Skip to main content
. 2021 Dec 23;10:e73080. doi: 10.7554/eLife.73080

Appendix 5—table 1. Association between gSG6 IgG seropositivity and log human biting rate (HBR), moderated by dominant vector species.

Variable log odds ratio (SE) 95% CI p-Value RE
Fixed part
log HBR 0.46 (0.11) 0.25–0.66 <0.001
DVS <0.001**
An. gambiae s.l. only Ref.
An. gambiae s.l. and other DVS 1.00 (0.18) 0.65–1.25 <0.001
 Non-An. gambiae s.l. 1.09 (0.68) –0.24 to 2.42 0.109
log HBR by DVS <0.001**
An. gambiae s.l. only Ref.
An. gambiae s.l. and other DVS –0.26 (0.08) −0.41 to –0.11 0.001
 Non-An. gambiae s.l. –0.38 (0.11) −0.59 to –0.17 <0.001
Random part
ψ1 0.96
ψ2 2.32
ψ3 0.08
ρ1 § 0.14
ρ2 0.51
–1488.8
Model fit indices
Akaike’s information criterion 2995.5
Bayesian information criterion 3021.5

HBR × dominant vector species (DVS) association: log odds ratio and standard error (SE), 95% confidence interval (95% CI), p-value, random-effect components (RE): variances (ψ), conditional intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) (ρ),* and model log likelihood () from generalised linear multilevel modelling (mixed effects, logistic). This analysis is based upon n = 132 study-specific observations from 12 studies. Of note, five studies that measured HBR and IgG antibodies to gSG6 were excluded from this analysis as they only reported gSG6 IgG levels.

* ρ = ψk+...+ψnkψk+...+ψnk+π2/3 , where ψk through ψnk are random-effect variance estimates pertaining to each of the respective variance components (see table notes ‡–¶) from the generalised linear multilevel modelling (mixed effects, logistic) for a specific ICC estimate.

Generalised linear multilevel modelling (mixed effects, logistic) estimating the association between log transformed HBR and anti-gSG6 IgG seropositivity including an interaction term between DVS and log HBR with random effects for country-specific and study-specific heterogeneity in gSG6 IgG seroprevalence and study-specific heterogeneity in effect of HBR.

ψ1 , ψ2, and ψ3 represent variances of the random effects for country, study, and effect of HBR, respectively.

§ ρ1 represents the conditional ICC for salivary antibody observations from the same country but different study.

ρ2 represents the conditional ICC for salivary antibody observations from the same country and study with the median HBR.

**indicates p-value from joint Wald test for polytomous variables.