11%)	9 (5.5%)	28 (18%)
2016	67	164	201	159	4 (6%)	5 (3%)	42 (26%)
2017	68	166	188	163	3 (4%)	3 (2%)	25 (15%)
2018	71	170	163	153	15 (21%)	17 (10%)	10 (7%)
2019	71	176	165	158	14 (20%)	18 (10%)	7 (4%)
2020	71	174	147	144	22 (31%)	30 (17%)	3 (2%)
2021	72	176	133	133	32 (44%)	43 (24%)	0 (0%)

From 2008 to 2016, PHO fellowship applications steadily rose from 150 applicants to a peak of 201 applicants in 2016. However, in the past 5 years fellow applications have steadily fallen, with only 133 applications in the 2021 match cycle (Table 2). Interestingly, the number of programs and positions has increased consistently during this time, with 72 PHO fellowship programs (representing 176 positions) participating in the 2021 Match. Other pediatric subspecialty programs did not demonstrate the same decline in fellowship applications (Table 1). Herein we try to offer some reasons that may have contributed to these findings.

Macy et al. highlight that one of the most common factors influencing resident career decisions is future job opportunity. We hypothesize that challenges in the PHO workforce may be contributing to the decrease in PHO fellow applications. The job market has been perceived by graduating fellows to be more competitive in the past several years. Fellows often report few job prospects upon graduation in “desirable” practices or geographical locations. Alternatively, they choose to continue training in a subspecialty fellowship to augment their research portfolio and increase clinical expertise in a particular niche, such as neuro-oncology, hemostasis, or stem cell transplant, with the hopes of “becoming more marketable” for highly sought after academic positions.² We worry that this additional training, along with a perception of a paucity of faculty positions in PHO, is negatively influencing resident subspecialty decisions.

The PHO provider workforce is also changing, which may be impacting employment opportunities for fellow graduates. Hord et al. reported that from 2012 to 2015 PHO practices employed more advanced practice practitioners, who perform some of the roles of a PHO physician and may decrease the number of faculty positions in a given practice.³

Additionally, subspecialty compensation may also contribute to the decrease in PHO fellow applications. According to the American Association of Medical Colleges 2019–20 Faculty Salary Report, Pediatric Critical Care has the highest median salary at the assistant professor level of any pediatric subspecialty, approximately $250,000 per year. Fields with higher median salaries tend to have the most applicants and the highest percentages of filled fellowship spots compared to those with lower median compensation (Table 1). Pediatric residents choosing a subspecialty likely are incorporating future wage potential into their career decisions, which may contribute to increased interest in higher paying pediatric specialties.

Recently, we have witnessed additional external factors impacting training programs. In 2018, restrictive US immigration and travel policies were implemented, which may have influenced international clinicians applying and entering US fellowship programs. During this time period, we have seen a decline in the number of PHO international applications. The coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic has also had a devastating economic impact on academic medical centers and has resulted in an employment freeze in many markets, thus limiting PHO faculty positions for graduates. The pandemic likely has also contributed to the decrease in fellowship applications in 2020 as pediatric residents have deferred future career decisions to remain closer to home and family until quarantine and social distancing measures abate. We certainly hope that we see a rebound of pediatric residents with an interest in a career in PHO, but it is essential to be aware of the changing landscape of our specialty. Further investigation is warranted into how these factors are affecting career decision making of pediatric residents to better understand fellowship applications as well as pediatric subspecialty workforce overall.

Competing interests

S.C.B. serves on the advisory board for Ipsen Pharmaceuticals and Fennec Pharmaceuticals.

Consent statement

No consent was required for this commentary.