Plasmablastic lymphoma with MYC translocation: evidence for a common pathway in the generation of plasmablastic features

Abstract

Plasmablastic lymphoma, which is considered a subtype of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma, shares many similar morphological and immunophenotypic features with plasmablastic transformation of plasma cell myeloma. In the setting of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection, both types of neoplasms can be associated with Epstein–Barr virus (EBV), thus making their distinction challenging. Moreover, the biological relationship between these entities remains unclear. We report four unique cases of plasmablastic lymphoma occurring in the setting of HIV infection that had overlapping clinical and genetic features with plasma cell myeloma. We reviewed the clinical, morphological, and cytogenetic findings and performed immunohistochemistry, in situ hybridization for EBV, chromosome analysis, and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) using the MYC break-apart rearrangement probe. All patients were males with a median age of 45 years. In addition to extra-nodal disease, plasmablastic morphology, and phenotype typical of plasmablastic lymphoma, three of the four cases also showed clinical findings overlapping with plasma cell myeloma, that is, monoclonal serum immunoglo-bulin and lytic bone lesions. Furthermore, these cases showed complex cytogenetic changes that are more commonly observed in plasma cell myeloma. A unique feature was the presence of MYC (8q24.1) rearrangement confirmed by FISH in all four cases. MYC translocation has been associated with tumor progression in multiple myeloma but has only rarely been previously reported in plasmablastic lymphoma. These cases show a clinical and biological relationship between plasmablastic lymphoma and the plasmablastic variant of plasma cell myeloma. Dysregulation of MYC may be a common genetic mechanism that imparts plasmablastic morphology and aggressive clinical course to B-cell neoplasms at a later stage of differentiation.

Plasmablastic lymphoma was first described as an aggressive lymphoma presenting in the oral cavity of patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).¹ It has since been shown to occur in other, mainly extranodal, often mucosal-associated sites such as the skin, soft tissue, and gastrointestinal tract.^2–5 The tumor is composed of large cells with a high proliferative index showing morphological and phenotypic evidence of plasmacytic differentiation, and hence the designation as plasmablastic lymphoma. Plasmablastic morphology, extra-medullary localization, and a plasma cell immunophenotype can also be observed in aggressive plasma cell myelomas.^6,7 The distinction between plasmablastic lymphoma and the anaplastic or plasmablastic form of myeloma is based largely on clinical presentation and presence of Epstein– Barr virus (EBV). Plasmablastic lymphoma has a high association with EBV and is thought to lack the hallmark clinicopathological characteristics of plasma cell myeloma, that is, monoclonal para-proteinemia and lytic bone lesions.⁴ We report four cases of plasmablastic lymphoma, three of which showed clinical and genetic features, in addition to morphology and phenotype that overlapped with plasma cell myeloma, underscoring the biological relationship between these neoplasms. Moreover, all four cases showed rearrangements of the MYC gene (v-myc myelocytomatosis viral oncogene homolog (avian)).

Materials and methods

The cases were obtained from the files of Howard University Hospital, Washington, DC.

A total of six cases of HIV-associated plasmablastic lymphoma diagnosed from 2002 to 2008 were reviewed. The four cases in this report were selected from among the six cases on the basis of unusual clinical features and MYC translocation. The H&E and Wright-Giemsa stained slides were reviewed. Immunohistochemical studies were performed on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue using an automated immunostainer (Ventana Medical Systems, Tucson, AZ, USA) with antibodies to CD20, CD79a, CD3, CD 56, CD10, Ki-67, HHV8, ALK-1, and cyclin D1 (Ventana Medical Systems), CD38, CD138, κ, λ (DAKO, Carpenteria, CA, USA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. In situ hybridization studies for EBV early RNA (EBER-1) were performed on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue sections using a Ventana (Ventana Medical Systems) in situ hybridization kit according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Flow cytometry studies were performed as part of the clinical workup of the cases. The medical records were reviewed for clinical presentation, staging, laboratory data, radiological studies, treatment, and outcome.

Cytogenetics

Chromosome analysis

Cytogenetic studies were performed as part of the clinical workup on three of the six patients. The samples (either bone marrow aspirate or pleural effusion) were processed using standard cytogenetic techniques. In brief, cultures were set up in RPMI-1640 medium enriched with 20% fetal calf serum, giant cell tumor-conditioned medium, L-glutamine, and antibiotics (penicillin and streptomycin). The unstimulated cultures were incubated for 24 and 48 h, whereas the mitogen-stimulated cultures (interleukin 4 (IL-4)) were incubated for 96 h in a 37 °C humidified environment with 5% CO₂ until harvest. Before harvest, the cultures were treated with colcemid (25 μl) for 16–18 h. After the colcemid treatment, the cells obtained from both cultures were exposed to hypotonic solution (0.075 mol/l KCl), fixed with methanol/acetic acid (3:1), spread onto a slide, and G-banded using trypsin and Giemsa stain. The slides were prepared and stained using G-banding (Giemsa–Trypsin–Wright), and 20 metaphases were analyzed from each sample. The cells were imaged and the karyograms were prepared with the Cytovision Computer-Assisted Karyotyping System (Applied Imaging, Santa Clara, CA, USA). These karyograms were described according to the International System for Human Cytogenetics Nomenclature (ISCN 2009).⁸

Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis

FISH studies were performed in all six patients with the MYC probe (LSI MYC Dual Color, Break-Apart Rearrangement probe: Abbott Molecular, Des Plaines, IL, USA) to investigate and/or confirm the presence of MYC gene rearrangement. The FISH procedure was carried out on various tissues, including bone marrow aspirate, pleural effusion as well as formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections, following the manufacturer’s guidelines with minor modifications. Furthermore, all samples were also tested for the presence of gains of 5p, as well as chromosomes 9 and 15 centromeres (LSI D5S23/D5S721, CEP 9, CEP 15 Multi-color Probe Set; Abbott Molecular), a common finding in myeloma cases with a hyperdiploid chromosome complement. After overnight hybridization and subsequent washing, the slides were analyzed using a Nikon 50i fluorescence microscope (Nikon, Tokyo, Japan). Selected images were captured using an Isis workstation (Metasystems, Watertown, MA, USA).

Results

Case Histories

The clinical features of the six patients with plasmablastic lymphoma are summarized in Table 1. The patients were all males with an age range of 37–59 years (median 48), all of whom were HIV positive. There was no evidence of a previous lymphoproliferative disorder in any of the patients. Four of the six patients (cases 1–4) with plasma-blastic lymphoma were positive for MYC translocation. These cases presented with disseminated disease with nodal as well as extra-nodal disease involving the gastrointestinal tract and soft tissue. The lymph node involvement was multifocal, including mesenteric, retroperitoneal, (case 1) cervical, paratracheal (case 2), and inguinal (case 4). The patients with gastrointestinal tract involvement had extensive infiltration of the small bowel and colon wall requiring resection for gastrointestinal obstruction, whereas the patient with a soft tissue mass of the thigh had a 5 cm ulcerated lesion with massive edema of the leg. Of the four patients with MYC translocation, three had clinical features of plasma cell myeloma, that is, monoclonal serum immunoglobulin and/or lytic lesions, but serum calcium, blood urea nitrogen (BUN), and creatinine were normal. The monoclonal immunoglobulin in all cases constituted <2 g per 100 ml. In two of these cases, the monoclonal protein was IgG and both of these patients had multiple lytic bone lesions by computed tomography (CT) scans. However, in both patients, despite the extensive mucosal involvement, there was no evidence of bone marrow involvement morphologically and by flow cytometry (performed both initially and at the later recurrence in case 1). The third patient had a monoclonal IgM spike and, in addition to a destructive soft tissue lesion, the bone marrow was diffusely infiltrated by large cells (Figure 1), but there was no evidence of lytic bone lesions. Three of the four MYC translocation-positive patients did not receive chemotherapy, either because of the patients’ clinical condition or refusal of treatment. In these patients, the median survival was 48 days. One of the patients (case 1) was treated with a myeloma regimen (vincristine, adriamycin, and dexamethasone) with improvement in the gastro-intestinal tract symptoms. The treatment decision was based on the clinicopathological presentation and marked evidence of plasmacytic differentiation in the tumor cells. The patient responded but relapsed 2 years later with plasmablastic lymphoma in the testis and pleural cavities and expired shortly after. The remaining two MYC translocation-negative cases (cases 5 and 6) presented with disease limited to the oral cavity with no evidence of lytic lesions. One of these patients received chemotherapy (etoposide, vincristine, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, and prednisone (EPOCH)) but developed disseminated disease and died 13 months after initial diagnosis. The second patient was lost to follow-up.

Table 1.

Clinical data of patients with plasmablastic lymphoma^a

Case no.	Age/sex	Site	SPEP	Lytic lesion	BM	Outcome
1	37/Mb	Small intestine, colon, mesenteric lymph nodes	IgG K	Humerus, rib, skull	−	Expired (2 years)
		Testis			−
		Pleural effusion
2	59/M	Small intestine, colon, generalized lymphadenopathy	IgG K	Thoracic spine	−	Expired (35 days)
		Pleural effusion
3	45/Mc	Soft tissue	IgM K	None	+	Expired (20 days)
4	53/M	Inguinal lymph node, soft tissue	ND	None	−	Expired (90 days)
5	41/M	Oral cavity	ND	None	ND	NA
6	50/M	Oral cavity	ND	None	−	Expired (13 months)

SPEP, serum protein electrophoresis; BM, bone marrow; ND, not done; NA, not available.

^aCases 1–4 are positive for MYC translocation.

^bLymphoma recurred in the testis 2 years later. The bone marrow was negative initially and at recurrence.

^cThe bone marrow was infiltrated by identical cells as in the soft tissue.

Figure 1.

Skin biopsy and bone marrow aspirate from the 45-year-old male patient with a soft tissue thigh mass and bone marrow involvement (case 3). Low-power view of the skin biopsy shows a destructive, lymphoid infiltrate in the dermis (a) (H&E). The cells are large, with amphophilic cytoplasm and prominent nucleoli (b) (H&E). The bone marrow was replaced by sheets of large cells with prominent nucleoli. Eccentric nuclei and paranuclear hofs were evident in some of the cells (c) (Wright-Giemsa).

Morphology

Histologically, all four MYC translocation-positive cases had extensive infiltration of involved sites by a diffuse proliferation of large cells showing plasma-blastic or immunoblastic morphology, that is, abundant basophilic cytoplasm and eccentric nuclei. In some of the cases, there was a starry sky pattern, high mitotic rate, and numerous apoptotic bodies. A variable number of cells that showed morphological features of mature plasma cells, that is, smaller size, clumped chromatin, and paranuclear hofs, were present. The number of the more mature plasma cells ranged from minimal to moderate in the various cases and was most prominent in the initial gastrointestinal tract tumor of one patient (case 1). The tumor in the latter case was most consistent with plasmablastic lymphoma with plasmacytic differentiation, whereas the recurrent tumor in the testis of the same patient 2 years later was more monomorphic and high grade, resembling plasma-blastic lymphoma of the oral cavity (Figure 2). The tumors in the two MYC translocation-negative plasmablastic lymphoma of the oral cavity were composed of uniform population of large cells.

Figure 2.

Small intestine and testis from case 1. The intestinal mucosa was extensively infiltrated by lymphoid cells that were large with prominent nucleoli (a) (H&E). The tumor also had areas of marked plasmacytic differentiation with numerous mature plasma cells (b) (H&E). The tumor in the testis was high grade with some evidence of plasmacytic differentiation (c) (H&E).

Immunophenotype

The immunophenotypic features of all six cases are summarized in Table 2. The tumor cells were positive for the plasma cell markers CD138 and/or CD38 and negative or weakly positive for B-cell markers (CD20 and CD79a) by flow cytometry and/ or immunohistochemistry in all except one case in which there was strong staining with CD20. The latter case was also positive for CD38 and showed strong monotypic cytoplasmic k light chain. Although expression of CD20 is unexpected, other features favored the diagnosis of plasmablastic lymphoma, including plasmablastic morphology, clinical features, strong cytoplasmic immunoglobulin, and expression of CD38. All cases were negative for cyclin D1. The proliferative rate with Ki-67 ranged from 60% in the tumors that showed a greater number of more mature plasma cells, to nearly 100% in the more monomorphic tumors composed mostly of large cells. Partial positivity for CD56 and CD10 was observed in two cases. In situ hybridization for EBV was positive in four of the six cases, including two of the four MYC translocation-positive plasmablastic lymphoma and both cases of MYC translocation-negative plasmablastic lymphoma in the oral cavity. HHV8 was negative in all cases.

Table 2.

Immunophenotypic features of patients with plasmablastic lymphoma

	Case 1			Case 2		Case 3	Case 4	Case 5	Case 6
	Small intestine	Testis	Pleural effusion	Small intestine	Pleural effusion	Soft tissue	Inguinal lymph node	Oral cavity	Oral cavity
CD138	+	+	+	−	−	+	+	+	+
CD38	+	+	+	+	+	+	+	+	+
CD20	−	−	−	+	+	−	−	−	−
CD79A	−	−	−	+	+	−	±	−	−
Kappa	+	+	+	+	+	+	−	NC	+
Lambda	−	−	−	−	−	−	+	NC	−
CD56	+	+	+	−	−	+	−	−	−
CD10	+	+	+	−	−	+	−	−	−
Cyclin D-1	−	−	−	−	−	−	−	−	−
ALK	−	−	−	−	−	−	−	−	−
HHV-8	−	−	−	−	−	−	−	−	−
Ki-67	60%	80%	80–90%	80–90%	80–90%	100%	90%	90%	90%
EBER	+	+	+	−	−	−	+	+	+

EBER, Epstein–Barr virus early RNA; NC, non-contributory.

Cytogenetics and FISH

The karyotypic and FISH data of the six patients with plasmablastic lymphoma are summarized in Table 3. The chromosome analysis of bone marrow or pleural effusion samples from three of the patients with serum monoclonal spikes and/or lytic bone lesions showed a complex karyotype (Figure 3). The common changes were characterized by rearrangements of chromosomes 1 and/or 6, loss of 13q and 17p, and whole or partial gains of chromosomes 3, 5, 7, 9, 11, and/or 15. FISH studies confirmed the presence of gains of 5p, 9 as well as 15 centromeres (Figure 3) in the various tissues, including the original as well as subsequent tumors in the patient who had recurrent disease (case 1). In addition, the analysis of the complete karyotype revealed translocations involving the MYC gene (8q24.1) in all three cases. The translocation partners included the immunoglobulin heavy chain (IGH 14q32) and k (IGK 2p12) or l light chain (IGL 22q11.2) genes. The rearrangement of the MYC gene was confirmed by FISH (Figure 3) in the three cases noted above, as well as in the fourth patient with plasmablastic lymphoma who had no evidence of a lytic bone lesion (case 4). The latter case also showed gains of 5p, 9 as well as 15 centromeres by FISH. Interestingly, in the plasmablastic lymphoma case that showed the most plasmacytic differentiation (case 1), rearrangement of MYC was detected in 11% of the tumor cells in the initial gastrointestinal tract lesion, whereas the recurrent, monomorphic high-grade tumor in the testis and pleural cavity showed MYC rearrangement in 89 and 94%, respectively, suggesting a MYC-driven tumor progression. FISH for MYC rearrangement and gains of chromosomes 5, 9, and 15 were all negative in the two patients with plasmablastic lymphoma of the oral cavity.

Table 3.

Karyotype and FISH data of patients with plasmablastic lymphoma

Case no.	Site	Karyotype	FISH
1	Small intestine	ND	MYC+ (11%) gain of 5p, 9 cen, and 15 cen (13%)
	Bone marrow	46,XY	ND
	Testis	No growth	MYC+ (89%) gain of 5p, 9 cen, and 15 cen (74%)
	Repeat bone marrow	46,XY	ND
	Pleural effusion	83~85<3n>,XX,-Y,+1,der(1)t(1;1)(p32;q25),+2,+3, +4,+6,del(6)(q25)×2, +7,+7,t(8;14) (q24.1;q32)×2,+10,+12,add(13)(q34), +16,psu dic(16;1)(q12;p13), +17,+18,+19,+20,+22,+mar[cp20]	MYC+ (94%) gain of 5p, 9 cen, and 15 cen (71%)
2	Small intestine	ND	MYC+ (90%) gain of 5p, (73%)
	Bone marrow	46,XY	ND
	Pleural effusion	47~49,x,+x,-y,der(1)t(1;4)(q21;p12),+3,del(3)q(13.2q23) x2,+5,+6,der(6)psu dic(6;1) (p25;p36.3) ins (6;?)(p25?), t(7;10)(q22;q22),t(8;22) (q24.1;q11.2), add11 (q23),−13,−20[cp20]	MYC+ (91%) gain of 5p (69%)
3	Soft tissue	ND	MYC+ (87%) gain of 5p, and 15 cen (68%)
	Bone marrow	46,X,-Y,t(2;8)(p12;q24.1),−4,der(6)t(5;6)(p12;q25),+7,+15, der(15;17)(q10;q10),+20[6]/46,XY[14]	MYC+ (55%) gain of 5p, and 15 cen (39%)
4	Inguinal lymph node, abdominal soft tissue mass	ND	MYC+ (35%) gain of 5p, and 15 cen (14%)
5	Oral cavity	ND	MYC negative gain of 5p, and 15 cen negative
6	Oral cavity	ND	MYC negative gain of 5p, and 15 cen negative

ND, not done; cen, centromere.

Figure 3.

G-banded karyogram and interphase FISH from two patients with a plasmablastic lymphoma. The pleural effusion karyotype (case 2) was complex. A translocation between chromosomes 8 and 22, (t(8;22)(q24.1;q11.2)) (arrows), and rearrangements of chromosome 1, loss of chromosome 13, and gain of chromosomes 3 and 5 were detected (a). Interphase FISH revealed one fusion (intact MYC), one red (5ʹ MYC), and one green (3ʹ MYC) signals confirming the rearrangement of MYC (b). The small intestine and testis (case 1) showed gain of one copy of 5p (green signal), as well as gains of chromosomes 9 (aqua signal) and 15 (red signal) centromeres.

Discussion

We report four unique cases that provide evidence that plasmablastic transformation is highly associated with MYC translocation and that this finding can be observed in both de novo plasmablastic lymphoma and in the plasmablastic transformation of a more low-grade plasma cell neoplasm, including plasma cell myeloma. These cases are additional evidence that MYC translocation, originally described in Burkitt’s lymphoma, may be observed in other lymphomas as well. There have been few previous reports noting the presence of MYC translocation in plasma cell myeloma, a finding that has been associated with tumor progression to high-grade morphology and an aggressive clinical course.^9–12 Previously, only rare case reports in the literature suggested an association of plasmablastic lymphoma with MYC translocation, all of which involved the IGH gene as the translocation partner.^13–16 A recent meeting report from Balague et al¹⁷ showed the presence of MYC rearrangement in 39% of 28 cases of plasmablastic lymphoma. Our cases are unique in that they had features of both plasmablastic lymphoma and plasma cell myeloma, suggesting a closer relationship between these neoplasms than previously thought. Notably, the cytogenetic changes were similar to those observed in plasma cell myeloma, particularly, the rearrangements of chromosome 1, deletions of 13q and 17p, and the simultaneous gains of the odd-numbered chromosomes. Clinical features were overlapping as well. These findings suggest a common histogenesis for both plasmablastic lymphoma and the plasma-blastic variant of plasma cell myeloma and provide further evidence linking these two tumors with morphological and immunophenotypic similarities. Moreover, MYC translocation, observed in all four of our cases, seems to be a common link in tumors showing plasmablastic morphology, with varying clinicopathological manifestations. EBV, which is closely linked to plasmablastic lymphoma, also has a role in producing the plasmablastic phenotype in plasma cell myeloma and was positive in two of the four MYC translocation-positive cases. EBV has been reported to be positive in some cases of plasma cell myeloma with anaplastic or plasmablastic features, often encountered in the setting of immunodeficiency. However, EBV is only rarely associated with plasma cell myeloma and the few cases that have been reported occurred in the setting of multiple myeloma or plasmacytoma, in contrast to the de novo presentation as high-grade aggressive lesion characteristic of plasmablastic lymphoma.^6,18

The relationship between plasmablastic lymphoma and plasmablastic transformation of plasma cell neoplasms was highlighted in a study by Colomo et al,⁶ in which plasmablastic lymphomas with plasmacytic differentiation were found to be morphologically similar to extra-medullary plasmablastic tumors arising in the setting of a preexisting or concurrent plasma cell neoplasm. Moreover, Vega et al⁷ provided evidence that plasmablastic lymphomas and plasmablastic plasma cell myelomas share many common immunophenotypic features, including a high proliferative rate and expression of CD56 and CD10. The latter two markers, which are more often associated with plasma cell neoplasms, were positive in more than half of plasmablastic lymphomas.⁷ Our cases confirm this observation with two of the four cases of plasmablastic lymphoma showing positivity for CD56 and CD10. Owing to the close morphological and phenotypic similarities, distinguishing plasmablastic lymphoma from plasmablastic plasma cell myeloma is based on additional clinical features and association with EBV. Thus, high-grade lymphomas with plasmablastic morphology, occurring in immunocompromised patients, localized primarily in extra-medullary sites that are positive for EBV would be designated as plasma-blastic lymphoma. In contrast, extra-medullary plasmablastic transformation of plasma cell myeloma occurs in patients with pre-existing or concurrent clinical evidence of multiple myeloma, that is, paraproteinemia, lytic lesions, and proliferation of plasma cells in the bone marrow, peripheral blood, or extra-medullary sites, most commonly the liver and spleen.⁶

Our cases further blur the line between plasma-blastic lymphoma and plasmablastic transformation of plasma cell myeloma. Monoclonal serum immunoglobulin spikes were observed in three patients, two of whom had lytic bone lesions. Yet, all patients had normal serum calcium, BUN, and creatinine and had extensive disease outside the marrow in sites often involved by plasmablastic lymphoma. Moreover, in all four cases, despite extensive extra-nodal and nodal disease, the patients did not have hepatosplenomegaly or peripheral blood involvement and bone marrow infiltration was observed in only one case. Similar overlapping features have also been noted in rare reports¹⁹ and bone marrow involvement can be observed in plasmablastic lymphoma.^{6,14,15,19,20} Furthermore, plasma cell tumors are reported to have an increased incidence in HIV-positive patients, in which they occur in younger patients, present in unusual sites, show a plasmablastic morphology, are often EBV positive, and show an aggressive clinical course with poor prognosis.^21–25 Although there is a high association of plasmablastic lymphoma with immunodeficiency (94%) and EBV positivity (74%), not all cases are EBV positive.²⁶ In the absence of a previous or concurrent well-differentiated plasma cell neoplasm, high-grade lymphomas with plasmablastic features occurring in HIV-positive patients, particularly when associated with paraproteinemia and bone lesions, are difficult to distinguish from plasma cell myeloma with transformation. The designation of these neoplasms as plasmablastic lymphoma, rather than plasma cell myeloma, is based on de novo presentation as aggressive tumors with plasmablastic morphology, predominant extra-medullary, often mucosal involvement, and associa-tion with HIV and EBV. Plasma cell myelomas rarely present de novo as high-grade lesions and the association with EBV and HIV is quite rare. Never-theless, the distinction between these neoplasms may be arbitrary and whether they represent two separate entities or part of a common pathway is controversial. However, the distinction has important clinical and therapeutic implications. The poor clinical outcome in our cases was similar to those reported in the literature for plasmablastic lymphoma with a mean survival ranging from 6 to 15 months with chemotherapy and/or radiation.^26,27 Plasmablastic lymphomas are mostly treated with combination chemotherapy used for diffuse large B-cell lymphoma. Only rare reports exist that address the potential use of myeloma regimens in the treatment of plasmablastic lymphoma. In one such report, a patient with extra-nodal plasmablastic lymphoma who also had t(8;14) was treated with Bortezomib and reported to have a good initial response.²⁸ It is interesting that one of the patients in our study had a relatively longer survival and an initial response to a myeloma-based therapy.

Our cases show that, in addition to the shared clinical and immunophenotypic features, there is a genetic overlap between plasmablastic lymphoma and plasma cell myeloma and that these two neoplasms may be different manifestations of malignancies with a common derivation from B cells at a later stage of B-cell maturation. It is therefore likely that dysregulation of MYC may be a common genetic feature that imparts a plasmablastic morphology and an aggressive clinical course in these tumors. The clinical manifestations may depend on when during the clinical course the plasmablastic transformation takes place.