New possibilities for neuroprotection in neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy

Abstract

Around 0.75 million babies worldwide suffer from moderate or severe hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) each year resulting in around 400,000 babies with neurodevelopmental impairment. In 2010, neonatal HIE was associated with 2.4% of the total Global Burden of Disease. Therapeutic hypothermia (TH), a treatment that is now standard of care in high-income countries, provides proof of concept that strategies that aim to improve neurodevelopment are not only possible but can also be implemented to clinical practice. While TH is beneficial, neonates with moderate or severe HIE treated with TH still experience devastating complications: 48% (range: 44–53) combined death or moderate/severe disability. There is a concern that TH may not be effective in low- and middle-income countries. Therapies that further improve outcomes are desperately needed, and in high-income countries, they must be tested in conjunction with TH. We have in this review focussed on pharmacological treatment options (e.g. erythropoietin, allopurinol, melatonin, cannabidiol, exendin-4/exenatide). Erythropoietin and allopurinol show promise and are progressing towards the clinic with ongoing definitive phase 3 randomised placebo-controlled trials. However, there remain global challenges for the next decade. 

Conclusion: There is a need for more optimal animal models, greater industry support/sponsorship, increased use of juvenile toxicology, dose-ranging studies with pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modelling, and well-designed clinical trials to avoid exposure to harmful medications or abandoning putative treatments.

What is Known: • Therapeutic hypothermia is beneficial in neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy. • Neonates with moderate or severe hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy treated with therapeutic hypothermia still experience severe sequelae.

What is New: • Erythropoietin, allopurinol, melatonin, cannabidiol, and exendin-4/exenatide show promise in conjunction with therapeutic hypothermia. • There is a need for more optimal animal models, greater industry support/sponsorship, increased use of juvenile toxicology, dose-ranging studies with pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modelling, and well-designed clinical trials.

Introduction

Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) is the neurological syndrome that occurs in the newborn infant subject to different degrees of a hypoxic-ischemia event. It is associated with loss of consciousness; decrease of spontaneous movements, tone, and reflexes; and appearance of convulsions in the more severe cases. HIE is a global problem with an estimated incidence of 1.5–2.0 per 1000 live births [1, 2]. Around 0.75 million babies worldwide suffer from moderate or severe HIE each year resulting in around 400,000 babies with neurodevelopmental impairment. HIE was associated with 2.4% of the total Global Burden of Disease (2010) [3]

Therapeutic hypothermia (TH), a treatment strategy that is now standard of care in high-income countries, provides proof of concept that treatment strategies that aim to improve neurodevelopment are not only possible but can be implemented to clinical practice [4]. In a meta-analysis of 7 trials, representing 1214 newborn infants, TH reduced the risk of the composite outcome of death or major neurodevelopmental disability at age 18 months (risk ratio (RR), 0.76; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.69–0.84; and numbers needed to treat (NNT), 7; 95% CI, 5–10) [5]. While TH is beneficial, neonates with moderate or severe HIE treated with TH still experience devastating complications: mortality 28% (24–38); cognitive impairment 24% (21–25); cerebral palsy 22% (13–28); epilepsy 19% (15–24); cortical visual impairment 6% (1–10), with combined death or moderate/severe disability 48% (44–53) [5]. Adjunctive therapies to further improve outcomes are desperately needed. In high-income countries, experimental therapies must be tested in conjunction with the standard of care: TH.

TH requires a high level of intensive care support, and this cannot always be provided in low- and middle-income countries. Furthermore, TH has been shown to be ineffective and possibly even harmful in the presence of infection/inflammation [6, 7].

There remains a need to develop newer neuroprotective treatment strategies. This review will compare emerging treatments in terms of efficacy in preclinical experiments, safety profile in humans, and toxicology experiments and anticipated effect size.

Erythropoietin

Erythropoietin is a cytokine with multiple roles in addition to haemopoietic growth factor. Erythropoietin receptors are in neurons, glia, and endothelial cells [8, 9]; they participate in proliferation and differentiation of these cells both during normal brain development and following hypoxia [10–14]. Hypoxia and pro-inflammatory cytokines activate hypoxia-inducible factor to induce expression of erythropoietin and receptors [15]. Erythropoietin provides neuroprotection by promoting anti-apoptotic, anti-oxidative, and anti-inflammatory responses [16, 17]. Additionally, erythropoietin increases neuronal and glial migration around the injured area via the secretion of matrix metalloproteinases [18].

Preclinical evidence

Much of the evidence supporting the use of erythropoietin as a neuroprotective agent in neonatal HIE was determined in rodent models with no added hypothermia [12, 17, 19–23]. In a nonhuman primate model of HIE (15–18-min occlusion of umbilical artery in Macaca nemestrina), intravenous erythropoietin (3500 U/kg × 1 dose followed by 3 doses of 2500 U/kg, or 1000 U/kg/day × 4 doses) was administered on days 1, 2, 3, and 7 and combined with 72 h hypothermia [24]. Erythropoietin improved motor and cognitive responses, cerebellar growth, and diffusion imaging measures and produced a death/disability (cerebral palsy at 9 months of age) relative risk reduction of 0.911 (95% CI − 0.429 to 0.994), an absolute risk reduction of 0.395 (95% CI 0.072–0.635), and a NNT of 2 (95% CI 2–14) when compared with no treatment [24]. Neuropathology was significantly decreased at 9 months of age [25].

In a piglet model of HIE (bilateral carotid artery ligation with exposure to 8–10% oxygen), erythropoietin (3000 U/kg) was administered as an intravenous bolus at 1 h, 24 h, and 48 h in conjunction with 12 h hypothermia [26]. The area under curve (AUC) target therapeutic concentrations of 117,677–140,331 U * h/L was achieved. Erythropoietin and hypothermia double therapy had no effect on brain lactate/N-acetyl aspartate (Lac/NAA) ratio on Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) or Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labelling-positive (TUNEL-positive) cells (a measure of apoptosis), but there was more rapid amplitude-integrated electroencephalography (aEEG) recovery from 25 to 30 h and increased oligodendrocyte survival [26].

Pharmaceutics and licenced preparation (Table 1)

Table 1.

Pharmaceutics and licenced dose*

Nonproprietary name	Trade name and maximum dose	Generic/biosimilar version approved	Licenced indication in children	Excipients of significance	Common side effects of active ingredient	Known side effects of excipient
Recombinant erythropoietin (Epoetin Alfa)	Epogen® (Amgen®, USA) 150 units/kg intravenous thrice weekly in children < 10 kg	Yes	Symptomatic anaemia in chronic renal failure	Benzyl alcohol	Arthralgia; embolism and thrombosis; headache; hypertension (dose-dependent); influenza-like illness; skin reactions; stroke	Benzyl alcohol administered intravenously in the range of 100 to 200 mg/kg/day has been linked to the “gasping syndrome” [116]
Melatonin	Slenyto® (Neurim Pharmaceuticals®, Israel) 10 mg/day oral in children > 2 years No intravenous preparation—poor water solubility	Not in UK and Europe Sold over the counter in the USA	Insomnia with autism spectrum disorder or Smith-Magenis syndrome	In animal experiments: ethanol (Sigma-Aldrich®, USA) and ethanol-free (Chiesi Farmaceutici®, Italy)	Arthralgia; abnormal behaviour; drowsiness; feeling abnormal; headaches; increased risk of infection; altered mood; pain; sleep disorders	Ethanol-free formulation required
Cannabidiol	Epidyolex® (GW Pharmaceuticals®, UK) 20 mg/kg/day oral in children > 2 years No intravenous preparation—poor water solubility	No	Seizures associated with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome or Dravet syndrome	In animal experiments: Ethanol (GW Research Ltd.)	Agitation; appetite abnormal; abnormal behaviour; cough; diarrhoea; drooling; drowsiness; fatigue; fever; increased risk of infection; insomnia; irritability; rash; tremor; vomiting; weight decreased	Ethanol-free formulation undergoing clinical trial
Exenatide/exendin-4	Byetta® (AstraZeneca®, UK) 10 μg twice daily subcutaneous in adults	Yes	Type 2 diabetes mellitus for glycaemic control	Metacresol	Appetite decreased; asthenia; constipation; diarrhoea; dizziness; gastrointestinal discomfort; gastrointestinal disorders; headache; nausea; skin reactions; vomiting	Metacresol at high doses may be cytotoxic and pro-inflammatory [117]  Metacresol-free formulation is required
Allopurinol sodium	Aloprim® (Mylan Institutional®, USA) 200 mg/m2/day intravenous. Lyophilised powder reconstituted in saline	Yes	Prophylaxis for hyperuricaemia induced by chemotherapy	Sodium hydroxide	Rash	Irritation to the skin, eyes, mucous membranes (high concentrations), toxic pneumonitis; dermatotoxin; and dysphagia

^*Source: US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and European Medicines Agency (EMA)

Recombinant human erythropoietin was used in most animal experiments and clinical trials [27].

Dosing and pharmacokinetics

In a dose-escalating, safety, and tolerance study, the AUC target therapeutic concentrations of 131,054 U * h/L were achieved using intravenous erythropoietin 1000 U/kg [28, 29]. The half-life at this dose was 15.7 h [29]. Clinical trials with dose < 1000 U/kg [30–33], single dosing [34], and repeat dosing with > 24-h intervals [30] may have not achieved maximum therapeutic benefit. Although efficacy has been demonstrated in animal models using subcutaneous dosing regimens, an intravenous dosing regimen where peak concentrations are rapidly achieved is more likely to achieve maximum therapeutic benefit [33–36]. In animal experiments, both immediate and delayed treatments are effective [27].

Safety and toxicology

Common side effects in adults and children are shown in Table 1. Sufficiently, high dose range has not been studied in toxicology experiments. Repeat dose toxicity (13 weeks) was noted at lower dose than anticipated neonatal dose (Table 2).

Table 2.

Toxicology*

Nonproprietary name	Neonatal HIE dose (based on animal studies with hypothermia)	Trade name under which toxicology performed	Toxicology: species, dose range, and route	Juvenile toxicology	Significant toxicology results
Recombinant erythropoietin/epoetin alfa	1000 U/kg intravenous on PNDs 1, 2, 3, and 7	Epogen® (Amgen®, USA)/Epoetin Hospira® (Hospira Inc.®, USA)	1500 U/kg (human equivalent dose of 833 U/kg) intravenous three times weekly for 13 weeks in dogs with recovery for 4 weeks. No single-dose toxicity studies reported	No studies	Hypoactivity, loss of limb function (1 male), discoloration of the faeces, reduced faecal output, dehydration, red gums and/or discoloration (yellow) of the teeth; 3 of 4 recovery remained thin throughout 4-week recovery period
Melatonin	10 mg/kg intravenous on PNDs 1 and 2	Circadin®(Neurim Pharmaceuticals®, Israel)/Slenyto®(Neurim Pharmaceuticals®, Israel)	Only single-dose toxicity studies using intravenous route reported. Dose range not reported	No studies	The intravenous lethal dose (LD50) is 180 to 472 mg/kg in mice and 356 mg/kg in rats (human equivalent dose: 15 to 58 mg/kg). The higher doses led to sedation, lethargy, impairment of righting, placing and flexor reflexes, marked reduction in body temperature, and respiratory distress preceding death
Cannabidiol	0.3 mg/kg intravenous on PND 1. Further dose-ranging studies are required	Epidyolex® (GW Pharmaceuticals®, UK)	See juvenile toxicology	Subcutaneous doses of 0 or 15 mg/kg on postnatal days 4–6 followed by oral administration of 0, 100, 150, or 250 mg/kg on PNDs 7–77 in rats	Increased body weight, delayed male sexual maturation, neurobehavioural effects, increased bone mineral density, and liver hepatocyte vacuolation. The lowest dose causing developmental toxicity was 15 mg/kg subcutaneous (human equivalent dose of 1 mg/kg) in juvenile rats
Exenatide/exendin-4	Dose-ranging studies are required Anticipated 90 μg/kg 12 hourly intravenous (equivalent)	Byetta® (AstraZeneca®, UK)	Subcutaneous doses of 100, 300, 1000, 3000, and 5000 μg/kg in monkeys	No studies	No mortality or signs of serious toxicity at any dose. Doses ≥ 5000 μg/kg (human equivalent dose of 1600 μg/kg) caused decreased food consumption
Allopurinol sodium	Dose-ranging studies are required	Aloprim® (Mylan Institutional®, USA)	No dose-ranging toxicology reported	No studies	In mice, the minimal lethal dose is 45 mg/kg intravenous (human equivalent dose of 3.65 mg/kg). Hypoactivity was observed with these doses. In rats, the minimum lethal dose is 100 mg/kg intravenous (human equivalent dose of 16 mg/kg)

^*Source: EMA and FDA; human equivalent dose was calculated according to FDA guidance [118] 

Clinical trials

Safety and tolerance was established in early phase clinical trials [37, 38]. In a phase 2 randomised placebo-controlled trial on 50 infants [39], intravenous erythropoietin (1000 U/kg) on postnatal days 1 (< 24 h after birth), 2, 3, and 5 showed a lower global brain injury score in erythropoietin-treated infants (median, 2 vs. 11, P = 0.01) on brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) done at mean 5.1 days (SD, 2.3). Moderate/severe brain injury (4% vs. 44%, P = 0.002), subcortical (30% vs. 68%, P = 0.02), and cerebellar injury (0% vs. 20%, P = 0.05) were less frequent in the erythropoietin group than in the placebo group.

Two ongoing phase 3 randomised placebo-controlled trials (NCT01732146; NCT02811263) aim to determine the effect of intravenous erythropoietin on death and disability at 24 months in infants with moderate or severe HIE [40]. The HEAL trial (NCT02811263; study completion September 2022) is evaluating the efficacy of intravenous erythropoietin (1000 U/kg) on postnatal days 1 (< 24 h after birth), 2, 3, 4, and 7 on 500 participants. The sample size is based on an anticipated 15–20% reduction in the combined outcome of death and disability [40]. The NUREPO trial (NCT01732146) is evaluating the efficacy of intravenous erythropoietin (1000–1500 U/kg) on postnatal days 1 (< 12 h after birth), 2, and 3 on 120 participants (completed 2017; not reported).

Melatonin

Melatonin (5-methoxy-N-acetyltryptamine) is produced by the pineal gland according to a circadian cycle [41]. It acts through three receptors (MT1, MT2, and MT3), highly expressed in the foetal brain and leptomeninges, where it plays a role in brain growth and development [42–44].

Melatonin acts as a direct and indirect antioxidant, being a potent scavenger of superoxide anion and stimulator of the synthesis of antioxidant enzymes [45]. Melatonin achieves neuroprotective effect via antioxidant, anti-apoptotic, and anti-inflammatory processes and by promoting neuronal and glial development [46, 47].

Preclinical evidence

The neuroprotective effect of intravenous melatonin (15–30 mg/kg) on postnatal days 1 (1–6 h after birth) and 2 has been assessed in a piglet model of HIE (bilateral carotid artery ligation with exposure to hypoxia) in conjunction with 12–24 h hypothermia [26, 48–50]. The target concentrations (maximum concentrations (C_max): 16.8 ± 8.3 mg/L and AUC: 555 ± 266 mg ∗ h/L) were achieved at 15-mg/kg dose. However, reduction in brain Lac/NAA ratios was achieved at 18-mg/kg and 30-mg/kg doses. Reduction in TUNEL-positive cell death was achieved in the hippocampus, caudate nucleus, internal capsule, and putamen at 30 mg/kg dose (with ethanol) and only in sensory cortex at the 20 mg/kg (without ethanol).

In a lamb model of HIE (umbilical cord occlusion for 9–10 min), intravenous melatonin (with ethanol) was administered at 15 mg/kg/day in 12 divided doses every 2 h; a steady plasma concentration of melatonin and cortical concentration of 0.46 ± 0.16 ng/mL were achieved [51]. Melatonin improved all neurodevelopmental assessments and reduced seizure burden. Significant reduction in brain Lac/NAA ratio and apoptosis was also achieved suggesting that alternative dosing approaches such as continuous infusion may also be effective [51].

Pharmaceutics and licenced preparation (Table 1)

Melatonin is photosensitive and degrades rapidly within hours of UV-A and UV-B exposure, necessitating specific storage and administration requirements [49].

Dosing and pharmacokinetics

Pharmacokinetic modelling in piglets indicates that a dose of 20–30 mg/kg intravenous for 2 h repeated 24 h later is required to maintain a therapeutic concentration of 15–30 mg/L [52]. Detailed pharmacokinetic studies are required in neonates with moderate and severe HIE before a dosing regimen is determined. Target therapeutic concentrations need to be achieved within 3 h after birth.

Safety and toxicology

Oral melatonin has been safely administered to children [53], pregnant women [54–56], and preterm newborn infants [57] at much lower doses with no safety concerns (Table 1). The intravenous lethal dose (LD₅₀) in rodents without anaesthesia is not much higher than the anticipated treatment dose (Table 2). Intensive care may be required for treatment.

Clinical trials

Small trials have been conducted with enteral melatonin with [58] or without hypothermia [59–61]. A clinical trial using low-dose enteral melatonin (0.5–5 mg/kg) is currently recruiting (NCT02621944; study completion: March 2022). In a randomised placebo-controlled trial on infants with moderate-severe HIE (n = 25), intravenous melatonin (5 mg/kg as 2 h infusion) on postnatal days 1 (< 6 h after birth), 2, and 3 only improved the cognitive composite score (101 ± 22 vs. 86 ± 17; p < 0.05) on Bayley Scales of Infant Development III at 18 months of age [62]. There were no differences between the groups according to the Gross Motor Function Classification System.

A well-designed early-phase escalating dose clinical trial is required to determine the pharmacokinetics, safety, and tolerance of intravenous melatonin.

Cannabidiol

Cannabidiol is one of the naturally occurring cannabinoids found in cannabis plants. It is a 21-carbon terpenophenolic compound which is formed following decarboxylation from a cannabidiolic acid precursor, although it can also be produced synthetically. It has a complex pharmacological profile, acting not only on endocannabinoid receptors, CB1 and CB2, but also on G protein–coupled receptors, ion channel, and nuclear receptors [63, 64]. While some of the neuroprotective effects of cannabidiol are mediated through CB1 and CB2, it is also partly due to activation of 5-hydroxytryptamine-1A, adenosine, and peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-gamma (PPARγ) receptors [65–68]. It reduces apoptosis and mitochondrial dysfunction and acts as an antioxidant by reducing the activity of the antioxidant system and increasing the activity of mitochondrial complexes [65, 69, 70]. It reduces inflammation by decreasing pro-inflammatory cytokine production and increasing anti-inflammatory cytokine production and stimulation of PPARγ [65, 71].

Preclinical evidence

Cannabidiol was administered to piglets as an intravenous bolus (1 mg/kg) on postnatal days 1 (30 min after hypoxic-ischemic insult), 2, and 3 in conjunction with 48 h hypothermia [72]. The hypoxic-ischemic insult (bilateral carotid artery ligation with exposure to 10% oxygen) induced increases in brain Lac/NAA ratio, and TUNEL-positive cells in the cerebral cortex were reversed by combined hypothermia and cannabidiol but not by either alone. No treatment modified the effects of hypoxic ischemia on oxidative stress, astroglial activation, background electroencephalography, or seizures [72].

The neuroprotective effect of combined intravenous cannabidiol (1 mg/kg, 30 min after hypoxic-ischemic insult) and hypothermia (6 h) was studied using a piglet HIE model (bilateral carotid artery occlusion with exposure to < 10% oxygen). Individually, hypothermia and the cannabidiol treatments reduced the number of necrotic neurons and prevented an increase in Lac/NAA ratio [73]. The combined effect of hypothermia and cannabidiol on excitotoxicity, on inflammation and oxidative stress, and on cell damage was greater than either hypothermia or cannabidiol alone [73]. In contrast, no neuroprotective effect was demonstrated when intravenous cannabidiol (1 mg/kg) and hypothermia (9 h) were administered to a global hypoxia–ischemia piglet model [74].

Low-dose cannabidiol alone (0.01 μg/kg intravenous 60 min after umbilical artery occlusion) significantly reduced TUNEL-positive cells in all brain regions (cortex, hippocampus, basal nuclei, cerebellum, brainstem) in foetal lambs at 3 h [75]. Subcutaneous cannabidiol (1 mg/kg) showed a therapeutic window of 18 h after hypoxia–ischemia in a 9–10-day-old mice using a Rice-Vanucci model (unilateral carotid artery ligation with exposure to 10% oxygen) [76].

Pharmaceutics and licenced preparation (Table 1)

Cannabidiol is stable in room temperature and not photosensitive but has poor water solubility.

Dosing and pharmacokinetics

Intravenous cannabidiol is rapidly distributed, followed by prolonged elimination (terminal half-life: 24 h) [77, 78]. Plasma cannabidiol concentration peaked at the end of the infusion 15 min after the end of intravenous bolus administration and rapidly decreased to low concentrations after 1 h in piglets [72]. No cumulative effect was observed after repeated doses. Hypothermia led to a significant increase in cannabidiol plasma concentration [72]. In healthy adults, mean plasma cannabidiol concentrations were reported at 686 ng/mL (3 min postadministration), which dropped to 48 ng/mL at 1 h following intravenous administration of 20 mg of deuterium-labelled cannabidiol [79].

Safety and toxicology

Cannabidiol has very low toxicity (Table 2). Liver safety concerns were raised in randomised controlled trials of cannabidiol in patients with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome or Dravet syndrome [80, 81]. 17.2% of patients receiving up to 20 mg/kg oral cannabidiol, all taking valproic acid, had liver transaminase elevations ≥ 3 times the upper limit of normal [81]. Since the oral bioavailability of cannabidiol is only 13–19% [77], neonates with HIE receiving intravenous cannabidiol may be at risk at much lower doses.

Clinical trials

A phase 1, escalating single dose (0.1–3 mg/kg), randomised placebo-controlled trial using a new ethanol-free intravenous formulation of cannabidiol on infants with moderate-severe HIE is currently recruiting to assess safety, tolerance, and pharmacokinetics (EudraCT Number: 2016–000,936-17; Sponsor: GW Pharmaceuticals).

Exenatide/exendin-4

Exendin-4 is a 39 amino acid agonist of the glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor. Exendin-4 is present in the saliva of the Gila monster, Heloderma suspectum. GLP-1, a gastrointestinal hormone secreted by the L cells of the intestine, regulates blood glucose primarily via stimulation of glucose-dependent insulin release [82]. GLP-1 agonists have neuroprotective properties when assessed in preclinical models of Alzheimer’s disease [83], Parkinson’s disease [84], traumatic brain injury [85, 86], and stroke [87, 88]. In oxygen–glucose deprivation models, GLP-1 and agonists increase neuronal survival by reducing reactive oxygen species and apoptotic and necrotic mechanisms partly through the PI3K/protein kinase B (Akt) pathway [89–91]. Exenatide readily penetrates the blood–brain barrier where it acts on GLP-1 receptors known to be present in the newborn brain [92].

Preclinical evidence

Using a Rice-Vanucci mouse model of HIE, the potential neuroprotective effect of exendin-4 in both postnatal day 7 and 10 mice [92]. An optimal exendin-4 treatment dosing regimen was found, where four high doses (500 μg/kg intraperitoneal with TH) starting at 0 or 2 h, then at 12 h, 24 h, and 36 h after postnatal day 7 hypoxic-ischaemic insult augmented TH resulting in 80% improvement in infarct volume and cell death. Treatment with liraglutide, a long acting GLP-1 agonist, also exerted neuroprotection in a Rice-Vanucci rat model of HIE [89].

Pharmaceutics and licenced preparation (Table 1)

Exenatide is readily soluble in water and photosensitive, necessitating special storage and administration requirements.

Dosing and pharmacokinetics

The pharmacokinetic profile of exenatide (60–600 μg/kg) following intraperitoneal injection is like a subcutaneous injection and differs from an intravenous dose in rats. Subcutaneous bioavailability at high doses is good, but the absorption rate and clearance of exenatide is nonlinear meaning attaining rapid therapeutic concentrations may not be feasible by this route [93]. Effective therapeutic concentrations can be achieved rapidly and maintained more precisely using an intravenous bolus followed by 48 h infusion [93]. Exenatide is metabolised throughout the body, resistant to proteolytic cleavage by dipeptidyl peptidase IV, eliminated through the kidney, and unaffected by liver impairment [94].

Safety and toxicology

Exenatide has an excellent safety profile in adults. It increases, on a glucose-dependent basis, the secretion of insulin and does not impair hormone responses to hypoglycaemia [95]. No toxicity was noted in human overdose case reports [96–98], but weight loss is a concern on repeated dosing (Table 2).

Clinical trials

No studies have been performed in neonates. A phase 3 trial on Parkinson’s disease is currently recruiting (NCT04232969).

Allopurinol

Allopurinol is a xanthine-oxidase inhibitor that inhibits the production of uric acid. The mechanism of neuroprotection in neonatal HIE is unclear, possibly by inhibiting the formation of the free radical superoxide production [99].

Preclinical evidence

Several studies in rodents and piglets have shown neuroprotective effects but none have been performed in conjunction with hypothermia [100–106].

Pharmaceutics and licenced preparation (Table 1)

Allokid® (unlicensed, ACE Pharmaceuticals®, Netherlands), specially formulated for neonates, is currently undergoing clinical trial (NCT03162653) [107]. An alternative licenced formulation, Aloprim® (Mylan Institutional®, USA), is discussed in Tables 1 and 2.

Dosing and pharmacokinetics

Target therapeutic concentrations have not been defined in preclinical studies. Allopurinol 20 mg/kg intravenous within 2 h after birth, second dose 12 h later, then every 12 h for 3 days improved neurodevelopment at 1 year [108] and forms the basis for ongoing phase 3 trial [107]. Pharmacokinetics of 10–20 mg/kg of intravenous allopurinol was studied in neonates with HIE (n = 46 from 3 studies) [109]. Xanthine-oxidase inhibition was achieved, and no dose adjustment for TH was proposed [109].

Safety and toxicology

Oral allopurinol has a good safety profile. Intravenous allopurinol has been used in association with cancer chemotherapy. An independent safety profile is difficult to establish. The intravenous lethal dose (LD₅₀) in rodents without anaesthesia is not much higher than the anticipated treatment dose (Table 2).

Clinical trials

A meta-analysis (n = 114 participants) did not reveal a statistically significant difference in the risk of death (typical risk ratio 0.88; 95% confidence interval (95% CI) 0.56 to 1.38; risk difference − 0.04; 95% CI − 0.18 to 0.10) or a composite of death or severe neurodevelopmental disability (typical risk ratio 0.78; 95% CI 0.56 to 1.08; risk difference − 0.14; 95% CI − 0.31 to 0.04) [110]. A phase III randomised placebo-controlled trial to evaluate the effect of postnatal allopurinol administered in addition to standard of care (including therapeutic hypothermia if indicated) on the incidence of death and disability at 24 months of age in neonatal HIE is ongoing (NCT03162653) [107].

Discussion

Several promising adjuvant treatment strategies for neonatal HIE are progressing towards the clinic (Table 3). We have in this review focussed on pharmacological treatment options. Stem cell therapy is outside the scope of this review. Serrenho I et al. (2021) provides a systematic review of preclinical studies done on stem cell therapy for neonatal HIE [111]. Eighty percent of these studies reported a significant improvement of cognitive and/or sensorimotor function, as well as decreased brain damage. There are no completed clinical trials on stem cell therapy, and several are ongoing [112]. Xenon [113] and magnesium sulphate [114] have been previously evaluated and did not demonstrate much benefit.

Table 3.

Milestones achieved in translation at the anticipated dose as described in Table 2

Pharmacological treatment strategies which have shown potential benefit in animal and human studies of HIE demonstrate that (1) there is a narrow time window within the first few hours after birth during which therapy should be started for best outcomes, (2) high doses are often needed and the anticipated side effects based on adult tolerability have not been noticed in newborn babies, and (3) TH changes the pharmacokinetics of drugs requiring special consideration. Key limiting factors are needed for industry support for developing new formulations suitable for use in neonates and inadequate dose range finding and pharmacokinetic studies in both animals and neonates. Allopurinol sodium and cannabidiol have received orphan designation for the treatment of neonatal HIE and only one of the ongoing clinical trials has an industry sponsor (cannabidiol; GW Pharmaceuticals).

Many treatments have progressed to human trials without juvenile toxicology. Since the proposed dose are often much higher than current licenced dose and animal models of neonatal HIE do not include a recovery period and multi-organ histopathology, the risk for serious unexpected adverse reactions remains. Juvenile toxicity studies with cannabidiol showed that lowest dose of developmental toxicity was 15 mg/kg. In contrast, the no adverse observed adverse event level (NOAEL) in adult rodents was 400–500 mg/kg emphasising the need for these studies.

Several pharmacological treatments have demonstrated efficacy in animal models. We have in this review focussed on nonrodent models of HIE. The use of unilateral/bilateral occlusion of carotid artery are well-accepted in models of neonatal HIE. However, focal ischemia models are unsuitable for assessment of pharmacokinetics. Kyng et al. (2015) describe a global hypoxia–ischemia model in piglets which may allow a more reliable preclinical assessment of target therapeutic concentration [115].

Double therapy in animal models is often tested in combination with < 48 h hypothermia. While the feasibility of maintaining ≥ 48 h hypothermia in animal experiments is low, anticipated effect sizes are unreliable with shorter duration hypothermia. Competitive advantage of different treatments cannot be determined as experiments with varying duration of hypothermia are not comparable.

Only erythropoietin has been studied in primates with follow-up included allowing for anticipated effect sizes for death or cerebral palsy as a combined outcome measure to be determined. Piglet models with no follow-up rely on surrogate biomarkers like TUNEL-positive count and Lac/NAA ratio. Adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes were correctly identified in 95.65% of cases (n = 62) by Lac/NAA measured using cerebral magnetic resonance spectroscopy in clinical studies. However, validation of Lac/NAA ratios as a surrogate biomarker in preclinical studies is lacking.

None of the ongoing clinical trials identified are recruiting in low- and middle-income countries where therapeutic hypothermia is not an option although bulk of the burden of neonatal HIE is in this region. All treatment strategies discussed above except for possibly melatonin can be administered without intensive care support. Further preclinical studies in the context of infection-inflammation are required before such trials are undertaken.

Conclusion

A wide variety of experimental treatment approaches for neonatal HIE have progressed towards the clinic over recent years. There is a need for more optimal animal models, greater industry support/sponsorship, increased use of juvenile toxicology, dose-ranging studies with pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modelling, and well-designed clinical trials to avoid exposure to harmful medications or abandoning putative treatments.

Abbreviations

aEEG

Amplitude-integrated electroencephalography

AUC

Area under curve

CI

Confidence interval

C_max

Maximum concentrations

GLP-1

Glucagon-like peptide-1

HIE

Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy

Lac/NAA

Lactate/N-acetyl aspartate ratio

MRI

Magnetic resonance imaging

MRS

Magnetic resonance spectroscopy

NNT

Numbers needed to treat

NOAEL

No adverse observed adverse event level

PPAR

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor

RR

Risk ratio

SD

Standard deviation

TH

Therapeutic hypothermia

TUNEL

Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase dUTP nick end labelling

Authors’ contributions

SV, ERF, AR, HH, and ADE drafted the article. HH and ADE did the critical appraisal of the manuscript. All authors accepted the final manuscript.

Declarations

Ethics approval

Not applicable.

Consent to participate

Not applicable.

Consent for publication

Yes, we consent for publication.

Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.