Cytokine Overproduction, T-Cell Activation, and Defective T-Regulatory Functions Promote Nephritis in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

Abstract

Lupus nephritis (LN) occurs in more than one-third of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. Its pathogenesis is mostly attributable to the glomerular deposition of immune complexes and overproduction of T helper- (Th-) 1 cytokines. In this context, the high glomerular expression of IL-12 and IL-18 exerts a major pathogenetic role. These cytokines are locally produced by both macrophages and dendritic cells (DCs) which attract other inflammatory cells leading to maintenance of the kidney inflammation. However, other populations including T-cells and B-cells are integral for the development and worsening of renal damage. T-cells include many pathogenetic subsets, and the activation of Th-17 in keeping with defective T-regulatory (Treg) cell function regards as further event contributing to the glomerular damage. These populations also activate B-cells to produce nephritogenic auto-antibodies. Thus, LN includes a complex pathogenetic mechanism that involves different players and the evaluation of their activity may provide an effective tool for monitoring the onset of the disease.

1. Introduction

Lupus nephritis (LN) is a major clinical manifestation of systemic lupus erythematosus that occurs in 15% of patients at diagnosis and in approximately 40% during the course of the disease. Renal biopsy is the gold standard for the diagnosis and follow-up, whereas the measurement of proteinuria identifies patients with overt renal failure, but fails to detect early silent disease. Thus, a better definition of the pathogenetic mechanisms leading to LN is required to identify effective markers of renal inflammation.

LN is generally attributed to an intriguing interplay between renal parenchymal cells and inflammatory cells recruited in consequence of the deposition and/or in situ production of immune complexes (ICs) [1]. ICs increase the production of cytokines, chemokines, and adhesion molecules which allow the progressive infiltration of macrophages, dendritic cells (DCs) and T-cells resulting in chronic renal failure [2]. Moreover, cytokines and chemokines secreted by cells infiltrating glomeruli further promote the migration of other inflammatory cells that are attracted toward the inflammatory sites in response to a concentration gradient [3, 4].

Notwithstanding SLE is considered a T helper- (Th-) 2 driven disease [5–7], experimental models of LN proved the primary role of Th1 cytokines for its development and severity, since large amounts of both interleukin- (IL-) 12 and IL-18 have been found within glomeruli of humans as well as in murine models of glomerulonephritis [8–11]. In parallel, high amounts of Th2 cytokines as IL-6 and IL-10 were found in sera of SLE patients with active disease, although they were not clearly associated with renal damage [12].

Macrophages and DCs are major producers of cytokines within glomeruli and their interaction with resident T-cells amplifies the renal inflammation. In this context, the impaired T-cell activation as altered function of DCs has been demonstrated in SLE, whereas DCs activate naïve T-cells and regulate the cytokine production, and the T-cell polarization [13]. It has been recently described as a defect of circulating DCs in parallel with their increased migration toward the kidney due to attractive stimuli promoted by glomerular IL-18, IL-1, and chemerin [14]. Thus, while glomerular IL-18 is nephritogenic since it recruits IL-18R⁺ DCs, these cells locally produce IL-12, interferon- (IFN-) γ and CXCR4 thus amplifying the immune-mediated glomerular damage. In addition, expansion of Th-17-producing cells and defective number and function of T-regulatory (Treg) cells have been demonstrated in LN [15].

Here, we review recent data on the key role of both Th1 and Th2 cytokines in LN and focus the defect of Th17 and Tregs in the modulation of inflammatory signals leading to the worsening of SLE renal function.

2. Pathogenetic Relevance of T-Cell Function in Lupus Nephritis

Derangement of T-cell function has been demonstrated in SLE in parallel to abnormal cytokine production associated to loss of immune tolerance, increased antigenic load, and defective B-cell suppression. A large number of studies suggested that SLE is a Th2-driven disease [5–7]. However, elevation of both Th1 and Th2 cytokines occurs in both humans and mice suggesting that SLE is a complex disease driven by different lymphocyte subsets [8] with high heterogeneity of clinical manifestations and organ involvement (Figure 1).

Figure 1.

Representation of pathogenetic mechanisms of lupus nephritis. LN is a disease that includes several mediators of glomerular inflammation. In this context, T-cell subsets, through the production of nephritogenic cytokines or by cooperating with B-cells, macrophages, and dendritic cells promote the activation of the glomerular immune response.

2.1. T-Cell Activation

T-cells play a crucial role in the pathogenesis of experimental and human LN, since they activate B-cell functions including the production of nephritogenic antibodies and the modulation of T helper immune response. Moreover, T-cells infiltrate the glomeruli and promote either direct cytotoxicity or recruit other inflammatory cells as macrophages and DCs [16]. Many studies suggested an imbalance in T-cell subsets, and reported an increase of CD4⁺ cells with respect to CD8⁺, altered Th1/Th2 cytokine production, and raise of the circulating CD4⁻/CD8⁻ subset. In this context, murine α/β and γ/δ CD4⁻/CD8⁻ cells induce B-cells to produce both anti-dsDNA and antichromatin antibodies and thus have been considered the major inducer of renal failure in experimental SLE [17–19]. Moreover, disruption of T-cell signals in experimental LN by depletion of α/β T-cells or by blocking the CD40/CD40 ligand cascade, delays the inflammatory state of LN and improves the proteinuria with reduced glomerular accumulation of both inflammatory cells and nephritogenic antibody [20]. In addition, γ/δ T-cells and CD16/CD56 natural killer cells cooperate in lupus, since MLR/lpr mice lacking these populations develop severe nephritis associated with polyclonal CD4⁺ T-cell expansion [21]. Thus, it is conceivable that CD4⁺ T-cells exert a negative regulatory function.

A parallel defective function of T-cell suppressor has been demonstrated. In fact, peripheral CD4⁺/CD25⁺ Tregs are reduced in patients with active LN, and expansion of this population through tolerogenic peptides strongly delays nephritis as well as the production of auto-antibodies by B-cells [22]. Since T-cell subsets produce different cytokines in response to inflammatory stimuli, their measurement is considered an effective tool for explaining the pathogenetic mechanisms of LN.

2.2. Cytokine Imbalance in Lupus Nephritis

Most of information concerning the pathogenetic role of cytokines in LN derives from murine models relevant for investigating the disease mechanisms under defined experimental conditions. In particular, knock-out mice for either cytokines and/or cytokine-receptors emphasized the role of IFN-γ and IL-12 [23], since treatment with relative neutralizing antibodies prevents renal disease in NZB/W mice, while IFN-γ receptor^−/− MRL/lpr are protected from glomerulonephritis and show defective anti-dsDNA production [24]. Moreover, these mice strains show high IL-12 production, whereas those defective for the cytokine are protected from LN through inhibition of both IFN-γ and IL-18 production. Other studies defined the IL-18 functions in MRL/lpr mice and demonstrated that its glomerular accumulation occurs in patients with proliferative glomerulonephritis and correlates with the infiltration of IL-18R⁺ DCs [8, 10, 25].

However, the majority of therapeutic approaches in humans with biologic or genetic modulation of cytokine production provided inconsistent results. This was at least in part attributed to the identification that IL-23 and IL-27 [26], additional members of the IL-6/IL-12 family may amplify the Th1 immune response through expansion of the CD4⁺ Th17⁺ cells [27]. Th17 cells develop under the influence of IL-6, TGF-β, and IL-23, and produce IL-17 [28]. Recently, the urinary expression of Th17 related genes has been demonstrated in patients with LN and thus further studies might be relevant for explaining its role to human LN.

We have recently provided evidence that production of Th1 over Th2 cytokines occurs in active LN, since a defect of both IL-6 and IL-10 counterbalances elevations of IFN-γ, IL-12, and IL-18 in both sera and urine in the majority of patients.

IL-6 is a pleyotropic cytokine produced by a large variety of cells that primes the differentiation of B-cells into antibody-producing cells as well as the differentiation of T-cells to effector cells and the activation of macrophages. IL-6 promotes the proliferation of renal mesangial cells in mice and several studies report IL-6 as a critical mediator of tissue damage for its ability to stimulate the production of nephritogenic antibodies in humans [29]. Moreover, it has been reported that urinary excretion of IL-6 is elevated in patients with active LN, whereas it declines during the treatment [30]. These studies, however, have not demonstrated a definite relationship between serum and/or urinary IL-6 overproduction in renal disease. As shown in Figure 2(a), we demonstrated in patients with SLE a remarkable increment of serum IL-6 with respect to normal subjects (P < .05). However, both serum and urinary IL-6 levels derived from LN patients were not associated with the presence of renal injury, although they were increased in patients with high levels of anti-dsDNA and antinuclear antibodies (Figure 2(b)). This suggests the potential role of IL-6 for the stimulation of auto-antibody production by B-cells, rather than acting as direct mediator of glomerular inflammation.

Figure 2.

Th1/Th2 cytokine profile in SLE. (a) Patients with LN (n = 69) produced large amounts of both IL-12 and IL-18, both in sera (black column) and urine (gray column). By contrast, those with different organ damages (n = 181) excluding LN, showed the highest production of IL-6 and IL-10. (b) IL-6 was overproduced in patients with high levels of anti-dsDNA antibodies independently from the presence of LN. Other cytokines were poorly associated with nephritogenic antibody production.

IL-10 has also been extensively studied. It is a key factor in regulating auto-antibody-secreting B-cell activity and promotes B-cell differentiation [31]. Elevated levels of serum IL-10 occur in SLE, although the treatment with anti-IL-10 monoclonal antibody failed to restore the disease activity in the majority of patients [32]. Moreover, IL-10 elevation occurs in different clinical conditions associated to SLE and a specific association with organ damage has not been definitively elucidated. Our data are in agreement with these results for the high levels of serum IL-10 (P < .05) in both patients with and without LN, whereas elevations of urinary IL-10 were revealed in those with minimal glomerular lesions. Thus, we concluded that overexpression of IL-10 in SLE may reflect an intrinsic defect of the cytokine homeostasis. However, it remains unclear whether elevations of IL-10 are a cause or, rather, an effect of this dysregulation.

Measurement of Th1 cytokines (Figure 2(a)) provided different results, since both IL-12 and IL-18 were strongly overexpressed in LN (410 ± 90 and 618 ± 105 pg/ml), correlated with IFN-γ overproduction (P < .05), and increased in their concentrations within the kidney of patients with proliferative glomerulonephritis. Parallel analyses revealed a large number of IL-18R⁺ DCs in glomeruli infiltrated by IL-18⁺ cells, thus suggesting that the cytokine also exerts a potent chemoattraction of inflammatory cells expressing the functional receptor. Additional studies also demonstrated a peculiar association between both serum and urinary IL-12 with serum IFN-γ (P < .05) in LN. In this context, presence of urinary neopterin as a bioactive marker of serum IFN-γ production further supported the Th1 predominance in kidney inflammation.

3. Interleukin-17 Producing T-Cells

IL-17 is a 17-kDa transmembrane protein that includes six members and five receptors mostly produced by activated T-cells. Although the downstream signals activated by IL17R remains to be elucidated, it has been recently shown that its stimulation activates both the nuclear factor kB and MAP kinase cascades [27]. IL-17 exerts a potent proinflammatory activity in parallel with functional recruitment of macrophages and neutrophils within inflamed tissues through the overproduction of IL-8 and monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 [33]. This cytokine also allows the expression of adhesion molecules by T-cells as well as the production of IL-6 and GM-CSF. Lastly, IL-17 synergizes with IL-1β, tumor necrosis factor- (TNF-) α and IFN-γ, and amplifies the Th1 immune response in autoimmune disorders [34].

IL-17 is mostly produced by CD4⁺, CD8⁺, CD4⁻/CD8⁻, and γ/δ T-cells, and the CD4⁺ T-cell effector subset, namely the Th17 cells, has been distinguished from other T helper populations for the specific origin, differentiation, and cytokine production. Recent studies demonstrated the involvement of Th17 cell in the pathogenesis of SLE, since NZB/NZW_F1 mice produce relevant amounts of the cytokine while IL-17 producing T-cells largely infiltrate the nephritic kidneys of these mice [35]. By contrast, treatment with anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies delayed the renal damage with concurrent defect of IL-17 production in both serum and glomeruli [36]. Parallel studies in lupus-prone mice described that presence of IL-23 as necessary for the development of a pathogenic Th17 functional immune response. In fact, IL-23 increases the IL-17 production by memory T-cells, thus suggesting a novel T helper functional axis formed by IL23/IL-17 interaction, almost similar to the IL-12/IFN-γ system. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that the majority of IL-17 producing T-cells arises from the CD3⁺/CD4⁻/CD8⁻ subset, that is the typical population revealed in nephritic glomeruli from MRL/lpr mice. Therefore, this cell population is considered an active mediator of renal cytotoxicity [37, 38]. It is conceivable that IL-17⁺ T-cells amplify the inflammatory signals activated by other Th1 cytokines. In this context, its inhibition by targeted therapies should represent a novel option for the treatment of patients with overt renal disease.

4. Regulatory T-Cells and Dendritic Cells in Lupus Nephritis

Regulatory T-cells (Tregs) are a heterogeneous population of CD4⁺/CD8⁺/CD25⁺ cells differentiated in two subsets in relation to the expression of Foxp3 transcription factor. The Foxp3⁻ population includes both IL-10-producing Tregs and Th3 cells that express the transforming growth factor- (TGF-) β. By contrast, Foxp3⁺ Tregs play a protective role in autoimmunity since they regulate the efficiency of the immune response. Notwithstanding Foxp3 is not necessary for the differentiation of Tregs, its expression prevents T-cells to differentiate into Th17 proinflammatory effector T-cells [39]. This is consistent with the accelerated autoimmune manifestations observed in mice depleted of Foxp3⁺ Tregs or in humans characterized by a genetic mutation of the Foxp3 gene [40]. Similarly, natural Tregs exert a protective effect in lupus-prone mice, since depletion of CD4⁺/CD25⁺ cells in NZB/NZW_F1 accelerates the onset of LN, whereas their transfer into CD4/CD25 knock-out mice delays the glomerulonephritis development. Moreover, high IL-6 production may interfere with Treg function and promote their switch toward Th17-producing cells [41]. In addition, stimulation and activation of DCs in nephritic glomeruli are promoted by interferons while limiting both expansion and protective functions of Tregs in SLE. Thus, although Tregs play an apparent primary role for the homeostasis of the immune system in SLE, the mechanisms leading to their depletion are unclear [42]. It has been suggested that defective number of peripheral Tregs in lupus promotes T- and B-cell hyperactivity while recent studies have attributed this defect to dysfunctional DC activation. For this reason, the restoring of the balance between immunogenic and tolerogenic DCs may represent a mechanism for the inhibition of IL-17 cytotoxicity and the correction of Treg defect during the active phases of LN.

Defective DC function and glomerular accumulation of these cells in LN are regarded as a consequence of their increased recruitment from peripheral blood in response to chemotactic stimuli [10, 43]. DCs interact with renal parenchymal cells through the activation of toll-like-receptors, FC-receptors, c-type lectins, and scavenger receptor, that, once stimulated by either cell-to-cell contact or paracrine signals, accelerate the enrollment of NK, T-cells, and γ/δ lymphocytes in inflammatory sites [44]. Furthermore, DCs exhibit the hallmark of well-equipped antigen-presenting cells in presence of peculiar costimulatory molecules and chemokine profile. In this scenario, presence of DCs within nephritic glomeruli supports their pathogenic effect. This aspect may thus explain why recent therapeutic approaches aimed to their functional disabling, ameliorate nephritis in rodents [45].

5. Conclusions

Recent data from experimental and human LN provided new insights to the role of cytokine interplay in the pathogenesis of renal damage. In this context, a cutting-edge on the Th1 deregulation has been demonstrated and both IL-12 and IL-18 exert a major nephritogenic role. However, further studies are needed to clarify the interplay of other mechanisms including both Th17 expansion and defective Treg function within inflamed glomeruli. Therefore, development and progression of renal failure in SLE is an event that involves multiple players whose regulation by novel-therapeutic strategies might prevent the progressive worsening of LN.