Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Aagaard 2005 | This RCT looked at muscle strength, muscle mass and muscle magnesium content. It did not look at measures of muscle cramping |
Bachem 1986 | No control group. Article in German with English abstract. Methods translated |
Bartl 1982 | Did not appear to be randomized. Evaluated serum magnesium levels in pregnant cramp sufferers before and after magnesium supplementation. Did not evaluate changes in muscle cramping. Article in German with English abstract. Methods translated |
Hammar 1987 | No magnesium treatment arm |
Häringer 1981 | No control group. Article in German. Abstract and Methods translated |
Riss 1983 | Uncontrolled. Article in German with English abstract |
Siegmund‐Schultze 2017 | Not a trial. Article in German reviewing and commenting on Roguin Maor 2017 |
Weiss 2018 | Not randomized |
Weller 1998 | This RCT looked at exercise performance and magnesium concentration in various tissues. It did not look at measures of muscle cramping |
Zarean 2017 | This RCT of pregnant women with hypomagnaesemia (only some of whom experienced muscle cramps) gave magnesium to the intervention group and not to the control group. However these 2 groups also appeared to take differing multimineral supplements (we attempted to confirm this with the trial authors but obtained no response). Our inclusion/exclusion criteria require treatment to be the same in each group, other than the provision of magnesium, and it is for this reason we chose to exclude the trial. This trial also looked at pregnancy outcomes more broadly, and did not focus on cramps. None of our specified outcomes were reported, only the number of unblinded participants self‐reporting "cramps" (yes/no) in each group |
RCT: randomized controlled trial