Pertussis in Individuals with Co-morbidities: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Pertussis is a highly contagious disease of the respiratory tract caused by Bordetella pertussis. Although the burden of pertussis is highest in children, available data suggests that pertussis in the elderly and those with underlying chronic conditions or illnesses can result in significant morbidity, mortality and costs. We undertook a comprehensive review to assess the association between pertussis and chronic conditions/illnesses. A search was undertaken on 17 June 2019 across EMBASE, Medline and BIOSIS. Citations were limited to those in English, in humans and published since 1 January 1990. There were 1179 papers identified with an additional 70 identified through a review of the reference lists. Of these, 34 met the inclusion criteria. Papers included were categorised in groups, those which reported: associations between prior pertussis and subsequent chronic conditions or illnesses; a link between chronic conditions/illnesses and subsequent risk of pertussis; and those which reported on the effect of the chronic conditions/illnesses on pertussis complications or exacerbations. Pertussis appears to increase the likelihood of developing some chronic conditions/illnesses, but also appears to decrease the likelihood of developing some haematological cancers. There were several chronic conditions/illnesses where the study results were mixed, and several studies that found no association with previous pertussis. There were also studies which showed that having some comorbid health condition(s) might increase the risk of developing pertussis. Three studies showed pertussis can lead to increased exacerbations of chronic conditions/illnesses and associated hospitalisations, although one study showed it reduced the effects of chronic bronchitis. Previous pertussis appears to contribute to the increased likelihood of developing some respiratory conditions like asthma, and conversely those with asthma or COPD are at increased risk of severe pertussis requiring further intervention. Further research is required to confirm or disprove these associations, and to characterise the pathophysiological mechanisms behind the potential associations with pertussis.

Plain Language Summary

Pertussis, or whooping cough as it is more commonly known, is a respiratory disease that mainly affects young children, although it can be caught at any age. An increasing number of cases are being identified in older adults. This is concerning since older people typically have other underlying health conditions that can increase the risk of severe outcomes leading to increased mortality. We assessed 34 published studies that examined the link between whooping cough and some health conditions. Several studies found that prior whooping cough was more likely in those with an underlying health condition, and this was particularly true in those with respiratory conditions like asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, whilst there were also studies which showed that having some health condition(s) might increase the risk of developing severe whooping cough which might require medical attention or hospitalisation. There was also some evidence that previous whooping cough might be protective against some blood cancers. Whooping cough was shown to exacerbate several underlying health conditions, although a single study found that it may reduce the risk of chronic bronchitis exacerbations. More research is required to corroborate these findings.

Key Summary Points

Pertussis is increasingly becoming a disease affecting an older group of people rather than young children.

A significant percentage of older people infected with Bordetella pertussis experience considerable morbidity, mortality and costs.

We reviewed 34 studies which considered the association between pertussis and underlying conditions/illnesses.

Previous infection with pertussis appears to contribute to the increased likelihood of developing some respiratory conditions like asthma and COPD, and conversely those with asthma or COPD are at increased risk of pertussis infection and for severe pertussis and/or asthma or COPD exacerbations.

Further research is required to confirm or disprove these associations, and to characterise the pathophysiological mechanisms behind the potential associations.

Digital Features

This article is published with digital features, including a plain language summary, to facilitate understanding of the article. To view digital features for this article go to https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.14627340.

Introduction

The World Health Organization (WHO) describes pertussis (or whooping cough) as ‘a highly contagious disease of the respiratory tract caused by Bordetella pertussis’, an exclusive human pathogen [1]. Although predominantly a paediatric disease, adolescents and adults can also contract the disease. In children the disease is characterised by paroxysmal cough followed by inspiratory ‘whoop’ and post-tussive vomiting, though the clinical course may be influenced by a number of factors including vaccination history and age. Adolescents and adults often have atypical symptoms, and may only present with a persistent prolonged cough illness. The WHO estimates that there were 151,074 cases worldwide in 2018, and up to 89,000 deaths have been reported in previous years (2008) [1]. Currently, vaccination remains the best available strategy to combat pertussis [2].

Infection with pertussis has been shown to have immunodulatory effects (with recent research focusing on the role of adenylate cyclase toxin [CyaA] and type III secretion system [TTSS] effector proteins) [3–8] that may impact the pathogenesis of underlying chronic conditions/illnesses, particularly with regards to mental health disorders and chronic inflammatory conditions [9]. There is evidence that B. pertussis infection can have an effect on asthmatic response [10], respiratory conditions [6, 11] and other atopic conditions [12].

Pertussis in patients with underlying chronic conditions such as asthma or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease can be associated with complications [13, 14] that can lead to increased healthcare costs [15]. In addition, pertussis may play a role in the aetiology of other diseases [16]. A recent estimate suggested that 60% of older people in Europe have at least two chronic conditions/illnesses [17]. Older people are often at significant risk of infectious diseases and resulting complications for several reasons, including no previous or incomplete immunization, waned immunity and immunosenescence.

Pertussis is increasingly being shown to affect the older population. A recent US estimate suggested that 59% of all cases between 2006-2015 were among adolescents and adults [18], a trend which has been noted in other countries [19]. B. pertussis infection in the elderly in particular can result in considerable morbidity, mortality and costs [20–23]. Complications associated with pertussis in adolescents and adults are not infrequent, and include urinary incontinence, rib fracture, pneumothorax, inguinal hernia, aspiration, pneumonia, seizures and otitis media [24]. It can also have a significant negative impact upon quality of life [25]. To date there has been little published on the relationship between pertussis and chronic conditions/illnesses, with only one previous review which focussed mainly on respiratory conditions in ‘at-risk’ populations [26]. The objective of our review was to assess any association between pertussis and chronic conditions/illnesses.

Methods

A search was undertaken on 17 June 2019 across three databases EMBASE, Medline and BIOSIS. The search strategy used the phrases “(pertussis OR whooping cough) AND (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease OR ag* OR comorbid* OR old* OR elderly OR asthma* OR diabet* OR allerg* OR cardiovascular* OR frailty OR COPD OR chronic) AND (risk)”. Citations were limited to those in English language, in humans and published since 1 January 1990. Papers were included if they met the following criteria: the full publication was in English and included subjects who had previously or have pertussis and at least one chronic condition/illness. Papers were excluded if they were reviews (i.e. contained no primary data but included if they contained data not reported elsewhere), reported data that was not categorised by chronic condition/illness, were vaccine trials (e.g. adverse events related to the vaccine) or single-subject design (e.g. case studies). The reference lists of papers retrieved were checked for potentially useful studies not identified in the original search.

The two authors (DM and KE) assessed the studies independently and discussed any papers where there were disagreements as to their potential inclusion or exclusion. Studies which met the inclusion criteria were then entered into Microsoft Excel. Since the potential studies did not involve standardised study designs, and the interventions and comparators were not relevant, only participant data and outcomes data were entered, alongside the chronic condition/illness reported and the study strengths and weaknesses identified by the authors. Since most of the studies were observational studies of exposure, rather than an intervention, and in the absence of a formal and well-validated ‘risk-of-bias’ tool for such studies [27], any formal analysis was not felt to be appropriate; however, each study was assessed against the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) criteria prior to inclusion in our review [28] and the GRADE quality of evidence associated with each study is reported in Table 1. Whilst the default for any observational study is to describe it as ‘low’ quality, there is discretion within the GRADE system to upgrade the quality of evidence level based upon several factors. Where this has been done we have indicated the reasons for our upgrading in the table.

Table 1.

Details of included studies

Citation	Study period	Country	Population	Chronic health conditions/illnesses	Pertussis diagnosis	Study results	GRADE quality of evidence
El Sharif et al. [43]	Dec 2000–Apr 2001	Palestine	273 school children (aged 6–12 years) with wheeze in the past 12 months (of whom 99 children had physician-diagnosed asthma) were matched with an equal number of non-wheezing controls	Asthma	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis increased risk of: – Wheezing in the last 12 months (3.01 [1.42–6.39]) – Physician diagnosed asthma (4.13 [1.76–9.67])	Low
Waked and Salameh [44]	Not reported	Lebanon	5522 school children aged 5–14 years	Asthma and allergic disease	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis increased risk of: – Asthma (3.39 [2.56–4.50]) – Allergic rhinitis (1.23 [1.06–1.42]) – Atopic eczema (1.28 [1.06–1.55]) – Any allergic disease (3.22 [2.41–4.32])	Moderate Large sample size Self-reported pertussis Diagnosed and suspected asthma
Aberle et al. [45]	Not reported	Croatia	411 children (at a local hospital) with asthma aged 6–18 years	Asthma	Not described in paper	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis increased risk of: – Asthma (8.14 [4.14–16])	Low
De Greeff et al. [46]	Jul 2005–Feb 2008	Netherlands	89 children with a history of pertussis, 172 non-pertussis control group. Included children were born between 1 July 2005 and 1 February 2008 and hospitalised for laboratory confirmed pertussis	Respiratory disorders and asthma	Lab confirmed (PCR, culture or serological testing)	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis increased risk of: – Respiratory infection (3.3 [1.6–6.6]) – Asthma symptoms (2.8 [1.1–7.0])	Moderate Small sample size Laboratory confirmed pertussis
Wickens et al. [47]	1992–1993	New Zealand	Potential cases (399) and controls (398) were selected from the Wellington, NZ, arm of the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood	Asthma	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis infection was not strongly associated with increased risks of asthma (1.57 [0.58–4.24])	Low
Bodner et al. [48]	1964	UK	Retrospective analysis of data gathered in 1964 when the MRC Medical Sociology Research Unit carried out a survey of a random sample of 2111 Aberdeen school children aged 10–14 years	Asthma, eczema and hay fever	Self-recall (questionnaire)	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis at age ≤ 3 years and the risk of: – Asthma (1.7 [0.9–2.9]) – Eczema (1.0 [0.5–2.0]) – Hay fever 0.8 [0.3–1.8]) Previous pertussis at age > 3 years and the risk of: – Asthma (1.6 [0.8–2.9]) – Eczema (2.0 [1.2–3.5]) – Hay fever 1.8 [0.9–3.4])	Low
Forastiere et al. [49]	1987	Italy	2226 school children in three areas of the Lazio region of Italy conducted January–June 1987 and September–November 1987	Atopy	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis did not increase risk of atopy (0.9 [0.73–1.12])	Low
Tennant et al. [50]	Cohort born in 1947	UK	All 1142 babies born to mothers resident in Newcastle-upon-Tyne (UK) during May–June 1947 were recruited into a prospective cohort study	Cancer	Reported to health visitors up to age 15	Hazard ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis (during age 0–15 years) increased risk of death from cancer during ages 15–60 years (4.88 [2.29–10.39])	Low
Tennant et al. [51]	Cohort born in 1947	UK	All 1142 babies born to mothers resident in Newcastle-upon-Tyne (UK) during May–June 1947 were recruited into a prospective cohort study	Cancer	Reported to health visitors up to age 15	Adjusted hazard ratio (95% CI): Previous pertussis (during childhood) increased risk of death from cancer during ages 18–60 years 1.95 (1.21–3.14)	Low
Becker et al. [52]	1999–2003	Multinational (Italy, Germany, Ireland, Czech Republic, France, UK, Australia, Canada, USA)	A pooled analysis of data from 17 case–control studies identified through the InterLymph Consortium that met the following eligibility criteria: cases diagnosed with incident histologically confirmed NHL as adults (age 16–96 years); collection of personal history of infections; and electronic data set available in March 2007	Non-Hodgkin lymphoma	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Previous pertussis decreased risk of NHL 0.85 (0.78–0.93)	Low
Parodi et al. [53]	1990–1993	Italy	1771 controls and 649 leukaemia cases from 11 Italian areas. To contain recall bias, the analysis was restricted to subjects directly interviewed and with a good quality interview (1165 controls and 312 cases)	Leukaemia and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma	Self-recall of childhood diseases (interview)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Previous childhood pertussis and the risk of: – CLL 0.66 (0.45–0.98) – AML 0.52 (0.32–0.87) – CML (0.77 [0.43–1.4]) – OL (0.83 [0.32–2.2])	Low
Parodi et al. [54]	1990–1993	Italy	1193 cases, diagnosed between 1990 and 1993, and 1708 population-based controls	Non-Hodgkin’s Lymphoma	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Previous childhood pertussis and the risk of: – All B cell lymphoma (0.74 [0.62–0.88]) – All T cell lymphomas (0.73 [0.24–1.2])	Low
Albonico et al. [55]	1993–1994	Switzerland	410 patients with a diagnosis of carcinoma (malignant solid epithelial tumour) who for any reason were seen in the office of a participating practitioner between 1 June 1993 and 31 January 1994, with a control group of same gender and age (± 3 years) and no malignancy	Cancer	Self-recall (questionnaire)	A history of pertussis did not show a significant effect on cancer risk	Low
Stagnaro et al. [56]	1990–1993	Italy	Information about 213 MM cases and 1128 healthy controls were obtained from a multicentre population-based Italian case–control study	Multiple myeloma	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratios (95% CI): There was no clear association between previous childhood pertussis and the risk of MM (0.91 [0.63–1.3])	Low
Bachmann and Kesselring [57]	1995	Switzerland	606 patients with MS in Switzerland. The data concerning their infectious childhood diseases were compared with epidemiological data for the normal Swiss population obtained from the Swiss Federal Health Office and from the Institute of Medical Statistics	Multiple sclerosis	Self-reported (questionnaire)	More cases in those with pertussis during ages 1–9 years later developed MS than in controls (86.0% vs. 56.7%)	Low
Bager et al. [58]	1940–1975 birth cohort	Denmark	Individuals with multiple sclerosis in the country born between 1940 and 1975, who had attended school in the capital, Copenhagen. Overall, 455 cases and 1801 controls were included in the study	Multiple sclerosis	School health records (reported by parents to physician)	Odds ratios (95% CI): There was no association between previous childhood pertussis (before age 15 years) and the risk of multiple sclerosis (1.0 [0.5–1.9])	Low
Montgomery et al. [60]	5–11 April 1970 and 3–9 March 1958 birth cohorts	UK	Longitudinal analysis of 16,820 members (100 with type 1 DM) of two nationally representative British birth cohorts [the 1970 British Cohort Study (BCS70) and the1958 National Child Development Study (NCDS cohort)] followed from birth to ages 30 years (BCS70) and 42 years (NCDS)	Type 1 diabetes	Reported to health visitors (interviews)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Previous childhood pertussis (onset from birth and onset after age 10 years) increased the risk of type 1 diabetes (2.21 [1.35–3.59] and 2.59 [1.56–4.30], respectively)	Low
Olsen et al. [59]	1978–2011 birth cohort	Denmark	4700 patients with pertussis, of whom 90 developed epilepsy during the follow-up	Epilepsy	Danish National Patient Registry with pertussis hospital-diagnosed during outpatient or emergency clinic visit	Hazard ratio (95% CI): The risk of epilepsy was increased in children with hospital-diagnosed pertussis compared with the general population (1.7 [1.3–2.1])	High Notified diagnosed pertussis Prospective cohort design Large sample size
Guggenheim and Williams [61]	2006–2010	UK	UK Biobank participants of White ethnicity aged 40–69 years who underwent autorefraction (N = 91,592) and were classified as myopic [≤ − 0.75 dioptres (D)], highly myopic (≤ − 6.00 D), or non-myopic (> − 0.75 D)	Myopia	Self-reported (interviews)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Previous childhood pertussis increased risk of: – Myopia (1.39 [1.03–1.87]) – High myopia (2.15 [1.24–3.71])	Low
Witthauer et al. [62]	1998	Germany	Data from the 1998 German Mental Health survey with 4181 subjects aged 18–65 years	Anxiety disorders	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Previous pertussis (lifetime)increased risk of: – Any anxiety disorder (1.69 [1.36–2.09]) But there was no association between previous pertussis (lifetime) and the risk of the following anxiety disorders: – Panic disorder with/without agoraphobia (1.52 [0.97–2.34]) – Panic attack (1.49 [1.07–2.06]) – Agoraphobia without panic disorder (2.15 [1.36–3.40]) – Simple phobia (1.52 [1.15–2.00]) – Phobic disorder (1.49 [0.99–2.24]) – Social phobia (1.35 [0.80–2.27]) – Generalized anxiety disorder (1.94 [1.12–3.35]) – Obsessive–compulsive disorder (1.15 [0.53–2.49])	Low
Hansen et al. [63]	2003–2004	Denmark	123 patients diagnosed with Crohn's disease (CD) and 144 with ulcerative colitis (UC) in Copenhagen (2003–2004) were matched 1:1 on age and gender to 267 orthopaedic controls	Inflammatory bowel disease/ulcerative colitis/Crohn's disease	Self-reported (questionnaire)	Odds ratios (95% CI): There was no association between previous pertussis (before age 20 years) and the risk of: – Crohn's disease (0.67 [0.24–1.87]) – Ulcerative colitis (0.44 [0.14–1.44]) – Inflammatory bowel disease (0.56 [0.27–1.20])	Low
Liu et al. [64]	2006–2008	Australia	Data from 263,094 participants joining a prospective cohort study of Australian adults aged over 45 years (the 45 and Up Study)	Obesity or asthma	Pertussis notifications (laboratory-confirmed and probable) reported to Notifiable Conditions Information Management System (NCIMS)	Hazard ratios (95% CI): Association between BMI and incident of pertussis: – BMI < 25: (1; reference) – BMI 25–29.9 (1.1 [0.78–1.55]) BMI > 30 (1.52 [1.06–2.19]) Association between asthma and incident of pertussis (1.64 [1.06–2.55]) Association between smoking and incident of pertussis: – Never (1; reference) – Current (0.89 [0.51–1.57]) – Past (0.95 [0.71–1.29])	High Notified and confirmed pertussis Retrospective cohort design Large sample size
Capili et al. [65]	2004–2005	USA	223 pertussis cases identified by means of PCR in 2004 and 2005. Age- and sex-matched control subjects from 5537 patients with negative test results for pertussis	Asthma	PCR confirmed	Odds ratio (95% CI): Those with asthma have an increased risked of pertussis (1.73 [1.12–2.67]) Population-attributable risk of asthma for risk of pertussis was 17%	High Confirmed pertussis Test-negative design
De Serres et al. [66]	1998	Canada	Study evaluated 280 adolescent and 384 adult cases with disease during 1 July and 30 December 1998 reported to public health units	Asthma	Clinical and laboratory-confirmed (30%), as per Health Canada case definition	There was a slightly higher prevalence of patients with pertussis who had asthma but it had no effect on the severity of the disease and the strength of any association was not reported Duration of cough, risk of sinusitis, and number of nights with disturbed sleep increased with smoking and asthma	Moderate Diagnosed and confirmed pertussis Descriptive analyses only
Mbayei et al. [67]	2011–2015	USA	15,942 cases of pertussis with cough onset from 1 January 2011 through 31 December 2015	Multiple comorbidities including obesity, asthma, diabetes, potentially immunocompromising conditions and COPD	Reported by healthcare providers from 7 US Emerging Infections Program Network states	Among adolescents and adults aged 12–20 years, 21–64 years and ≥ 65 years 43.5% (10/23), 26.3% (20/76) and 26.85 (11/41) had a history of asthma, respectively Other underlying conditions in adults aged 21–64 years (n = 76) and ≥ 65 years (n = 41) respectively included: obesity (52.6% and 39.0%, respectively), smoker (34.2% and 26.8%), having a potentially immunocompromising condition (25% and 9.8%), being diabetic (19.7% and 31.7%) having some form of cardiac condition (9.2% and 29.3%), COPD (14.5% and 26.8%), renal disease (10.5% and 9.8%) or a neurological condition (5.3% and 9.8%). The strength of any association was not reported. Birth weight < 2500 g was a risk factor for hospitalisation among pertussis patients aged < 2 months (RR 1.92 [1.23–2.98]) and 2–11 months (RR 1.98 [1.01–3.86])	High Notified pertussis Large sample size
Buck et al. [15]	2006–2014	USA	Patients aged 5–11 years with diagnosed pertussis and pre-existing COPD (n = 343) or asthma (n = 1041) were matched 1:1 to patients with diagnosed pertussis but without COPD or asthma. The data sources were the MarketScan Commercial Claims and Encounters and Medicare Supplemental and Coordination of Benefits (1/2006–6/2014) and Medicaid Multi-State (1/2007–12/2013) databases	Asthma or COPD	Primary or secondary diagnosis of pertussis (defined by International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM) codes 033.0x, 033.9x and 484.3x	The incidence of diagnosed pertussis was higher among patients with COPD or asthma than among matched patients. Compared with matched patients, patients with pertussis and pre-existing COPD or asthma accrued greater all-cause adjusted costs across study period ($3694 and $1193 more, respectively, in the 45-day period; $4173 and $1301 more in the 3-month period; and $6154 and $1639 more in the 6-month period)	High Diagnosed pertussis Large sample size Retrospective cohort design
Hashemi et al. [68]	Not stated	Iran	90 consecutive patients referred to outpatient with COPD and 90 age- and sex-matched control subjects	COPD	Antibody titres against pertussis toxin (anti-PT) were measured by ELISA anti-PT IgG titres > 24 U/mL and anti-PT IgA titres > 12 U/mL were considered to be positive	The frequency of anti-PT IgG seropositivity was significantly higher in patients with COPD than in controls (P < 0.001) No association between B. pertussis IgA seropositivity and COPD No association observed between B. pertussis infection and severity of COPD	Low
Harju et al. [74]	1999	Finland	103 asthmatics and 30 control subjects	Asthma	PCR test	B. pertussis positive individuals had lower FEV1/FVC (77.1% vs. 80.7%, P = 0.012) and more asthma symptoms than B. pertussis negative cases	Low
Meyer et al. [69]	2010–2014	USA	464 hospitalised case-patients with confirmed or probable pertussis from 1 January 2010 to 31 December 2014	Asthma/COPD	Reported by healthcare providers in the 7 US states participating in the Enhanced Pertussis Surveillance network	High rates of obstructive pulmonary disease such as asthma or COPD suggest a potential risk factor for severe pertussis infection requiring hospitalisation	Moderate Diagnosed, notified pertussis Descriptive analyses only
Rigelman-Hedberg et al. [70]	2004–2005	USA	142 pertussis cases and for each case 2 birthday- and gender-matched controls (284) who had a negative test for pertussis within the same month	Atopic dermatitis, eczema, allergic rhinitis and hay fever	Reported by healthcare provider	Individuals with non-asthmatic atopic conditions do not appear to have increased susceptibility to pertussis	High Diagnosed pertussis 1:2 case to control ratio
Røysted et al. [72]	May 2007–Dec 2008	Norway	387 adult patients admitted to hospital with two or more symptoms/signs of lower respiratory tract infection and radiologically confirmed pneumonia	Community-acquired pneumonia	Lab confirmed by PCR	No relationship was found between CAP and pertussis infection	High
Barger-Kamate et al. [73]	Aug 2011–Jan 2014	7 African and Asian countries	B. pertussis was detected in 53 of 4200 (1.3%) cases and 11 of 5196 (0.2%) controls. These were children 1–59 months of age hospitalised with World Health Organization-defined severe or very severe pneumonia and similarly aged community controls	Pneumonia	Lab confirmed	Pertussis causes a small fraction of hospitalised pneumonia cases and deaths; however, case fatality pertussis-infected pneumonia cases aged 1–5 months substantial (12.5% [95% CI 4.2–26.8%]) Pertussis-positive African cases 1–5 months old (where all cases in this age group occurred), compared to controls, were more often human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) uninfected-exposed (OR, 2.2 [0.99–4.76]) and underweight (aOR 6.3 [3.0–13.0]) (all P ≤ 0.05)	High
Karki et al. [71]	2006–2012	Australia	Cases and controls identified from a cohort of 267,153 adults aged 45 years and older (45 and Up Study)	Age	Pertussis notifications reported to Notifiable Conditions Information Management System (NCIMS)	Odds ratios (95% CI): Factors associated with pertussis hospitalisations were age: – Age 45–545 years (1; reference) – Age 65–74 years (5.4 [1.6–18.2]) – Age ≥ 75 years (8.9 [2.3–34.7])	High Notified pertussis Large sample size Prospective cohort design
Bonhoeffer et al. [75]	Oct 2000–Jun 2002	Switzerland	26 patients with acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis	Acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis	All culture and PCR samples were negative Serology revealed Bordetella infection in eight (31%) patients	Duration of cough was shorter in patients with B. pertussis compared to those without B. pertussis (mean 15 vs. 41 days, P = 0.04). Cough ≥ 21 days duration was present in three (43%) of seven patients with evidence of B. pertussis compared to 17 (94%) of 18 controls (P = 0.012	Moderate Confirmed pertussis Small sample size

AML acute myeloid leukaemia, BMI body mass index, CAP community-acquired pneumonia, CD Crohn's disease, CI confidence intervals, CLL chronic lymphocytic leukaemia, CML chronic myeloid leukaemia, COPD chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, DM diabetes mellitus, ELISA enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, GRADE Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation, IBD inflammatory bowel disease, MM multiple myeloma, MS multiple sclerosis, NHL non-Hodgkin lymphoma, OL other leukaemia, PCR polymerase chain reaction, PT-IgG pertussis toxin-immunoglobulin G, UC ulcerative colitis

Compliance with Ethics Guidelines

This article is based on previously conducted studies and does not contain any new studies with human participants or animals performed by any of the authors.

Results

There were 1179 papers identified through the search of databases with an additional 70 papers identified from other sources; after checking the abstract of the articles, 285 papers (21% of the original search) were obtained for full assessment. The reasons for exclusion are summarised in Fig. 1. There was heterogeneity across the studies in terms of population assessed, study locations, identification of pertussis cases and study designs, which precluded meaningful statistical pooling/meta-analysis of the available data (Table 1). The available data are synthesized into a narrative summary focusing on general trends within selected groupings.

Fig. 1.

PRISMA 2009 flow diagram

Overall, 34 papers met the inclusion criteria. These papers are summarised in three sections: those that reported associations between pertussis and subsequent chronic health conditions/illnesses, those which reported associations between underlying chronic conditions/illnesses and subsequent risk of pertussis, and those that reported on the effect of pertussis on the complications or severity of underlying chronic health conditions/illnesses. One of the methods used for the diagnosis of pertussis is to measure immunoglobulin M (IgM), immunoglobulin A (IgA) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies against B. pertussis by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA) [29], which are faster and more accurate than traditional bacterial agglutination tests [30] and immunofluorescence tests [31]. Although both culture and serology tests should be conducted for optimal diagnosis [32, 33], these have largely been superseded by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay [34, 35]. Nonetheless, culture and PCR lack sensitivity among those tested late after presenting with symptoms [36–39]. There is also wide variation in laboratory diagnosis of pertussis both within countries and between countries [40–42]. Since there is a lack of standardised testing for the disease we have included studies with both laboratory-confirmed and suspected/clinically diagnosed pertussis. A brief summary of the key results from each of the relevant studies is provided below, categorised where possible by comorbid condition and we have also distinguished between studies where pertussis was confirmed by laboratory testing or suspected/clinically diagnosed (e.g. diagnosed by a healthcare professional, and those studies which relied on patient self-recall of infection).

Associations Between Previous Pertussis and Subsequent Development of Chronic Health Conditions/Illnesses

Asthma

There were four studies in infants and young children that suggested previous pertussis could lead to an increased risk of developing asthma or other respiratory conditions [43–46].

The only study relying on confirmed diagnosis of pertussis was conducted in the Netherlands. It reported that those born between 1 July 2005 and 1 February 2008 with a history of laboratory-confirmed pertussis in infancy (within the first 6 months) (n = 89) had a relative risk of 2.8 (95% confidence intervals [CI], 1.1–7.0) for “asthma symptoms” at toddler age (13–45 months) [46]. The small sample size in this study might, in part, explain the wide confidence intervals associated with the estimate of effect.

Four additional studies investigated this association relying on survey-based parental confirmation of prior pertussis, and found comparable results. A study conducted between December 2000 and April 2001 among children (n = 273) aged 6–12 years in Palestine with wheezing (including asthmatics) in the previous 12 months reported that pertussis (which was reported by the parents as having occurred any time prior to the study) was an important determinant of asthma (odds ratio [OR] 4.13; 95% CI 1.76–9.67) [43]. Another study conducted in the Middle East found that children aged 5–14 years (n = 209) with a history of pertussis (by self-report at any stage prior to the study) had higher odds of probable asthma (OR 3.39; 95% CI 2.56–4.50), allergic rhinitis (OR 1.23; 95% CI 1.06–1.42), atopic eczema (OR 1.28; 95% CI 1.06–0.55) or any of these diseases combined (OR 3.22; 95% CI 2.41–4.32) [44]. A history of pertussis was also identified as an independent risk factor for asthma in Croatia (OR 8.14; 95% CI 4.14–16, P < 0.001) in a sample involving school children (n = 411) aged 6–18 years compared to non-asthmatic controls (n = 403) [45].

In contrast, one case–control study conducted in New Zealand in 1994 which included 399 children with asthma aged 7–9 years and 398 matched controls, reported no statistically significant association between pertussis infection and increased risk of asthma (OR 1.57; 95% CI 0.58–4.24) [47].

Atopic Conditions

There were two studies examining potential associations between pertussis and atopic conditions, both of which relied upon self-report of pertussis [48, 49].

A study in the UK assessing childhood infections and atopic diseases in children (n = 2111) aged 10–14 years in 1964 found that there was an increased risk of eczema in patients who reported a history of pertussis after age 3 years (OR 2.0; 95% CI 1.2–3.5) [48]. Conversely, another study undertaken in Italy in 1987 (children [n = 2226] aged 7–11 years) observed that a self-reported history of pertussis was not associated with increased risk of atopy [49]. These contradictory findings, all based on self-reporting of pertussis, give weak evidence towards such an association.

Cancer

All studies which analysed the association between pertussis and cancer relied on self-reported prior experience of pertussis. As a result, and considering the contradictory findings explained below, the level of evidence for any such association is weak.

There were two studies based on a longitudinal cohort of individuals (n = 1142) born in Newcastle, UK in 1947. The authors reported that childhood pertussis was associated with higher cancer mortality during age 15–60 years (adjusted hazard ratio = 4.88, 95% CI 2.29–10.38) [50]. In an abstract (based on the same study), the authors reported that either tuberculosis or pertussis was independently predictive of mortality between ages 18 and 60 years [adjusted hazard ratio (aHR) = 2.00 (95% CI 1.17–3.41) and 1.95 (95% CI 1.21–3.14), respectively] [51]. However, the effect of pertussis on mortality was largely attributable to a higher risk of death from cancer. It was hypothesised that possibly pertussis and cancer may share some common risk factors that were not examined in the study (e.g. parental smoking or lower fruit and vegetable consumption during childhood). Other alternatives considered were poor immune function in the individuals affected, thereby increasing their susceptibility to pertussis and cancer, or that pertussis toxin itself might cause a relative increase in cell proliferation.

In contrast, three case–control studies found an inverse association between self-reported previous pertussis and a risk of developing some forms of cancers [52–54]. Becker et al., in a large multinational study (n = 12,585 cases and 15,416 controls aged 16–96 years) found that self-reported prior pertussis disease was associated with a 15% reduced risk in the subsequent development of non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) [52]. In an Italian study of 649 leukaemia cases between 1990 and 1999 (vs. 1771 controls) [53], Parodi et al. found that previous childhood pertussis was associated with lower risk of chronic lymphoid leukaemia (CLL) (OR 0.66, 95% CI 0.45–0.98) and acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) (OR 0.52, 95% CI 0.32–0.87). A later publication by Parodi et al. of 1193 NHL cases, diagnosed between 1990 and 1993, found that previous childhood pertussis was associated with lower risk (OR 0.74, 95% CI 0.62–0.88) of B cell lymphomas (1102 cases assessed vs. 1708 controls) [54].

Two case-controlled studies found no association between pertussis in childhood (either prior to age 14 [55] or age 21 [56] years) and solid tumour-related cancers [55, 56]. Albonico et al. showed no association between previous pertussis and the risk of developing carcinoma (malignant solid epithelial tumour [n = 410] vs. controls [n = 379]) in Switzerland between June 1993 and January 1994 [55]. Stagnaro et al. showed no association between previous pertussis and the risk of multiple myeloma (213 cases vs. 1128 controls) in Italy between 1990 and 1993 [56]. In addition, it should be noted that in both the Parodi papers described earlier [53, 54], there were no associations found between pertussis and some haematological cancers including chronic myeloid leukaemia and T cell lymphomas.

Multiple Sclerosis

A study conducted in Switzerland compared survey data of those with multiple sclerosis (n = 606) in 1995 with data obtained from the Swiss Federal Health Office and from the Institute of Medical Statistics. It identified that a higher proportion of participants (86.0% vs. 56.7%) reported prior experience of pertussis below age 10 years in those who subsequently developed multiple sclerosis [57]. However, another study reported no association (aOR 0.9, 95% CI 0.7–1.1) between self-reported previous childhood pertussis and diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (at age 15–56 years) in Danish cohorts born since 1940 (455 cases vs. 1801 controls) or since 1950 (182 cases vs. 690 controls) and 1975 [58]. These contradictory findings, and the more robust design of the Danish study, argue in favour of a lack of association.

Epilepsy

A Danish population-based study assessed the association between hospital-diagnosed pertussis and the long-term risk of epilepsy in a cohort born between 1978 and 2011. There were 4700 patients with pertussis diagnosis identified from the Danish National Patient Registry, of whom 90 developed epilepsy during the up to 15-year follow-up (versus 511 in the 47,000 members in the comparison cohort). Whilst the risk of epilepsy was increased in children with hospital-diagnosed pertussis compared with the general population (hazard ratio 1.7; 95% CI 1.3–2.1 at age 10 years) , the absolute risk was low [incidence rate 1.56 per 1000 person-years (95% CI 1.55–1.57)]. Interestingly, although the hazard ratio was not statistically different between the 1978–1997 and the 1998–2011 birth cohorts, the absolute risk of epilepsy was reduced among participants with previous pertussis diagnosis who were born from 1998 onwards and thus vaccinated with an acellular pertussis vaccine, compared to 1997 and before [59].

Diabetes Mellitus

A large longitudinal study of two British birth cohorts (the 1970 British Cohort Study [born 5–11 April 1970] and the National Child Development Study [born 3–9 March 1958]) followed from birth to ages 30 and 42 years, respectively, assessed the association of previous childhood pertussis (ascertained during periodic home interviews) and type 1 diabetes mellitus (DM) [60]. There were 100 type 1 DM cases among the 16,820 individuals assessed. Self-reported previous pertussis was associated with increased risk of type 1 DM onset after age 10 years (aOR 2.59; 95% CI 1.56–4.30). Of note, infant vaccination against pertussis appeared to decrease this risk (aOR 0.63; 95% CI 0.42–0.94).

Myopia

One study assessed the association between pertussis before age 17 years and the risk of myopia among UK Biobank participants of white ethnicity aged 40–69 years who underwent autorefraction (n = 91,592) during 2006–2010. After adjusting for potential confounding variables (age, sex, birth order and educational qualifications) a self-reported history of pertussis was associated with increased risk of myopia (OR 1.39; 95% CI 1.03–1.87) [61].

Anxiety Disorder

A study in Germany involving 4181 adults aged 18–65 years in 1998 found that self-reported previous (during lifetime) pertussis (OR 1.69; 95% CI 1.36–2.09) was associated with increased prevalence of any anxiety disorder and that those subjects with both infectious diseases and anxiety disorders reported lower levels of both mental and physical quality of life, compared with subjects with only one or neither condition [62].

Inflammatory Bowel Disease

No association between self-reported childhood pertussis and development of inflammatory bowel disease (Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis) at age 10–95 years was observed in a Danish case–control study (267 cases and 267 matched control) undertaken for the period 2003–2004 (combined OR, 0.56; 95% CI 0.27–1.20) [63].

Associations Between Underlying Chronic Conditions/Illnesses and Subsequent Risk of Pertussis

Asthma

A study in Australia (the 45 and Up Study), which included 263,094 adults aged over 45 years recruited between January 2006 and December 2008 [64], reported that after adjustment for age, sex and other factors, adults with pre-existing asthma were more likely to be diagnosed with pertussis (based on notification record) compared to those without asthma (RR 1.64; 95% CI 1.06–2.55). Capili et al. [65] in a US-based study (223 PCR confirmed pertussis cases in 2004–2005 matched against 5537 negative controls) also reported that asthma was associated with an increased risk of pertussis (OR 1.73; 95% CI 1.12–2.67; P = 0.013), representing a 17% population attributable risk percentage of asthma for the risk of pertussis. In a Canadian study conducted by De Serres et al. during an outbreak in 1998, there was increased prevalence of asthma in patients at least 12 years old (n = 664) with clinical pertussis (30% of cases laboratory confirmed), compared to the general population, but the strength of the association was not assessed. Nonetheless, while patients with asthma did not assess their pertussis illness as more severe than patients without asthma, pertussis in patients with asthma resulted in increased duration of cough (P = 0.004) and increased number of disturbed night sleep (P = 0.03) [66].

A review of pertussis cases (n = 15,942) with cough onset in 2011–2015 notified in the seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states found at least one underlying medical condition in 32.6% (168/515) of hospitalised cases. This increased to 87.2% (102/117) among hospitalised adults aged 21 years or older. Among adolescents and adults aged 12–20 years, 43.5% (10/23) had a history of asthma. More than a quarter of hospitalised adults 21–64 years old and elderly adults aged 65 years old and above with pertussis had a history of asthma (26.3% and 26.8%, respectively) [67].

A retrospective analysis of the US administrative claims databases covering the 2006–2014 period recorded a relative risk of diagnosed pertussis of 3.96 (95% CI 3.81–4.12) in persons with pre-existing asthma (incidence rate 0.274 per 1000 person-years) compared to persons without asthma (incidence rate 0.069 per 1000 person-years) [15]. In addition, a larger proportion (2.02% vs. 1.44%) of patients with pertussis and pre-existing asthma than patients with pertussis but no asthma had at least one pertussis-related hospitalisation in the 45 days, 3 months and 6 months period following pertussis diagnosis. Patients with pertussis and pre-existing asthma accrued greater all-cause adjusted costs compared with matched patients ($1193 more in a 45-day period, $1301 more in a 3-month period and $1639 more in a 6-month period; all P < 0.0001).

Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD)

The review of 2011–2015 pertussis cases (n = 15,942) notified in the seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states described earlier in more detail also reported that 14.5% (11/76) of adults 21–64 years old and 26.8% (11/41) of elderly adults (aged 65 years or older) had a history of COPD [67].

The retrospective analysis of US administrative claims databases (described in more detail earlier) found that the incidence of diagnosed pertussis was higher among patients with COPD (0.176 per 1000 person-years than among matched patients (0.069 per 1000 person-years), with a relative risk of 2.53 (95% CI 2.40–2.68) [15]. In addition, a larger proportion (4.08% vs. 2.33%) of patients with pertussis and pre-existing COPD than patients with pertussis but no COPD had at least one pertussis-related hospitalisation in the 45 days, 3 and 6 months period following pertussis diagnosis. Patients with pertussis and pre-existing COPD accrued greater all-cause adjusted costs compared with matched patients ($3694 more in a 45-day period, $4173 more in a 3-month period and $6154 more in a 6-month period; all P < 0.0001).

A case–control study in Iranian adults (mean age 67.7 years) found 92.2% of 90 patients with COPD vs. 51.1% of 90 matched controls without COPD (P < 0.001) had serological indication (anti-PT IgG) of recent B. pertussis infection [68].

Asthma or COPD

A chart review survey of hospitalised laboratory-confirmed and clinically diagnosed pertussis cases (n = 464) notified in 2010–2014 in the seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states identified 165 (35.6%) cases with at least one underlying condition, with higher rates reported among adults aged 21 years or older (89.2%), including a substantial proportion (31.4%) with a history of asthma and/or COPD [69]. The authors concluded that the high rates of asthma or COPD suggest a potential risk factor for severe pertussis requiring hospitalisation, although the study did not test the hypothesis statistically.

Atopic Conditions

A population-based case–control study of pertussis cases (n = 142) identified in 2004 and 2005 in the USA found similar rates of atopic conditions (eczema, hay fever, atopic dermatitis and allergic rhinitis) among cases (37.4%; 53/142) and corresponding controls (39.4%; 112/284) [70]. The OR for atopic conditions predicting risk of pertussis was 0.91 (95% CI 0.58–1.40), suggesting that these conditions did not increase susceptibility to pertussis.

Obesity

The previously described review of 2011–2015 pertussis cases (from seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states) found that among those hospitalised with pertussis 52.6% (40/76) of adults aged 21–64 years and 39.0% (16/41) aged 65 years or older were obese [67]. The Australian 45 and Up Study described earlier also examined the association between body mass index (BMI) and pertussis. Adults with a high BMI (RR 1.52 [95% CI 1.06–2.19]; BMI > 30 kg/m² vs. BMI < 25 kg/m²) were more likely to be notified as a pertussis case [64]. It should be noted that a subsequent analysis of data from the same cohort [71] did not observe that the risk of pertussis hospitalisation was statistically significantly higher for patients with obesity but the point estimate suggested that the risk ‘may well be increased’.

Miscellaneous Conditions

The review of 2011–2015 pertussis cases (from seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states) described earlier also found other underlying conditions were common in adults aged 21–64 years (n = 76) and 65 years or older (n = 41) including having a potentially immunocompromising condition (25% and 9.8%, respectively), being diabetic (19.7% and 31.7%) having some form of cardiac condition (9.2% and 29.3%), renal disease (10.5% and 9.8%) or a neurological condition (5.3% and 9.8%) [67].

A study that investigated the bacterial aetiology of community-acquired pneumonia (CAP) in hospitalised adults in Norway from May 2007 through December 2008 found that less than 1% (2/324) were positive for pertussis [72]. No relationship was found between CAP and pertussis infection. It was concluded that routine testing for pertussis would have no place in these groups of patients. Another study, which assessed the clinical and epidemiologic characteristics of pertussis among children aged 1–59 months hospitalised with severe pneumonia in seven African and Asian countries between August 2011 and January 2014, identified pertussis by PCR in 1.3% (53/4200) cases and 0.2% (11/5196) controls [73]. Among the African cohort, pertussis was identified in 3.7% of 137 in-hospital deaths among those aged 1–5 months; the pertussis-infected pneumonia case fatality ratio was 12.5% (95% CI 4.2–26.8%; 5/40). No pertussis-positive cases aged 1–5 months were identified at the Asian sites involved. In comparison, 23% (3/13) died among the pertussis-positive cases aged 6–59 months.

Smoking

Three studies investigated the impact of smoking on the risk and burden of pertussis. The review of 2011–2015 pertussis cases (from seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states) described earlier identified that 31.6% of adults 21 years of age and older hospitalised with pertussis were current or past smokers [67]. An analysis of the Australian 45 and Up Study also found that smoking was a risk factor for pertussis-related hospitalisations (aOR 2.37 [95% CI 1.11–5.06] ever versus never) [71]. These findings were reinforced by the results of the retrospective analysis of notified pertussis cases among adolescent and adults 12 years of age and older in the 1998 outbreak in Québec, Canada. De Serres et al. found that smokers had increased duration of paroxysmal cough (P = 0.004), increased prevalence of sinusitis in pertussis (P = 0.008) and somewhat increased number of nights disturbed by coughing (P = 0.4) [66].

Effect of Age on Pertussis Burden

The Australian 45 and Up Study reported that the pertussis incidence in the cohort was 94 per 100,000 (95% CI 82–108), which did not differ by age group, although hospitalisations increased with older age (2.2, 8.5 and 13.5 per 100,000 person-years in age groups 45–64, 65–74 and 75 years or older, respectively). However, it was acknowledged that passive notification and variations in laboratory testing may have contributed to underestimation of true rates in the cohort [64]. An additional analysis [71] based upon the same study sample reinforced the conclusion that age was a significant factor in pertussis-related hospitalisations (aOR 5.4 [95% CI 1.6–18.2] and 8.9 [95% CI 2.3–34.7] in those aged 65–74 years and 75 years or older, respectively). The influence of age was also mentioned as a factor that appeared to increase the burden of pertussis in the analysis of cases notified during the 1998 outbreak in Québec, Canada (although in this study only 30% of cases were confirmed pertussis) [66]. The study by Mbayei et al., which looked at pertussis-related hospitalisations (n = 515) in the USA between 2011 and 2015, also found that patients aged 65 years or older were at increased risk of both hospitalisations and intensive care admissions (relative risk [RR], 4; 95% CI 3–5.4 and RR, 1.8; 95% CI 0.67–4.9) respectively, compared to other age groups [67].

Impact of Pertussis on Progression of Chronic Conditions/Illnesses

Asthma

In the review of 2011–2015 pertussis cases (from seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states) described earlier, 13.2% of 21–64-year-olds and 24.4% of those aged 65 years or older were hospitalised with admission diagnosis of asthma or COPD exacerbation [67]. Harju et al. [74] assessed respiratory infections, including pertussis, as triggers of asthma exacerbations in Finland in 1999. Among the 103 asthmatics and 30 control subjects assessed there were 30 PCR-positive pertussis cases: five healthy controls (16.7%), 15 mild asthmatics (28.3%) and 10 moderate asthmatics (20%). Pertussis-positive individuals had lower forced expiratory volume/forced vital capacity (77.1% vs. 80.7%, P = 0.012) and more asthma symptoms than pertussis-negative cases (P = 0.053) [74]. In addition, in the retrospective analysis of cases in the 1998 pertussis outbreak in Québec, Canada, 93% of pertussis cases who were previously using bronchodilator aerosol had to increase their medication because of pertussis [66]. Finally, the retrospective analysis of US administrative claims databases (described in more detail above) found that the proportion of patients with at least one all-cause hospitalisation in the 45 days, 3 and 6 months following pertussis diagnosis was higher in the asthma cohort (6.92%, 5.47% and 4.51%, respectively) than in the no-asthma cohort (2.60%, 2.98% and 1.92%, respectively) [15].

COPD

As noted earlier, both the retrospective analysis of 2011–2015 notified cases in the seven US Emerging Infections Program Network states and the review of cases notified in the 1998 outbreak in Québec, Canada identified significant increase in signs of asthma or COPD exacerbation among pertussis cases [66, 67]. In addition, as for asthma, the retrospective analysis of US administrative claims databases (described in more detail earlier) found that the proportion of patients with at least one all-cause hospitalisation in the 45 days, 3 and 6 months following pertussis diagnosis was higher in the COPD cohort (12.24%, 10.21% and 8.46%, respectively) than in the non-COPD cohort (6.41%, 5.54% and 4.95%, respectively) [15].

Although the case–control study undertaken in Iran among patients with COPD and controls without COPD found increased signs of pertussis infection among patients with COPD, no association was observed between B. pertussis infection and severity of COPD [68].

A small study of adults (n = 26) with acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis conducted in Switzerland between 2000 and 2002 [75] identified B. pertussis infection by serology in eight (31%) of the patients. The study showed that pertussis infection was associated with a shorter duration of cough (mean 15 vs. 41 days, P = 0.04) compared with cough of unknown aetiology. Cough of at least 21 days duration was present in three (43%) of seven patients with evidence of Bordetella infection compared to 17 (94%) of 18 controls (P = 0.012). The shorter duration of cough in those with pertussis was somewhat unexpected and it was postulated that this was probably due to pertussis reinfection, which is common in adults, leading to comparatively mild symptoms in these cases owing to the partial immunity from previous infection.

Discussion

Over time, a significant amount of evidence has been accumulated on the potential association of pertussis with various chronic conditions, resulting in heterogeneous findings, but also some clear signs of correlation, specifically with chronic respiratory diseases.

Pertussis infection induces strong immunomodulatory mechanisms which are known to play an important role in the pathophysiology of whooping cough. Therefore, it stands to reason that these actions on the immune system may play a role in triggering or enhancing other pathologies which may involve the immune system. The evidence we uncovered on the possible associations of pertussis with the subsequent development of chronic conditions is generally weak. One of its main shortcomings is that given the time lag between pertussis and the condition of interest, evidence of prior pertussis infection often relied on self-reporting. The fundamental bias introduced by such an exposure definition puts into question the validity of the findings. Nonetheless, in the case of asthma, one study, albeit of small size, using confirmed cases of pertussis demonstrated an association between infant pertussis and subsequent development of asthma symptoms in childhood [46]. While the rest of the evidence on risk of asthma after pertussis infection relied on self-reported cases of pertussis, it was generally consistent with this finding [43–45]. The immunologic nature of asthma may be at play in this association, and it seems reasonable to think that the immunomodulatory effects of pertussis, particularly if effected on a specifically susceptible background, may stimulate the development of allergic asthma in subsequent years. The results presented here are, in many ways, consistent with the hypotheses of Rubin and Glazer (2018) [76] who suggested that B. pertussis colonization was an important cause of asthma and diseases of allergic sensitization after applying the Bradford Hill criteria in a review of data from the USA and the former Democratic Republic of Germany (1980–2007). It has also been suggested, in contrast, that previous infections with pertussis, early in childhood, promote allergic sensitisation [44, 49, 47, 74, 48, 60, 75]. Similar hypotheses have been made for the association found between pertussis and diabetes, especially type 1 diabetes. Although relying on self-reported pertussis, one study did conclude to an increased risk of diabetes following a pertussis episode, and further supported this with indications that pertussis vaccination reduced this risk [60]. The authors in this case suggested that the immunomodulatory effect of pertussis may trigger autoimmune mechanisms causing type 1 diabetes. With somewhat different mechanisms at play, one study relying on diagnosed pertussis cases found a significant association between infant pertussis and later risk of epilepsy [59]. While the overall risk was low, the authors hypothesised that neurological damage which can result from severe pertussis disease in early infancy (cases in this study were hospital diagnosed) could be behind this association [59]. In fact, an apparent reduction in incidence of epilepsy diagnosis noted in this study coincided with the introduction of the more immunogenic acellular pertussis vaccine, and possibly reflected the milder course of pertussis in breakthrough pertussis cases. For the other conditions studied, including atopic conditions [49], cancers [52–55], multiple sclerosis [57, 58], myopia [61] and inflammatory bowel disease [63], the evidence we found was weak (i.e. relying on self-reported pertussis, single studies, small sample sizes or design limitations) and often contradictory, making it difficult to draw conclusions.

Conversely, a larger and more robust body of evidence exists to show that underlying conditions/illnesses could increase the likelihood of developing pertussis or more severe forms of pertussis, potentially requiring medical interventions and, in some cases, hospitalisation. In particular, consistent evidence from different settings (i.e. Australia [64, 71], Canada [66], Iran [68] and mainly the USA [15, 65, 67, 69]) and using different data sources or methodologies (i.e. cohorts, notification databases, administrative claims databases) indicates that asthma and/or COPD [15, 64–67, 69] is particularly associated with a 1.64-fold [64] to almost 4-fold [43] increased likelihood of pertussis. Asthma represented an associated risk factor in 43.5% of adolescents hospitalised with pertussis, and asthma or COPD was a risk factor in more than a quarter of adults hospitalised with pertussis [67]. These conditions appear not only to increase the risk of pertussis but also to increase the duration and severity of its symptoms, the risk of hospitalisation for pertussis and consequently the costs associated with pertussis in these age groups [15]. The inflammatory pathophysiology of pertussis and the offense caused by pertussis infection on reactive airways of patients with asthma and COPD provide the likely explanation for this increased burden of whooping cough in these specific populations. In contrast, there was no association found between atopic conditions and subsequent pertussis [70]. Studies in Australia and the USA found an association between obesity and increased risk of pertussis diagnosis [64, 67]. However, the association is not clearly explained. In fact, it is unclear whether obesity represents a risk factor for pertussis per se, or whether it is a proxy for other associated comorbidities which could more clearly provide a causal risk factor for pertussis. Interestingly, several studies also explored the role of smoking and age [66, 67, 71] in the risk of pertussis and found that current or past smoking, as well as older age, increased the risk and severity of pertussis. In the case of smoking, the damage to the airways caused by tobacco smoke, and the increased risk of COPD in smokers, could certainly explain on their own the increased risk of pertussis. The effect of age likely reflects the higher likelihood of clinical pertussis and more severe forms of pertussis that come from the combined effect of more fragile health resulting from aging and the increased prevalence of chronic diseases. Other studies also investigated and suggested how other conditions, including compromised immune systems [67], diabetes [60] and cardiovascular disease [67], could increase the risk of pertussis. The evidence is weaker for these conditions and it is possible that pertussis infection on such backgrounds may lead to higher likelihood of diagnosis and healthcare usage.

Finally, the evidence we found also indicates that, in the presence of an underlying chronic conditions/illnesses, pertussis can lead to exacerbation of the underlying comorbidity and result in increased healthcare need. Consistent and strong study results from the USA [15, 65, 67, 69], Canada [66], Finland [74] and Switzerland [75] using diverse data sources and analytical methods showed that pertussis infection in persons with asthma or COPD leads to poorer respiratory capacity, more and stronger asthma/COPD exacerbations, increased use of bronchodilator and increased hospitalisation, resulting in higher healthcare costs [69, 74].

The principal strength of our study is that it uses a well-defined and accepted methodology (i.e. that of a systematic review) to identify suitable studies for inclusion. The weakness of our study is that we restricted the literature to those publications which are in the English language, so we may have omitted studies published in other languages, and by restricting our search to three databases we may have been unable to identify studies which were published in non-indexed journals. In addition, much of the data were from single studies of a condition, which make interpretation of the data difficult. Whilst some of the studies were large and longitudinal, many were hampered by the lack of definitive laboratory confirmation of pertussis. As noted above, the diagnosis of pertussis in adults is often not reliant upon laboratory testing which limits the robustness of the evidence suggesting potential associations or lack thereof.

Conclusion

Previous pertussis appears to contribute to the increased likelihood of developing some respiratory conditions like asthma, and conversely those with asthma or COPD are at increased risk of pertussis and severe pertussis requiring further intervention. Further research is required to better confirm and characterise these associations, and the pathophysiological mechanisms behind the potential associations with pertussis.