Skip to main content
. 2021 Oct 28;13(10):e19102. doi: 10.7759/cureus.19102

Table 3. Summary of Reported Infection/Reinfection Incidences (per person, person-years).

1 Lumley et al. included 1- and 2-dose vaccination groups. For this analysis, only the 2-dose vaccination group was counted. 2 Satwik et al. data was not entirely provided in the publication. Data obtained via personal communication. 3 Gazit et al. described three models of study, with a matching comparison. For this analysis, Model 2 was used for NPI/V,    and PI/UV analysis and Model 3 was used for the PI/V group. An NPI/UV group was not reported in this study and therefore omitted from the analysis. 4 Risk ratios and differences calculated from Events/Person-Year figures 5 Pooled RR and risk differences adjusted and determined by M-H methods. 6 Time-at-risk not published in Shrestha et. al. manuscript. Estimated by taking a number of people in the group, multiplied by the length of    study (in years)  7 Noted that there is no difference in incidence between NPI/UV and NPI/V groups. The authors of this study were contacted, and relayed at vaccine efficacy of 28%, after adjustment by a Cox proportion regression. Additionally, the author notes the implementation of vaccination during the peak phase of Delta and the shorter follow-up in the vaccinated cohort.

Study NPI/UV     NPI/V PI/UV PI/V NPI/V vs. PI/UV PI/UV vs PI/V
  Cases (N) Cases (N) Cases (N) Cases (N) RR [95% CI]4 RR [95% CI]4
  % % % % AR [95%CI]4 AR [95%CI]4
  Person-Years Person-Years Person-Years Person-Years    
  Events/P-Y Events/P-Y Events/P-Y Events/P-Y    
Pfizer [17] 164 (17,720) 8 (17,637) 1 (567) 1 (526) 0.21 [0.03-1.69] 0.93 [0.06-14.57]
  0.93% 0.05% 0.18% 0.19% -0.013 [-0.046-0.019] -0.001 [-0.049-0.046]
  2,242 2,237 60 56    
  0.073 0.004 0.017 0.018    
Moderna [18] 90 (14,730) 6 (14,312) 1 (334) 0 (341) 0.15 [0.02-1.21] 3.05 [0.13-73.39]
  0.63% 0.04% 0.30% 0.0% -0.014 [-0.47-0.019] 0.017 [-0.029-0.063]
  2,787 2,387 59 60    
  0.032 0.002 0.017 0.0    
J&J  [19] 509 (19,544) 173 (19,514) 4 (2030) 3(2122) 4.46 [1.67-11.93] 1.40 [0.31-6.19]
  2.60% 0.89% 0.20% 0.14% 0.043 [0.029-0.058] 0.004 [-0.012-0.019]
  3,089 3,114 321 336    
  0.164 0.056 0.012 0.009    
RCT Pooled 763 (51,634) 187 (52463) 6 (2931) 4 (2989) 0.59 [0.04-8.28]5 1.45 [0.43-4.85]  
  1.48% 0.36% 0.20% 0.13% 0.007 [-0.037--.051]5 0.004 [-0.010-0.019]
  8,118 7,738 439 453    
  0.094 0.024 0.014 0.009    
Shrestha et.al  [21] 2139 (15,317) 15  (28,836) 0 (1265) 0 (1265) 1.36 [0.08-22.71] Not estimable
  14.0% 0.05% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0026 [-0.003-0.0081] 0.000 [-0.008-0.008]
  3,5116 5,8466 2566 2476    
  0.609 0.002 0.0 0.0    
Lumley et al. [22]1 635 (10,513) 2 (940) 12 (1273) 1 (974 0.85 [0.19-3.73] 2.03 [0.27-15.42]
  6.0% 0.21% 0.94% 0.10% -0.003 [-0.032-0.025] 0.011 [-0.013-0.036]
  6,231 107 543 92    
  0.102 0.019 0.022 0.011    
Satwik et. al. [24]2 128  (790) 323 (2120) 5  (147) 4 (596) 5.01 [2.21-11.32] 4.48 [1.27-15.82]
  16.2% 15.2% 3.4% 0.67% 0.55 [0.4354-0.6775] 0.108 [-0.0090-0.225]
  182 430 36 129    
  0.6857 0.6967 0.138 0.031    
Gazit et. al. [25]3 - 640 (46,035) 108 (46,035) 20 (14,029) 5.93 [4.84-7.25] 1.65 [1.02-2.65]
    1.39% 0.23% 0.14% 0.056 [0.051-0.062] 0.005 [0.001-0.008]
    9,459 9,459 2,882    
    0.068 0.011 0.007    
OBS Pooled 2902(26,620) 980(77,931) 125(48,720) 25 (16,819) 3.71 [1.75-7.86]5 1.94 [1.17-3.21]5
  10.9% 1.26% 0.26% 0.15% 0.092 [0.031-0.153]5 0.0038 [-0.0036-0.011]5
  9,925 15,842 10,296 3,352    
  0.292 0.062 0.012 0.007    
Total Pooled 3665(78,254) 1167 (129,394) 131(51,651) 29(19,808) 1.86 [0.77-4.51]5   1.82 [1.21-2.73]5  
  4.68% 0.90% 0.25% 0.15% 0.049 [0.0084-0.0893]5 0.0039 [0.001-0.007]5
  18,042 23,580 10,735 3,804