Sequential or Simultaneous Injection of Preformed Fibrils and AAV Overexpression of Alpha-Synuclein Are Equipotent in Producing Relevant Pathology and Behavioral Deficits

Abstract

Background:

Preclinical rodent models for Parkinson’s disease (PD) based on viral human alpha-synuclein (h-αSyn) overexpression recapitulate some of the pathological hallmarks as it presents in humans, such as progressive cell loss and additional synucleinopathy in cortical and subcortical structures. Recent studies have combined viral vector-based overexpression of human wild-type αSyn with the sequential or simultaneous inoculation of preformed fibrils (PFFs) derived from human αSyn.

Objective:

The goal of the study was to investigate whether sequential or combined delivery of the AAV vector and the PFFs are equipotent in inducing stable neurodegeneration and behavioral deficits.

Methods:

Here we compare between four experimental paradigms (PFFs only, AAV-h-αSyn only, AAV-h-αSyn with simultaneous PFFs, and AAV-h-αSyn with sequential PFFs) and their respective GFP control groups.

Results:

We observed reduction of TH expression and loss of neurons in the midbrain in all AAV (h-αSyn or GFP) injected groups, with or without additional PFFs inoculation. The overexpression of either h-αSyn or GFP alone induced motor deficits and dysfunctional dopamine release/reuptake in electrochemical recordings in the ipsilateral striatum. However, we observed a substantial formation of insoluble h-αSyn aggregates and inflammatory response only when h-αSyn and PFFs were combined. Moreover, the presence of h-αSyn induced higher axonal pathology compared to control groups.

Conclusion:

Simultaneous AAV and PFFs injections are equipotent in the presented experimental setup in inducing histopathological and behavioral changes. This model provides new and interesting possibilities for characterizing PD pathology in preclinical models and means to assess future therapeutic interventions.

INTRODUCTION

The most common preclinical rodent models of Parkinson’s disease (PD) are produced by either injecting neurotoxicants, overexpressing PD-related genes, or by introducing mutations. Neurotoxicants such as 6-hydroxydopamine (6-OHDA) and 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1, 2, 3, 6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP) cause a robust and rapid degeneration of the dopaminergic midbrain system, with subsequent behavioral impairments [1–6]. These approaches, however, neither replicate the alpha synuclein (αSyn)-linked pathology seen in PD patients [7, 8] nor the progressive neurodegeneration [9]. By contrast, genetic-based models, either transgenic animal lines or viral vector overexpression models, exhibit αSyn pathology although with variable levels of neurodegeneration and behavioral phenotypes. Viral vector-based overexpression of h-αSyn is a promising method to trigger the desired PD-like key features. The field has gone through several generations of viral vectors [10–13] and the most commonly used are recombinant adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors. However, there is a great heterogeneity in the results from AAV-based studies in terms of αSyn expression levels, neurodegeneration, and behavioral deficits. This may be due to differences in expression systems and transgene cassettes such as promoter-transgene combinations, and posttranscriptional modifying and regulatory sequences (e.g., polyA and WPRE) as well as in the choice of capsid serotype, and in the quality control of the virus itself, resulting in variable success rate [11, 14–22]. Overexpression of clinical mutations such as the A53T variant [23–25], S129D and S129A [16, 26], and A30P [24] is an alternative to exacerbate relevant pathology. Moreover, increasing dosing of AAV to elicit a greater effect may confound the experimentation as the use of control vectors (e.g., GFP) can also confer a negative effect on the integrity of nigrostriatal neurons [27–30]. Nonetheless, in a typical experimental design, neurodegeneration seen in most AAV-based expression systems has been rather moderate with usually few animals per experimental group displaying a stable behavioral phenotype.

The development of a reliable model is imperative in order to investigate the mechanisms of disease pathology as well as to test therapeutic interventions. High predictive and face-validity are needed to be able to translate approaches into clinical trials. As an example, glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) showed great promise in the 6-OHDA model but failed to meet its primary endpoint in double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trials [31–35]. A direct comparison of the effects of GDNF between the 6-OHDA model and the αSyn model demonstrated neuroprotection only in the 6-OHDA model [36]. The availability of a robust model that mimics the progressive cell loss, αSyn pathology, and stable behavioral deficits is thus currently not widely available. In the attempt of accomplishing this aim, a more recent approach combines AAV vector-based overexpression methods with injection of preformed fibrils (PFFs), which seed endogenous αSyn inclusions [37–41]. PFFs have been injected either 4 weeks after an AAV-αSyn injection [37] or simultaneously [40, 42], with the latter approach being more practical and less invasive, requiring only a single surgical intervention. Finally, the combination of ectopic human αSyn together with PFFs derived from the human protein allows for studies focused on studying the human synucleinopathy with minimal interference from endogenous rodent αSyn. In the present study we directly compare the effects of the combination of human PFFs inoculation and AAV-h-αSyn in the midbrain of rats, either individually, combined, or after a 4-week delay. Pathological changes were assessed by immunohistochemical analysis, electrochemical recordings, and behavioral testing. The aims of the present study were i) to establish a model that generates stable behavioral phenotypes in the majority of animals, and ii) to investigate whether there is a difference in outcomes between the sequential or simultaneous PFFs injection approach.

We report that transgene expression along the nigrostriatal pathway in all the AAV-injected groups (both AAV-h-αSyn and AAV-GFP) produces downregulation of tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) expression in the midbrain and striatum, irrespective of whether the AAV-vector was injected alone or in combination with PFFs. These animals also displayed altered dopamine release and reuptake kinetics in electrochemical recordings as well as motor impairments which did not recover over time. However, only when AAV-h-αSyn was combined with PFFs we observed phosphorylated αSyn similar to that seen in patient brains. Moreover, the combination of PFFs and AAV-h-αSyn triggered an enhanced inflammatory response around the area of transduction, which was not observed in the remaining experimental groups. Lastly, the presence of ectopic h-αSyn induced strong axonal pathology, with elevated numbers of striatal axonal swellings on the side of injection.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Animals

All experimental procedures performed in this study were approved by the Malmö/Lund Ethics Committee on Animal Testing as well as according to Swedish national guidelines (Jordbruksverket) and the EU Directive 2010/63/EU for animal experiments. Sixty-four adult (220–250 g) female Sprague-Dawley rats were purchased from Janvier Labs (France) and were housed under a 12:12 h dark:light cycle with ad libitum access to food and water in a temperature-controlled room in standard laboratory cages. A total of 64 rats were used in the current study and allocated randomly to the seven experimental groups.

Experimental outline

Naïve Sprague-Dawley rats (n = 63) were randomly assigned into seven experimental groups receiving PFFs and AAV-vector overexpressing h-αSyn or GFP either alone or in combination (see Fig. 1 and Table 1). In the combination groups, one group received both PFFs and AAV simultaneously (h-αSyn/PFFs and GFP/PFFs) and in the other group PFFs inoculation followed the AAV injection sequentially after a four-week delay (h-αSyn + PFFs and GFP + PFFs). All rodents were subjected to a battery of behavioral tests at four-weeks intervals (i.e., week 4, 8, and 12 after the first injection). Twelve weeks after the first surgical session we performed electrochemical recordings for dopamine (DA) from three anaesthetized rats per group. After all data was collected, we either perfused the animals with PFA and harvested the brains for immunohistochemistry (5–7 rats per group) or we harvested the brains (three rats per group) for dissections of midbrain and striatum, and snap-froze the tissue for subsequent quantification of phosphorylated αSyn protein. A single rat was injected with the neurotoxin 6-OHDA for histological comparison.

Fig. 1.

Experimental layout. A) Description of the experimental groups and timepoints for behavioral test, electrochemical analysis, perfusions, and dissections. One group was injected with PFFs only (PFFs), two groups received either AAV-h-αSyn or AAV-GFP (AAV), two groups received AAV-h-αSyn or AAV-GFP and PFFs simultaneously (Sim.), and two groups received AAV-h-αSyn or AAV-GFP and PFFs sequentially (Seq.). B) Schematic of the pre-formed fibrils and viral genome expressing h-αSyn or GFP under the CBA promoter injected into the midbrain of rats. ITR, inverted terminal repeat; CBA, chicken β-actin; pA, polyadenylation site; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein; PFFs, preformed fibrils; MB, midbrain; ST, striatum.

Table 1.

Experimental groups. Schematic of the experimental groups and sample size for the analyses. Echem, electrochemistry; IHC, immunohistochemistry

Group Name	Description	AAV injection	PFFs injection	N Tot	Behavior	FRET	Echem	IHC
PFFs	PFFs only	–	week 0	8	8	3	3	5
h-αSyn	AAV only	week 0	–	8	8	3	3	5
h-αSyn/PFFs	Simultaneous	week 0	week 0	10	10	3	3	7
h-αSyn+PFFs	Sequential	week 0	week 4	9	9	3	3	6
GFP	AAV only	week 0	–	8	8	3	3	5
GFP/PFFs	Simultaneous	week 0	week 0	10	10	3	3	7
GFP+PFFs	Sequential	week 0	week 4	10	10	3	3	7

Preformed fibrils production

Human wild type αSyn was expressed in E. coli BL21 DE3 CodonPlus cells (Stratagene, San Diego, CA, USA) and purified and assembled into the fibrillar polymorph “Fibrils” as described previously [43]. Briefly, the protein (100μM) was incubated in 50 mM Tris–HCl, pH 7.5, 150 mM KCl at 37°C under continuous shaking in an Eppendorf Thermomixer set at 600 rpm for 5 days while withdrawing aliquots (20μl) at different time intervals, mixing them to Thioflavin T (10μM final) and recording the fluorescence increase on a Cary Eclipse Fluorescence Spectrophotometer (Varian Medical Systems Inc., Palo Alto, CA, USA) using an excitation wavelength = 440 nm, an emission wavelength = 480 nm and excitation and emission slits set at 2 and 5 nm, respectively. The assembly reaction completion was also assessed by sedimentation at 100,000 g at 25°C for 30 min and measurement of the amount of protein remaining in the supernatant. The fibrillar nature of αSyn was assessed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) after adsorption of the fibrils onto carbon-coated 200 mesh grids and negative staining with 1% uranyl acetate using a Jeol 1400 transmission electron microscope. The images were recorded with a Gatan Orius CCD camera (Gatan, Pleasanton, CA, USA). The resulting αSyn fibrils were fragmented by sonication for 20 min in 2 ml Eppendorf tubes in a Vial Tweeter powered by an ultrasonic processor UIS250v (250 W, 2.4 kHz; Hielscher Ultrasonic, Teltow, Germany) to generate fibrillar particles with an average size 42–52 nm as assessed by TEM analysis. The final fibrils concentration was quantified to be 350μM e.g., 5μg/μL. Fibrils were flash frozen in liquid nitrogen (6μl aliquots) and stored at –80°C until use. To defrost the samples, tubes were placed in a water bath at 37°C and incubated for 3 min. After incubation, samples were stored at room temperature and utilized within the same day.

AAV production

AAV was produced as previously described [44]. HEK293T cells were triple transfected with either CBA-human αSyn or CBA-GFP, pAAV2/9 and the helper plasmid pXX6. AAVs were purified by iodixanol ultracentrifugation gradient and concentrated using centrifugation columns (Orbital Biosciences). Titration was performed using digital droplet PCR (ddPCR) with primers specific for the ITRs (forward primer 5’-CGGCCTCAGTGAGCGA-3’ and reverse primer 5’-GGAACCCCTAGTGATGGAGTT-3’). The AAVs batches were diluted to a working titer of 6x10¹² gc/mL using modified PBS.

Stereotaxic surgery

Intracerebral injections were performed under general anesthesia using Isoflurane (Attane vet 1000 mg/g, VM Pharma AB) in a 2% air mixture. All working solutions containing viral vector and/or PFFs were prepared so that the final concentrations of viral vector and PFFs were 6x10¹² gc/mL and 2.5μg/μL, respectively. Animals were head-fixed in a stereotaxic frame with the incisor bar adjusted to the flathead position (–4.5 mm below the interaural line). Each solution was infused unilaterally into the midbrain using a pulled glass capillary attached to a 10μL Hamilton syringe. The following coordinates (from Bregma, in mm) and volumes were utilized: 2μL at AP = –5.3, ML = –0.8, DV = –7.5 and 2 uL at AP = –5.6, ML = –2.3, DV = –7.5 with an infusion rate of 0.5μL/min. After injection, the syringe was left in place for additional 3 min and thereafter slowly retracted. 6-OHDA was injected as described previously [45]. In brief, 5.41μg/μL 6-OHDA (calculated from free-base 6-OHDA-HBr salt, Sigma) was dissolved in 0.2 mg/ml ascorbic acid in 0.9% sterile saline and a volume of 3μL was injected at the following coordinates AP = –4.0, ML = –1.3, DV = –7.0. The injection speed was set to 1μL/min and the needle was left in place for an additional 3 min to allow for diffusion of the toxin.

Behavioral analysis

All behavioral assessment was performed at 4, 8, and 12 weeks after lesion by the same researcher, blind to the rats’ treatment group.

Drug-induced rotations

Rats were injected i.p. with 2.5 mg/kg d-amphe-tamine (Apotheksbolaget) and placed in automated rotameter bowels modelled after the design of Ungerstedt [6, 46]. All full ipsilateral and contralateral rotations, with respect to the side of injection, were quantified over 90 min. The data are presented as average rotations per minute.

Stepping test

Forelimb akinesia was assessed by quantifying forelimb adjusting steps as previously described [47, 48]. In brief, rats were constrained by the experimenter so that only one forelimb was freely movable. The animal was moved over 90 cm at a constant speed. The number of both backward and forward adjusting steps was counted three consecutive times for each paw. Out of the three trials, the best two trials, in terms of number of steps performed, were averaged, and adjusting steps data was presented as percentage bias.

Cylinder test

Forelimb asymmetry in exploratory behavior was assessed by placing the animals in a glass cylinder and recording with a digital video camera for a total of 5 min [49]. The number of right and left forepaw weightbearing touches for a total of 20 touches was counted post-hoc by a blinded researcher and the score was expressed as percentage bias. Two GFP/PFFs rats were removed from the final analysis of the Cylinder test at week 4, two h-αSyn rats, three GFP rats, one GFP/PFFs rat and one GFP + PFFs rat at week 8, three GFP rats, two GFP/PFFs rats and two GFP + PFFs rats at week 12 due to a failure to complete at least 15 touches.

Electrochemistry

In vivo electrochemical chronoamperometric recordings were performed as previously described [50, 51] using Nafion®-coated carbon fiber electrodes (∅ 30μm, L 150μm, Quanteon) coupled to FAST-16mkII hardware (Quanteon). DA release was induced by local injection of 220–240 nL KCl (120 mM, pH = 7.4) through a glass capillary connected to a picospritzer (Aldax) micropressure system (15–20 PSI for 0.1–0.5 s). The glass capillary was mounted ∼50–100μm from the electrode tip. Before the recording, each electrode was calibrated in 0.1 M PBS. Only electrodes with a linear response rate to three 2μM additions of DA (r² < 0.995) were selected. Moreover, only electrodes that displayed a selectivity of 1:100 over ascorbic acid and a limit of detection smaller than 0.01 MM DA were used [52]. During in vivo recordings, an Ag/AgCl reference electrode was used which was previously prepared by electroplating an Ag wire in NaCl-saturated 1 M HCl solution. High-speed (4 Hz) chronoamperometric recordings were performed by applying a square wave potential (+0.55 V; 0 V resting) and the resulting oxidation and reduction currents were analyzed using the F.A.S.T. analysis software. For each recording, the electrode-micropipette assembly was left in the recording site for at least 30 min to stabilize before 4 recordings were made at 10 min intervals.

Perfusion

Animals were given a terminal anesthetic dose of Sodium Pentobarbital i.p. and transcardially perfused by infusing approximately 150 mL of 0.9% saline solution at RT, followed by 250 mL ice-cold 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA, pH = 7.4) in 0.1 M phosphate buffer. After perfusion, the brain was removed from the skull and stored in 4% PFA solution for additional 24 h before being transferred into a 25% sucrose and 0.01% NaN3 solution where they were kept until they sunk.

Immunohistochemistry

Brains were sectioned on a freezing sledge microtome (Leica) at a section thickness of 40μm and collected in a 1:12 series. Sections were stored in antifreeze solution at –20°C until further use. The protocol for immunohistochemistry has been described elsewhere [53] and a list of the primary and secondary antibodies used can be found in Table 1. Briefly, tissue sections were washed (3x) in potassium phosphate buffered saline (KPBS, pH = 7.4) and then incubated for 15 min in 3% H₂O₂, 10% methanol in PBS to quench endogenous peroxidase activity. After (3x) PBS washes, sections were incubated for 1 h in blocking solution consisting of 5% serum in KPBS and 0.25% Triton X-100 (TPBS, pH = 7.4). The sections were then incubated in primary antibody in 5% serum overnight at room temperature. On the second day, sections were rinsed with (2x) KPBS and subsequently incubated in 5% serum for 1 h before being incubated for 1 h in secondary antibody solution in 5% serum. The secondary antibody was removed by (3x) KPBS washes and sections were incubated in avidin-biotin-peroxidase complex (ABC, Vectorlabs) in KPBS for 1 h. After an additional (3x) KPBS washes sections were incubated for 2–10 min in a peroxidase (HRP) detection system (Vector® DAB, Vector Laboratories). The sections were mounted on gelatine-coated glass slides, dehydrated in an ascending series of ethanol (70%, 95%, 99.5%, 99.5%) for 2 min each, followed by (2x) 2 min incubations in xylene to remove lipids and cover-slipped using DPX mounting medium. For fluorescence immunohistochemistry, the quenching step, the ABC incubation, and the DAB reaction were skipped; instead, sections were incubated for 1 h in fluorophore-conjugated secondary antibody, washed (3x) in KPBS, mounted onto gelatine-coated glass slides and cover-slipped as soon as dry using PVA/DABCO solution. When DAPI was needed, sections were incubated for 5 min at RT before the last washing step. Thioflavin S coloration was executed as described elsewhere [54].

Table 2.

Antibodies and dyes used in the current study for immunohistochemical analysis

Antibody	Species	Cat. no	Concentration
Human αSynuclein 211	Mouse	SC-12767	1:1000
GFP	Chicken	A10262	1:10000
αSynuclein, p-S129	Rabbit	ab51253	1:100000
αSynuclein 81A (p-S129)	Mouse	AB184674	1:10000
CD11b (Ox42)	Mouse	MCA275G	1:500
TH	Sheep	ab113	1:750–1:1000
TH	Mouse	MAB318	1:1000
VMAT2	Rabbit	20042	1:10000
Ubiquitin	Rabbit	AB7780	1:200
ThioflavinS	-	T1892	1:100
DAPI	-	D9542	1:2000
Anti-rabbit Biotinylated	Goat	BA6000	1:200
Anti-mouse Biotinylated	Horse	BA2001	1:200
Anti-chicken Biotinylated	Goat	BA9010	1:200
Anti-sheep Alexa 488	Donkey	A11015	1:500
Anti-chicken Alexa 488	Chicken	A11039	1:500
Anti-rabbit Alexa 488	Goat	A11008	1:500
Anti-rabbit Alexa 568	Goat	A11011	1:500
Anti-mouse Alexa 568	Goat	A11004	1:500
Anti-mouse Alexa 647	Donkey	A31571	1:500
Anti-rabbit Alexa 647	Goat	A21245	1:500

Proteinase K treatment

Coronal sections were mounted on permafrost-glass slides and were incubated in proteinase K solution (25μg/mL; QIAGEN) for one hour at room temperature before proceeding with the immunostaining for pSer129 as described above.

Dissections

Three rats per group were sacrificed by decapitation at 13 weeks post-injection. Brains were extracted, rinsed in 0.9% saline solution, and coronally sectioned using a rat brain matrix on ice. The striatum and midbrain from each hemisphere were dissected using sterile razor blades. Tissue samples were snap-frozen in isopentane on dry ice and stored in 1.5 mL Eppendorf tubes at –80°C until further processing.

Brain tissue homogenization

Frozen tissues were weighed in 2 ml Eppendorf tubes. The samples were diluted ten times in 150 mM KCl, 50 mM Tris–HCl pH 7.5 to obtain a homogenate at 10% (weight:volume). The homogenization was performed by sonication using the SFX 150 Cell Disruptor sonicator with a 3.17 mm microtip probe (Branson) for 15 s, with 1 s pulses followed by 1 s pauses in a biosafety level 3 environment (BSL-3). The homogenates were aliquoted and immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen before storage at –80°C. All contaminated surfaces were cleaned with SDS (1%) [55].

Protein quantification

The quantification by TR-FRET of phosphorylated αSyn at Ser-129 or aggregated αSyn was performed using a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) assay (Cisbio, France, cat #6FSYNPEG and # 6FASYPEG respectively). Briefly, the brain homogenates were diluted to 5% (W:V) in lysis buffer provided in the HTRF kit. For phosphorylated αSyn assay, 16μL of each diluted brain homogenates were loaded into a 96 well plate and mixed with 4μL of the FRET donor and acceptor antibodies in the kit. For aggregated αSyn assay, 10μL of each diluted brain homogenates were loaded into a 96 well plate and mixed with 10μL of the FRET donor and acceptor antibodies in the kit. The plates were sealed with a film (CmlAB, Denmark, cat #13076-9P-500) and incubated for 20 h at 20°C without shaking in a Thermomixer comfort (Eppendorf, Montesson, France). Time-resolved FRET was measured after incubation upon excitation at 337 nm using a plate reader (CLARIOstar, BMG Labtech, Germany) as described [56]. The HTRF signal was recorded at two different wavelengths (665 nm and 620 nm). The amount of aggregated αSyn was derived from the 665/620 nm fluorescence ratio and multiplied by 10000.

Densitometry

High resolution scans were taken with an Epson flatbed scanner at 600 DPI. The level of staining intensity was measured from 4 striatal sections (AP + 1.6, + 0.7, –0.26, and –0.6 mm) for αSyn211-DAB, GFP-DAB and TH-DAB and one midbrain section (AP: –5.6 mm) for OX42-DAB, using ImageJ software (NIH, Version 1.8.0). Before measurement, each image was transformed into grayscale 8-bit and calibrated using a step-tablet from Epson with known OD values using the Rodbard function (https://imagej.nih.gov/ij/docs/examples/calibration/). Correction for non-specific background was done by subtracting values obtained from the corpus callosum to the measured values. The regions of interest were outlined, and the grey-pixel intensity value average was measured. The data are expressed as optical density values of contralateral vs ipsilateral striatum or midbrain.

Stereology

Quantification of TH⁺ cells in the substantia nigra pars compacta (SNpc) was performed according to the optical fractionator principle using ImageJ Software (NIH, Version 1.8.0) [57]. In brief, z-stack images of every sixth series (section sampling fraction, ssf = 1/6) of the SNpc region were acquired at 20X magnification using a Leica DMi8 microscope, which yielded to 8–10 sections per animal. The average mounted section thickness (t) was 20 ± 2.6μm and the heigh of optical dissector (h) used was 12μm (3μm guard zones). Grid area was set at 170x170μm and the counting frame size at 55x55μm. A maximal coefficient of error (CE) of 0.11 for the intact side was accepted and animals with higher CE values were excluded from the analysis.

Axonal swellings quantification

Quantification of striatal axonal swellings was performed following αSyn211, GFP and TH DAB-IHC. Three high-resolution 63X z-stacks were taken from central, dorso-medial, and dorso-lateral regions of the striatum as previously described [19]. Each z-stack had a z-step size of 1μm for a total of 30 z-steps. The ImageJ 3D object count tool was used to identify the swellings and calculate their total number, as well as their volume, by setting an exclusion threshold for particles < 4μm³ and circularity between 0.5–1.0. The average number and volume size of swellings was calculated based on the total swelling number from all the three pictures from one animal and for Fig. 7M and 7O and Supplementary Figure 5G and 5I were divided in small (4–10μm³), medium (10–20μm³) and large (> 20μm³).

Fig. 7.

Axonal pathology in the ipsilateral striatum. Immunohistochemical analysis to investigate the presence of axonal pathology using antibodies for αSyn211 (A-C), GFP (D-F), and TH (G-L). Quantification of αSyn211⁺ (M,N) and GFP⁺ swellings (O,P) in the ipsilateral striatum. The quantified swellings were counted by total number (M,O) and volume size (N,P). PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM.

Statistics

All data were analyzed using the statistical software GraphPad Prism (V 8.4.3) using an alpha of 0.05 as threshold for determining statistical significance. For group and group by side analysis we performed analysis of variance with the factors Group and Side as dependent variables. For time-course analysis we performed repeated measures ANOVAs with the factors Week and Group. Post hoc testing used Sidak’s correction were applied to avoid Type 1 errors/inflating alpha due to multiple comparison testing.

RESULTS

In the current study we injected PFFs and/or αSyn overexpressing AAV either individually or in combination, simultaneous or sequentially after a 4-week delay, to induce a pathologically relevant level of neuronal cell loss in the midbrain of rats.

Injection of AAV-h-αSyn leads to strong overexpression of αSyn along the nigrostriatal pathway

We first assessed the expression of h-αSyn throughout the nigrostriatal pathway at 12 weeks following vector delivery. The groups injected with AAV-h-αSyn displayed strong αSyn immunoreactivity on the injected side of the midbrain with evident spread along dopaminergic nigrostriatal projections (Fig. 2A-D) with some diffusion into the contralateral hemisphere in the midbrain. The comparison of the staining intensity between the left and right striatum (Fig. 2E) for the four treatment groups showed that there was a significant difference in human synuclein immunoreactivity between the groups and the side of the brain analyzed (Groups^*Side, F_3,18 = 6.88, p < 0.01). All groups injected with AAV-h-αSyn displayed a similar degree of αSyn immunoreactivity which was absent in the group that received PFFs only (Sidak, all p < 0.0001). Triple immunofluorescent immunoreactivity for the enzyme tyrosine-hydroxylase (TH), the Vesicular Monoamine Transporter 2 (VMAT2), and αSyn211 (human αSyn) confirmed that the midbrain dopaminergic neurons of the PFFs-inoculated group did not express h-αSyn (Fig. 2F-F_iii), whereas all groups receiving the AAV-vector expressed h-αSyn throughout most of the midbrain dopamine neurons (Fig. 2G-I_iii). The lack of staining in the PFFs treated group is not surprising as the 211 antibody is directed against the C-terminal end of the human protein, which is known to be cleaved off rapidly [58]. Similar results were observed for the GFP expression in the control groups (Supplementary Figure 1A-C) where we observed a significant difference in GFP expression between left and right side (Side, F_1,13 = 67.40, p < 0.0001). Indeed, all groups that were injected with AAV-GFP displayed a similar degree of GFP immunoreactivity in the ipsilateral side compared to the contralateral side (Supplementary Figure 1D, Sidak, all p < 0.01). Triple immunofluorescence for TH, VMAT2 and GFP further confirmed that all the AAV-GFP injected groups were expressing GFP in midbrain dopaminergic neurons (Supplementary Figure 1E-G_iii).

Fig. 2.

AAV-vector overexpression. A-D) Representative midbrain and striatal sections for each group stained for human αSyn (αSyn211). E) Densitometric analysis comparing human αSyn211 staining intensity between contralateral and ipsilateral right striatum. F-I_iii) Triple immunofluorescence demonstrating colocalization between TH, VMAT2, and αSyn211 antibodies in SNpc. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; contra, contralateral; ipsi, ipsilateral; O.D., optical density. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM. (^****p < 0.0001).

Strong transgene overexpression results in TH downregulation in the striatum and midbrain

After confirming AAV-mediated expression levels, we investigated whether overexpression of h-αSyn was sufficient to induce a change in the nigrostriatal DA system. We performed immunohistochemical labelling on serial sections for the rate-limiting enzyme in dopamine production, TH, as a proxy marker for dopaminergic neurons (Fig. 3A-D) and demonstrate that in rats injected with the AAV-vector alone or in combination, but not with PFFs alone, there was an overt reduction in TH immunoreactivity in the striatum and midbrain ipsilateral to the injection. Optical density measurements in the striatum confirmed that there was a difference in TH staining intensity between groups and hemisphere (Fig. 3H, Group^*Side, F_3,17 = 12.04, p < 0.001). All three AAV-h-αSyn injected groups, but not the PFFs group, displayed a reduction in ipsilateral TH staining intensity which was on average by 52.86 % ± 5.12 (Fig. 3H, Sidak, all p < 0.0001). Surprisingly, we observed similar results when GFP was overexpressed (Fig. 3E-G). Densitometric analysis of the AAV-GFP injected animals revealed a significant reduction by 69.01% ±9.00 in TH staining intensity in the ipsilateral side (Fig. 3I, Side F_1,13 = 54.10, p < 0.0001, Sidak, all p < 0.01).

Fig. 3.

TH downregulation in striatum and substantia nigra. A-G) TH immunoreactivity from representative midbrain and striatal sections. H-I) Densitometric analysis comparing TH staining intensity between left and right striatum. J) Cell count of TH⁺ cells in the SNpc represented as number of TH⁺ cells between contralateral and ipsilateral SNpc. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein; ST, striatum; SN, substantia nigra pars compacta; O.D., optical density. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM. (^**p < 0.01, ^***p < 0.001, ^****p < 0.0001).

To quantify the degree of TH+neuron loss in the midbrain we performed unbiased stereological counting of TH immunoreactive cells in the midbrain in the ipsi- and contralateral SN (Fig. 3J). There was a significant difference in the number of TH immunoreactive cells in the SNpc between the groups and the brain side (Fig. 3J; Group^*Side, F_6,24 = 4.96, p < 0.01). All AAV-h-αSyn injected groups, but not the PFFs group, displayed a difference between the absolute TH⁺-cell numbers counted between the injected and non-injected side (Sidak, all p < 0.05). In particular, the TH⁺ cell loss in PFFs, h-αSyn, h-αSyn/PFFs, and h-αSyn+PFFs groups was –3.29% ±4.44, 31.10% ±3.29, 34.57% ±10.91, and 44.68% ±4.90 respectively. Quantification for the AAV-GFP injected groups revealed a reduction in TH⁺ cells in the ipsilateral side similar to that observed for the AAV-h-αSyn injected groups (Sidak, all p < 0.001). Specifically, the TH⁺ cell loss in GFP, GFP/PFFs, and GFP+PFFs groups was 46.38% ±15.72, 52.80% ±14.12, and 50.23% ±11.04 respectively. Although the TH⁺ loss in the three AAV-GFP groups seemed to be higher compared to the loss observed in the three AAV-h-αSyn groups, the comparison between counts in the ipsilateral side did not reach statistical significance (Sidak, all n.s.). Three h-αSyn/PFFs rats, one h-aSYN+PFFs rat, one GFP rat, three GFP/PFFs rats, and one GFP+PFFs rat were excluded from the stereological counting due to a coefficient of error (CE) bigger than 0.11.

Although TH is often used as a proxy marker for cell loss, it does not reveal whether the midbrain dopamine neurons have degenerated or whether there was a mere downregulation of expression as a result of αSyn pathology [27]. To address this question, we performed immunohistochemistry for TH and NeuN, a pan-neuronal marker. We observed both a loss of TH and NeuN immunoreactive cells ipsilateral to the injection in all groups injected with the AAV-h-αSyn alone or in combination with PFFs, but not in the PFFs-only group (Supplementary Figure 2A-D_ii). A comparison between the AAV-h-αSyn model and the 6-OHDA model showed that the loss of NeuN immunoreactive cells is not restricted to the anatomical location of the SNpc (Supplementary Figure 2E-E_ii). These observations suggest that the αSyn pathology caused a combination of TH downregulation and overt neurodegeneration.

Transgene overexpression results in behavioral impairments with or without additional insult with PFFs

Assessment of motor function was performed at 4, 8, and 12 weeks after the first surgery. To assess forelimb akinesia and asymmetry we performed stepping and cylinder tests, respectively. Unilateral depletion of dopaminergic signaling was assessed additionally through drug-induced rotation test after d-amphetamine injection and eventually through electrochemical detection of striatal DA release.

To facilitate the visualization of the seven groups in the behavioral analyses, graphs for h-αSyn (Fig. 4A, C, E) and GFP control (Fig. 4B, D, F) groups were kept separate; however, statistical analyses were performed with all groups together. Across the three post-injection timepoints, animals in the three AAV-h-αSyn injected groups and AAV-GFP injected groups displayed a bias to neglect the paw contralateral to the side of the lesion, whereas animals in the PFFs-alone group did not display a side bias (Fig. 4A, B). The deficit in the Cylinder test was slightly more pronounced at week 8 and 12 post-injection (Week, F_2,96  = 6.54, p < 0.05); however, this effect was not significantly different for the groups (Week^*Group, F_12,96 = 1.33, p = ns). Similar to the Cylinder test, animals in the AAV-h-αSyn and AAV-GFP injected groups performed fewer adjusting steps on the stepping test compared to their PFFs-only injected counterparts (Fig. 4C, D). Again, there was a significant effect of time (Week, F_2,112 = 11.08, p < 0.0001) with performance in week 4 being significantly less pronounced than that in weeks 8 and 12 (Sidak, p < 0.001), indicating a progressive phenotypic evolution of the behavioral deficit on this test. The most commonly used test to assess a unilateral depletion of dopamine is the drug induced rotation test. Here we injected the rats with 2.5 mg/kg d-amphetamine and recorded the rotational behavior for 90 min. As can be seen in Fig. 4E and F, a strong net contralateral rotational response was seen already at the 4 weeks timepoint for all the AAV-h-αSyn injected groups, whereas the PFFs-alone injected group did not display any rotational behavior and the AAV-GFP injected groups had a lower rotational response. Indeed, there was a significant effect of week (Week, F_2,112 = 3.19, p < 0.05). Over time, all groups maintained a stable behavioral phenotype, except for the h-αSyn + PFFs group which increased its rotational response at 8 and 12 weeks.

Fig. 4.

Behavioral impairments following h-αSyn and/or PFFs injection. A-F) Behavioral tests performed to assess motor function at 4-, 8-, and 12-weeks post-injection for Cylinder, Stepping, and Rotation test for the h-αSyn (circles, A, C, E), GFP (squares, B, D, F), and PFF (circles, A-F) injected groups, respectively. G) Electrochemical recordings (chronoamperometry) for KCl-evoked striatal DA release; black arrow indicates the timepoint of KCl application. H) Average peak amplitude, reflecting the maximum amount of dopamine available, for all the seven experimental groups. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein; w, weeks; s, seconds. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM. Note: the behavioral results of the PFFs group are duplicated in each graph for ease of comparison.

One major challenge of the protein overexpression model is the difficulty to establish clear histopathological thresholds for predicting behavioral impairments. Whereas in the classical neurotoxicant-based models (e.g., 6-OHDA) a loss of 70–80% of dopaminergic neurons is necessary to induce behavioral deficits, in the AAV vector-based models cell loss is not necessary to see behavioral effects. In the toxicant-based models, cell loss is a rather binary event where the cells are either in the process of dying or already degenerated. However, an important aspect of the vector-based models is that neurons can be still alive, albeit severely dysfunctional. To address the neuronal function, we performed electrochemical recordings to investigate the DA release and reuptake kinetics of the remaining dopaminergic fibers in the striatum. As can be seen from the representative traces of individual animals (Fig. 4G) local KCl application resulted in a reduced peak amplitude in all the groups compared to the PFFs only group. Overall, the peak amplitude, which reflects the maximum amount of DA available, was lower in all the AAV-injected groups compared to the PFFs only group (Fig. 4H). These results are in line with the behavioral deficits and TH downregulation and associated behavioral deficits reported above and suggest that surviving dopaminergic cells are dysfunctional.

h-αSyn overexpression and PFFs inoculation results in parkinsonian-like pathology and inflammatory response

In human PD, αSyn in Lewy bodies is subjected to post-translational modifications, such as phosphorylation and ubiquitination [59–61]. Moreover, it is known that αSyn fibrils are forming when αSyn assembles in repeated β-sheet structures, which can be recognized by amyloid-specific dyes such as Thioflavin S [62]. Accordingly, we investigated whether our samples displayed αSyn inclusions with similar histopathological features. pSer129 immunoreactive cells can be detected in the surviving DA neurons in the ipsilateral side in all four target groups (Fig. 5A-D_i, Supplementary Figure 3A-D_ii) but not in control groups (Supplementary Figure 3E-G_ii). Importantly, the phosphorylated αSyn inclusions found in all target groups receiving PFFs were resistant to proteinase K-digestion (pK), a feature that is a key characteristic of the Lewy body (Fig. 5A_i, C_i, D_i). Although there was a substantial amount of punctate pSer129-immunoreactivity in the AAV-h-αSyn group, after pK-digestion, only little immunoreactivity remained (Fig. 5B_i). Quantitatively, h-αSyn/PFFs and h-αSyn + PFFs treated groups showed levels of phosphorylated αSyn (Fig. 5E) and aggregated αSyn (Fig. 5F) in the ipsilateral midbrain comparable to that seen in the brains of human patients with Lewy body dementia or PD. The remaining groups displayed no significant amount of phosphorylated αSyn neither in midbrain nor striatum (data not shown). The lack of p-αSyn or aggregated αSyn in the striatum is not surprising as the timeframe of this study (12 weeks) is likely insufficient for the spread and seeding of pathological αSyn to target areas [37, 63].

Fig. 5.

h-αSyn overexpression and PFFs treatment results in Lewy-like midbrain pathology. A-D_i) pSer129 immunoreactivity in midbrain before (-pK) and after (+pK) proteinase K treatment. E, F) TR-FRET quantification of pSer129 (E) and aggregated αSyn (F) in the ipsilateral midbrain and striatum of rats and cingulate cortex of human samples. Black dots represent single subjects. G-J_iii) Triple immunofluorescence showing co-localization between pSer129 and Thioflavin S. K-N_iii)  Triple immunofluorescence showing co-localization between 81A (pSer129) and Ubiquitin antibodies. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; pK, Proteinase K; Ub, ubiquitin; ThioS, Thioflavin S; ST, striatum; MB, midbrain; CC, cingulate cortex. (A.U. = ratio 665 nm/620 nm multiplied by 10000).

Even though detectable levels of aggregated αSyn in midbrain were present only in h-αSyn/PFFs and h-αSyn+PFFs groups, all four target groups showed pSer129⁺ and ThioS⁺ inclusions (Fig. 5G-J_iii) and pSer/81A⁺ and Ub⁺ inclusions (Fig. 5K-N_iii), which resemble the histopathological hallmarks presented in human Lewy pathology.

It has been hypothesized that neurodegeneration in PD may result from inflammation in response to abnormal forms of αSyn [64, 65]. We therefore investigated whether our samples showed any alteration in the inflammatory response and particularly in microglia activation (Fig. 6A-G). The combination of h-αSyn and PFFs led to a strong microglial activation in the ipsilateral side of the midbrain (Fig. 6C_ii, D_ii). When comparing the Ox42 staining intensity between control side (Fig. 6A_i-G_i) and ipsilateral side (Fig. 6A_ii-G_ii) for the seven groups, using densitometry, we measured a significant increase in the injected hemisphere (Fig. 6H; Side, F_1,33 = 22.30, p < 0.0001). When compared to the PFFs only group, this increase was only significant for the h-αSyn/PFFs and h-αSyn + PFFs groups (Sidak, p < 0.05 and p < 0.01, respectively). Microglia of an amoeboid and bushy morphology, indicating a high level of activation compared to the ramified natural state, were present in high amount in animals that received both AAV-h-αSyn and PFFs, irrespective whether they were administered simultaneously or sequential (Fig. 6C_ii, D_ii, insets). This pronounced microglial activation was not detected in the control animals (Fig. 6E_ii-G_ii and H, Sidak, p = n.s.). Co-labelling of Ox42 and pSer129 (Supplementary Figure 4) showed a strong overlap between the inflammation marker and the marker for phosphorylated αSyn.

Fig. 6.

Inflammatory response. A-G) Overviews of rat midbrain sections stained for Ox42. A_i-G_ii) Close-up 20X images for Ox42 immunoreactivity in contralateral (A_i-G_i) and ipsilateral (A_ii-G_ii) side for target and control groups and additional 63X magnification images (A_ii-G_ii) for the ipsilateral side. H) Densitometric analysis showing the increase in percentage for Ox42 staining intensity in the ipsilateral midbrain (vs. contralateral) for target and control groups. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein; Ipsi, ipsilateral; Contra, contralateral. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM. (^*p < 0.05, ^**p < 0.01).

Axonal pathology is more pronounced in AAV-h-αSyn injected groups

The AAV injections caused a distinct dendritic pathology in the terminal fibers of midbrain dopamine neurons. In accordance with the behavioral and electrochemical data, pathological changes in striatal fibers are only seen in groups which received injections of AAV with or without additional PFFs, but not in the PFFs-only group. In high-magnification images of αSyn211 (Fig. 7A-C) and GFP (Fig. 7D-F) immunoreactivity, swellings can be detected in the three AAV groups, which are absent in the contralateral side of the brain or in PFFs-only rats (Supplementary Figure 5A-C). These swellings appear in single fibers and have a beaded chain-like structure as described previously [19]. In AAV-h-αSyn injected animals, this axonopathy could also be detected after immunohistochemistry for TH (Fig. 7G-I), while it was not detected for the AAV-GFP injected animals (Fig. 7J-L). Again, the contralateral side of the brain and PFFs only group (Supplementary Figure 5D-F) did not display any clear axonopathy.

Volumetric quantification of axonal αSyn211⁺, GFP⁺, and TH⁺ swellings further corroborated these observations. At first, we quantified the number of αSyn211⁺ and GFP⁺ swellings in target and control groups, respectively. Overall, AAV-h-αSyn injected groups had higher numbers of swellings than the AAV-GFP injected groups (Fig. 7M, O). The h-αSyn groups had 4465 ± 1030 αSyn211⁺ swellings per brain area analyzed, while GFP control groups had 969 ± 306 GFP⁺ swellings. As expected, PFFs only group did not show relevant numbers of αSyn211⁺ swellings (2 ± 2). We then divided the swellings in small (5–10μm³), medium (10–20μm³), and large (> 20μm³) volumes. Overall, the AAV-h-αSyn injected groups had higher number of swellings, independently from the size, than the AAV-GFP injected groups (Fig. 7N, P). Interestingly there was no difference in the quantity of small, medium, and large swellings within groups. Subsequently, we quantified TH⁺ swellings and obtained a proportionally similar outcome as in the previous quantification. Overall, AAV-h-αSyn injected groups had higher number of swellings than the AAV-GFP injected groups (Supplementary Figure 5G, I). Target groups had 808±206 TH⁺ swellings per brain area analysed, while control groups had 209 ± 124 TH⁺ swellings. As above, AAV-h-αSyn injected groups had higher number of TH⁺ swellings, independently from the size, than the AAV-GFP injected groups (Supplementary Figure 5H, L) with no clear difference in the quantity of small, medium, and large swellings within groups.

These findings clearly corroborate the observed functional impairments and are indicative of a stage where the dopaminergic cells might be still alive, but dysfunctional. As can be seen in the representative images in Fig. 7, and the volumetric quantifications and the striatal fiber density measures reported previously, the difference in the quantity of h-αSyn211/GFP positive fibers and TH positive fibers suggest a downregulation of TH in the striatum.

DISCUSSION

In this manuscript we present a direct comparison of AAV-mediated h-αSyn overexpression and inoculation with PFFs either in combination or alone, simultaneous or sequential. In doing so we utilized human protein in a rodent background in order to generate a preclinical rodent model of PD.

AAV-vector based overexpression of h-αSyn

AAV vectors are a preferred tool for protein overexpression in vivo providing spatiotemporal control, and they are widely used to generate preclinical models for PD. AAV-based strategies have gone through several generations of development, using a variety of serotypes, promoters, transgenes, and post-transcriptional elements. Additionally, differences between studies in terms of genome copies (gc) injected, volumes and coordinates have introduced a large variability in AAV-h-αSyn mediated histopathological and phenotypical outcomes [11, 12, 66]. Overall, the overexpression of h-αSyn by AAV vectors injected into the midbrain of rodents can lead to a loss of TH expressing midbrain dopamine cells and dopaminergic denervation of the striatum [18, 19, 23, 36, 50, 67–70]. Few studies have confirmed that loss of TH immunoreactivity represents overt neurodegeneration and not simply a loss of TH expression [19, 67, 68, 70]. As the levels of degeneration depend on the levels of overexpressed αSyn, there is a need for a vector expression system that achieves robust expression and subsequent degeneration in the majority of test subjects [19, 27]. In our current study, we injected 2.4x10¹⁰ gc of AAV9 carrying the CBA-h-αSyn construct and animals were tested over a time period of 12 weeks. We observed a stable behavioral deficit, loss of TH immunoreactivity in midbrain and striatum, neuronal cell loss in the midbrain, impaired DA release and reuptake kinetics, as well as relevant pathology such as TH⁺ and αSyn211⁺ axonal swellings. Moreover, we report the development of pSer129⁺, Ub⁺, and ThioS⁺ inclusions in midbrain indicating Lewy-like pathology.

The combinatorial effect of h-αSyn and PFFs

In the human condition one of the pathological hallmarks of PD is the formation of Lewy bodies and Lewy neurites in cortical and subcortical structures, with one of the major components being insoluble oligomers of h-αSyn assemblies [8, 71]. αSyn present in Lewy bodies is post-translationally modified, with phosphorylation at serine 129 and ubiquitination [59, 60] being among the predominant modifications. Additionally, αSyn fibrils can be recognized by Thioflavin S dye [62]. Pre-formed fibrils have been used in several model systems such as rats [37, 38, 40, 42, 72] and mice [41, 73] either alone or in combination with AAV-mediated overexpression of h-αSyn. As PFFs are cleared after injection they are most frequently being injected sequentially after a stable AAV-based overexpression of h-αSyn has been reached for efficient seeding [37]. However, more recent approaches aim for simultaneous injection of AAV and PFFs [40, 42], as this would negate the need for a second surgery.

In the current study, we compare for the first time the simultaneous and sequential strategies. Importantly, we did not observe significant difference between h-αSyn/PFFs and h-αSyn + PFFs groups, indicating that in our experimental setup the timing of PFFs delivery was not relevant in facilitating the development of αSyn pathology. We report pSer129⁺, Ub⁺, and ThioS⁺ inclusions in surviving midbrain neurons in all the groups injected with AAV-h-αSyn and/or PFFs implying the development of Lewy-like pathology. However, this was especially pronounced when AAV-h-αSyn and PFFs were combined, as demonstrated from the TR-FRET quantification of pSer129 +αSyn aggregates in the ipsilateral midbrain. These results can be explained by the fact that we utilized PFFs of human origin in order to better model the aggregation of this species of protein. The efficiency of human PFFs in seeding aggregation of endogenous rat αSyn is rather scant. Our experimental paradigm thus provides for a backdrop wherein one can study seeding and aggregation of the human protein on a rat background. Whereas previous work has largely focused on rodent PFFs which alone can induce αSyn pathology and neurodegeneration in rats [38, 40, 41, 73, 74]. In agreement, our data confirmed that human PFFs alone were insufficient to trigger pathology within 12 weeks, likely due to the inability to recruit of endogenous rat αSyn. Moreover, the seeding ability is highly dependent on the levels of αSyn expressed [75] and it is thus possible that the effects of the PFFs would be more pronounced with longer incubation times in the brain. In contrast, the combination of human αSyn and human PFFs facilitated rapid templating of both endogenous and ectopic αSyn [76], thereby accelerating the pathological timeline of the AAV-vector based overexpression model. One major, albeit valid, critique of AAV vector models is that the levels of αSyn necessary to induce the levels of degeneration leading to behavioral impairments exceed those seen in patients [19]. It is important to keep this limitation in mind and critically evaluate and apply models to the specific research question [27, 77]. Another interesting difference between the h-αSyn group and the three target groups that were injected with PFFs was the difference in phosphorylated αSyn after enzymatic digestion with pK. The addition of PFFs did produce more Lewy-like insoluble αSyn aggregates whereas the pSer129⁺ inclusions were eliminated in the h-αSyn only group following pK digestion suggesting that mere h-αSyn overexpression produces a distinct aggregation species from that originating from a PFF seed.

The combination of h-αSyn and PFFs also exerted a pro-inflammatory effect. Microglia are activated by h-αSyn aggregation and may play a crucial role in PD onset and progression [78]. In pathological conditions, activated microglia migrate to the injury site where they can both exacerbate or relieve disease progression. Our data show that the combination of AAV-h-αSyn and PFFs produced a strong inflammatory response in the side of injection, where microglia had a bushy and amoeboid morphology characteristic of their activated state. This reaction might be due to the high levels of phosphorylated αSyn aggregates present in the midbrain of these animals, as demonstrated by the TR-FRET quantification.

Loss of tyrosine-hydroxylase immunoreactivity and axonal pathology

The decrease in TH is clearly indicative of changes affecting dopaminergic neurons and several studies have shown that αSyn overexpression can lead to a downregulation of TH [27, 50, 79]. To address changes in the nigrostriatal DA system we first assessed the difference in TH immunoreactivity between the injected and the control striatum. Our data shows that h-αSyn overexpression, as well as GFP overexpression, with or without PPFs, induced a strong reduction in striatal TH immunoreactivity. This downregulation was absent only in the PFFs group. This can be indicative of TH downregulation or actual denervation. Corresponding to the striatal densitometry, unbiased stereology of TH⁺ cells in the SNpc demonstrated a loss of TH⁺ neurons ipsilateral to the injection for all the groups except the PFFs only group. A reduction in TH immunoreactivity does not causally demonstrate neurodegeneration, therefore we used double labelling for TH and the neuronal marker NeuN, confirming that the AAV-mediated overexpression does indeed lead to a loss of DA cells in the midbrain. Interestingly, the pattern of neurodegeneration appeared to spread beyond that seen with a typical 6-OHDA lesion which is specific to DA neurons.

It is important to note that the majority of preclinical rodent models of AAV vector based overexpression of αSyn has focused mainly on the loss of dopaminergic neurons alone, but axon loss and dysfunction is an early and predominant feature of PD which has been postulated to exhibit retrograde degeneration (as discussed in [80]). In the present study, AAV-h-αSyn injected animals, but not AAV-GFP injected groups, displayed an elevated number of axonal swellings in the dorsolateral striatum, the region which underlie motor function in PD.

Behavioral impairments

In humans, about 30 % of SNpc dopamine neurons and about 50–70% of striatal dopaminergic terminals are lost by the time of symptom onset [81–83]. In the present study we observed about 37% of TH loss in SNpc and 53 % in striatum of AAV-h-αSyn groups with evident dysmorphic axons, and 49% of TH loss in SNpc and 69% in striatum of AAV-GFP groups with low axonal dysmorphia. In our study, both treatment paradigms resulted in behavioral deficits, which remained stable over a period of 12 weeks. For the d-amphetamine induced rotations, most rats reached the behavioral threshold that is considered to be indicative of a well lesioned rat of five rotations per minute (rpm) at 8 weeks [84–86]. The threshold of 5 rpm as chosen here is considered quite conservative as similar studies had either lower “success” rates (e.g., 25% [11]) or used a more lenient threshold of 3 rpm (e.g., [19]). It is worth also mentioning that the rotational response to d-amphetamine seen in rats is neither a naturally occurring behavior, nor does it have a linear relationship with cell loss [84, 85]. Therefore, of interest are the non-drug induced behavioral tests, where we report distinct and stable lateralized deficits in paw use on the Cylinder test (20–50% bias) and on the Stepping test (20–50% bias) for all the groups except the PFFs only group. Similar deficits have been reported on the Cylinder test when overexpressing the A53T mutant form of αSyn [23]. An interesting aspect of the AAV vector model compared to the classic neurotoxicant-based models is the fact that the behavioral impairments cannot be easily ascribed to TH-cell numbers alone. In the AAV-based model, depending on the level of transgene expression, the neuron can persist in a dysfunctional state. Many presynaptic and axonal transport proteins are indeed downregulated before overt loss of dopaminergic fibers takes place [69] and striatal dopamine levels are significantly reduced as shown by HPLC [87]. As absolute cell counts do not provide an indication of the level of functional impairment, methods such as electrochemistry are valuable additions to the characterization of the model or intervention and warrant further investigation. On the other hand, in the neurotoxicant-based models neuronal death occurs rapidly and resembles an advanced disease stage. In our study the combination of TH loss, neurodegeneration, and axonal pathology were associated with impairments in DA release- and reuptake kinetics as measured by electrochemical recordings (chronoamperometry) in the striatum. Our results suggest a direct effect of αSyn on the functionality of dopaminergic axons, which is further supported by the impaired dopamine transmission reported by us and others [50, 88, 89].

In conclusion, the pathology observed in our model is more likely caused by a combination of axonal dysfunction, TH downregulation and actual neurodegeneration. In our own work we have compared several AAV-vector constructs and observed variable behavioral and electrochemical outcomes, even though the histopathology appeared similar and in agreement with previous studies [19, 37, 90]. Importantly, we did not observe any differences between the simultaneous or sequential addition of PFFs with respect to histopathology and behavioral phenotype.

GFP as a control protein in AAV overexpression studies

GFP is a commonly used control protein in AAV overexpression-based studies. However, it has been reported that GFP can induce in vivo toxicity and can lead to a decrease in TH immunoreactivity [27, 28, 30]. In order to mitigate this unspecific TH loss, some studies have been lowering the titer of the AAV-GFP compared to the AAV-h-αSyn [11, 36, 91], but this approach might not be ideal in studies where protein overexpression is used to cause cell loss. The levels at which GFP vectors become toxic are not clear, and it is difficult to determine the exact gc titer in which the αSyn construct is inducing pathology while the GFP control vector has no significant effect. Albert et al. (2019) [27] reported that the GFP vector becomes significantly toxic at 3.5x10¹⁰ gc whereas Landeck et al. (2017) [28] set this threshold above 4x10¹¹ gc. Differences in the experimental setup, vector construct and titration method do not allow for a direct comparison between studies, and it is therefore not possible to provide a precise estimate. From our own work we report neurotoxicity of h-αSyn and GFP at levels above 2.4x10¹⁰ gc, with minor dissimilarities between the two proteins. Differences between the present work and those reported previously may additionally come from the AAV quantification method utilized. ddPCR-based quantification is less variable than using qPCR, which can produce results varying of a factor of two or even more [92]. Therefore, in such studies where a qPCR-based quantification method was used, the actual titers might have been lower than those reported. In the present study, we injected 2.4x10¹⁰ gc of an AAV9 carrying the CBA-GFP construct. We observed a stable behavioral deficit, TH downregulation in midbrain and striatum and impaired dopamine release and reuptake kinetics similarly to what observed in AAV-h-αSyn injected animals. However, AAV-GFP injected animals displayed fewer levels of axonal swellings and absence of pSer129⁺ inclusions. Our results confirm that exogenous protein overexpression can lead to unspecific neuronal pathology when it exceeds a certain threshold. The use of GFP as control protein should be taken carefully as it can complicate the interpretation of results. Alternatives such as “empty” AAVs, or AVVs carrying an inducible genome or missing the transgene might be used instead of the prototypical GFP control [27, 93, 94].

CONCLUSION

We present here a direct comparison of synucleinopathy models which result in overt dopaminergic degeneration and reliably produce a stable behavioral phenotype. Importantly, the AAV9-CBA construct utilized in our work does allow for studies to be conducted within a reasonable timeframe where neuroprotective and restorative treatments are still a viable option. However, as stated above, the levels of protein expression needed to induce a stable behavioral phenotype makes the choice of an appropriate control vector difficult. In the current study, GFP overexpression was as toxic as h-αSyn overexpression and it therefore complicated the identification of the pathological effects specific to αSyn. The transgene overexpression led to stable behavioral phenotypes, TH loss, and changes in DA kinetics. However, the presence of h-αSyn induced relevant axonal pathology, and the addition of PFFs did generate additional cell body pathology that shares some of the characteristic of human Lewy bodies. Importantly, the simultaneous injection of PFFs led to a comparable model which avoids the confounding effect of repeated injection mechanical injury of the sequential approach. This model can represent a robust platform for the study of PD related h-αSyn etiology and the development of novel targets.

Supplementary Material

Supplementary Figure 1

AAV-vector overexpression in control groups. A-C) Representative midbrain and striatal sections for each group stained for GFP. D) Densitometric analysis comparing GFP staining intensity between contralateral and ipsilateral right striatum. E-G_iii) Triple immunofluorescence demonstrating colocalization between TH, VMAT2 and GFP antibodies. PFFs, preformed fibrils; αSyn, alpha-synuclein; contra, contralateral; ipsi, ipsilateral. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM. (**p<0.01, ***p<0.001).

Supplementary Figure 2

TH⁺ and NeuN⁺ cells in the ipsilateral midbrain. A-E_ii) Double immunofluorescence staining for TH and NeuN in the ipsilateral midbrain of the four target groups (A-D_ii) and of one representative 6OHDA animal (E-E_ii). White dotted ellipse delineates SNpc. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein; 6OHDA, 6-hydroxydopamine.

Supplementary Figure 3

TH-pSer129 colocalization in the injected midbrain. A-G_ii) Double immunofluorescence staining for TH and pSer129 in the ipsilateral midbrain of all the seven experimental group. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; GFP, green fluorescent protein.

Supplementary Figure 4

Ox42-pSer129 colocalization in the injected midbrain. A-D) Overview of rat midbrain section showing double immunofluorescence for the inflammation marker Ox42 and phosphorylated alpha synuclein pSer129 for the four experimental groups displaying phosphorylated αSyn. High magnification images from the side of injection are presented in A_i-D_i for Ox42 and A_iiD_ii for pSer129. PFFs, preformed fibrils; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein.

Supplementary Figure 5

Axonal Pathology. Immunohistochemical analysis to investigate the presence of axonal pathology using antibodies for i) αSyn211 in PFFs group ipsilateral side (A) and contralateral side of AAV-h-αSyn injected animals (B) ii) GFP in contralateral side of AAV-GFP injected animals (C) iii) TH in PFFs group ipsilateral side (D) and contralateral side of AAV-h-αSyn (E) and AAV-GFP (F) injected animals. (G-L) TH⁺ swellings quantification for target and control groups. Swellings were counted by total amount (G, I) and volume size (H, L). PFFs, preformed fibrils; GFP, green fluorescent protein; h-αSyn, human alpha-synuclein; Contra, contralateral. Data are expressed as mean ± SEM.

CONFLICT OF INTEREST

The authors have no conflict of interest to report.