Skip to main content
Acta Crystallographica Section A: Foundations and Advances logoLink to Acta Crystallographica Section A: Foundations and Advances
. 2021 Sep 24;77(Pt 6):559–571. doi: 10.1107/S205327332100783X

Layer groups: Brillouin-zone and crystallographic databases on the Bilbao Crystallographic Server

Gemma de la Flor a,*, Bernd Souvignier b, Gotzon Madariaga c, Mois I Aroyo c
PMCID: PMC8573847  PMID: 34726633

The set of databases of the Bilbao Crystallographic Server (https://www.cryst.ehu.es/) including crystallographic data on generators, general positions, Wyckoff positions, maximal subgroups and Brillouin-zone figures and k-vector tables for all 80 layer groups are discussed in detail and illustrated.

Keywords: Bilbao Crystallographic Server, layer groups, Brillouin-zone database

Abstract

The section of the Bilbao Crystallographic Server (https://www.cryst.ehu.es/) dedicated to subperiodic groups contains crystallographic and Brillouin-zone databases for the layer groups. The crystallographic databases include the generators/general positions (GENPOS), Wyckoff positions (WYCKPOS) and maximal subgroups (MAXSUB). The Brillouin-zone database (LKVEC) offers k-vector tables and Brillouin-zone figures of all 80 layer groups which form the background of the classification of their irreducible representations. The symmetry properties of the wavevectors are described applying the so-called reciprocal-space-group approach and this classification scheme is compared with that of Litvin & Wike [(1991), Character Tables and Compatibility Relations of the Eighty Layer Groups and Seventeen Plane Groups. New York: Plenum Press]. The specification of independent parameter ranges of k vectors in the representation domains of the Brillouin zones provides a solution to the problems of uniqueness and completeness of layer-group representations. The Brillouin-zone figures and k-vector tables are described in detail and illustrated by several examples.

1. Introduction  

The Bilbao Crystallographic Server (https://www.cryst.ehu.es/) (Aroyo et al., 2006, 2011; Tasci et al., 2012) is a free web site that grants access to specialized databases and tools for the resolution of different types of crystallographic, structural chemistry and solid-state physics problems. The server has been operating for more than 20 years, and is in constant improvement and development, offering free-of-charge tools to study an increasing number of crystallographic systems (Elcoro et al., 2017; Gallego et al., 2019; de la Flor et al., 2019). The programs on the server are organized into different sections depending on their degree of complexity, in such a way that the more complex tools make use of the results obtained by the simpler ones. The Bilbao Crystallographic Server (hereafter referred to as BCS) is built on a core of databases that include data from International Tables for Crystallography, Vol. A, Space-group Symmetry (Aroyo, 2016; henceforth abbreviated as ITA), Vol. A1, Symmetry Relations between Space Groups (Wondratschek & Müller, 2010), and Vol. E, Subperiodic Groups (Kopský & Litvin, 2010; henceforth referred to as ITE). A k-vector database with Brillouin-zone figures and classification tables of the wavevectors for all 230 space groups (Aroyo et al., 2014) is also available in the server, together with the magnetic and double-space-group databases. The magnetic and the incommensurate structure databases are also hosted on the server.

Aside from the subgroups of space groups with three-dimensional lattices which are again space groups, there also exist subgroups called subperiodic groups with translation lattices of dimensions one or two. These groups are essential to describe polymers, nanotubes, nanowires, layered and multilayered materials. The interest in materials with sub­periodic symmetry is constantly growing due to their outstanding properties and possible technological applications. There are three types of subperiodic groups: frieze groups (two-dimensional groups with one-dimensional translation lattices), rod groups (three-dimensional groups with one-dimensional translation lattices) and layer groups (three-dimensional groups with two-dimensional translation lattices). The crystallographic data for subperiodic groups are compiled in ITE and also now offered online in the BCS section dedicated to subperiodic groups. This section includes programs which give access to the generators/general positions (GENPOS), Wyckoff positions (WYCKPOS) and maximal subgroups (MAXSUB) databases.

In addition, we have developed the Brillouin-zone database of layer groups which contains k-vector tables and Brillouin-zone figures that form the background of the classification of the irreducible representations of layer groups. The Brillouin-zone figures and the wavevector data for space groups are well established and many authors have contributed to the standardization of the data (see e.g. Miller & Love, 1967; Bradley & Cracknell, 1972; Cracknell et al., 1979; Stokes & Hatch, 1988). For layer groups, however, the Brillouin-zone and wavevector descriptions proposed by several authors (Ipatova & Kitaev, 1985; Hatch & Stokes, 1986; Milošević et al., 2008) are incomplete and difficult to compare due to the lack of standards in the classification and nomenclature of the k vectors. To the best of our knowledge, the only complete compilation of layer-group k vectors together with the Brillouin-zone diagrams is found in the work of Litvin & Wike (1991) (in the following, referred to as LW). In this description the k vectors are labelled following the classification scheme of space-group k vectors used by Cracknell et al. (1979). Based on the group–subgroup relations between space and layer groups and using the so-called reciprocal-space-group approach (cf. Wintgen, 1941; Aroyo & Wondratschek, 1995; Aroyo et al., 2014), we have derived the k-vector data and Brillouin-zone figures for all 80 layer groups and compared them with the classification of LW. An auxiliary tool for the complete characterization of wavevectors is also available: given the wavevector coefficients referred to a primitive or conventional dual basis, the program assigns the corresponding wavevector symmetry type, specifies its LW label, determines the layer little co-group of the wavevector and generates the arms of the wavevector star. The BCS Brillouin-zone database of layer groups is accessed by the retrieval tool LKVEC.

The aim of this contribution is to present the crystallographic databases and the Brillouin-zone database for layer groups available in the BCS. In the following, the retrieval tools GENPOS, WYCKPOS, MAXSUB and LKVEC, and the procedure to derive and classify the k vectors of layer groups are described in detail. The utility of the programs is demonstrated by several illustrative examples.

2. Crystallographic databases for layer groups  

The BCS section Subperiodic Groups: Layer, Rod and Frieze Groups hosts the layer-group crystallographic databases. The structure of these databases is similar to that of the space groups – they include information on generators, general positions, Wyckoff positions and maximal subgroups for the 80 layer groups. Apart from the data shown in ITE the server offers additional information and computer tools that allow the generation of data not available in ITE. The BCS programs and databases use the so-called standard or default settings of the layer groups. These are the specific settings of layer groups that coincide with the conventional layer-group descriptions found in ITE. For layer groups with more than one description in ITE, the following settings are chosen as standard: (i) cell-choice 1 description for the two monoclinic/oblique layer groups p11a (No. 5) and Inline graphic (No. 7) described with respect to three cell choices in ITE, and (ii) origin choice 2 descriptions (i.e. origin at an inversion centre) for the three layer groups Inline graphic (No. 52), Inline graphic (No. 62) and Inline graphic (No. 64) listed with respect to two origins in ITE.

Note that, following the conventions of ITE, the ab plane is the plane of periodicity for the layer groups and therefore the translation vectors are of the form

2.

2.1. Generators and general positions  

The BCS database of layer groups includes the list of generators/general positions of each layer group. These data can be retrieved using the program GENPOS, by specifying the sequential ITE layer-group number (which, if unknown, can be determined by choosing the corresponding Hermann–Mauguin symbol from a table with the layer-group symbols). The generators and/or general positions of layer groups are specified by their coordinate triplets, the matrix-column representations of the corresponding symmetry operations and their geometric interpretation:

(a) The list of coordinate triplets (x, y, z) reproduces the data of the General Positions blocks of layer groups found in ITE. The coordinate triplets may also be interpreted as shorthand descriptions of the matrix presentation of the corresponding symmetry operations.

(b) Matrix-column presentation of symmetry operations. With reference to a coordinate system, consisting of an origin O and a basis (a 1, a 2, a 3), the symmetry operations of layer groups are described by (3 × 4) matrix-column pairs.

(c) Geometric interpretation. The geometric interpretation of symmetry operations is given (i) following the conventions in ITE [including the symbol of the symmetry operation, its glide or screw component (if relevant) and the location of the related symmetry element], and (ii) using the Seitz notation. It is worth pointing out that, in contrast to the online and printed editions of ITE, the programs of BCS use the standard International Union of Crystallography Seitz notation. For example, a twofold rotation around the c axis is denoted by Inline graphic instead of Inline graphic (for details, cf. Litvin & Kopský, 2014).

Fig. 1 shows the general position for the layer group Inline graphic (No. 7) in the default setting (cell-choice 1).

Figure 1.

Figure 1

General-position table of the layer group Inline graphic (No. 7), provided by the program GENPOS.

The program GENPOS lists the generators and/or general positions of layer groups in the standard/default setting as well as in conventional non-standard settings of monoclinic/rectangular and orthorhombic/rectangular layer groups described in Table 1.2.6.1 of ITE (option ITE settings). In addition, the program can produce the data in any non-conventional setting if the transformation relating the non-conventional setting to the standard one is specified (option Non-conventional setting). The matrix-column pair (P, p) of the transformation relating the two settings consists of two parts: a linear part P defined by a (3 × 3) matrix, which describes the change of direction and/or length of the basis vectors (a 1, a 2, a 3)non-conv = (a 1, a 2, a 3)stan P, and an origin shift p = Inline graphic defined as a (3 × 1) column, whose coefficients describe the position of the non-conventional origin with respect to the standard one.

The URL of the program GENPOS is https://www.cryst.ehu.es/subperiodic/get_sub_gen.html.

2.2. Wyckoff positions  

The BCS Wyckoff-positions database for layer groups is accessible under the WYCKPOS program. The data on Wyckoff positions can be retrieved by specifying the ITE number of the layer-group type. As a result, the program WYCKPOS shows a table with the Wyckoff positions [see Fig. 2(a)]. Following ITE, each Wyckoff position is characterized by its multiplicity, Wyckoff letter, site-symmetry group and a set of coordinate triplets of the Wyckoff-position points in the unit cell. For centred subperiodic groups, the centring translations are listed above the coordinate triplets. The site-symmetry groups [see column three of Fig. 2(a)] are described by oriented symbols which display the same sequence of symmetry directions as the layer-group symbols (cf. Table 1.2.4.1 of ITE). An explicit listing of the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group of a point is obtained by clicking directly on its coordinate triplet. A recently implemented auxiliary tool permits the identification of the Wyckoff position and the site-symmetry operations of a point specified by its coordinate triplet [see Fig. 2(b)]. The program accepts as input relative point coordinates in fractions, decimals or variable parameters (indicating a generic value). Fig. 3 shows the list of the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group of the layer group cmmm (No. 47) for the points Inline graphic . The points belong to the Wyckoff position 8h with site-symmetry group ..2.

Figure 2.

Figure 2

A screenshot of the output of the program WYCKPOS, showing (a) the Wyckoff positions of the layer group cmmm (No. 47), and (b) the interface of the auxiliary tool for the determination of the Wyckoff position and the site-symmetry group of a specific point.

Figure 3.

Figure 3

Output of the auxiliary tool in WYCKPOS that shows the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group for points with coordinates Inline graphic of the layer group cmmm (No. 47). The points belong to the Wyckoff position 8h with site-symmetry group ..2.

Apart from the standard/default setting option the program is also able to calculate the Wyckoff positions in different ITE (conventional) settings (option ITE settings) or with respect to a non-conventional setting if the corresponding coordinate transformation (P, p) is defined (option Non-conventional setting).

The URL of the program WYCKPOS is https://www.cryst.ehu.es/subperiodic/get_sub_wp.html.

2.3. Maximal subgroups  

The listing of maximal subgroups of layer groups available in ITE is incomplete and lacks additional information, such as, for example, possible unit-cell transformations and/or origin shifts involved. In contrast, the BCS database of maximal subgroups of layer groups provides the complete listing (not just by type but individually) of (i) all maximal non-isotypic subgroups for each layer group, and (ii) all maximal isotypic subgroups of indices 2, 3 and 4. The list of maximal subgroups is retrieved by the access tool MAXSUB. Each subgroup is specified by its ITE number, Hermann–Mauguin symbol, index, subgroup type (t for translationengleiche or k for klassengleiche) and transformation matrix-column pair (P, p) that relates the standard setting of the group with that of the subgroup (see Fig. 4). The different maximal subgroups are distributed into conjugacy classes. The identification of the subgroup symmetry operations as a subset of the elements of the group is achieved by an optional tool of MAXSUB that transforms the general-position representatives of the subgroup to the coordinate system of the group.

Figure 4.

Figure 4

Maximal subgroups of the layer group cmmm (No. 47) provided by the program MAXSUB.

The URL of the program MAXSUB is https://www.cryst.ehu.es/subperiodic/get_sub_maxsub.html.

3. Classification of wavevectors  

A layer group Inline graphic is defined as a three-dimensional crystallographic group with periodicity restricted to a two-dimensional subspace. Just as for space groups, the general strategy for determining the irreducible representations, called irreps for short, of such a group is to exploit the fact that it contains the translation subgroup Inline graphic as a normal abelian subgroup and that irreps of abelian groups are one-dimensional. The elements of Inline graphic have matrix-column pairs of the form Inline graphic where Inline graphic lies in a two-dimensional lattice Inline graphic with basis Inline graphic . Each one-dimensional irrep of Inline graphic is then of the form Inline graphic for a Inline graphic vector Inline graphic in the reciprocal space spanned by the reciprocal basis Inline graphic defined by Inline graphic .

Starting from an irrep Inline graphic of Inline graphic , an irrep of the full layer group Inline graphic is obtained by first extending Inline graphic to the stabilizer of Inline graphic under the conjugation action of Inline graphic and then inducing to the full group Inline graphic . When the induced irrep of Inline graphic is restricted to Inline graphic , it is the sum of those one-dimensional irreps Inline graphic of Inline graphic which lie in the orbit of Inline graphic under the conjugation action of Inline graphic and these are precisely the irreps of Inline graphic that yield irreps of Inline graphic equivalent to the one obtained from Inline graphic . For the action of Inline graphic on the Inline graphic vectors only the part acting on the plane of periodicity of Inline graphic is relevant and the restriction of Inline graphic to this plane gives rise to a plane group Inline graphic associated to Inline graphic . In the convention of ITE, the matrix-column pairs of Inline graphic are expressed with respect to a basis Inline graphic such that the first two basis vectors span the plane of periodicity. Therefore, the matrices of the linear parts of the plane group Inline graphic are simply the upper Inline graphic diagonal blocks of the linear parts of the layer group Inline graphic .

An explicit computation shows that the Inline graphic in the orbit of Inline graphic are of the form Inline graphic for Inline graphic an element of the point group Inline graphic of Inline graphic and Inline graphic an element from the reciprocal lattice Inline graphic of Inline graphic , i.e. for Inline graphic with Inline graphic integers. The set of elements Inline graphic for which Inline graphic is called the little co-group Inline graphic of Inline graphic . The k vector is called general if Inline graphic contains only the identity element of Inline graphic , i.e. Inline graphic = {I}; otherwise Inline graphic > {I} and k is special (Bradley & Cracknell, 1972; Dresselhaus et al., 2008). If { Inline graphic } is the set of coset representatives of the decomposition of Inline graphic with respect to Inline graphic , then the set of Inline graphic vectors { Inline graphic } is called the star of Inline graphic while the vectors Inline graphic are called the arms of the star. Using the relation between the elements of the layer group Inline graphic and the plane group Inline graphic associated to Inline graphic , in analogy to Inline graphic , one defines the little layer co-group Inline graphic which is essential for the derivation of the irreps of Inline graphic .

The preceding discussion indicates the importance of the so-called reciprocal plane group Inline graphic , defined as the symmorphic plane group having the reciprocal lattice Inline graphic as translation vectors and Inline graphic as point group. It is crucial that the operations in Inline graphic act on reciprocal space, i.e. they act on rows, as opposed to Inline graphic which acts on columns. In order to identify Inline graphic with one of the symmorphic plane groups in their standard setting, the action on reciprocal space (on rows) has to be transformed into one on direct space (on columns).

3.1. Transformation between reciprocal space and direct space  

After fixing a basis Inline graphic for direct space, the action of the point group Inline graphic of Inline graphic on Inline graphic is given by Inline graphic matrices Inline graphic acting on columns. We now have to relate the action on the reciprocal lattice Inline graphic to that on Inline graphic . Defining

3.1.

the basis Inline graphic is mapped by Inline graphic to the new basis Inline graphic . The corresponding matrix Inline graphic for the action on reciprocal space (on rows) must then map the reciprocal basis Inline graphic to the reciprocal basis Inline graphic of Inline graphic . From

3.1.

it follows that Inline graphic must be the identity matrix Inline graphic . We thus have Inline graphic , i.e. the action on the rows of reciprocal space is given by the inverse matrices acting on the columns of direct space. Since Inline graphic is a group, it contains with every matrix Inline graphic of course also the inverse matrix Inline graphic ; hence the set of matrices remains the same, but they now act from the right on rows.

As an example, we take the layer group Inline graphic (No. 78). Restricting the action to the plane of periodicity gives the plane group Inline graphic (No. 14). If we look at the Inline graphic vector Inline graphic , applying the threefold rotation with matrix

3.1.

to the row Inline graphic gives Inline graphic and applying it again gives Inline graphic . On the other hand, applying the reflection with reflection line Inline graphic and matrix

3.1.

we see that the row Inline graphic is mapped to Inline graphic , which is equal to Inline graphic up to a reciprocal-lattice vector. The star of Inline graphic consisting of the Inline graphic vectors in the orbit under Inline graphic is therefore Inline graphic .

As we have just demonstrated, it is natural to consider the action of the reciprocal plane group Inline graphic on rows, but on the other hand Inline graphic is by construction isomorphic to a symmorphic plane group Inline graphic . In order to identify Inline graphic with the proper symmorphic plane group, the action on rows has to be transformed to an action on columns. This is of course achieved by simply transposing the matrices of the point group Inline graphic , since Inline graphic and the transpose Inline graphic of a row is a column. The symmorphic plane group Inline graphic isomorphic to Inline graphic is therefore the group

3.1.

The only problem that may occur is that Inline graphic is not given in its standard setting. This can be seen from different (strongly interrelated) perspectives:

(i) The reciprocal basis Inline graphic may not be a conventional basis of the lattice Inline graphic . For example, the reciprocal lattice of a hexagonal lattice is also a hexagonal lattice, but while the vectors Inline graphic in the conventional basis have an angle of 120°, the reciprocal basis vectors Inline graphic enclose an angle of 60° and are therefore not a conventional basis of a hexagonal lattice.

(ii) The matrices Inline graphic of the point group fix the metric tensor Inline graphic of the lattice Inline graphic , i.e. one has Inline graphic . The transposed matrices fix the inverse metric tensor Inline graphic as can be seen from inverting the above equation: Inline graphic = Inline graphic = Inline graphic . This corresponds to the fact that the reciprocal lattice Inline graphic has metric tensor Inline graphic . But Inline graphic may not be the metric tensor of a lattice with respect to its conventional basis. For example, a hexagonal lattice has a metric tensor of the form

3.1.

which has inverse

3.1.

This is the metric tensor of a hexagonal lattice with basis vectors having an angle of 60°, i.e. in a non-conventional setting.

(iii) The transposed matrices Inline graphic simply do not occur as matrices of one of the point groups of plane groups in their standard setting. For example, the transposed matrix

3.1.

of the matrix

3.1.

of a threefold rotation Inline graphic does not belong to the point group of any of the plane groups.

For plane groups, the hexagonal lattice is actually the only case in which the transposed matrices do not belong to a point group in its standard setting. For all other lattices, the inverse of the metric tensor still belongs to a conventional basis or, in other words, the set of matrices of the point group does not change by transposing.

In order to identify the symmorphic plane group Inline graphic in the case of a hexagonal lattice, the group has to be transformed to a basis in the conventional setting, i.e. which has a metric tensor equal to a multiple of

3.1.

Such a transformation is

3.1.

(or its compositions with powers of a sixfold rotation) and the transposed matrices of the point group have to be conjugated by this. This interchanges the two types of reflections (in p6mm), those with normals along the two basis vectors and their sum and those with reflection lines along the basis vectors (and their sum). For example, for

3.1.

the reflection with reflection line Inline graphic , one gets

3.1.

which is the reflection with reflection line along the a axis.

As a result, for a layer group with plane group of type p3m1, the symmorphic plane group Inline graphic isomorphic to the reciprocal plane group Inline graphic is of type p31m and vice versa.

Based on the identification of the reciprocal plane group Inline graphic with a symmorphic plane group Inline graphic , the special Inline graphic vectors for a layer group Inline graphic can be directly read off from the Wyckoff positions of Inline graphic .

3.2. Crystallographic conventions in the classification of layer-group irreps  

The isomorphism between a reciprocal plane group Inline graphic and a symmorphic plane group Inline graphic allows the application of crystallographic conventions in the classification of the wavevectors (and henceforth of the irreps) of the layer groups Inline graphic :

(i) The unit cells of the symmorphic plane groups listed in ITA can replace the Brillouin zones as unit cells of the reciprocal space. To find all irreps of Inline graphic , it is necessary to consider only the wavevectors of the so-called representation domain. It is defined as a simply connected part of the (first) Brillouin zone (a unit cell of the reciprocal space) which contains exactly one k vector of each orbit of k. The asymmetric units of plane groups can serve as representation domains. The advantage of choosing the crystallographic unit cells and their asymmetric units becomes evident in layer groups where the Brillouin zones may belong to different topological types depending on the ratios of the lattice parameters. Lines on the Brillouin zone may appear or disappear or change their relative sizes depending on the lattice parameters. In contrast to that, the unit cells and their asymmetric units of ITA are independent of the ratios of the lattice parameters.

(ii) The action of the reciprocal plane group Inline graphic on the wavevectors results in their distribution into orbits of symmetry-equivalent k vectors with respect to Inline graphic . Thanks to the isomorphism of ( Inline graphic ) Inline graphic with the symmorphic plane group Inline graphic , the different types of k vectors correspond to the different kinds of point orbits (Wyckoff positions) of Inline graphic . In this way, a complete list of the special sites in the Brillouin zone of ( Inline graphic ) Inline graphic is provided by the Wyckoff positions of Inline graphic found in ITA. The site-symmetry groups of ITA correspond to the little co-groups of the wavevectors and the number of arms of the star of a wavevector follows from the multiplicity of the Wyckoff position. The Wyckoff positions with zero, one and two variable parameters correspond to special k-vector points, special k-vector lines and special (or general) k-vector planes, respectively. A k-vector type, i.e. the set of all k vectors corresponding to a Wyckoff position, consists of complete orbits of k vectors and thus of full stars of k vectors. The different orbits (and stars) of a k-vector type are obtained by varying the free parameters. Correspondingly, the irreps of k vectors of a k-vector type are interrelated by parameter variation and are said to belong to the same type of irreps (Boyle, 1986). In this way all wavevector stars giving rise to the same type of irreps are related to the same Wyckoff position and designated by the same Wyckoff letter.

(iii) A complete set of irreps of Inline graphic is derived by considering exactly one k-vector representative per k-vector orbit. To achieve that, it is necessary to specify the exact parameter ranges of the independent k-vector regions within the representation domain (or the asymmetric unit). While such data are not available in the literature, the Brillouin-zone database of BCS offers the listing of the exact parameter ranges for the k vectors which are absolutely necessary for the solution of the problems of uniqueness and completeness of layer-group irreps. For this purpose it is advantageous to describe the different k-vector stars belonging to a Wyckoff position applying the so-called uni-arm description. Two k vectors of a Wyckoff position are called uni-arm if one can be obtained from the other by parameter variation. The description of k-vector stars of a Wyckoff position is called uni-arm if the k vectors representing these stars are uni-arm. Frequently, in order to achieve a uni-arm description, it is necessary to transform k vectors to equivalent ones. In addition, to enable a uni-arm description, symmetry lines outside the asymmetric unit may be selected as orbit representatives. Such a segment of a line is called a flagpole. Examples of flagpoles are displayed in Fig. 9, and Figs. 10 and 11 for the layer group cm2m (No. 35) [cf. Section 5.2 for a detailed account of the use of flagpoles in the uni-arm description of k-vector types that belong to Wyckoff position 2a of the reciprocal plane group Inline graphic ].

4. The Brillouin-zone database for layer groups  

The k-vector data of the Brillouin-zone database of the BCS are accessed by the retrieval tool LKVEC which uses as input the ITE number of the layer group. The output consists essentially of wavevector tables and figures. There are several sets of figures and tables for the same layer group when its Brillouin-zone shape depends on the lattice parameters of the reciprocal lattice. The k-vector data are the same for layer groups of the same arithmetic crystal class.

In the k-vector tables, the wavevector data of LW are compared with the Wyckoff-position data of ITA. In the figures, the Brillouin zones and the representation domains of LW, and the asymmetric units, chosen often in analogy to those of ITA, are displayed.

LW describe the monoclinic/rectangular layer groups with respect to a setting that is different from the conventional one found in ITE. Using the relationship between the two settings, we have transformed the k-vector data of LW to the conventional setting of ITE for all six monoclinic/rectangular arithmetic crystal classes: 211p, 211c, m11p, m11c, Inline graphic and Inline graphic . The transformed special k-vector points, lines and planes keep the LW labels of the k vectors from which they were derived.

The URL of the program LKVEC is https://www.cryst.ehu.es/subperiodic/get_layer_kvec.html.

4.1. Guide to the tables  

Each k-vector table is headed by the corresponding Hermann–Mauguin symbol of the layer group, its ITE number and the symbol of the arithmetic crystal class to which the layer group belongs. If there is more than one table for an arithmetic crystal class, then these tables refer to different geometric conditions for the lattice parameters that are indicated after the symbol of the arithmetic crystal class. The set of layer groups of the arithmetic crystal class are also indicated in the headline block. They are followed by the symbol of the corresponding reciprocal plane-group type together with the conditions for the lattice parameters of the reciprocal lattice, if any (asterisks denote reciprocal-space quantities). From the k-vector table there is a link to the corresponding Brillouin-zone figure.

The k-vector tables consist of two parts: (i) ‘Litvin & Wike’ description and (ii) ‘Plane-group description’. The first three columns under the heading ‘Litvin & Wike’ refer to the description of the k-vectors found in Tables 24 and 25 of LW. It consists of labels of k-vectors (column 1), their parameter descriptions (column 2) and their layer little co-group (column 3 for primitive lattices and column 4 for c-centred). Note that LW substitutes the Greek-character labels for the symmetry points and lines inside the Brillouin zone by a symbol consisting of two Roman characters, e.g. GM instead of Γ, LD instead of Λ etc. In order to enable the uni-arm description new k-vector types, equivalent to those of LW, are added to the k-vector lists. Equivalent k vectors (related by the sign ∼) are designated by the same labels; additional indices distinguish the new k vectors.

Different k vectors with the same LW label always belong to the same k-vector type, i.e. they correspond to the same Wyckoff position. k Vectors with different LW labels may either belong to the same or to different types of k vectors. When k vectors with different LW labels belong to the same k-vector type, the corresponding parameter descriptions are followed by the letters ‘ex’ (from Latin, with the meaning of ‘from’ or ‘out of’). Symmetry points or lines of symmetry of LW, related to the same Wyckoff position, are grouped together in a block. In the k-vector tables, neighbouring Wyckoff-position blocks are distinguished by a slight difference in the background colour. The parameter description of the uni-arm region of a k-vector type is shown in the last row of the corresponding Wyckoff-position block.

The wavevector coefficients of LW (column 2 of the k-vector tables) refer always to a primitive basis irrespective of whether the conventional description of the group in ITE is with respect to a centred or primitive basis. For that reason, for layer groups with centred lattices, the wavevector coefficients with respect to the usual conventional reciprocal basis, i.e. dual to the conventional centred basis, are listed in the column under the heading ‘Conventional’ of the k-vector tables. The relations between the conventional coefficients (k 1, k 2) and the primitive coefficients ( Inline graphic , Inline graphic ) are summarized in Table 1. (For layer groups with primitive lattices, the wavevector coefficients referred to a primitive basis coincide with those referred to the basis dual to the conventional one of ITA.)

Table 1. ‘Conventional’ k-vector coefficients {k}_{j} (i.e. with respect to a basis dual to the conventional basis of ITA) expressed by the ‘primitive’ k-vector coefficients {k}_{{\rm p}j} (i.e. referred to a primitive basis) for the different Bravais lattices in direct space.

Bravais lattice {k}_{1} {k}_{2}
mp, op, tp, hp {k}_{{\rm p}1} {k}_{{\rm p}2}
oc {k}_{{\rm p}1}+ {k}_{{\rm p}2} -{k}_{{\rm p}1}+{k}_{{\rm p}2}

The layer little co-group data of each k vector are listed under the heading ‘Layer little co-group’ of the k-vector tables. The layer little co-groups are subgroups of the point group of the layer group and are described by oriented point-group symbols (as is customary for site-symmetry groups of Wyckoff positions).

The data for the crystallographic classification scheme of the wavevectors are listed under the heading ‘Plane-group description’ in the k-vector tables. The columns ‘Wyckoff positions’ show the ‘multiplicity’, ‘Wyckoff letter’ and ‘site-symmetry’ of the Wyckoff positions of the corresponding symmorphic plane group Inline graphic of ITA which is isomorphic to the reciprocal plane group ( Inline graphic ) Inline graphic . The multiplicity of a Wyckoff position divided by the number of lattice points in the conventional unit cell of ITA is equal to the number of arms of the star of the corresponding k vector. The alphabetical sequence of the Wyckoff positions determines the sequence of the LW labels. Unlike in ITA, the tables start with the Wyckoff letter ‘a’ for the Wyckoff position of the highest site symmetry. Site symmetries are described by means of oriented point-group symbols which are also links to more detailed information on the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group. Besides the shorthand description, the matrix-column representation and the geometric representation of the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group, the program also provides a table with the relationship between the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group and the layer little co-group (cf. Fig. 5 and Section 3.1 for detailed explanations).

Figure 5.

Figure 5

Relation between the symmetry operations of the site-symmetry group .m. of the plane group Inline graphic (No. 5) and the layer little co-group Inline graphic of the layer group Inline graphic (No. 35) for the k vector DT = (−u, u).

The parameter description of the Wyckoff positions is shown in the last column of the wavevector tables under the heading ‘Coordinates’. It consists of a representative coordinate doublet of the Wyckoff position and algebraic statements for the description of the independent parameter range. In some cases, the algebraic expressions are substituted by the designation of the parameter region in order to avoid clumsy notation. Because of the dependence of the shape of the Brillouin zone on the lattice parameter relations there may be vertices of the Brillouin zone with a variable coordinate. If such a point is displayed and designated in the tables and figures by an upper-case letter, then the label of its variable coefficient used in the parameter-range descriptions is the same letter but typed in lower case.

Because of the isomorphism between Inline graphic and ( Inline graphic ) Inline graphic the coordinate doublets of the Wyckoff positions of Inline graphic can be interpreted as k-vector coefficients ( Inline graphic , Inline graphic ) determined with respect to the conventional ITA basis of Inline graphic . The relation between the ITA coefficients ( Inline graphic , Inline graphic ) and the conventional coefficients ( Inline graphic , Inline graphic ) is shown in Table 2.

Table 2. ‘Conventional’ k-vector coefficients {k}_{j} (i.e. with respect to a basis dual to the conventional basis of ITA) expressed by the ITA k-vector coefficients {k}_{{\rm a}j} (i.e. referred to the conventional ITA basis of {\cal P}_{0}) for the different Bravais lattices in direct space.

Bravais lattice {k}_{1} {k}_{2}
mp, op, tp {k}_{{\rm a}1} {k}_{{\rm a}2}
oc {2k}_{{\rm a}1} {2k}_{{\rm a}2}
hp {k}_{{\rm a}1}-{k}_{{\rm a}2} {k}_{{\rm a}2}

At the bottom of the web page with the k-vector table one finds an auxiliary tool which allows the complete characterization of a wavevector of the reciprocal space (not restricted to the first Brillouin zone): given the k-vector coefficients referred either to a primitive (LW) or to a conventional basis, the program assigns the k vector to the corresponding wavevector symmetry type, specifies its LW label, and calculates the layer little co-group and the arms of the k-vector star. Consider again the example of the k vector with coefficients Inline graphic for the layer group Inline graphic (No. 78), cf. Fig. 6 and Fig. 8. It is a vector outside the first Brillouin zone and its coefficients do not correspond to any of the parameter descriptions of the k-vector representatives listed in Fig. 6. The output of the auxiliary tool indicates that k Inline graphic is a point of a special k-vector line of type SM and belongs to the Wyckoff-position block 3c. As already commented in Section 3.1, its star consists of three k vectors, Inline graphic = {(−1.21, 1), (1, 0.21), (0.21, −1.21)}. The site-symmetry group ..m is generated by a reflection plane that can be identified by direct inspection among the symmetry operations of (p31m) Inline graphic . The layer little co-group, however, is mm2, due to the additional reflection in the layer plane.

Figure 6.

Figure 6

k-Vector table of the layer group Inline graphic (No. 78) as shown on the BCS. The Brillouin-zone diagram is shown in Fig. 8.

4.2. Guide to the figures  

The headline of each Brillouin-zone figure includes the same information as the k-vector tables: the Hermann–Mauguin symbol of the layer group, the ITE number and the symbol of the arithmetic crystal class to which the layer group belongs. Different figures for the same arithmetic crystal class are distinguished by the geometric conditions for the lattice. The corresponding conditions for the lattice parameters of the reciprocal lattice are indicated after the symbol of the reciprocal plane group.

The Brillouin zones are two-dimensional objects in the reciprocal space. The coordinate axes are designated by kx and ky , and the origin with coefficients (0, 0) always coincides with the centre of the Brillouin zone and is called Γ (indicated as GM in the k-vector tables). In the Brillouin-zone figures the representation domains of LW are compared with the asymmetric units of ITA. A statement of whether the representation domain of LW and the asymmetric unit are identical or not is given below the k-vector table. The asymmetric units are often not fully contained in the Brillouin zone, but protrude from it, in particular by flagpoles.

The representatives of the orbits of k-vector symmetry points or k-vector symmetry lines, as well as the edges of the representation domains of LW and of the asymmetric units are brought out in colour (see Fig. 7):

Figure 7.

Figure 7

Colour coding of points and lines applied in the Brillouin-zone diagrams.

(a) Symmetry points. A representative point of each orbit of special k-vector points is designated by a circle filled in red with its label also in red. Note that a point is coloured red only if it is really a special point, i.e. a point whose layer little co-group is a supergroup of the little co-groups of the points in its neighbourhood. In the figures, a point is marked by its label and an empty circle if it is listed in the corresponding k-vector table but is not a point of special symmetry. For example, points listed by LW are not coloured if they form part of a symmetry line or a symmetry plane. The same designation is used for the auxiliary points that have been added in order to facilitate the comparison between the traditional and the reciprocal plane-group descriptions of the k-vector types.

(b) Symmetry lines. A line is coloured in red with its label also in red only if it is a special k-vector line, i.e. the layer little co-groups of the points on the line are supergroups of the little co-groups of the points in its neighbourhood. The colour of the line is pink for an edge of the asymmetric unit which is not a symmetry line. The colour of the line is brown with the name in red for a line which is a symmetry line as well as an edge of the asymmetric unit. The edges of the representation domains are coloured light blue if the representation domain of LW does not coincide with the asymmetric unit. Edges of the representation domain and their labels are coloured dark blue if they are symmetry lines. Flagpoles are always coloured in red. Coordinate axes, edges of the Brillouin zone or auxiliary lines are displayed by thin solid black lines.

5. Examples  

The relation between the traditional and the reciprocal group descriptions of the wavevector types is illustrated by the following examples. The figures and tables included here form part of the output of the access tool LKVEC.

5.1. k-Vector table and Brillouin zone for the layer group p 62m (No. 78)  

The k-vector table and the Brillouin-zone diagram of the hexagonal layer group Inline graphic (No. 78) are shown in Fig. 6 and Fig. 8, respectively. The reciprocal lattice of a hexagonal p lattice is also a hexagonal p lattice and the Brillouin zone is a hexagon. The conventional basis for the reciprocal lattice has Inline graphic while the ITA description of hexagonal layer groups is based on a basis a H, b H with Inline graphic . In the Brillouin-zone diagrams, the axis k x is taken along a H while k y points out in the direction of a H + b H.

Figure 8.

Figure 8

Brillouin zone and representation domain of LW, and asymmetric unit of the layer group Inline graphic (No. 78). The reciprocal plane group is Inline graphic (No. 15). The representation domain of LW is different from the asymmetric unit.

The k vectors of Inline graphic (No. 78) listed by LW (Fig. 6) are distributed in four k-vector types: (i) the Wyckoff-position block 1a formed by the GM point, (ii) the block 2b formed by the K point, (iii) the k-vector point M and the k-vector lines SM and SN correspond to the block 3c, and (iv) the Wyckoff-position block 6d formed by the k-vector lines LD and T and the k-vector planes B and BB. The parameter description of a k-vector type is given in the last column of the table. Consider for example the line SM which, according to the ITA description, forms part of the k-vector type that is assigned to the Wyckoff position 3c with a site-symmetry group ‘..m’. Its parameter description x, 0: 0 < x < 1/2 indicates that the independent segment of the line x, 0 in the asymmetric unit is limited by the special k-vector points Γ (x = 0) and M (x = 1/2) with x varying between 0 and 1/2. The parameter descriptions of the uni-arm regions of the k-vector types are shown in the last row of the corresponding Wyckoff-position block. For example, in the block for position 3c, the k-vector line SN is equivalent (by a threefold rotation) to Inline graphic which in turn is equivalent (by a translation) to the line Inline graphic , denoted by SN1. This gives the uni-arm description M+SM+SN1 for the Wyckoff position 3c in Fig. 6.

As the asymmetric unit and the representation domain do not coincide, their edges are coloured in pink and light blue, respectively. It has already been pointed out that k-vector points and lines are brought out in red only if they are special k-vector points and lines. For example, the lines T and LD (indicated as Λ on Fig. 8) are not coloured as special lines since they belong to the k-vector type of the Wyckoff-position block 6d, and their symmetry coincides with that of the neighbouring points of the symmetry plane B = [GM K M]. The points GM (indicated as Γ on Fig. 8) and K, however, are represented by red circles as they are special k-vector points (cf. Fig. 6). Likewise, the line SM (indicated as Σ on Fig. 8) is coloured in brown because it is an edge of the asymmetric unit and at the same time is a special k-vector symmetry line. The k-vector line SN is coloured in dark blue as it is a special symmetry line along the edge of the representation domain. As already indicated, the k-vector line SN together with SM and the point M belong to the special k-vector type of the Wyckoff-position block 3c, i.e. all these different wavevectors belong to the same k-vector type. Although M is explicitly listed by LW as a special k-vector point, it is represented by an open circle in Fig. 8: in fact, it joins the symmetry lines SM and SN1 to a continuous line as its little co-group type coincides with those of the points on the lines.

5.2. k-Vector table and Brillouin zone for the layer group cm2m (No. 35)  

The layer group cm2m (No. 35) is an example of ortho­rhombic layer groups with a c-centred lattice. It belongs to the arithmetic crystal class m2mc which also includes the layer group cm2e (No. 36). The k-vector tables and Brillouin-zone figures for the layer groups belonging to the arithmetic crystal class m2mc are given in Fig. 9, and Figs. 10 and 11, respectively.

Figure 9.

Figure 9

k-Vector tables of the layer groups with arithmetic crystal class m2mc, acute (a > b) and obtuse (a < b) cases, as shown on the BCS. The Brillouin-zone diagrams are shown in Figs. 10 and 11.

Figure 10.

Figure 10

Brillouin zone and representation domain of LW, and asymmetric unit of the arithmetic crystal class m2mc: layer group cm2m (No. 35) and cm2e (No. 36) acute case (a > b). The reciprocal group is Inline graphic (No. 5). The representation domain of LW does not coincide with the asymmetric unit.

Figure 11.

Figure 11

Brillouin zone and representation domain of LW, and asymmetric unit of the arithmetic crystal class m2mc: layer group cm2m (No. 35) and cm2e (No. 36) obtuse case (a < b). The reciprocal group is Inline graphic (No. 5). The representation domain of LW does not coincide with the asymmetric unit.

The k-vector tables show all special wavevectors with their coefficients and layer little co-groups as specified in Tables 24 and 25 of LW. The wavevector coefficients with respect to the conventional reciprocal basis, i.e. dual to the conventional centred basis, are listed in the column under the heading ‘Conventional’ of the k-vector tables. For example, a k-vector point of the DT line (Fig. 9) with primitive coefficients Inline graphic is described as Inline graphic with respect to a basis dual to the conventional basis of cm2m.

The comparison of the wavevector list of LW and the reciprocal plane-group description indicates clearly the redundancy of most of the k vectors given by LW. In fact, for the derivation of a complete set of irreps it is necessary to consider just two k-vector types: a general one corresponding to the general Wyckoff position 4b, and the k-vector symmetry line related to the special Wyckoff position 2a. The large number of additional k vectors given in the tables of LW are due to two main reasons:

(a) The more symmetry a layer group has lost compared with its holosymmetric layer group (layer groups whose point groups are holohedral), the more k vectors are introduced in LW. In the case of cm2m, the holosymmetric layer group is cmmm (No. 47), and the lines DA and FA are examples of such additional k vectors. In most cases these additional k vectors can be avoided by extending the parameter range in the k-vector space.

(b) In the transition from a holosymmetric Inline graphic to a non-holosymmetric layer group Inline graphic , the order of the little co-group of a special k vector in Inline graphic may be reduced in Inline graphic and, as a result, the special k vector in Inline graphic may lose its ‘special nature’ in Inline graphic . Such k vectors become part of a more general k-vector type (i.e. assigned to a Wyckoff position of lower site symmetry) and can be described by an extension of the corresponding parameter range. Consider, for example, the k-vector points Γ and Y in the tables of cm2m. They are special k-vector points lying on the reflection plane of Inline graphic in the holosymmetric layer group cmmm, but in (the non-holosymmetric group) cm2m which does not contain Inline graphic the two points form part of the special k-vector line with the uni-arm description: Inline graphic (cf. the last row of the 2a Wyckoff-position block, Fig. 9).

The Brillouin zone of the layer groups of the arithmetic crystal class m2mc is a non-regular hexagon (cf. Figs. 10 and 11). Depending on the relation between the lattice parameters a and b, two topologically different Brillouin zones are to be distinguished: (i) the acute case with Inline graphic and (ii) the obtuse case with Inline graphic . Because of the reflection Inline graphic (with normal Inline graphic ) of the reciprocal plane group Inline graphic , the representation domain is only one half of the hexagon: for example, in the acute case (Fig. 10) it is the trapezium with vertices Inline graphic (light blue boundary). The asymmetric unit is different from the representation domain: it is the rectangle with vertices Inline graphic (pink boundary), i.e. the points Inline graphic . While the representation domains of the acute and obtuse unit cells have the more complicated form of a trapezium, the asymmetric units in both cases have the topologically identical and relatively simple shape of a rectangle.

As already indicated, the points Γ, Y2 and S (acute case), and Γ, Y and S (obtuse case) are not special k-vector points but form part of special lines and planes and in the diagrams they are represented by open circles. The line SM is not a symmetry line and is represented by a thin black line because it is located inside the Brillouin zone. The lines DT and DA are coloured in brown because they are symmetry lines and at the same time are edges of the asymmetric unit. Parts of DT and DA are also coloured in red because they correspond to flagpoles. The k-vector lines F and FA (acute case) are coloured in dark blue as they are symmetry lines along the edges of the representation domain.

Because of the special shape of the Brillouin zone and the representation domain for the acute case ( Inline graphic ), the special k-vector line corresponding to the Wyckoff-position block 2a splits into several segments: the lines DT and DA, located inside the Brillouin zone, and the lines F and FA (coloured dark blue) at the border of the Brillouin zone (cf. Figs. 9 and 10). For the description of the end points of the segments, it is necessary to introduce additional parameters as dt0 and f0 whose values depend on the specific relations between the lattice parameters. [In fact, the vertices Inline graphic and F0 of the representation domain have the coordinates Inline graphic Inline graphic and F0: Inline graphic .] The use of flagpoles enables the uni-arm description: the flagpole [J2 Y2] Inline graphic is equivalent to the segment [V4 Y] Inline graphic and the flagpole [V2 Y4] Inline graphic Inline graphic is equivalent to the segment [Y J4] Inline graphic . The uni-arm description of the k-vector type of the Wyckoff position 2a is shown in the last row of the Wyckoff-position block and it is formed by the union of the points GM and Y2, the lines DT, DA, DT1(∼FA) and DA1 (∼F). Its parameter description (0, y) with y varying in the range (−1/2, 1/2) coincides with that of the acute case. The parameter description of the flagpole and its parameter range with respect to the basis of the reciprocal group are given below the k-vector table.

6. Conclusions  

In this paper we have presented the layer-group crystallographic and wavevector databases of the BCS, together with the programs which give access to these data. Like the rest of the programs on the server, these tools are freely available and can be accessed via user-friendly web interfaces. The programs GENPOS, WYCKPOS and MAXSUB provide access to generators/general positions, Wyckoff positions and maximal subgroup information, respectively.

The wavevector database which contains the Brillouin-zone figures and wavevector tables for all 80 layer groups was recently implemented on the BCS. One can access the database through the program LKVEC. In this compilation, the representation domains and lists of special k vectors in the tables on layer-group representations by Litvin & Wike (1991) are compared with the figures and wavevector data derived applying the reciprocal-space-group approach. This new database provides a solution to the completeness problem of layer-group representations by specifying the independent parameter ranges of general and special k vectors within the representation domains.

Acknowledgments

Open access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL.

Funding Statement

This work was funded by Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación grant MINECOG19/P21; Government of the Basque Country grant IT1301-19.

References

  1. Aroyo, M. I. (2016). Editor. International Tables for Crystallography, Vol. A, Space-group Symmetry, 6th ed. Chichester: Wiley.
  2. Aroyo, M. I., Orobengoa, D., de la Flor, G., Tasci, E. S., Perez-Mato, J. M. & Wondratschek, H. (2014). Acta Cryst. A70, 126–137. [DOI] [PubMed]
  3. Aroyo, M. I., Perez-Mato, J. M., Capillas, C., Kroumova, E., Ivantchev, S., Madariaga, G., Kirov, A. & Wondratschek, H. (2006). Z. Kristallogr. 221, 15–27.
  4. Aroyo, M. I., Perez-Mato, J. M., Orobengoa, D., Tasci, E. S., de la Flor, G. & Kirov, A. (2011). Bulg. Chem. Commun. 43, 183–197.
  5. Aroyo, M. I. & Wondratschek, H. (1995). Z. Kristallogr. 210, 243–254.
  6. Boyle, L. L. (1986). Proceedings of the 14th International Colloquium on Group Theoretical Methods in Physics, pp. 405–408. Singapore: World Scientific.
  7. Bradley, C. J. & Cracknell, A. P. (1972). The Mathematical Theory of Symmetry in Solids: Representation Theory for Point Groups and Space Groups. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
  8. Cracknell, A. P., Davies, B. L., Miller, S. C. & Love, W. F. (1979). Kronecker Product Tables, Vol. 1, General Introduction and Tables of Irreducible Representations of Space Groups. New York: IFI/Plenum.
  9. Dresselhaus, M. S., Dresselhaus, G. & Jorio, A. (2008). Group Theory Application to the Physics of Condensed Matter. Berlin: Springer.
  10. Elcoro, L., Bradlyn, B., Wang, Z., Vergniory, M. G., Cano, J., Felser, C., Bernevig, B. A., Orobengoa, D., de la Flor, G. & Aroyo, M. I. (2017). J. Appl. Cryst. 50, 1457–1477.
  11. Flor, G. de la, Orobengoa, D., Evarestov, R. A., Kitaev, Y. E., Tasci, E. & Aroyo, M. I. (2019). J. Appl. Cryst. 52, 1214–1221. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed]
  12. Gallego, S. V., Etxebarria, J., Elcoro, L., Tasci, E. S. & Perez-Mato, J. M. (2019). Acta Cryst. A75, 438–447. [DOI] [PubMed]
  13. Hatch, D. M. & Stokes, H. T. (1986). Phase Transit. 7, 87–279.
  14. Ipatova, I. P. & Kitaev, Y. E. (1985). Prog. Surf. Sci. 18, 189–246.
  15. Kopský, V. & Litvin, D. (2010). Editors. International Tables for Crystallography, Vol. E, Subperiodic Groups, 2nd ed. Chichester: Wiley.
  16. Litvin, D. B. & Kopský, V. (2014). Acta Cryst. A70, 677–678.
  17. Litvin, D. B. & Wike, T. R. (1991). Character Tables and Compatibility Relations of the Eighty Layer Groups and Seventeen Plane Groups. New York: Plenum Press.
  18. Miller, S. C. & Love, W. F. (1967). Tables of Irreducible Representations of Space Groups and Co-Representations of Magnetic Space Groups. Boulder: Pruett Press.
  19. Milošević, I., Nikolić, B., Damnjanović, M. & Krčmar, M. (2008). J. Phys. A, 31, 3625–3648.
  20. Stokes, H. T. & Hatch, D. M. (1988). Isotropy Subgroups of the 230 Crystallographic Space Groups. Singapore: World Scientific.
  21. Tasci, E. S., de la Flor, G., Orobengoa, D., Capillas, C., Perez-Mato, J. M. & Aroyo, M. I. (2012). EJP Web Conf. 22, 00009.
  22. Wintgen, G. (1941). Math. Ann. 118, 195–215.
  23. Wondratschek, H. & Müller, U. (2010). Editors. International Tables for Crystallography, Vol. A1, Symmetry Relations between Space Groups, 2nd ed. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.

Articles from Acta Crystallographica. Section A, Foundations and Advances are provided here courtesy of International Union of Crystallography

RESOURCES