Abstract
Dielectric nanosphere arrays are considered as promising light-trapping designs with the capability of transforming the freely propagated sunlight into guided modes. This kinds of designs are especially beneficial to the ultrathin hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) solar cells due to the advantages of using lossless material and easily scalable assembly. In this paper, we demonstrate numerically that the front-sided integration of high-index subwavelength titanium dioxide (TiO2) nanosphere arrays can significantly enhance the light absorption in 100 nm-thick a-Si:H thin films and thus the power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) of related solar cells. The main reason behind is firmly attributed to the strong scattering effect excited by TiO2 nanospheres in the whole waveband, which contributes to coupling the light into a-Si:H layer via two typical ways: 1) in the short-waveband, the forward scattering of TiO2 nanospheres excite the Mie resonance, which focuses the light into the surface of the a-Si:H layer and thus provides a leaky channel; 2) in the long-waveband, the transverse waveguided modes caused by powerful scattering effectively couple the light into almost the whole active layer. Moreover, the finite-element simulations demonstrate that photocurrent density (Jph) can be up to 15.01 mA/cm2, which is 48.76% higher than that of flat system.
Although conventional hydrogenated amorphous silicon (a-Si:H) thin-film solar cells (TFSCs) encountered resistance of continuous improvement in efficiency, a-Si:H solar cells (SCs) with a relative thinner intrinsic layer are still of great interest because of many inherent advantages such as lower cost, high throughput, reduced detrimental Staebler-Wronski degradation effect1, as well as the numerous derivative applications in semi-transparent SCs2, top-sided sub-cells for tandem SCs3, flexible SCs4, etc. By scaling down the thickness of the active layer, the carrier transport loss is significantly decreased, and thus contributing to a good performance of the internal quantum progress inside the SCs. However, as light absorption is usually proportional to the film thickness, the ultrathin absorber thus appeals for advanced light-trapping strategies. For ultrathin a-Si:H layer (for example, 100 nm or less), the commonly used light-trapping option of textured transparent conducting oxide (TCO) with depth around several hundred nanometers (wavelength-scale) may cause severe degradations in efficiency, due to the leakage problem relates to the unsatisfied coating of a-Si:H. Alternatively, the emerging light-trapping schemes without structuring the active material, like photonic crystals (PC)5,6,7, plasmonics8,9,10, whispering gallery modes (WGMs)11,12,13,14,15 have been proved to be efficient ways to substantially improve the light-harvesting efficiencies by coupling incident light into the underlying absorber layer.
WGMs that are excited in the periodically arranged dielectric nanospheres can be coupled into particular modes of the solar cell and significantly enhance its efficiency by increasing the fraction of incident light absorbed16. As mentioned by Grandidier et al.11, through the use of wavelength-scale resonant SiO2-dielectric nanospheres, the highest current density of Jph = 14.14 mA/cm2 can be achieved on 100 nm-thick a-Si:H TFSCs, representing an enhancement of 15% compared to the flat reference together with a well-designed antireflection coating. The broadband enhancement was explained when considering the spheres as a textured antireflection coating. Besides, as indicated by Wang et al. that the conversion efficiency can be improved from 8.10% to 9.89%, by introducing GaP (refractive index: n > 3) scatterers on the top surface of the flat a-Si:H TFSCs17. The underlying enhancement was attributed to the antireflection coating based on the excitation of a Mie resonance and the coupling of incident light into the waveguide modes by excited optical resonance, which both can greatly increase the light path in the active layer. However, the contribution to the photocurrent density is not satisfactory enough and the enhanced mechanism is also not very clear. Based on a fundamental theory of light management for SCs, Brongersma et al. proposed that the mechanisms on outstanding light-trapping can be classified as follows: 1) Fabry–Perot (FP) standing-wave resonance caused by the confinement light between top surface and the back-reflector; 2) optical (Mie) resonance, which is hybridized with a guided resonance in the underlying active layer; 3) guided resonance results from the periodic grating that ensures phase-matched coupling of a normally incident plane wave to a waveguided mode of the active layer; 4) diffracted modes, which are usually excited under oblique angle18. Specific to the case of light-harvesting by assembling high-index dielectric nanospheres, a quantitative analysis and a more detailed cognition are eagerly needed.
In this letter, we propose a new design by employing TiO2 (high index, n ≈ 2.7) dielectric nanospheres arrays (subwavelength scale) on top of a 100 nm-thick a-Si:H layer. The detailed simulation results show that absorption efficiency is significantly improved over a broad spectral band, leading to the photocurrent density increased from 10.09 mA/cm2 (flat design) to 15.01 mA/cm2. The optimized TFSCs exhibit a light-conversion efficiency up to 10.53%, which is improved by 43.85% over the flat counterparts. More importantly, the underlying mechanism for excellent light-trapping is attributed to scattering effect of the TiO2 nanospheres, judging by the direct evidence of exactly well-matched spectrum in scattering and absorption in the whole waveband. Combinational effects of the forward Mie scattering in the short-wavelength and waveguide modes excited by strong omnidirectional scattering in the long-wavelength clearly contribute to coupling the light into active layer and thus effectively increase the optical-path. Therefore, our work not only presents a novel and efficient strategy to design high performance TFSCs without active-layer structuring, but also resolves and confirms the optical coupling mechanism on high-index dielectric nanospheres, imposing a certain significance to manage the light for SCs.
Figure 1(a,b) describe the schematic diagrams of the proposed a-Si:H TFSCs under a superstrate configuration, which is made up of a tetragonal array with arranged TiO2-nanospheres, an indium tin oxide layer (ITO, 80 nm), an ultrathin photoactive region (a-Si:H, 100 nm), an aluminum-doped zinc oxide layer (AZO, 130 nm) and a back silver reflector11,19. TiO2 nanospheres are packed by an 80 nm ITO antireflective layer, with the aims to achieve outstanding impedance-match effect and to form electrical contact. With the optical constants from Palik20, we perform three-dimensional (3D) electromagnetic simulations by solving the Maxwell’s equations based on finite-element method (FEM)21. Specially, the optical constants (including the refractive index n and extinction coefficient k) for each materials were plotted in the Fig. S1 (supplement information). The photocurrent density (Jph) by spectrally integrating the absorption efficiency (Pabs) (weighted by AM 1.5 G) is used to evaluate optical performance of the SCs22.
To identify the optimal design, a complete screening of the featured parameters including the lattice constant (P) and the diameter (D) of TiO2 nanospheres is carried out. Figure 1(c,d) plot the Jph as a function of P (blue line) and D (red line), respectively. As reported previously, the subwavelength scale dielectric spheres can readily excite the resonance modes, so we tentatively fix D = 200 nm when sweeping P from 360 to 900 nm23. It is shown that Jph tends to rise and then drop with a peak of 14.96 mA/cm2 at P = 510 nm. We then vary D from 0 to 600 nm with the same space of adjacent TiO2 nanospheres (i.e., P − D = 310 nm). Specially, as D = 0 nm, the TiO2 nanospheres are not presented at the front surface of SCs, so that it degrades to the conventionally flat system. With the increase of D, Jph is substantially improved, especially when D > 150 nm. The maximum Jph of 15.01 mA/cm2 occurs at D = 210 nm, with an enhancement of 48.76% compared to 10.09 mA/cm2 of flat reference (planar a-Si:H coated with 80 nm ITO). The improvement ratio of Jph (48.76%) in our device is far beyond than that of wavelength-scale dielectric nanospheres design (WGMs) one (15%) in ref. 11. Here, we need to point out that the thickness of AZO and ITO is not the optimal design for both the flat and nanosphered TFSCs. The two coating layers were defined exactly same as ref. 11, a classical demonstration on WGM and a good reference to our design, for direct comparison purpose. The 3D plot of calculated photocurrent density (Jph) as a function of the thickness of AZO and ITO are shown in the Fig. S2 (supplement information).
Above photocurrent density values validate that strong optical enhancement can be achieved by properly setting parameters in the proposed device. We now examine the absorption spectral responses of the flat and proposed design in Fig. 2(a), where D = 210 nm and P = 510 nm for TiO2-nanosphered configuration are considered. Besides, the nanospheres design without ITO coating is also plotted as a comparison. As shown in Fig. 2(a), the optical absorption efficiency of the TiO2-nanosphered design with ITO coating is improved for λ > 370 nm, showing an almost full-spectral enhancement compared to the flat and solely TiO2-nanosphered design (without ITO coating). Obviously, the presence of the ITO coating upon TiO2 nanospheres contributes to the suppression of the reflection in the short-waveband and increase of the optical path in the long-waveband. The results demonstrate that the ITO coating plays a crucial role in coupling incident-light into SCs. The relatively weak optical response at λ < 370 nm, which is caused by strong parasitic absorption in TiO2 nanospheres and ITO layer, gives negligible contributions to the Jph because the absorptions in this range are almost invalid to a-Si:H. However, attention should be paid on the long-wavelength range (λ > 550 nm), where the Pabs of flat a-Si:H TFSC is monotonously decreased due to the degenerative material-extinction coefficient, but the light-trapping capacity is dramatically improved by introducing TiO2 nanospheres arrays atop. For instance, at λ = 580 nm, Pabs = 41.67%, 67.66% and 80.45% for flat, TiO2 nanospheres with and without ITO coating systems, respectively. Especially, at the wavelengths close to the bandgap, taking λ = 720 nm for example, Pabs can be up to 40.34%, more than twenty times that of the flat (1.37%) and the design without ITO coating (1.76%) designs.
For correlation purpose, the scattering spectra of the TiO2 nanoshperes under the same configuration (i.e., D = 210 nm and P = 510 nm) is plotted in Fig. 2(b).In this simulation, the scattering efficiency (Qsca) is calculated by integrating energy flux densities under the entire surface area of nanosphere. Detailed information in this regard is presented in the formulas and Fig. S3 in the supplement information. As λ < 380 nm, the Qsca is relatively low and smooth due to the parasitic loss of the TiO2 and ITO, which weaken the intensity of incident light and thus has negative effects on the scattering of TiO2 nanospheres. At 380 nm < λ < 540 nm, the dielectric TiO2 nanospheres together with the ITO layer act as a perfect antireflection layer, leading to slight increase in Qsca. This implies that the scattering efficiency is positively correlated with the absorption ability. While, as λ > 540 nm, Qsca is significantly oscillated, benefiting from the secondary or repeated reflection light from the bottom reflector. The resonance wavelengths of the absorption peaks in the long-wavelengths range match well with that in the scattering one (see the vertical black-dotted lines in Fig. 2), which verifies that the improved light-trapping ability is closely related to the scattering effect of the TiO2 nanospheres.
For further insights into the electromagnetic coupling mechanism of the TiO2 nanosphered TFSC, the profiles of normalized electric field intensity inside the solar cells at representative wavelengths of 420 nm and 750 nm are shown in Fig. 3, in which the flat system is also given for comparison. The TiO2 nanospheres on the top surface behaves as a resonance nanocavity of approximate hexapolar symmetry in SC, giving rise to an improved absorption efficiency by exciting the Mie resonance at λ = 420 nm16,24,25. Compared to the flat system [Fig. 3(a)], the new design focuses the incident light into a region close to the bottom the TiO2 nanospheres, leading to a powerful energy spot [Fig. 3(b)]. The field distribution of the new design has a clear overlap with the a-Si:H layer, which implies that the light of radiative emission is effectively coupled into the TFSC by introducing a leaky channel for the light confined in the nanosphere, thus yielding a strong near-field electrical distribution and absorption efficiency in a-Si:H layer [can be seen in the Fig. 2(a)]. More clearly, the normalized integrated electric field and the calculated absorption at λ = 420 nm around the center of a TiO2 nanosphere are shown in Fig.3 (c) in cross-sectional manner. As shown in Fig. 3(c), the optical absorption of the a-Si:H layer concentrates on the front surface, while the parasitic absorption in TiO2 nanospheres and ITO layer is negligible. That means the forward scattering is dominant in all directions and thus TiO2 nanospheres in this wavelength can be thought as an optical lens that helps to focus the incident light into the active layer effectively.
As the wavelength increases, the absorption ability of a-Si:H is declined due to a low material-extinction coefficient, but the strong omnidirectional scattering ability that responsible for the outstanding light-trapping [in the Fig. 2(a,b)] is tremendously improved. Let us taking λ = 720 nm for an example, the effective optical absorption and increased light-trapping performance of the new design is mainly caused by coupling light into the active layer, so that the energy spots of the proposed design in the Fig. 3(e) spread almost all over the entire active layer than that of planar system [Fig. 3(d)]. The strong resonance coupling of light is explained by the powerful scattering of light from the resonant Mie scattering due to the high optical mode density of the high-index TiO2 nanospheres and a-Si:H substrate. Moreover, the resonant property leads to a large cross-sectional leaky channel and the guided resonance spread along the horizontal direction, so that even an array of TiO2 nanospheres only covers 41% (i.e., D/P) of the surface area nearly complete interaction with the incident-light can also be achieved. Unlike the absorption distribution in the Fig. 3(c), although the optical absorption in the ITO and Ag layer is increased [as the Fig. 3(f) shown], the absorption distribution still penetrates the whole active layer.
The outstanding light-trapping performance benefitted from the TiO2 nanospheres has been fully demonstrated in above sections. Therefore, it is necessary to examine the optical responses of the TFSCs and the scattering effect under various refractive indices of the dielectric nanospheres. Here, we don’t consider the parasitic absorption in the dielectric nanospheres (i.e., the extinction coefficient k = 0). Figure 4(a,c) display the light absorption (Pabs) in the a-Si:H layer and normalized scattering efficiency (Qsca) of the TiO2 nanospheres as functions of the response wavelengths (λ) and the refractive indices (n), respectively. Besides, the relation of Jph versus n is inserted in the Fig. 4(b). One can find that Jph shows an unnoticeable change as n < 2, but a strong enhancement when n > 2. Moreover, as n > 2.8, Jph is substantially improved (more than 15.0 mA/cm2). With the increase of n, the spheres can couple more Mie resonance modes, the intensity of Qsca is strengthened and the response wavelengths is shifted to long-wavelength. In order to combine the theory obtained with practice, we further consider four typical dielectric nanospheres with refractive indices (n) of 1.5 (close to SiO2), 2.0 (close to SiNx), 2.7 (close to TiO2), and 3.5 (close to GaP), respectively. Figure 4(b,d) show the absorption and normalized scattering spectra of the optimized parameters (D = 210 nm and P = 510 nm). As shown in Fig. 4(b), for short-wavelength range (300 nm < λ < 600 nm), there is no obvious difference in the Pabs. This means that n is not the decisive factor for texturing antireflection, and the perfect impedance-match condition can be fulfilled in a wide range of n. While, with increasing n, the light-harvesting ability of the TFSC is strengthened gradually at λ > 600 nm due to the improved scattering effect. Obviously, with n increases from 2.0 to 2.7, the Qabs is significantly increased. As a result, Jph of the TFSC is straightly enhanced (i.e., 12.02 mA/cm2 for n = 2.0, and 14.80 mA/cm2 for n = 2.7, respectively), as shown in the inset of Fig. 4(b). Therefore, the best light-trapping performance is determined by scattering efficiency when introducing the dielectric nanospheres atop, in which high-index is more advantageous.
Finally, based on the carrier drift-diffusion and Poisson’s equations, electrical evaluations of addressing the carrier transport and collection process are performed for the three systems mentioned above [in the Fig. 2(a)]. The detailed information on electrical simulation and electrical parameters (including carrier concentration, carrier mobility, lifetime, recombination coefficients, etc.) can be found in the supplement information as well as our previous publications26,27,28. Figure 5(a) exhibits the calculated external quantum efficiency (EQE) spectra of the TiO2 nanospheres with/without ITO coating and flat a-Si:H TFSCs, respectively. The EQE spectra of the three types of SCs show slightly lower than that of Pabs [as indicated in Fig. 2(a)] due to the carrier recombination loss. For the sample combined with TiO2 nanospheres and ITO, a broadband enhancement (λ > 370 nm) for EQE is achieved, contributing to a high short circuit current density (Jsc). Figure 5(b) illustrates the current-voltage (J−V) characteristics of the three types of TFSCs, from which electrical parameters such as Jsc, open-circuit voltage (Voc), fill factor (FF), and light-conversion efficiency (η) can be obtained. Apparently, Jsc of the proposed device with TiO2 nanospheres and ITO can be improved to 13.34 mA/cm2 with an enhancement ratio of 42.07% and 29.01% when separately comparing to the flat (Jsc = 9.39 mA/cm2) and the TiO2-nanosphered sample without ITO coating (Jsc = 10.34 mA/cm2) cases. Besides, the improved Jsc is responsible for the slightly increased Voc (i.e., 903, 906 and 914 mV for the three designs). As a result, under an approximate FF (i.e., 86.32%, 86.35% and 86.36%), the TiO2-nanosphered TFSC with ITO coating achieves a higher η of 10.53%, with an enhancement ratio of 43.85% (30.16%), compared to 7.32% (8.09%) of the conventional flat with ITO coating (TiO2-nanosphered TFSCs without ITO coating) design. To have a well understanding of the electrical recombination and transport processes, we have presented the spatial distributions of the stabilized electrical parameters (including carrier generation, electron concentration, hole concentration, and bulk recombination in the Fig. S4 (supplement information). As a whole, the new design shows outstanding performance in both light-trapping and electrical transport process.
In summary, we present a novel approach to enhance the light-trapping capability and the light conversion efficiency of the ultrathin a-Si:H solar cells by introducing high-index TiO2 nanosphere arrays together with ITO coating on top of the a-Si:H layer. The simulation results show that absorption efficiency is significantly improved over a broad spectral band, leading to the photocurrent density increased from 10.09 mA/cm2 (flat design) to 15.01 mA/cm2 in 100 nm-thick active layer of a-Si:H. The optimized thin cell exhibits a light-conversion efficiency up to 10.53%, representing a improvement of 43.85% over its flat counterpart. The underlying mechanism is well explained by the normalized scattering spectrum and the electric field profile associated with the absorption distributions. The Mie resonance as well as guided modes that excited by strong scattering effect afford leaky channels, so that light can be effectively couple into the active layer. This light-trapping design offers great flexibility in dielectric nanospheres with different indices and can be easily extended to other thin-film solar cells with versatile materials.
Additional Information
How to cite this article: Yang, Z. et al. Scattering effect of the high-index dielectric nanospheres for high performance hydrogenated amorphous silicon thin-film solar cells. Sci. Rep. 6, 30503; doi: 10.1038/srep30503 (2016).
Supplementary Material
Acknowledgments
This work is supported by Zhejiang Provincial Natural Science Foundation (No. LY14F040005, LR16F040002), National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 61404144), International S&T Cooperation Program of Ningbo (Grant No. 2015D10021), Major Project and Key S&T Program of Ningbo (No. 2016B10004), “Thousand Young Talents Program” of China, One Hundred Person Project of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, the Instrument Developing Project of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (No. yz201328).
Footnotes
Author Contributions Z.Y. did the optical and electrical simulation. P.G., C.Z., X.L. and J.Y. helped data analysis and co-wrote the paper. All the authors discussed the results and commented on the manuscript.
References
- Fritzsche H. Development in understanding and controlling the Staebler-Wronski effect in a-Si:H. Annu. Rev. Mater. Res. 31, 47–79 (2001). [Google Scholar]
- Biancardo M. et al. Characterization of microspherical semi-transparent solar cells and modules. Solar Energy 81, 711–716 (2007). [Google Scholar]
- Park S. H. et al. Tandem solar cells made from amorphous silicon and polymer bulk heterojunction sub-cells. Adv. Mater. 27, 298–302 (2015). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Ichikawa T., Yoshida T., Hama T., Sakai H. & Harashima K. Production technology for amorphous silicon-based flexible solar cells. Sol. Energy Mat. Sol. C. 66, 107–115 (2001). [Google Scholar]
- Mutitu J. G. et al. Thin film silicon solar cell design based on photonic crystal and diffractive grating structures. Opt. Express 16, 15238–15248 (2008). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Zeng L. et al. Demonstration of enhanced absorption in thin film Si solar cells with textured photonic crystal back reflector. Appl. Phys. Lett. 93, 221105 (2008). [Google Scholar]
- Guldin S. et al. Dye-sensitized solar cell based on a three-dimensional photonic crystal. Nano Lett. 10, 2303–2309 (2010). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Li X. et al. Bridging electromagnetic and carrier transport calculations for three-dimensional modelling of plasmonic solar cells. Opt. Express 19, A888–A896 (2011). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Atwater H. & Polman A. Plasmonics for improved photovoltaic devices. Nat. Mater. 9, 205–213 (2010). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Notarianni M., Vernon K., Chou A., Liu J. & Motta N. Plasmonic effect of annealed gold islands for improving efficiency of organic solar cells. Adv. Device Mater. 1, 27–32 (2015). [Google Scholar]
- Grandidier J., Callahan D. M., Munday J. N. & Atwater H. A. Light absorption enhancement in thin-film solar cells using whispering gallery modes in dielectric nanospheres. Adv. Mater. 23, 1272–1276 (2011). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Grandidier J., Callahan D. M., Munday J. N. & Atwater H. A. Gallium arsenide solar cell absorption enhancement using whispering gallery modes of dielectric nanospheres. IEEE J. Photovolt. 2, 123–128 (2012). [Google Scholar]
- Wang B. & Leun P. W. High index of refraction nanosphere coatings for light trapping in crystalline silicon thin film solar cells. Nano Energy 13, 226–232 (2015). [Google Scholar]
- Mariano M., Rodríguez F. J., Romero-Gomez P., Kozyreff G. & Martorell J. Light coupling into the whispering gallery modes of a fiber array thin film solar cell for fixed partial sun tracking. Sci. Rep. 4, 4959 (2014). [Google Scholar]
- Grandidier J. et al. Solar cell efficiency enhancement via light trapping in printable resonant dielectric nanosphere arrays. Phys. Status Solidi A. 210, 255–260 (2013). [Google Scholar]
- Yin J. et al. Self-assembled hollow nanosphere arrays used as low Q whispering gallery mode resonators on thin film solar cells for light trapping. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 15, 16874–16882 (2013). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Wang D. & Su G. New strategy to promote conversion efficiency using high-index nanostructures in thin-film solar cells. Sci. Rep. 4, 7165 (2014). [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Brongersma M., Cui Y. & Fan S. Light management for photovoltaics using high-index nanostructures. Nat. Mater. 13, 451–460 (2014). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Betancur R. et al. Optical interference for the matching of the external and internal quantum efficiencies in organic photovoltaic cells. Sol. Energ. Mat. Sol. C. 104, 87–91 (2012). [Google Scholar]
- Palik E. D. Handbook of Optical Constants of Solids (Academic, 1985). [Google Scholar]
- Comsol Multiphysics. http://www.comsol.com/(2016), Date of access:12/2/2016.
- ASTM, http://rredc.nrel.gov/solar/spectra/am1.5/(2016), Date of access:17/2/2016.
- Kroll M. et al. Employing dielectric diffractive structures in solar cells–a numerical study. Phys. Status Solidi A. 205, 2777–2795 (2008). [Google Scholar]
- Wang Z. et al. Broadband optical absorption by tunable Mie resonances in silicon nanocone arrays. Sci. Rep. 5, 7810 (2015). [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Spinelli P., Verschuuren M. A. & Polman A. Broadband omnidirectional antireflection coating based on subwavelength surface Mie resonators. Nat. Commun. 3, 692 (2012). [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Yang Z., Shang A., Zhan Y., Zhang C. & Li X. Ultra-broadband performance enhancement of thin-film amorphous silicon solar cells with conformal zigzag configuration. Opt. Lett. 38, 5071–5074 (2013). [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- Li X. et al. Multi-dimensional modelling of solar cells with electromagnetic and carrier transport calculations. Prog. Photovolt. Res. Appl. 21, 109–120 (2013). [Google Scholar]
- Zhan Y., Li X. & Li Y. Numerical simulation of light-trapping and photoelectric conversion in single nanowire silicon solar cells. IEEE J. Sel. Top. Quantum Electron. 19, 4000208 (2013). [Google Scholar]
Associated Data
This section collects any data citations, data availability statements, or supplementary materials included in this article.