Synthesis, characterization, and functional evaluation of branched dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ethers: a novel class of surfactants with excellent wetting properties

Abstract

A series of branched dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ethers (b-DPEO_n) were successfully synthesized via alkylation and ethylene oxide addition reactions. The alkylation reaction was conducted by using a branched internal olefin as the raw material. Furthermore, the conversion rate of the branched dodecene was measured to be 98.1% and the selectivity towards branched dodecyl phenol (b-DP) was 95.9%. Moreover, b-DPEO_n (b-DPEO₇, b-DPEO₁₀, b-DPEO₁₂) were obtained via the reaction of ethylene oxide with b-DP. Notably, b-DPEO₁₀ can efficiently reduce the surface tension of water below 31.55 mN m⁻¹ at the critical micelle concentration (cmc) and the cmc value in water was approximately 1.3 × 10⁻² g L⁻¹ at 25 °C. The preferable wetting ability of b-DPEO₁₀ was superior to that of commercialized dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ether (c-DPEO_n), so it will be promoted and used in the textile and pesticide industries.

A series of branched dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ethers (b-DPEO_n) were successfully synthesized by using internal olefins with branches, in which branched structures promote good wetting ability.

Introduction

Surface tension is caused by the imbalance of the forces on the molecules at the interface of the two phases. Surfactant molecules usually feature a hydrophilic group at one end and a lipophilic group at the other, which can form an arrangement on the surface of the solution to improve the unbalanced state of the surface molecules, thereby reducing the surface tension of the solution.^1–4 Non-ionic surfactants represent an important subgroup of surfactants, whose hydrophobic groups are generally composed of alkylphenols, fatty alcohols, etc. On the other hand, their hydrophilic groups consist of polyoxyethylene (EO) or polyoxypropylene (PO) chains.^5–8 The properties of non-ionic surfactants can be adjusted by changing the lengths of hydrophobic or hydrophilic groups and by modifying the structures of the hydrophobic moiety.^9,10

At present, commercialized alkylphenol polyoxyethylene ethers are obtained from alpha olefins (primarily the linear ones), while only a few branched alkylphenol polyoxyethylene ethers have been reported. However, studies have revealed that the hydrophobic base with a branched structure show better wetting and penetrating properties than those of linear ones, even when their types and molecular sizes are comparable.^11–15 Sha and coworkers successfully synthesized a novel branched fluorinated anionic surfactant 4-(3,3,4,4,5,5,5-heptafluoro-2,2-bis-trifluoromethyl-pentyl)-benzene lithium phosphonate via a four-step route by using perfluoro-2-methyl-2-pentene as a starting material.¹⁶ This branched fluorinated anionic surfactant exhibits excellent surface activity, which reduces the surface tension of water to be 19.2 mN m⁻¹. Zhang et al. successfully obtained novel anionic surfactants alcohol polyoxyethylene ether carboxylates with three branched chains.¹⁷ One of these novel branched surfactants features allows for the reduction of surface tension of water to around 27 mN m⁻¹. Compared with linear surfactants, branched surfactants exhibit preferable wetting ability toward potential application, which was mainly caused by the difference in diffusion rate.^18–20

Although high-branched alkyl tails may lead to poor biodegradability, branched surfactants with limited short side-chains have been testified to have negligible effect on their biodegradability.²¹ With respect to the linear isomer, a branched alkyl amine oxide surfactant (C₁₀DAO-branched) showed the ability to form concentrated solutions without generating lyotropic liquid crystals²² or to tune supramolecular aggregation upon pH stimuli.²³ Moreover, C₁₀DAO-branched can keep low viscosity even in mixtures with other linear surfactants, thereby the rational design of branched alkyl structures has become an efficient strategy to increase the concentration of surfactants in detergent formulations.²⁴

In this research, we present a series of branched dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ether (b-DPEO_n), which were obtained through alkylation and ethylene oxide addition reaction in high yields, as shown in Scheme 1. It is noteworthy that the raw material non-terminal dodecene is a by-product of the butene oligomerization unit and contains some branched olefins. Their ability to reduce surface tension and wetting performance were investigated and compared with the commercialized dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ether (c-DPEO_n).

Scheme 1. The synthesis process of the b-DPEO_n.

Experimental

Materials

Branched non-terminal dodecenes were obtained from Sinopec Maoming Petrochemical Company. The composition analysis of the dodecenes was provided by Sinopec Maoming Petrochemical Company and analyzed by GC-MS and NMR instruments. The composition is as follows: the content of low-carbon chain components such as octylphenol and octane is less than 0.5%, the content of dodecene is more than 98%, and the content of dodecane and high-carbon olefins is less than 1%. The approximate content of terminal dodecenes was ca. 10%. The catalyst (sulfonic acid resin, DA330) was purchased from Dandong Mingzhu Special Resin Co., Ltd. Ethylene oxide was industrial pure grade. Phenol, methanol, KOH, and lactic acid were all analytical pure grade. The c-DPEO_n used for comparison was purchased from Jiangsu Hai'an Petrochemical Company.

Synthesis of branched dodecyl phenol (b-DP)

The specified molar ratio of phenol and branched non-terminal dodecene was added in a 250 mL flask. Added the catalyst DA330 to the flask and fixed the stirring device. When the reaction device was prepared, the raw materials were heated to melt through the oil bath, and then stirred. The reaction time was started being counted when the temperature reached the specified temperature. The resulting products were analyzed for the composition by GC.Conversion rate: X = 1 − mwhere m was the remaining content of dodecene in the product, n was the content of the b-DP.

Synthesis of branched dodecyl phenol polyoxyethylene ether (b-DPEO_n)

The b-DP and 0.06% wt KOH were added to a 0.3 L pressure reactor. N₂ was used to replace the air in the reactor for three times. For the first hour, water removal was proceeded from the reactor under the condition of reduced pressure at 100 ± 5 °C. Then the temperature was increased to about 160 °C, and EO was introduced from the bottom of the reactor. The reaction temperature was set at 175 ± 5 °C and the pressure at 0.3–0.4 MPa until all EO had been added. Finally, after cooling to ca. 70 °C, the unreacted EO was removed, and the products were obtained by adding lactic acid to neutralize. (m_KOH : m_{85% lactic acid} = 1 : 1.89).

Test conditions of GC

Test instrument

Shimadzu GC-2010AF.

Agilent J&W GC column: DB-1MS, 30 m × 0.25 mm × 0.25 μm.

Setting parameters

The initial temperature of the chromatographic column was 60 °C, maintained for 2 minutes and then increased to 280 °C at a rate of 20 °C min⁻¹, and then maintained for 15 minutes. The temperature of the inlet was 250 °C, and the temperature of the FID detector was 280 °C. N₂: 30 mL min⁻¹, air: 400 mL min⁻¹, H₂: 40 mL min⁻¹.

Test of surface tension

Test instrument

K100 automatic surface tension instrument from KRUSS, Germany.

Test conditions

Platinum plate method

The concentration of the starting and the final solution was 500 and 1 mg L⁻¹, respectively, with the starting volume of 60 mL. A total of 12 points had been tested upon the addition of deionized water.

A series of parameters such as surface tension reduction efficiency (pc₂₀), efficiency (Π_cmc), saturated adsorption capacity (Γ_max) and saturated adsorption area (A_min) can be obtained by the following formulas:

Π_cmc = γ₀ − γ_cmc 1

pc₂₀ = −lg c₂₀ 2

3

4

where γ₀ was the surface tension of pure water at 25 °C, approximately 72.0 mN m⁻¹, c₂₀ was the mass concentration of surfactant (g L⁻¹) when γ₀ was less than 20 mN m⁻¹. R was the gas constant with the value of 8.314 J (mol K)⁻¹, and N_A was Avogadro's constant.

Test of hydroxyl value

The hydroxyl value was tested by titration. In this method, acetic anhydride and pyridine were selected as acylation reagents. The hydroxyl value I_(OH) (mg KOH per g) was calculated according to the following formula:where V₀ was the volume of KOH solution consumed in the blank experiment, V₁ was the volume of KOH solution consumed by the sample, c was the concentration of KOH solution, and m₀ was the mass of the sample.

Test of wetting ability

The coarse canvas is used in the test, and the specification is C/C 21/2 × 8/2. The canvas is cut into round cloth pieces with a diameter of 30 mm, with a mass range of 0.44 to 0.45 g. The 0.5 g L⁻¹ solution of surfactant in water is prepared, and the temperature is kept at 25 °C after dissolution. The round cloth pieces were put into the solution horizontally. The time from entering the solution to the beginning of sinking was denoted as the wetting time, and three parallel tests were carried out for each surfactant.

Test of polyethylene glycol content

Test instrument

Agilent Technologies 1260 Infinity LC.

Agilent LC column:

ZORBAX SB-C18, 4.6 × 150 mm × 5 μm.

The content of polyethylene glycol was analyzed by LC, and the content of polyethylene glycol was obtained from the standard curve. The function of the standard curve was lg A = 1.5025 lg x + 2.1948, ikwhere A was the peak area and x was the concentration of polyethylene glycol. The test method of the sample was as follows: weighed m₁ g of the sample in a 10 mL volumetric flask, dissolved it in a methanol aqueous solution. The mass concentration of the aqueous methanol solution was 80%. The formula for the content of polyethylene glycol was as follows:

Results and discussion

Synthesis of b-DP

Excess phenol was typically added in the alkylation reactions with the presence of olefin and phenol as raw materials to reduce the content of multi-substituted products and increase the yield of mono-substituted ones.²⁵ In this paper, the conversion rate of the reaction was calculated based on the remaining content of dodecene in the products, showing that the main by-products in the reaction were multi-substituted alkylphenol. The alkylation reaction also yielded other organics including decyl phenol and cetyl phenol. However, their contents were less than 0.5% wt and therefore they were not discussed in this study. As shown in Fig. 1, lowering the reaction temperature, increasing the molar ratio of phenol to olefin, and reducing the reaction time exclusively resulted in the reduction of the selectivity of multi-substituted products. As a consequence, conversion rate of olefins decreased and the difficulty of the separation and purification increased. To maintain the high conversion rate of olefins and high selectivity of mono-substituted products, the reaction condition was optimized. The amount of catalyst added was 5%, the molar ratio of phenol to olefin was 4 : 1, the reaction temperature was 90 °C, and the reaction time was 5 h. Under this condition, the conversion rate of branched non-terminal dodecene and the selectivity of b-DP was determined to be 98.1% and 95.9%, respectively.

Fig. 1. Effects on the synthesis of b-DP.

Synthesis of b-DPEO_n

Characterization of b-DPEO_n

After separating and purifying, b-DPs further reacted with ethylene oxide to yield three kinds of b-DPEO_n (b-DPEO₇, b-DPEO₁₀, and b-DPEO₁₂). The structures were analyzed by FTIR and ¹H NMR, and the results were shown in Fig. 2 and S1,† respectively.

Fig. 2. FTIR spectra.

The main characteristic absorption peaks of the DPEO_n can be found in the FTIR spectra. The peak of 3450 cm⁻¹ corresponds to the stretching vibration of the O–H group in the phenolic hydroxyl group, and the peaks of 1640, 1600, 1510, and 1460 cm⁻¹ can be assigned to the stretching vibration of the benzene ring. The anti-symmetric stretching vibration peak of C–O–C group and the symmetric stretching vibration peak locate at 1250 cm⁻¹ and 1100 cm⁻¹, respectively. Combined with the analysis of the ¹H NMR, it can be seen that b-DPEO₁₀ and c-DPEO₁₀ have similar chemical shifts regions of phenyl H, methyl H and methylene H, which further confirm their structural relevance. However, the branched chain in b-DPEO₁₀ leads to more complicated chemical environments for the H on the hydrocarbon chain, as exemplified by the larger integration in the range of 0–2 ppm due to the presence of more methyl H in the branched one.

Properties of b-DPEO_n

The hydroxyl value can be used to define the average molecular weight of the product. Furthermore, the contents of polyethylene glycol may affect the surface activity of the product. These two parameters are summarized in Table 1.

Hydroxyl values and polyethylene glycol contents.

Sample	Hydroxyl value/mg KOH g−1	Polyethylene glycol content/% wt	Theoretical hydroxyl value/mg KOH g−1
b-DPEO7	96.07	1.81	98.37
b-DPEO10	80.26	2.13	79.89
b-DPEO12	73.17	2.76	70.93
c-DPEO10	85.79	2.60	79.89

It can be seen from Table 1 that all the hydroxyl values of the synthesized samples are close to the theoretical values, while the hydroxyl value of b-DPEO₁₂ is higher than the calculated value. This result combined with the polyethylene glycol content suggests that the hydroxyl value of b-DPEO₁₂ is higher because the reaction time was longer and more polyethylene glycol was formed. The hydroxyl value of c-DPEO₁₀ is higher than the theoretical value, which is mainly caused by the naming convention in the industry. According to the hydroxyl value calculation, its actual degree of polymerization should be around 9. The molecular weights of the b-DPEO_n were in a reasonable range based on the theoretical hydroxyl values, which allows for the measurement of surface tension and test of performance.

Surface tension of b-DPEO

The surface tension (γ) was taken as the ordinate, and the logarithm of the concentration (lg c) was taken as the abscissa to get Fig. 3. Because the solubility of b-DPEO₇ is modest, the surface tension research cannot be carried out under the same experimental condition as the other samples. The data in Table 2 can be calculated by formulas (1)–(4). Compared with the commercialized samples, the cmc value of the products are significantly lower, which was mainly due to the influence of the branched hydrophobic chains. The minimum surface area A_min of the molecules with branched chains is larger, which reduces the saturated adsorption amount (Γ_max) at the interface. Therefore, micelles can be easily formed in the solution at low concentrations, and the correspondingly the cmc value is lower. Although the adsorption capacity of b-DPEO_n at the interface is not as large as that of the commercialized sample, the hydrocarbon chain of the later one is prone to bend due to its linear nature. This phenomenon results in the lower –CH₃ group number in the outermost layer of the commercialized sample than that of the branched ones. Since the surface energy of –CH₃ group was higher than –CH₂ group, the γ_cmc of b-DPEO_n can be comparable to that of the commercialized sample.

Fig. 3. Plots of γ-lg c of the DPEO_n at 25 °C.

Surface tension of surfactants.

Sample	cmc/g L−1	γ cmc/mN m−1	Π cmc/mN m−1	pc20	Γ max × 1010/mol cm−2	A min/nm−2
b-DPEO10	0.013	31.55	40.45	5.48	0.99	1.68
b-DPEO12	0.020	31.85	40.15	5.72	0.85	1.95
c-DPEO10	0.200	31.60	40.40	2.41	2.09	0.80

Wetting ability of b-DPEO_n

As depicted in Fig. 4, the wetting ability of b-DPEO_n was tested under three different mass concentrations, showing that the performance of b-DPEO_n are better than c-DPEO₁₀. Specifically, b-DPEO_n shows good wetting ability at the concentration of 0.1 g L⁻¹ and the its performance can be optimized at a concentration of 0.5 g L⁻¹. The pc₂₀ of b-DPEO_n is higher, implying that b-DPEO_n has a higher efficiency of reducing surface tension. At the same time, the sizes of b-DPEO_n in water are smaller than that of the linear surfactant c-DPEO₁₀. Branched surfactant can penetrate to the surface of the internal fibers more quickly to complete the directional arrangement, which give rise to a better wetting ability than the linear one. In contrast, a recent work showed that the cmc of a branched amine-oxide was higher than that of the linear analogue.²³ It appears that the effect of branches depends on the final architecture of the tail, which regulates the critical packing parameter of the surfactants bearing short side chains.

Fig. 4. Wetting ability of b-DPEO_n.

Conclusions

The b-DP was obtained through the reaction of branched non-terminal dodecenes and phenol. The optimal reaction condition was as follows: the amount of catalyst added is 5%, the molar ratio of phenol to branched dodecene is 4 : 1, the reaction temperature is 90 °C, and the reaction time is 5 h. Under this condition, the conversion rate of branched non-terminal dodecene is 98.1%, and the selectivity of b-DP is 95.9%. A series novel surfactants b-DPEO_n were synthesized by the ethylene oxide addition reaction of b-DP. The characterizations of FTIR and ¹H NMR confirmed that the structures of b-DPEO_n and the commercialized linear sample are similar. It was found that the b-DPEO₁₀ exhibits excellent surface activity to reduce the surface tension of water below to 31.55 mN m⁻¹ at the cmc and the cmc value in water is about 1.3 × 10⁻² g L⁻¹ at 25 °C. Compared with c-DPEO_n, b-DPEO_n exhibited preferable wetting ability. This work can provide a feasible solution for the application of internal olefins, by-products of the olefin oligomerization unit.

Author contributions

Xing Wang: data curation, writing-original draft, formal analysis. Junfeng Qian: conceptualization, methodology, validation. Zhonghua Sun: investigation, methodology. Zhihui Zhang: writing-review & editing. Mingyang He: project administration, conceptualization, funding acquisition.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.