Abstract
Background:
Warm needling acupuncture (WNA) has been widely utilized for pain management in patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN). However, its results are still inconsistent, and no systematic review has specifically addressed this issue. Thus, this systematic review will comprehensively and systematically investigate the effectiveness and safety of WNA for pain relief in DPN.
Methods:
A comprehensive literature search of MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Scopus, Allied and Complementary Medicine Database, CBM database, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure will be performed for randomized controlled trials that report WNA for pain relief in patients with DPN. All electronic databases will be searched from initial to the present without limitations of language and publication status. Two investigators will independently screen papers, collect data, and assess study quality. Cochrane risk of bias tool will be used for study quality assessment, and evidence quality will be evaluated using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluations approach. RevMan 5.3 software will be applied for running statistical analysis.
Results:
This study will summarize the evidence for the effectiveness and safety of WNA for the management of pain in patients with DPN.
Conclusions:
The findings of this study may provide helpful evidence to judge whether WNA for pain relief in DPN is effective or not.
Keywords: acupuncture, diabetic peripheral neuropathy, effectiveness, moxibustion, pain, safety
1. Introduction
Diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN) is a common complication of diabetes mellitus (DM), affecting 50% to 90% of people with DM.[1–3] It is characterized by varying degrees of pain, tingling, numbness, burning, sharp, and shooting in the extremities[4,5]; and is usually considered as much worse and severer at night.[4,5] Of those, pain is a constant distress.[6–9] It accounts for 10% to 30% of such population based on the different studied patients.[10–17] If it cannot be treated effectively and timely, it can significantly restrict recreational social activities, negatively impact mood, and substantially affect quality of life in patients with DPN.[18–20]
The pathogenesis of pain in DPN is still not fully understood, which presents a great therapeutic challenge.[21] Alternative therapy, such as acupuncture, is commonly utilized in the clinical practice of pain management with increasing popularity and is gaining acceptance among the public and academic community around the world.[22–24] It is a meridian-based therapy, with needles inserting into specific acupoints on the body, which exerts distinct therapeutic actions.[25,26] Clinical and animal studies found that acupuncture treatment is associated with an increase in blood circulation for DPN.[27] Specifically, acupuncture needle stimulation with Deqi sensation showed substantially greater blood supply than surrounding tissue,[28,29] which benefits DPN and relieves pain in DPN.[30]
Warm needling acupuncture (WNA) is a combination therapy of acupuncture and moxibustion, which simultaneously exerts effects of acupuncture, moxibustion, and specific acupoint stimulation.[31] Studies have found that WNA demonstrates better efficacy in enhancing blood supply and pain relief than acupuncture or moxibustion alone.[31,32] A variety of clinical trials reported that WNA can be widely utilized for pain relief in patients with DPN.[33–48] However, all conclusions are drawn from an individual clinical trial. In addition, although 3 relevant systematic reviews have been conducted to explore the effect of acupuncture for DPN,[49–51] no study specifically investigates the effectiveness and safety of WNA on pain relief in DPN systematically and comprehensively. Therefore, this systematic review protocol will specifically assess the effectiveness of WNA for pain relief in DPN.
2. Methods
2.1. Study registration
This protocol is funded and registered with osf.io/m4qe3. It has been reported based on the guideline of Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Protocols statement.[52]
2.2. Eligibility criteria
2.2.1. Inclusion criteria
Inclusion criteria are as follows: Types of studies: only randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on use of WNA for pain relief in patients with DPN; Types of interventions: studies including any types of WNA, regardless duration, frequency, dosage, and other related parameters; Types of controls: all comparators are eligible for inclusion, such as pain killers, acupuncture or moxibustion alone; Types of participants: only adult patients (≥18 years old) with confirmed diagnosis of painful DPN, irrespective race, gender, medical histories, and conditions; and Types of outcomes: at least 1 outcome indicator related to DPN pain.
2.2.2. Exclusion criteria
Exclusion criteria are as follows: Besides WNA, treatments also involved nonpenetrating needles, electroacupuncture, acupuncture, or moxibustion in the intervention group; comparator involved any forms of WNA; outcome indicators without pain measurement; any other studies, such as animal study, review, case report, case series, comments, nonclinical trial, uncontrolled study, and non-RCTs; and repeated or overlapping publications.
2.2.3. Outcome measurements
The primary outcome is pain intensity, as measured by any pain scales, such as Visual analogue scale, Numeric Rating Scale, or any other relevant tools.
The secondary outcomes consist of sensory conduction velocity, motor conduction velocity of the peroneal nerve, complete response rate, neuropathic syndrome score, glycemic profile, quality of life (as assessed by any associated scales), and adverse events.
2.3. Search strategy
2.3.1. Electronic databases sources
A comprehensive literature search for relevant randomized controlled trials will be conducted from their initial to the present in the following electronic databases: MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, Scopus, Allied and Complementary Medicine Database, CBM database, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure. We will not apply any limitations to language and publication status. A research librarian with expertise in literature search strategies will help to develop detailed sample for MEDLINE (Table 1). We will also create similar detailed search strategies for other electronic databases.
Table 1.
Search strategy applied to MEDLINE.
| Number | Search terms |
| 1 | Diabetic peripheral neuropathy |
| 2 | Diabetic neuropathy |
| 3 | Peripheral neuropathy |
| 4 | Distal symmetric peripheral neuropathy |
| 5 | Diabetes |
| 6 | Diabetic mellitus |
| 7 | Pain |
| 8 | Painful |
| 9 | Pain intensity |
| 10 | Pain relief |
| 11 | Or 1–10 |
| 12 | Acupuncture |
| 13 | Warm needle |
| 14 | Needling |
| 15 | Electroacupuncture |
| 16 | Acupoint |
| 17 | Scalp acupuncture |
| 18 | Manual acupuncture |
| 19 | Moxibustion |
| 20 | Or 12–19 |
| 21 | Randomized controlled trials |
| 22 | Clinical trials |
| 23 | Controlled study |
| 24 | Random |
| 25 | Randomly |
| 26 | Blind |
| 27 | Concealment |
| 28 | Placebo |
| 29 | Control |
| 30 | Comparator |
| 31 | Study |
| 32 | Trial |
| 33 | Or 21–32 |
| 34 | 11 and 20 and 33 |
2.3.2. Other literature sources
We will plan to search gray literatures, such as conference proceedings, websites of clinical trial registries, and reference lists of all included studies.
2.4. Study selection
All relevant citations will be selected through a 2-stage process by 2 independent investigators, respectively. In the first stage, titles and abstracts of all citations will be screened, and those considered not to be associated with the topic will be excluded. In the second stage, 2 investigators will examine the remaining full papers for concordance to check whether they fulfill all inclusion criteria. A third experienced investigator will help to solve any disagreements between 2 investigators. The flowchart with results generated and reasons for exclusion will be presented.
2.5. Data collection and management
Two investigators will independently collect data from each included trial using a structured standardized form. Any disagreements in the data collection between 2 investigators will be solved by a third experienced investigator. Data collection includes authors, year of publication, region, number of patients, patient demographics (gender, age, diagnostic criteria, and eligibility criteria), study methods (details of randomization, blind, and allocation), intervention and control details (delivery types, mode, frequency, dosage, and duration), outcome measurements, and follow-up details. If we identify any insufficient or missing information, we will ask for primary authors to provide that. If that kind of information is not available, we will only analyze data at hand using intention-to-treat analysis, and will discuss its potential affects.
2.6. Study quality assessment
Study quality for each included trial will be evaluated using Cochrane risk of bias tool by 2 independent investigators, respectively. It covers domains of selection bias, performance bias, attrition bias, detection bias, reporting bias, and other bias. Each field will be further graded as high, unclear or low risk of bias. Disagreements will be solved by a third investigator through discussion.
2.7. Statistical analysis
2.7.1. Data synthesis
We will employ RevMan 5.3 software to analyze extracted data, and carry out a meta-analysis whenever it is possible. We will estimate outcomes as relative risks, odds ratios, or risk difference and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for dichotomous data, and weighted mean difference or standardized mean difference and 95% CIs for continuous data. The data from each trial will be utilized to construct evidence tables of a narrative summary description of the included trials. If the trials are diverse and quantitative synthesis is not feasible, we will report trials using albatross plots based on the methodological guideline.[53] Statistical heterogeneity across trials with respect to characteristics of studies will be identified by I2 test.[54]I2 ≤ 50% exerts little statistical heterogeneity, and a fixed-effects model will be applied. I2 > 50% indicates distinct heterogeneity, and a random-effects model will be placed.[55] If meta-analysis is appropriate and trials are found to be combinable, fixed-effects or random-effects meta-analysis will be carried out, and will calculate pooled effect sizes for primary and secondary outcomes. We will conduct it when at least 2 eligible trials available for comparison and they are sufficiently homogeneous in terms of study design, participants, interventions, and outcomes. For all outcomes, no quantitative synthesis will be undertaken and coefficients of each reported outcome will be elaborated at the study level.
2.7.2. Subgroup analysis
If necessary, we will undertake a subgroup analysis based on the different patient demographics, study quality, types of interventions and comparators, and outcome measurements.
2.7.3. Sensitivity analysis
We will plan to conduct sensitivity analysis to verify the stability of conclusions by deleting low-quality studies.
2.7.4. Reporting bias
If at least 10 eligible trials are included, we will explore the reporting bias using funnel plot and Egger regression test.[56,57]
2.8. Grading the quality of evidence
Quality of evidence will be checked by 2 investigators according to the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation. It covers 4 different levels, including very low, low, moderate, and high levels.[58] Any conflicts will be cleared up by discussion with a third investigator, and a final consensus will be reached.
2.9. Ethics and dissemination
No ethical approval is required, because no individual patient data will be obtained in this study. This study is expected to be disseminated through a peer-reviewed journal.
3. Discussion
Painful DPN is a common disorder in patients with DM, which brings very poor quality for such patients. Presently, WNA approach is utilized for the treatment of pain in DPN. In spite of the clinical and experimental support, the effect and safety of WNA for pain have not been fully validated and evaluated. In addition, no systematic review and meta-analysis regarding it has been conducted. Therefore, this study aims to assess the effect and safety of WNA for pain in DPN. The results of this study have the potential influence on the management of WNA for pain relief in DPN. Its findings may supply evidence for the reference of clinical practice and health-related policy maker.
Author contributions
Conceptualization: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Data curation: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Formal analysis: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Funding acquisition: Li-qin Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Investigation: Xuehui Wang.
Methodology: Fei Wang.
Project administration: Xuehui Wang.
Resources: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang.
Software: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang.
Supervision: Xuehui Wang.
Validation: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Visualization: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Writing – original draft: Li-qin Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Writing – review & editing: Li-qin Wang, Fei Wang, Xuehui Wang.
Footnotes
Abbreviations: CIs = confidence intervals, DPN = diabetic peripheral neuropathy, RCTs = randomized controlled trials, WNA = warm needling acupuncture.
How to cite this article: Wang Lq, Wang F, Wang Xh. Effectiveness of warm needling acupuncture for pain relief in patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy: a protocol of systematic review. Medicine. 2020;99:45(e23077).
Study registration: osf.io/m4qe3.
This study was partly funded by Natural Science Foundation of Heilongjiang Province (H2015029), and Planned Project of Cultivating Innovative Personnel Fund of Heilongjiang University of Chinese Medicine (2018RCD02). The supported institute did not involve any parts of this study.
The authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose.
Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analyzed during the current study.
References
- [1].Pop-Busui R, Boulton AJ, Feldman EL, et al. Diabetic neuropathy: a position statement by the American Diabetes Association. Diabetes Care 2017;40:136–54. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [2].Almuhannadi H, Ponirakis G, Khan A, et al. Diabetic neuropathy and painful diabetic neuropathy: Cinderella complications in South East Asia. J Pak Med Assoc 2018;68:85–9. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [3].Selvarajah D, Kar D, Khunti K, et al. Diabetic peripheral neuropathy: advances in diagnosis and strategies for screening and early intervention. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol 2019;7:938–48. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [4].Bansal V, Kalita J, Misra UK, et al. Mechanisms and management of diabetic painful distal symmetrical polyneuropathy. Diabetes Care 2013;36:2456–65. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [5].Bansal V, Kalita J, Misra UK. Diabetic neuropathy. Postgrad Med J 2006;82:95–100. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [6].Snyder MJ, Gibbs LM, Lindsay TJ. Treating painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy: an update. Am Fam Physician 2016;94:227–34. [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [7].Sloan G, Shillo P, Selvarajah D, et al. A new look at painful diabetic neuropathy. Diabetes Res Clin Pract 2018;144:177–91. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [8].Nawroth PP, Bendszus M, Pham M, et al. The quest for more research on painful diabetic neuropathy. Neuroscience 2018;387:28–37. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [9].Feldman EL, Callaghan BC, Pop-Busui R, et al. Diabetic neuropathy. Nat Rev Dis Primers 2019;5:41. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [10].Daousi C, MacFarlane IA, Woodward A, et al. Chronic painful peripheral neuropathy in an urban community: a controlled comparison of people with and without diabetes. Diabet Med 2004;21:976–82. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [11].Harris M, Eastman R, Cowie C. Symptoms of sensory neuropathy in adults with NIDDM in the U.S. population. Diabetes Care 1993;16:1446–52. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [12].Low PA, Dotson RM. Symptomatic treatment of painful neuropathy. JAMA 1998;280:1863–4. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [13].Spallone V, Lacerenza M, Rossi A, et al. Painful diabetic polyneuropathy: approach to diagnosis and management. Clin J Pain 2012;28:726–43. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [14].Partanen J, Niskanen L, Lehtinen J, et al. Natural history of peripheral neuropathy in patients with non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. N Engl J Med 1995;333:89–94. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [15].Jambart S, Ammache Z, Haddad F, et al. Prevalence of painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy among patients with diabetes mellitus in the Middle East region. J Int Med Res 2011;39:366–77. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [16].Hall GC, Carroll D, Parry D, McQuay HJ. Epidemiology and treatment of neuropathic pain: the UK primary care perspective. Pain 2006;122:156–62. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [17].Davies M, Brophy S, Williams R, et al. The prevalence, severity, and impact of painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy in type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Care 2006;29:1518–22. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [18].Gore M, Brandenburg NA, Dukes E, et al. Pain severity in diabetic peripheral neuropathy is associated with patient functioning, symptom levels of anxiety and depression, and sleep. J Pain Symptom Manage 2005;30:374–85. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [19].Quattrini C, Tesfaye S. Understanding the impact of painful diabetic neuropathy. Diabetes Metab Res Rev 2003;19: suppl 1: S2–8. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [20].Thisted RA, Klaff L, Schwartz SL, et al. Dextromethorphan and quinidine in adult patients with uncontrolled painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy: a 29-day, multicenter, open-label, dose-escalation study. Clin Ther 2006;28:1607–18. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [21].Chong MS, Bajwa ZH. Diagnosis and treatment of neuropathic pain. J Pain Symptom Manage 2003;25: 5 suppl: S4–11. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [22].Hao JJH, Mittelman M. Acupuncture: past, present, and future. Glob Adv Health Med 2014;3:6–8. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [23].Vincent A, Kruk KM, Cha SS, et al. Utilisation of acupuncture at an academic medical centre. Acupunct Med 2010;28:189–90. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [24].Patil MS, Sen S, Bral M, et al. The role of acupuncture in pain. Curr Pain Headache Rep 2016;20:22. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [25].Hurtak JJ. An overview of acupuncture medicine. J Altern Complement Med 2002;8:535–8. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [26].Paul JG, Karen B, Xue LW, et al. Acupuncture and neuropathy. Am J Psychiatry 2000;157:1342–3. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [27].Sandireddy R, Yerra VG, Areti A, et al. Neuroinflammation and oxidative stress in diabetic neuropathy: futuristic strategies based on these targets. Int J Endocrin 2014;2014:674987. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [28].Sandberg M, Lundeberg T, Lindberg LG, et al. Effects of acupuncture on skin and muscle blood flow in health subjects. Eur J Appl Physiol 2003;90:114–9. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [29].Hsiu J, Huang SM, Chao PT, et al. Microcirculatory characteristics of acupuncture points obtained by laser Doppler flowmetry. Physiol Meas 2007;28: N77eN86. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [30].Ahn AC, Bennani T, Freeman R, et al. Two styles of acupuncture for treating painful diabetic neuropathy—a pilot randomised control trial. Acupunct Med 2007;25:11–7. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [31].Xu HW, Du W, He LL, et al. Effectiveness and safety of warm needle acupuncture on insomnia in climacteric women: protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis. Medicine (Baltimore) 2019;98:e15637. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [32].Kim H, Shim I, Yi SH, et al. Warm needle acupuncture at Pungsi (GB31) has an enhanced analgesic effect on formalin-induced pain in rats. Brain Res Bull 2009;78:164–9. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [33].Feng LQ. Clinical observation of warm acupuncture treatment of diabetic peripheral neuropathy with qi deficiency and blood stasis. Inner Mongolian Med 2020;39:105–6. [Google Scholar]
- [34].Ma GQ, Ye T, Sun ZR. Comparative observation of warm acupuncture and conventional acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy of Yang deficiency, cold coagulation and collateral stasis. Chin Acupuncture Moxibustion 2018;38:229–33. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [35].Wu CY. Observation of clinical effect of warm acupuncture on patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy. New World Diabetes 2017;20:191–2. [Google Scholar]
- [36].Xia SH, Fan MJ. Analysis of clinical effect of warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy with qi deficiency and blood stasis. Diabetes New World 2017;20:7–8. [Google Scholar]
- [37].Nanjing University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Winther J. Clinical observation of acupuncture treatment of diabetic peripheral neuropathy lower limb pain. 2017;(Dissertation). [Google Scholar]
- [38].Chen X, Li M. Observation on the therapeutic effect of Xiaobi Tang combined with warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Shanxi Traditional Chin Med 2016;32:18–20. [Google Scholar]
- [39].Anhui University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Yang XH. Clinical observation of warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy of Qi deficiency and blood stasis type. 2016;(Dissertation). [Google Scholar]
- [40].Zhai CM. Discussion on clinical efficacy of 71 patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy treated with warm acupuncture and moxibustion. New World Diabetes 2015;21:93–5. [Google Scholar]
- [41].She WJ, Chen DG. Observation on the therapeutic effect of warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Massage Rehabil Med 2015;6:19–20. [Google Scholar]
- [42].Yi JC, Xu LN, Zhang S, et al. Clinical observation of warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Hebei J Traditional Chin Med 2012;34:242–4. [Google Scholar]
- [43].Yang M. Summary of 58 cases of warm acupuncture treatment of diabetes with peripheral neuropathy. Hunan J Traditional Chin Med 2011;27:28–9. [Google Scholar]
- [44].Chen D, Li X, Gao WB. Clinical effect of warm acupuncture on 60 cases of diabetic peripheral neuropathy. Clin Res Traditional Chin Med 2011;3:6–7. [Google Scholar]
- [45].Heilongjiang University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Li X. Clinical observation of warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy. 2010;(Dissertation). [Google Scholar]
- [46].Guiyang College of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shen L. Evaluation of the effect of warm acupuncture on diabetic peripheral neuropathy. 2010;(Dissertation). [Google Scholar]
- [47].Sun YZ, Xu YY, Wu D. Clinical and electrophysiological observation of warm acupuncture treatment of diabetic peripheral neuropathy (English). World J Acupuncture Moxibustion 2008;2:1–6. [Google Scholar]
- [48].Ma SQ, Xu J, Yin XY, et al. Clinical observation of 40 patients with diabetic peripheral neuropathy treated with warm acupuncture and moxibustion and decoction. Hunan J Traditional Chinese Med 2020;36:76–9. [Google Scholar]
- [49].Nash J, Armour M, Penkala S. Acupuncture for the treatment of lower limb diabetic peripheral neuropathy: a systematic review. Acupunct Med 2019;37:3–15. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [50].Amato Nesbit S, Sharma R, Waldfogel JM, et al. Non-pharmacologic treatments for symptoms of diabetic peripheral neuropathy: a systematic review. Curr Med Res Opin 2019;35:15–25. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [51].Dimitrova A, Murchison C, Oken B. Acupuncture for the treatment of peripheral neuropathy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Altern Complement Med 2017;23:164–79. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [52].Shamseer L, Moher D, Clarke M, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015: elaboration and explanation. BMJ 2015;350:g7647. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [53].Harrison S, Jones HE, Martin RM, et al. The albatross plot: a novel graphical tool for presenting results of diversely reported studies in a systematic review. Res Synth Methods 2017;8:281–9. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [54].Higgins JPT, Thompson SG. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 2002;21:1539–58. [DOI] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [55].Bell A, Fairbrother M, Jones K. Fixed and random effects models: making an informed choice. Qual Quant 2019;53:1051–74. [Google Scholar]
- [56].Sutton AJ, Duval SJ, Tweedie RL, et al. Empirical assessment of effect of publication bias on meta-analyses. BMJ 2000;320:1574–7. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [57].Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, et al. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997;315:629–34. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]
- [58].Guyatt GH, Oxman AD, Vist GE, et al. GRADE: an emerging consensus on rating quality of evidence and strength of recommendations. BMJ 2008;336:924–6. [DOI] [PMC free article] [PubMed] [Google Scholar]