Author |
Antidepressant use |
Previous treatment failure |
Psychosocial intervention used |
Change of dosages allowed |
Croarkin et al. [43] |
None |
Yes |
No change in psychosocial interventions |
N/A |
Zhang et al. [42] |
All used one type of antidepressant treatment during rTMS along with other medications |
Unspecified but excluded patients who were taking more than one antidepressant |
Unspecified |
No |
MacMaster et al. [27] |
Psychotropic medications use were allowed if stable for 6 weeks 31.25% were not on psychotropics |
At least two previous failed medication trials |
Unspecified |
No unless medically necessary |
Pan et al. [38] |
Either drug naïve or was not taking antidepressants for 2 weeks prior to the study |
All three patients took an antidepressant in the past for an unspecified dose and duration |
Unspecified |
N/A |
Wall et al. [28] |
All used either SSRI or SNRI |
At least one prior medication trial failure as defined by ATHF. Study participants had a mean of 4.0 prior failed medication trial (SD 2.1). |
No change in psychotherapy treatment was allowed within the last 4 weeks of treatment |
No |
Croarkin et al. [29] |
All were on antidepressants |
At least one prior failed medication trials |
Unspecified |
No |
Yang et al. [39] |
Unspecified |
At least one failed trial |
Unspecified |
Unspecified |
Wall et al. [30] |
All were on antidepressants |
At least one prior failed trial |
No change in psychotherapy or therapist |
No |
Wall et al. [31] |
Yes |
Yes - at least two failed trials |
No change in psychotherapy or therapist in 4 weeks prior to rTMS |
No |
Croarkin et al. [40] |
Case 1 - none; Case 2 - yes |
Case 1 - none; case 2 - multiple |
Unspecified |
No |
Bloch et al. [32] |
Yes |
Failure of one course of psychotherapy and two courses of medication trials 8 weeks each, with at least one of the antidepressants being Fluoxetine |
No change in therapy within 5 weeks before starting of rTMS |
No |
Loo et al. [41] |
Case 1 - unspecified; case 2 - yes |
Case 1 - failure of one course of psychotherapy; case 2 - one course of psychotherapy, two medication trials |
Unspecified |
Case 1 - unspecified; Case 2 - no |
Walter et al. [44] |
No |
Unspecified |
Unspecified |
Unspecified |