Skip to main content
. 2021 Feb 18;75(4):764–778. doi: 10.1111/evo.14181

Table 1.

Studies that have compared the rate of evolution of different RI barriers

Taxon Number of species pairs Result Phylogenetic correction Reference
Darters Etheostoma 13 Sexual isolation accumulates faster than postzygotic RI. Hybrid inviability does not increase over time. Species pair selected to be strictly phylogenetically independent (Mendelson 2003)
Stickleback Gasterosteus 5 Sexual and ecological isolation accumulate faster than other barriers No (Lackey and Boughman 2017)
Streptanthus 39 Climatic niche differences are substantial early in speciation and evolve faster than differences in phenology and floral morphology. Node‐weighted average phylogenetic correction, (Fitzpatrick 2002) (Christie and Strauss 2018)
Nolana 15‐22 Prezygotic pollen–pistile isolation accumulates slower than all postzygotic barriers. Node‐weighted average phylogenetic correction, (Fitzpatrick 2002) (Jewell et al. 2012)
Drosophila 72 Prezygotic and postmating‐prezygotic RI accumulate faster than postzygotic barriers. Random sampling of strictly phylogenetically independent species pairs and bootstrapping (Turissini et al. 2018)
Glycine 18‐55 Postmating‐prezygotic and postzygotic RI accumulate at similar rates. Random sampling of strictly phylogenetically independent species pairs and bootstrapping (Moyle et al. 2004)
Silene 19‐49 Postmating‐prezygotic and postzygotic RI accumulate at similar rates. Random sampling of strictly phylogenetically independent species pairs and bootstrapping (Moyle et al. 2004)
Food‐deceptive orchids 110, 125 Premating and postmating‐prezygotic RI show no clear increase over divergence. Postzygotic RI evolves in a clock‐like manner. Node‐weighted average phylogenetic correction, (Fitzpatrick 2002) and identification of strictly phylogenetically independent species pairs (Scopece et al. 2007)
Sexually deceptive orchids 36 Strong premating RI but weak postmating RI Node‐weighted average phylogenetic correction, (Fitzpatrick 2002) and identification of strictly phylogenetically independent species pairs (Scopece et al. 2007)
Stalk‐eyed flies 12 Hybrid male sterility accumulates faster than premating RI, hybrid inviability, and female hybrid sterility No (Charistianson et al. 2005)