Macrophage adaptation in airway inflammatory resolution

Abstract

Bacterial and viral infections (exacerbations) are particularly problematic in those with underlying respiratory disease, including post-viral infection, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and pulmonary fibrosis. Patients experiencing exacerbations tend to be at the more severe end of the disease spectrum and are often difficult to treat. Most of the unmet medical need remains in this patient group. Airway macrophages are one of the first cell populations to encounter airborne pathogens and, in health, exist in a state of reduced responsiveness due to interactions with the respiratory epithelium and specific factors found in the airway lumen. Granulocyte–macrophage colony-stimulating factor, interleukin-10, transforming growth factor-β, surfactant proteins and signalling via the CD200 receptor, for example, all raise the threshold above which airway macrophages can be activated. We highlight that following severe respiratory inflammation, the airspace microenvironment does not automatically re-set to baseline and may leave airway macrophages more restrained than they were at the outset. This excessive restraint is mediated in part by the clearance of apoptotic cells and components of extracellular matrix. This implies that one strategy to combat respiratory exacerbations would be to retune airway macrophage responsiveness to allow earlier bacterial recognition.

Short abstract

Re-educating airway macrophages that do not reset to baseline following severe inflammation http://ow.ly/NeMmM

Introduction

Airway macrophages are 95% pure in the healthy murine and human lung. These sentinel cells must select contradictory responses which are dependent on the requirement of the tissue at that time; such as inflammation to pathogens, or anti-inflammatory responses when clearing self-apoptotic cells and components of extracellular matrix turnover and degradation. Their function is exquisitely tuned by the airspace microenvironment which is rich in soluble (granulocyte–macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), interleukin (IL)-10, transforming growth factor (TGF)-β) and surfactant proteins and contact-dependent (CD200) immune-regulatory signals. Macrophages colonise the airways shortly after birth, originating from fetal monocytes [1], and are particularly long-lived compared to those from other sites [2, 3]. Due to current technical limitations in the ability to trace lineage, it is difficult to ascertain the percentage of turnover of tissue-resident macrophages. In addition, alveolar macrophages have a remarkable capacity for self-renewal, and it is suggested that they are replenished from circulating monocytes following their ablation by severe irradiation [4–7] or infection [8]. Alveolar macrophages are also unusual in that they express a unique repertoire of receptors [9]. These include CD11c, which is an integrin that is otherwise only expressed on mucosal macrophages such as those found in the gut [10], SiglecF, which has only previously been described on eosinophils [11] and Axl, which is not found on other macrophage populations [12].

The activation of alveolar macrophages must be tightly regulated to prevent unwanted immune responses to innocuous inhaled antigens, and this is mediated by both soluble factors in the lumen of the airways and through cell–cell interactions [9]. The dominant cell–cell interactions in the healthy airways are between alveolar macrophages and respiratory epithelial cells, including the bronchial epithelium as well as type I and type II alveolar epithelial cells, which can exert a range of immunomodulatory stimuli over macrophages. The human bronchial epithelial cell line BEAS-2B restricts alveolar macrophage responses in vitro through both cell contact- and soluble factor-mediated interactions [13] and exemplifies the complex crosstalk between the epithelium and luminal macrophages.

Negative regulators of alveolar macrophages

Alveolar macrophages are highly regulated to prevent unwanted inflammatory responses to innocuous inhaled antigens. This is achieved through soluble factors such as IL-10 and surfactant proteins A and D, as well as physical interactions between alveolar macrophages and the respiratory epithelium via CD200R and αvβ6-tethered TGF-β. Interactions between hyaluronan and CD44 may also inhibit Toll-like receptor (TLR) signalling through the induction of the TLR-negative regulators A20 and IL-1 receptor-associated kinase (IRAK)-M.

Little is known about airway macrophage heterogeneity or regulation following inflammatory resolution. Macrophages are significantly depleted during influenza infection. Replenishment occurs from the interstitial lung macrophage pool rather than from blood monocytes [14]. Though this return to immune homeostasis leaves an airway macrophage population essentially phenotypically identical to those at the beginning (CD11c⁺, CD11b intermediate, F4/80⁺, Siglec F⁺), their responsiveness is significantly dampened [15]. We referred to this inhibition as “innate imprinting” in 2004 [16], but more recently the concept of “trained immunity” has been proposed, whereby monocytes acquire a tolerant phenotype after stimulation that is associated with a switch from oxidative metabolism to glycolysis [17, 18]. Interestingly, this refractory airway macrophage response exists across a wide spectrum of pathologies (post-viral, allergic, fibrotic, etc.) in mice and humans, which implies that it is not driven by the “antigen” or immune response to it, but by specific features of the repairing lung.

Infection risk

The spectrum of pathologies in which we identified a refractory macrophage phenotype is coincidentally associated with recurring bacterial complications (exacerbations) leading to increased sepsis, hospitalisation, morbidity and death, and accounts for some of the most prevalent diseases in the world today. These patients account for a large fraction of overall cost, and most of the unmet need remains at the severe end of the disease spectrum. Despite the diversity in pathology, the bacterial species responsible for exacerbation of disease are remarkably reproducible, suggesting a common underlying deficient process(es). This is irrespective of the initial causative agent or the immune response induced.

Respiratory viral infection often causes bacterial complications that increase disease morbidity [8, 19, 20]. Bacterial species such as Streptococcus pneumoniae, Staphylococcus aureus and Haemophilus influenzae normally exist commensally within the lung, but can act as opportunistic pathogens during viral infection [21]. These secondary bacterial infections are sometimes termed superinfections, and are a leading cause of increased mortality following viral infection. During the 1918 “Spanish flu” and 1957 “Asian flu” pandemics, up to 20% of patients infected with influenza also harboured a secondary bacterial infection [22]. Post-mortem examinations revealed that during the 1918 pandemic >93% of deaths were associated with bacterial complications [23]. Similarly, a retrospective study of medical records from various United States army bases described an onset of bacterial infection 7–10 days after initial influenza infection in ∼20% of patients [24]. In addition, during the 2009 H1N1 pandemic, secondary bacterial infections accounted for 20–41% of deaths [25, 26]. While not as prevalent during seasonal influenza, bacterial co-infections still account for 40% of all respiratory viral infections resulting in hospitalisation [27].

Various animal infection models have confirmed the link between respiratory virus infection and susceptibility to secondary bacterial superinfection, but the complex underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood [28, 29]. It is likely that physical damage to the lung itself, long-lasting changes to innate immunity and synergistic interactions between virally infected host cells and bacteria all play a role in susceptibility to bacterial infection.

Mechanisms of susceptibility to infections

Whatever the mechanism following severe inflammation, negative interactions between alveolar macrophages and the airway epithelium increase. CD200R on alveolar macrophages and IL-10 are increased, both of which provide strong inhibitory signals [30, 31] and lead to heightened susceptibility to bacterial infections [32].

Overproduction of interferon-γ during viral infection impairs the phagocytosis of bacteria by alveolar macrophages, and reduces their expression of the bacterial scavenger receptor MARCO (macrophage receptor with collagenous structure) [33], and similarly the presence of type I interferons generated during influenza infection can limit antibacterial immunity [34]. Alveolar macrophage TLR responses are restricted for several months following the resolution of influenza, highlighted by reduced nuclear translocation of nuclear-factor (NF)-κB in response to the TLR5 ligand flagellin [15]. Depleting and regenerating the resident macrophage pool after viral infection restores antibacterial immunity [15], highlighting the importance of alveolar macrophages in the susceptibility to bacterial complications. Asthmatic patients can also suffer from bacterial complications, and increased susceptibility to bacterial infection is observed in mouse models of allergic airway disease. As with viral infections, this is associated with increased expression of the negative regulators such as CD200R on alveolar macrophages [35] (fig. 1).

FIGURE 1.

Resident alveolar macrophages in health (green) are influenced by the airway microenvironment to express a unique phenotype high in regulatory receptors that prevent responses to innocuous antigens. During inflammation airway macrophages are depleted and may be replaced in resolution by recruited monocytes that differentiate to macrophages and adapt to the airspace microenvironment (yellow). Generic processes include removal of extracellular matrix and efferocytosis of apoptotic cells. GAS: growth arrest specific protein; PS: phosphatidylserine; CCR: chemokine receptor.

Another contributing generic process relevant to all pulmonary inflammatory conditions is the need to remove apoptotic cells before they undergo secondary necrosis. The Tyro3, AXL and MerTK (TAM) receptor tyrosine kinase family [36] recognise phosphatidylserine on apoptotic cells via the bridging molecules protein S and growth arrest specific (GAS)-6 proteins. TAM receptors are expressed on phagocytic cells [36, 37] and inhibit inflammation during apoptotic cell efferocytosis via a negative feedback loop involving activation of suppressor of cytokine signalling-1 and -3 that in turn inhibit cytokine and Toll-like receptor signalling pathways [38–40]. Although inhibition of innate inflammation is essential to prevent autoimmunity during apoptotic cell clearance, prolonged engagement of TAM receptors may cause a state of unresponsiveness in antigen presenting cells required to clear pathogenic micro-organisms. To support this hypothesis, elevated GAS-6 plasma levels are observed in patients with severe sepsis [41, 42], and MerTK is elevated on monocytes from patients with septic shock, and is linked to an adverse outcome [43]. The consequences of these observations remain as yet unexplored. We have published several novel concepts that relate to TAM receptor function in the lung: 1) in health AXL is exclusively expressed on airway macrophages due to the presence of high levels of GM-CSF; 2) AXL-lacking human monocyte-derived macrophages (MDMs) can be induced to express AXL in the presence of GM-CSF; and 3) unlike AXL, the bridging molecule GAS-6 is exclusively expressed in macrophage-CSF-driven MDMs. It thus appears that macrophages either express AXL (and efferocytose apoptotic cells) or produce GAS-6 (and assist other cells in efferocytosis). This suggests a previously undiscovered functional dichotomy in macrophage subsets and that only those expressing AXL may be blunted in their response to bacteria (fig. 2).

FIGURE 2.

Axl is constitutively expressed on murine airway macrophages (MΦ). Granulocyte–macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), polyinosinic-polycytidylic acid (polyIC) or interferon (IFN)-α upregulate Axl expression to mediate efferocytosis of apoptotic cells. Axl signalling induces suppressor of cytokine signalling-1 and -3 which impair tumour necrosis factor receptor associated factor (TRAF)3, TRAF6 and Mal, required for Toll-like receptor-4 signalling. This prevents autoimmunity to self-proteins. However, ongoing removal of apoptotic cells causes macrophage insensitivity to subsequent bacterial infection.

Another process common to all lung inflammatory conditions is the alteration of the matrisome through damage and repair of extracellular matrix. Similar to apoptotic cell efferocytosis, clearance of self-matrix requires processes to prevent inadvertent autoimmune reactions. Damaged extracellular matrix provides cues to surrounding cells to drive a protective response. In a dysregulated state, the excess production of a pathological matrix is likely to contribute to chronic inflammatory conditions, aberrant airway macrophage training and subsequent bacterial exacerbation.

Concluding remarks

There is a real possibility that generic treatments may alleviate exacerbations common in inflammatory lung conditions. An over-regulated airway macrophage will not be able to alert the presence of a pathogenic micro-organism quickly. Thus, replacement of the initial mediators produced may be one strategy. This is supported by our observation that instillation of the neutrophil chemoattractant KC (keratinocyte chemoattractant) restores neutrophil recruitment and reduces bacterial load in allergic mice by several logs [35]. Alternatively, the fact that airway macrophages are so long lived presents a problem in that if they are over-regulated they will not be able to respond to a pathogenic micro-organism quickly. This suggests that macrophage replenishment may also be beneficial, i.e. repopulating the pool with less regulated macrophages so that they are more responsive and able to sense more readily a pathogenic micro-organism. However, this assumes that the defect or alteration is within the macrophage, but we believe the change is in the repaired epithelium/matrix and so any incoming macrophage would be similarly affected. Finally, extracellular matrix components, such as hyaluronan, dominates the airspace matrisome in a number of situations. This hyaluronan can be complexed to other self-proteins and, in some cases, assume the functions of that adopted protein. For example, the hyaluronan complexes with heavy chains derived from inter-α inhibitor catalysed by TNF-stimulated gene 6 [44]. The complex of inter-α inhibitor with heavy chains functions to limit complement-mediated phagocytosis [45] and so it is tempting to speculate that this function is transferred to hyaluronan during inflammation. Discovering the molecular mechanisms of macrophage adaptation in the airspaces has the potential to open entirely new avenues amenable to therapeutic intervention that target the host.