A spectrum of Thymic mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma and Thymic amyloidosis in the patient with Auto immune disease: a case series

Abstract

Background

The thymus is associated with an immunodeficient status, autoimmune disease (AD), and the common thymic tumor, thymoma. We encountered two rare thymic tumors, thymic mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) lymphoma and localized thymic amyloidosis, both in the presence of Sjögren’s syndrome (SjS). This suggests a possible link between rare thymic tumors and SjS. Therefore, we reviewed cases of thymic tumors to examine the spectrum of these tumors in patients with AD.

Methods

The clinical information of thymic amyloidosis and MALT lymphoma surgically treated at Kanagawa Cardiovascular and Respiratory Center, and Yokohama City University Hospital from January 2010 to December 2019 were reviewed. The correlation between resected thymic tumors at same period and ADs were also investigated.

Results

There were 5 cases of thymic amyloidosis and MALT lymphoma. ALL cases had coexistent ADs (4 SjS, 1 SSc). The median age was 66 (38–76) year-old, and 4 of the patients were female. Three cases had already diagnosed as ADs before detection of tumors. Only SSc case was received preceding steroid medication. Two cases diagnosed as SjS at the same time of the operation. The median maximum tumor diameter was 70 mm. On chest computed tomography (CT), tumors contained solid part and some cystic part at various rated. Calcification was recognized with appearance of amyloid deposition. All patients were surgically treated with total thymectomy and they are alive without recurrence. At the same period, there were 163 resected thymic tumors, including amyloidosis, MALT lymphoma, thymoma, thymic cancer, neuroendocrine tumor and so on. Among them, nine patients (5.5%) had ADs. There was a correlation between ADs and thymic MALT lymphoma/amyloidosis (P<0.001).

Conclusions

We propose a process for tumorigenesis of thymic MALT lymphoma and amyloidosis. Underlying AD causes persistent and chronic inflammatory reactions. In this theory, ADs, especially SjS, might be important underlying conditions in formation of rare tumors. When the clinician encounters a patient with AD, routine chest CT is recommended and may provide thymic tumors. Conversely, in case of mediastinum tumor, screening test for AD is also recommended.

Introduction

The thymus is an important organ for maintenance of systemic cellular immunity and prevention of autoimmune diseases (ADs) by production of mature T lymphocytes. It has a unique characteristic of spontaneous degeneration with age and displacement with fat tissue. The thymus has also been linked to disorders such as immunodeficiency; hematologic, endocrinologic, collagen, and neuromuscular defects; and AD, but the detailed mechanisms are unclear (1).

It is uncommon for tumors to originate from thymic tissue. The most common type is thymoma, with a 47% incidence of all mediastinum tumors in the anterior compartment in adults (1). In Japan, 2,365 cases of thymic tumors (thymoma, thymic cancer, thymic carcinoid and thymolipoma) were surgically treated in 2017, and 1,939 were cases of thymoma (82.0%) (2). Generally, thymic tumors are divided into four basic categories; epithelial cell, neuroendocrine cell, adipose tissue and miscellaneous tumors (1). On the other hand, several minor thymic tumors are also known, and in recent years we have surgically treated cases of thymic mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) lymphomas (3) and localized thymic amyloidosis. All patients in these cases also had Sjögren’s syndrome (SjS), which suggests a possible link between these rare thymic tumors and SjS. Therefore, we reviewed cases with resected thymic tumors at our institute and affiliated hospital to examine the spectrum of these tumors in patients with ADs.

We present the following article in accordance with the AME Case Series Checklist (available at http://dx.doi.org/10.21037/med-20-68).

Methods

The clinical information of thymic amyloidosis and MALT lymphoma cases surgically treated at Kanagawa Cardiovascular and Respiratory Center, and Yokohama City University Hospital from January 2010 to December 2019 were reviewed. The correlation between resected thymic tumors at same period and coexistent ADs were also reviewed. The tumors were divided into four categories according to pathological findings: thymic epithelial tumors, lymphoproliferative lesions, mesenchymal tumors and non-neoplastic lesions. Non-neoplastic lesions (thymic hyperplasia, lymphoid hyperplasia and thymic cyst) that were suspected to be thymic tumors preoperatively were also defined as a thymic tumor. The clinical information and the follow-up were obtained on medical records and an outpatients’ clinic or phone call basis respectively. The inclusion criteria were all thymic tumors including non-neoplastic lesions diagnosed pathologically after surgery.

The correlation between each type of thymic tumor and AD was analyzed by Pearson χ² test. Data are shown as a median and range. A P-value of <0.05 was considered to be significant. All analyses were performed using SPSS for Windows ver. 11.0 J (SPSS, Chicago, IL, USA).

This study is a retrospective and consecutive case series analysis of thymic tumor in multi center and was conducted in accordance with the Helsinki Declaration (as revised in 2013). This study was approved by the Kanagawa Cardiovascular and Respiratory Center Institutional Review Board for Clinical Research (approval number KCRC-20-0017). The informed consent requirement was waived because of the retrospective study design.

Results

There were 5 cases of thymic amyloidosis and MALT lymphoma. The characteristics of the patients are shown in Table 1. The median age was 66 (range, 38–76) year-old, and 4 of the patients were female. Three cases (case 1, 3 and 5) had already diagnosed as ADs before detection of thymic tumors. Only SSc case was received preceding steroid medication. Two cases (case 2 and 4) diagnosed as SjS at the same time of the operation. Tumors were detected by medical checkup or by screening for cough and elevated serum soluble interleukin-2 receptor antibody.

Table 1. Characteristics of thymic MALT lymphoma and amyloidosis.

Thymic tumor	Case No.	Age	Gender	Coexistent AD	Age at diagnosis of AD	Treatment of AD	Tumor detection	Tumor size (mm)	CT findings of tumor		SUVmax	Amyloid protein	Treatment	Follow up period (days)	Prognosis
									calcification	cystic lesion
Amyloidosis	1	71	F	SjS	50	None	Medical checkup	100	(+)	(+)	5.9	AL	Total thymectomy	449	Alive with no recurrence
MALT lymphoma with amyloid deposition	2	49	F	SjS	49	None	Medical checkup	120	(+)	(+)	NE	AL	Total thymectomy	1,918	Alive with no recurrence
	3	76	M	SSc	62	Steroid	Medical checkup	28	(+)	(+)	3.6	AL	Total thymectomy	424	Alive with no recurrence
MALT lymphoma	4	66	F	SjS	66	None	Screening for cough	20	(–)	(–)	NE	NE	Total thymectomy	1,957	Alive with no recurrence
	5	38	F	SjS	36	None	sIL-2R antibody	70	(–)	(–)	5.8	NE	Total thymectomy	1,747	Alive with no recurrence

MALT, mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue; AD, autoimmune disease; SjS, Sjögren’ syndrome; SSc, Systemic sclerosis; sIL-2R, serum soluble interleukin-2 receptor; SUVmax, maximum standard uptake value; AL, amyloidogenic light chain; NE, Not examined; AIS, adenocarcinoma in situ.

The median maximum tumor diameter was 70 (range, 20–120) mm. Tumors which had contrasted effect contained solid part and some cystic parts at various rated on chest computed tomography (CT). Calcification was recognized with appearance of amyloid deposition. In (¹⁸F)-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) performed in 3 cases (cases 1, 3 and 5), the median maximum standard uptake value (SUV_max) was 5.8 (3.6–5.9). Four cases had hyperglobulinemia (cases 1, 2, 4 and 5) (data not shown). The amyloid protein was all AL type (cases 1, 2 and 3), which was compatible with localized amyloidosis (4,5). Two cases (cases 1 and 3) showed κ light chain dominant monoclonal overproduction of immunoglobulins (data not shown). In SjS cases, 3 of 4 had multiple lung cysts (cases 1, 2 and 4) on chest CT (data not shown).

In case 1, chest CT showed a solid, large, soft tissue density mass with calcification located in the anterior mediastinum (Figure 1A), and a grand glass opacity (GGO) lesion in the right upper lobe and multiple lung cysts in bilateral lung fields. FDG-PET showed increased uptake of FDG in the mediastinum tumor (SUV_max 5.9). Based on the radiological diagnosis of suspected thymoma and primary lung cancer, both of which were judged to be resectable, surgery via a median sternotomy was performed. The anterior mediastinum tumor was found to originate from the thymus gland and to be adhered to the pericardium firmly, but could be peeled off manually (Figure 1B). A GGO lesion in segment 3 of the right upper lobe was resected using staplers. An intraoperative histological examination of the thymic tumor revealed deposits of amorphous, eosinophilic materials, and no malignant cells. Finally, tumorectomy with thymectomy and right lung wedge resection were completed.

Figure 1.

Thymic amyloidosis (Case 1). (A) Chest CT showed a solid, large mass with calcification located in the anterior mediastinum in the mediastinal window. (B) A hard tumor with a smooth surface originated from the thymus gland and firmly adhered to the pericardium alone (arrowheads). The left innominate vein was encircled using vessel tape. (C) The resected tumor measured 100 mm in maximum diameter, had a smooth appearance, and was extremely firm. The cut surface was light yellow with cystic lesions. (D) The tumor included diffuse deposits of amorphous and eosinophilic material, calcification, lymphocytes and plasma cells, but no neoplastic cells (hematoxylin and eosin stain). (E) Amorphous materials were positive in direct fast scarlet 4BS staining and showed an “apple-green” birefringence under polarized light (arrows). (F) Immunohistochemical staining was positive for κ light chain.

The resected thymic tumor measured 100 mm in maximum diameter, and had a smooth appearance and was firm. The cut surface was light-yellow with cystic lesions (Figure 1C). Histologically, small calcification foci and a small number of lymphocytes and plasma cells were observed in diffuse deposits of amorphous and eosinophilic material (Figure 1D). Hassall bodies were also seen, suggesting that the tumor developed in the thymus. The amorphous materials were positive in direct fast scarlet (DFS) 4BS staining and showed an “apple-green” birefringence under polarized light. These findings were compatible with amyloidosis (Figure 1E). Subsequent immunohistochemical staining showed that the amyloid material was positive for κ light chain (Figure 1F), slightly positive for transthyretin (TTR), and negative for λ light chain, amyloid A protein. Mass spectrography of amyloid material collected by laser microdissection confirmed that the amyloid consisted of immunoglobulin κ light chain (data not shown). In postoperative screening for systemic amyloidosis, an echocardiogram and examinations of gastric and colon fibers showed no abnormal findings. In urinalysis, Bence-Jones protein was not observed. Thus, diagnosis of localized amyloidosis arising from the thymus was confirmed. The GGO lesion was diagnosed as adenocarcinoma in situ.

Cases 2 and 4 with thymic MALT lymphoma and SjS have been previously reported (3). In case 2, chest CT showed a large mass with a cystic lesion located on the right side of the heart toward the anterior mediastinum (Figure 2A) and multiple cysts in both lungs. In the operation, the tumor was found not to have invaded the surrounding structures and was easily removed (Figure 2B). Right lung wedge resection for sampling of the lung cystic lesions was also performed. The maximum diameter of the tumor was 120 mm, and it had a smooth surface. On sectioning, the tumor was solid yellowish, and was circumscribed by a thin fibrous capsule with small cysts containing clear yellowish fluid (Figure 2C). Histologically, the tumor consisted of diffuse monotonous proliferation of mononuclear cells and scattered atrophic lymphoid follicles. The mononuclear cells occasionally infiltrated into Hassall bodies to form lymphoepithelial lesions (LELs) (Figure 2D,E). Focal deposits of amorphous and eosinophilic materials were also scattered in the tumor. The deposits were positive on DFS 4BS staining and showed an “apple-green” birefringence under polarized light, suggesting amyloidosis (Figure 2F). These findings led to diagnosis of thymic MALT lymphoma with amyloid deposition. Lung cysts were bullae with amyloid deposits, consistent with lung manifestation of SjS (6,7).

Figure 2.

Thymic MALT lymphoma with amyloid deposition (Case 2). (A) A large mass consisting of a cystic lesion and a solid portion was located on the right side of the heart toward the anterior mediastinum in the mediastinal window on chest CT. Small calcification was also recognized. (B) Intraoperative findings. The tumor was well capsulated. Adhesion to and invasion of surrounding organs were not seen. (C) The maximum diameter was 120 mm and the tumor had a smooth surface appearance. On sectioning, the tumor appeared to be solid yellowish, and was circumscribed by a thin fibrous capsule with occasional small cysts containing clear yellowish fluid. (D) The tumor consisted of diffuse monotonous proliferation of mononuclear cells, which occasionally infiltrated into Hassall bodies forming a LEL (hematoxylin and eosin stain). (E) An immunohistochemical examination for cytokeratin AE1/AE3 outlined Hassall bodies and confirmed formation of a LEL. (F) Focal deposits of amorphous and eosinophilic materials were scattered, and were positive in DFS 4BS staining and gave an “apple-green” birefringence under polarized light. LEL, lymphoepithelial lesion.

Case 3 was the only male patient with MALT lymphoma and SSc. This case also had amyloid deposition. Coexistence of SSc and MALT lymphoma is extremely rare, with only 8 cases of SSc with MALT lymphoma at another site reported in the English-language literature (8). Cases 4 (3) and 5 had thymic MALT lymphoma with no amyloid deposition.

All patients were surgically treated with total thymectomy. The median postoperative follow-up period was 1,747 (range, 424–1,957) days and they are alive without recurrence, indicating a good prognosis.

At the same period, there were 163 resected thymic tumor cases consisting of 94 thymomas (57.7%), 13 thymic cancers (8.0%), 1 neuroendocrine tumor (0.6%), 4 thymic MALT lymphomas (2.5%), 1 diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (0.6%), 3 lymphoid hyperplasias (1.8%), 2 lipomas (1.2%), 39 thymic cysts (23.9%), 5 thymic hyperplasias (3.1%) and 1 case of localized thymic amyloidosis (0.6%). In this series, 9 patients (5.5%) had ADs: 2 with thymoma (SjS), 1 with thymic cancer (SjS), 4 with thymic MALT lymphomas (3 SjS and 1 systemic sclerosis (SSc)), 1 with thymic hyperplasia (rheumatoid arthritis) and 1 with thymic amyloidosis (SjS) in our institute and the affiliated hospital at the same period. All 5 patients (3.1%) with thymic MALT lymphoma/amyloidosis had ADs (4 SjS and 1 SSc), and consequently there was a relation between ADs and thymic MALT lymphoma/amyloidosis (P<0.001) (Table 2).

Table 2. Coexistence of autoimmune disease and thymic tumors.

Thymic tumors		n	%	Autoimmune disease		P
				(+)	(–)
Thymic epithelial tumor	Thymoma	94	57.7	2	92	<0.001
	Thymic cancer	13	8.0	1	12
	Neuroendocrine tumor (carcinoid)	1	0.6	0	1
Lymphoproliferative lesion	Thymic MALT lymphoma	4	2.5	4	0
	DLBCL	1	0.6	0	1
	Lymphoid hyperplasia	3	1.8	0	3
Mesenchymal tumor	Lipoma	2	1.2	0	2
Non-neoplastic lesion	Thymic cyst	39	23.9	0	39
	Thymic hyperplasia	5	3.1	1	4
	Thymic amyloidosis	1	0.6	1	0
Total		163		9	154

MALT, mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue; DLBCL, Diffuse large B-cell lymphoma.

Discussion

Thymic amyloidosis defined as “primary localized amyloidosis arising from the thymus, not a part of manifestation of systemic amyloidosis” is extremely rare (1), with only six cases reported in the English-language literature (9-14): a case of sclerosing thymoma-like amyloidoma (9), two cases combined with myasthenia gravis (10,11), and a case of thymic amyloidosis with diplopia that resolved immediately after thymectomy (12). These cases included 3 AL (amyloidgenic light chain) types, 1 AA (amyloidogenic A protein) type with rheumatoid arthritis, and 2 cases that were negative for AL and AA amyloidosis. Chest CT showed a soft tissue density mass with calcification in all 6 previous cases, and in our case (case 1). Complete resection is thought to be the best treatment for a localized lesion, with five of the previous cases of thymic amyloidosis undergoing thymectomy. The surgical procedure was not indicated in the case of sclerosing thymoma-like thymic amyloidoma (9) due to advanced thymoma (Masaoka stage IVa pericardial dissemination) and the patient was treated with steroid therapy only. Although “calcification in 20% to 50% of lung nodular amyloidosis” (15) and “increased uptake of FDG in 70% of other-site AL amyloidosis with a median SUV_max of 6.5 and no uptake in patients with cardiac amyloidosis and pulmonary amyloidosis” (16) were previously reported, the detailed etiology and clinical manifestations of thymic amyloidosis are still unknown.

Thymic MALT lymphoma is a type of extranodal marginal zone B cell lymphoma (MZBL) defined by Isaacson in 1990 (17). Unlike at other sites, thymic MALT lymphoma has unique characteristics, including geographic and gender concentration in Asian women, an association with ADs (>60% of cases, especially SjS), and monoclonal gammopathy of IgA (3,18-20). Radiologically, the tumor appears as a solid mass with cystic changes in the anterior mediastinum on chest CT and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (18). Previous studies have reported a median SUV_max of 6.0 (range, 0.7–28.0) for MALT lymphoma, but with PET activity depending on the organ site (i.e., thyroid lesions, high; skin lesions, low) (21); however, no data for thymic MALT lymphoma are available.

Pathologically, extensive infiltration of lymphocytes with a small fraction of centrocyte-like (CCL) cells to Hassall bodies (i.e., LELs) are a distinctive finding. The reasons for the clinical bias and etiology are unknown, but several theories for the etiology have been proposed. For example, an AD, such as SjS, promotes continuous replication of B lymphocytes that can lead to development of nodular lymphoid hyperplasia and subsequent neoplastic transformation in the thymic gland (8,18,20). Ströbel et al. (22) also speculated that abnormal production of chemoattractants by the thymic epithelia might contribute to MALT lymphoma development. Thymic MALT lymphoma has as excellent prognosis with a 5-year survival rate of 83%, indicating that surgical resection and/or chemotherapy is effective (1,19,20). Furthermore spontaneous regression may occur based on a watch and wait follow-up study, although we note that this was for a case of lung MALT lymphoma (23).

Although the causal relationship has not been determined, several studies have shown an association of AD with pulmonary MALT lymphoma and pulmonary amyloidosis (22,24-26). To our knowledge, no study has associated with the relationship of these rare thymic tumors with AD. In our investigation, there was a relation between ADs and thymic MALT lymphoma/amyloidosis (P<0.001). Based on our experience, we propose a process of tumorigenesis from thymic MALT lymphoma to amyloidosis (Figure 3). Underlying AD causes a persistent or chronic inflammatory reaction, and lymphoid hyperplasia may then develop in the thymus. Some cases develop MALT lymphoma (cases 4, 5) and this causes overproduction of immunoglobulins in the form of κ or λ light chains that are misfolded and deposited in thymic tissue. In this phase, a pathological examination shows both MALT lymphoma and amyloid deposition (cases 2, 3). MALT lymphoma can show spontaneous regression (23) and may disappear in some cases, leaving only amyloid tissue to be seen pathologically in this phase (case 1). Calcification was seen dominantly in amyloid deposition cases on CT. It is possible that Calcium deposition might be caused by MALT lymphoma degeneration. All MALT lymphomas were easily removed whereas amyloidosis was fixed firmly to the pericardium. This intraoperative findings suggested that MALT lymphoma regression might case fibrosis leading to adhesion to the surrounding structures in the sequential phase. In some thymic amyloidosis cases, combined resection with surrounding organs (i.e., lungs, vessels and pericardium) might be necessary.

Figure 3.

Proposed pathway of tumorigenesis from thymic MALT lymphoma to thymic amyloidosis in patients with autoimmune disease. MALT, mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue.

Conclusions

When the clinician encounters a patient with AD, especially SjS including subclinical case, routine chest CT is recommended and may provide thymic tumors. Conversely, in case of mediastinum tumor, screening test for AD is also recommended. In conclusion, our study shows a possible spectrum of thymic MALT lymphoma and thymic amyloidosis, in which ADs, especially SjS, might be important underlying conditions in tumorigenesis of these rare tumors. A further study is warranted to examine this hypothesis.

Limitation

The major limitation of this study is the small series.

Ethical Statement: The authors are accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved. This study is a retrospective and consecutive case series analysis of thymic tumor in multi center and was conducted in accordance with the Helsinki Declaration (as revised in 2013). This study was approved by the Kanagawa Cardiovascular and Respiratory Center Institutional Review Board for Clinical Research (approval number KCRC-20-0017). The informed consent requirement was waived because of the retrospective study design.