In a recent issue of Movement Disorders, Diniz de Lima and colleagues1 report the results of a double‐blind randomized placebo‐controlled crossover trial on the effects of botulinum toxin type A (BoNT‐A) injections—targeting the triceps surae and adductor magnus, bilaterally—in patients with hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP). This is the first randomized controlled trial evaluating the effect of BoNT‐A in HSP. HSP is a rare condition, and we applaud the authors for successfully completing this trial and for contributing to the scientific knowledge in this field. However, we are concerned about the validity of the findings, and these concerns are related to the very essence of spasticity management.
The authors included 55 patients with various forms of HSP, including 25% with complex (and probably very diverse) phenotypes. More importantly, besides having a diagnosis of HSP, being an adult, and being able to walk 14 m, there were no inclusion criteria. This implies that patients were not selected based on a history or physical examination showing that they were actually bothered or functionally hindered by calf muscle or hip adductor spasticity during walking (eg, abrupt knee hyperextension in the stance phase or gait scissoring).2 Such a treatment approach is not based on internationally accepted standards.3 Preferably even, spasmolytic treatment of the legs should be based on some form of gait analysis to identify proper muscular targets, although we understand that this may not be possible in each center in the word. Several patients may have had forms of spasticity and gait patterns that did not require spasmolytic treatment at all. Moreover, it is generally accepted that focal spasmolytic treatment should be based on (individual) goal setting, of which there is no mention. This “global” way of selecting participants may be a very important reason for the negative results, because improper selection may have actually worsened functional performance in some participants.
Second, the authors already acknowledged that their BoNT‐A dosing was relatively low, particularly for triceps surae. However, treating only adductor magnus in the case of hip adductor spasticity is also not common practice, because specifically gracilis and adductor longus muscles may still have a significant functional impact.4 Moreover, injections were placed merely on the basis of palpation and anatomical landmarks. Even in experienced hands, this technique is not sufficiently reliable (more than 50% inaccuracy has been reported),5 in particular to target deeper muscles such as adductor magnus.
Given these concerns, also acknowledged by the authors, future controlled studies are warranted incorporating a personalized treatment approach to further evaluate the functional effects of BoNT‐A treatment in patients with HSP.
Author Roles
Both J.N. and A.G. were involved in writing and editing of the manuscript.
Relevant conflicts of interests/financial disclosures: The authors report no conflict of interest. Dr. Nonnekes was supported by ZonMW Veni (grant 16.196.022) and reports grants from ZonMW (OffRoad grant), The Michael J. Fox Foundation, Ipsen Pharmaceuticals, and Gossweiler Foundation outside the submitted work. Dr. Geurts reports unrestricted research grants from Ipsen Pharaceuticals and Merz Pharma related to the submitted work.
References
- 1.Diniz de Lima F, Faber I, Servelhere KR, et al. Randomized trial of botulinum toxin type a in hereditary spastic paraplegia—the SPASTOX trial. Mov Disord 2021. 10.1002/mds.28523. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 2.Nonnekes J, Goselink RJM, Ruzicka E, Fasano A, Nutt JG, Bloem BR. Neurological disorders of gait, balance and posture: a sign‐based approach. Nat Rev Neurol 2018;14(3):183–189. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 3.Wissel J, Ward AB, Erztgaard P, et al. European consensus table on the use of botulinum toxin type a in adult spasticity. J Rehabil Med 2009;41(1):13–25. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 4.van Lith BJH, den Boer J, van de Warrenburg BPC, Weerdesteyn V, Geurts AC. Functional effects of botulinum toxin type a in the hip adductors and subsequent stretching in patients with hereditary spastic paraplegia. J Rehabil Med 2019;51(6):434–441. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- 5.Schnitzler A, Roche N, Denormandie P, Lautridou C, Parratte B, Genet F. Manual needle placement: accuracy of botulinum toxin a injections. Muscle Nerve 2012;46(4):531–534. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]