Table 2.
Compound | Treatment | |||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Control | CuO (mg/L) | ZnO (mg/L) | Fe3O4 (mg/L) | |||||||
1 | 5 | 10 | 1 | 5 | 10 | 1 | 5 | 10 | ||
L. viridis | ||||||||||
O-Caffeoylquinic acid | 81 ± 8 a | 92 ± 7 a | 83 ± 0 a | 80.6 ± 0.7 a | 97 ± 7 a | 101 ± 2 a | 100 ± 5 a | 83 ± 10 a | 83 ± 3 a | 91 ± 8 a |
Caffeic acid hexoside isomer I | 1039 ± 80 b | 1229 ± 85 a,b | 583 ± 32 c | 1400 ± 71 a | 171 ± 126 d | 144 ± 1 d | 221 ± 7 d | 221 ± 13 d | 325 ± 27 d | 231 ± 13 d |
Caffeic acid hexoside isomer II | 159 ± 3 b | 1866 ± 16 b | 1091 ± 29 c | 2269 ± 170 a | 258 ± 207 d,e | 212 ± 7 e | 331.1 ± 0.5 d,e | 341 ± 35 d,e | 564 ± 96 d | 369 ± 55 d,e |
Fertaric acid | 227 ± 16 a | 119 ± 5 b | 70 ± 3 c | 233 ± 9 a | 52 ± 2 c,d | 27.6 ± 0.4 e | 23.0 ± 0.1 e | 38 ± 1 d,e | 50 ± 4 c,d | 35 ± 1 d,e |
Caffeic acid | 147.2 ± 0.5 | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOD |
Ferulic acid | 2996 ± 134 a | 2336 ± 173 b | 1328 ± 14 d | 1650 ± 29 c | 1247 ± 48 d | 291 ± 3 f | 499 ± 36 f | 827 ± 44 e | 1352 ± 8 d | 751 ± 16 e |
Rosmarinic acid | 59874 ± 1040 b | 59183 ± 1429 b | 49922 ± 772 c | 64501 ± 2858 a | 27262 ± 47 e | 9450± 2 g | 20505 ± 250 f | 17086 ± 483 f | 32747 ± 1317 d | 19656 ± 587 f |
Salvianolic acid A isomer I | 287 ± 24 c | 415 ± 24 b | 484 ± 23 a | 108 ± 1 e | 169 ± 6 d | 86 ± 2 e | 206 ± 8 d | 118.0 ± 0.4 e | 197 ± 4 d | 106 ± 3 e |
Salvianolic acid A isomer II | <LOQ | 50 ± 8 | 52 ± 10 | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOD |
Salvianolic acid I | <LOQ | 49.0 ± 0.1 | 45.2 ± 0.2 | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOD |
Salvianolic acid B | 7281 ± 534 c | 11035 ± 654 a | 9545 ± 449 b | 3673 ± 55 d | 3344 ± 63 d | 1181 ± 44 e | 1612 ± 34 e | 2093 ± 61 e | 4078 ± 2 d | 2072 ± 91 e |
Total phenolic acids | 73522 ± 1818 a | 76374 ± 2371 a | 63203 ± 1253 b | 73916 ± 3196 a | 32599 ± 489 d | 11494 ± 51 f | 23498 ± 330 e | 20808 ± 651 e | 39396 ± 1433 c | 23311 ± 741 e |
Apigenin | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | 63.78 ± 2.17 | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOD |
Herniarin | 519 ± 26 b | 733 ± 7 a | 521 ± 31 b | 142 ± 17 e | 259 ± 5 d | 71 ± 4 f | 238 ± 5 d | 147 ± 8 e | 361 ± 4 c | 177 ± 2 e |
Total phenolic compounds | 74042 ± 1845 a | 77107 ± 2378 a | 63725 ± 1284b | 74122 ± 3214 a | 32858 ± 494 d | 11565 ± 55 f | 23735 ± 325 e | 20955 ± 659 e | 39758 ± 1437 c | 23489 ± 739 e |
T. lotocephalus | ||||||||||
O-Caffeoylquinic acid | <LOQ | 64 ± 5 | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | n.d. | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ |
Caffeic acid hexoside isomer I | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | 77 ± 3 |
Caffeic acid hexoside isomer II | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | <LOQ | 74.2 ± 0.5 |
Caffeic acid | <LOQ | <LOD | 91 ± 6 b | <LOD | <LOQ | <LOQ | 110 ± 9 b | 113 ± 3 b | <LOQ | 149 ± 3 a |
Rosmarinic acid | 30326 ± 1453 e | 10413 ± 512 f | 31285 ± 3028 d,e | 15743 ± 1239 f | 31395 ± 697 d,e | 40635 ± 331 c,d | 64658 ± 6034 a | 55268 ± 5250 b | 46136 ± 851 b,c | 65998 ± 2478 a |
Salvianolic acid A isomer I | 225 ± 5 e | 217 ± 8 e | 1387 ± 200 a | 755 ± 96 b,c | 203 ± 12 e | 207 ± 6 e | 234 ± 22 e | 561 ± 51 c,d | 434 ± 5 d,e | 891.2 ± 0.72 b |
Salvianolic acid A isomer II | 57 ± 8 f,g | 55 ± 7 f,g | 303 ± 6 a | 158 ± 2 b | 56 ± 2 f,g | 50 ± 1 g | 70 ± 4 e,f | 96 ± 4 d | 75 ± 3 e | 123 ± 8 c |
Salvianolic acid I | 116 ± 6 d | 113 ± 4 d | 666 ± 91 a | 339 ± 45 b | 129 ± 7 c,d | 119 ± 2 d | 182 ± 17 c,d | 238 ± 24 b,c | 178 ± 2 c,d | 294.6 ± 0.4 b |
Salvianolic acid B | 53 ± 4 e | 45 ± 1 e | 240 ± 33 a | 146 ± 16 b,c | 52 ± 2 e | 77 ± 2 d,e | 69 ± 7 e | 132 ± 13 c | 111.7 ± 0.3 c,d | 184 ± 3 b |
Salvianolic acid A isomer III | 78 ± 4 e,f | 45 ± 3 f | 156 ± 22 a,b | 75 ± 10 e,f | 91 ± 4 d,e | 120 ± 2 c,d | 182 ± 14 a | 170 ± 11 a,b | 77 ± 1 e,f | 144 ± 5 b,c |
Total phenolic acids | 30855 ± 1481 e | 10952 ± 540 f | 34128 ± 3375 d,e | 17216 ± 1408 f | 31927 ± 719 d,e | 41208 ± 344 c,d | 65506 ± 6090 a,b | 56578 ± 5355 b | 47013 ± 839 c | 67936 ± 2461 a |
Luteolin-7-O-glucuronide | 133 ± 2 d | 81 ± 4 e | 215 ± 21 b | 83 ± 8 e | 134 ± 6 d | 167 ± 6 c,d | 209 ± 23 b | 301 ± 20 a | 193.3 ± 0.6 b,c | 315 ± 3 a |
Herniarin | 76 ± 6 e | <LOQ | 120 ± 16 c | 49 ± 4 f | 88 ± 2 d,e | 107 ± 3 c,d | 174 ± 3 b | 163 ± 9 b | 157 ± 3 b | 204 ± 12 a |
Total phenolic compounds | 31064 ± 1488 e | 11033 ± 544 f | 34463 ± 3412 d,e | 17348 ± 1421 f | 32149 ± 724 d,e | 41483 ± 352 c,d | 65889 ± 6070 a,b | 57042 ± 5366 b | 47363 ± 842 c | 68456 ± 2469 a |
Notes: n.d.—not detected; LOD—limit of detection; LOQ—limit of quantification. The results were analysed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Duncan’s New Multiple Range Test. Different letters (a to g) in each row and for each phenolic compound mean significant differences (p < 0.05) among treatments.